Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 07:43

DysmalRadius · 14/05/2023 07:39

The glee with which some posters have appeared on this thread to suggest that an 11 year old should just 'get singing lessons' or 'become more resilient' after being excluded, by an adult, is truly saddening.

Living in the society we do makes us all competitive to a fault. I really loved the perspectives on this thread about music being part of the human experience. I’m pleasantly surprised not everyone sees things I the same way.

A mix of views feels right to me; no we can’t get everyone we want however there should be places even the mediocre can get together and sing :)

Also OP some of the children who got in may be exceptional or they may have had more resources to practice; paid tutors etc. We don’t all start from the same position!

beachwhirly · 14/05/2023 07:43

Nope. You need to sing well to be in a choir.

A lesson I learnt at the same age as your DD. This is real life and rejection happens!

EnidSpyton · 14/05/2023 07:42

@Flibbyjibby I don’t think anyone would disagree with your approach. It sounds wonderful.

However, not every school can afford to offer the myriad of opportunities your school does. In the last school I taught in, we only had one music teacher. If she’d led an auditioned and non auditioned choir as well as the various bands and orchestras she offered with help from the sixth formers, the poor woman would never have had a break during the school day.

We don’t know the situation in the OP’s daughter’s school. There may well be an auditioned and non auditioned choir. Or maybe the music teacher has been pressured into providing competition level musical opportunities by the Head and so has been forced to be exclusive. As teachers we shouldn’t do other teachers down. The budgets for arts subjects are tough right now in schools and we don’t know what pressures this school and its teachers are under. You have a wonderful and ideal situation and are doing a great job, and that’s brilliant. I’m so glad there are music departments like yours. But for those of us (like me) who are one man bands in schools who don’t care much about the arts, we have to do the best we can with what we have, and sometimes that means we can’t be as inclusive as we’d like to be.

arethereanyleftatall · 14/05/2023 07:41

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Actually, the opposite is true. If you persist on telling your child they're brilliant at everything, then when life happens, this happens...

'Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc'

That is a complete over reaction. I expect she has learnt entitlement from you, and now has over the top responses to things because she has no resilience,

KinderCat · 14/05/2023 07:40

Whilst it does seem quite ruthless to reject a 11 year old I don't necessarily think it is a bad thing OP.

Firstly, I work in a school and the lack of resilience is one of the biggest hurdles I come across. Do think there is value is learning this alone, tough as it seems in the short term.

Secondly, most curricular clubs tend to become competitive or have to perform after time and if your daughter didn't naturally improve this would mean either them dropping her at a later stage for the best chances/accepting they will not be the best or, worse, allowing her to potentially be embarrassed if she performs. Clubs like this that are via audition tend to build on existing skills rather than teach the basics.

Premiumchange · 14/05/2023 07:40

It was an audition so YABU. A good school will provide other musical opportunities but a school choir is for people with the right voices.

Xenia · 14/05/2023 07:39

Most of my children's schools have had a choir for the very good people and one for anyone who wants to join. 3 of my children won music scholarships and we have a lot of singers in the family including me so picking schools with good choirs was even a factor (and their father is an organist).

The more you can encourage people to try the choir the better however as that way you can get people who had no understanding they could sing and develop them; but in the example here there was an audition so it should have been explained that most people would not get in (and perhaps say we have another choice you will be joining however if you do not get into this one)

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 14/05/2023 07:39

YABU.

I was one of three kids in my year who wasn't allowed in the school choir at primary school - it didn't cause me any kind lifelong trauma or "kill my love of music". Not everyone is good at everything and children need to learn that.

Also to a PP who said that schools wouldn't tell children they were rubbish at maths and geography - of course they do. When I was at school anyone who wasn't getting decent marks in optional subjects at Year 9 wouldn't have been allowed to continue them in Year 10.

For subjects like maths, you'd be put in the lower stream where you could only take the foundation paper to make it as easy as possible for you.

If your DD really wants to sing, why not book her into singing lessons?

When I was

DysmalRadius · 14/05/2023 07:39

The glee with which some posters have appeared on this thread to suggest that an 11 year old should just 'get singing lessons' or 'become more resilient' after being excluded, by an adult, is truly saddening.

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 07:38

Flibbyjibby · 14/05/2023 07:31

I can see that a lot of people here don’t share my philosophy on music education, and that’s ok.

I will continue to teach music in an inclusive way and see the joy on my students faces when they do their first performance to an audience and receive their first applause. I will smile when the student who was quiet and shy begins chatting and laughing with the others in the choir. I will burn with pride when the student who was apathetic and disillusioned with school performs their first solo.

Music is more than talent. Music is a human process. It is community. It is built into our very being and it is for everybody.

There is time enough to learn resilience in our lives. Let children have a safe space to express themselves, make friends, learn new skills and feel accomplishment.

That's fine but there comes a point in the not to distant future (or even at 11 for arts schools that specialise in music) where they have to accept that there can be 300 people competing and auditioning for two places. 298 people are going to miss out. They can't be picked just because they enjoy it or want it.

AngelineGarcia · 14/05/2023 07:38

Also, is it any different to trying out for a football team? They only let the best players in, with idea of building a winning team rather than a “learning to play” team.

whitesnowflake · 14/05/2023 07:37

I disagree with you OP and think if a choir is auditioning for singers then they are actually looking for people who can sing. I was in the same position as your DD and didn't make the cut for my school choir either. It's a life lesson and hasn't done me any harm.

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 14/05/2023 07:36

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:21

I see singing as a recreational activity, not a competitive sport. Pp have said singing lessons/reading sheet music are required - basically rich parents and a tiny handful of 11 year olds.

Nothing wrong with kids learning that things don't always go their way, they need to persevere, other people need to be considered etc.

But the 'oh well you'll be crushed by capitalism we might as well start now' mentality is terrible. There are recreational activities that are worth doing for their own sake.

The sports/competitive mentality is what put me off exercise at school - if you're not naturally good at something, you get the message not to bother. There's nothing wrong with doing something for enjoyment, without competition coming into it.

Music is actually extremely competitive (unless it's just a fun choir). A lot of schools have very serious music departments with very well qualified students. At this age a lot of things - dance, music, sports, etc, stop being all just fun and students start to find their niches (and where their talents do and do lie). At 11 my daughter had to audition for very competitive dance schools. It took three years before she was accepted to a top dance school. At this stage this is where those that can hack the future professional environment get sorted. You can still do dance for fun but those who will go on to tertiary study in these areas find it starts to become very selective.

They need to learn that it's okay to be disappointed and feel it, then pick themselves up and try again knowing they may or may not succeed. That's reality.

Fairislefandango · 14/05/2023 07:36

Apparently most people can be taught to sing in tune, even if they start out pretty much tone deaf. The thing is though, I expect that takes quite a bit of individual attention and instruction, which isn't going to be possible for one poor singer in a school choir. If your dd is that keen, get her singing lessons.

It may seem harsh, but by that age children are becoming well aware of tgeir strengths and weaknesses. Schools are generally very keen to encourage students' interest regardless of ability, and like you say, there are no doubt umpteen other clubs she chould join to have a go at things. It doesn't seem that unreasonable to audition for a choir, when the level of ability in one individual will genuinely affect how they sound. Better than letting her join and everyone noticing she's the one who can't sing!

Soontobe60 · 14/05/2023 07:35

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

No, you lie and tell them they’re going to be the next Rhiannon and start applying for BGT.
What precisely is right about lying to a child about what they’re good at or not good at?

Equalitea · 14/05/2023 07:33

There’s usually try outs for the sports teams in secondary too. This isn’t like primary where anyone can go to.

I’ve had 5 children go through secondary and they’ve all had to compete/try out. (4 different secondary schools). I just assumed it was the normal procedure. The school wants the best to represent the school.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 14/05/2023 07:32

SabbatWheel · 14/05/2023 07:30

Why tolerate the mediocre when the pursuit of excellence is what actually gives a true sense of fulfilment and pleasure (to participants and teachers)?

I have run a variety of musical ensembles over many years, including choirs. Some have been all-access and some by audition. The layers of musical subtlety you can add to an auditioned group can be thrilling. The sheer amount of extra work you have to put into an all-access group to get even near similar standards can be overwhelming.

This is so laughably pompous and misses the point entirely 🤣

Flibbyjibby · 14/05/2023 07:31

I can see that a lot of people here don’t share my philosophy on music education, and that’s ok.

I will continue to teach music in an inclusive way and see the joy on my students faces when they do their first performance to an audience and receive their first applause. I will smile when the student who was quiet and shy begins chatting and laughing with the others in the choir. I will burn with pride when the student who was apathetic and disillusioned with school performs their first solo.

Music is more than talent. Music is a human process. It is community. It is built into our very being and it is for everybody.

There is time enough to learn resilience in our lives. Let children have a safe space to express themselves, make friends, learn new skills and feel accomplishment.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 14/05/2023 07:31

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 03:41

I'm actually on your side. My gran had the worst singing voice ever, and a professional voice coach once said "I could make you sing - anyone has the ability to sing if they're taught correctly."

School's for learning and encouraging, if her singing isn't good enough for the choir, she needs extra support, not told she's not good enough.

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

For persistent low performance in Maths, my school would have given remedial lunch hour tuition. For Geography, the child would have been advised not to take the subject in year 10 when choosing GCSE options.

For persistent low performance in History (my "least worst" choice out of a pool of three subjects that I had to choose one of for Year 10), I was kicked off the GCSE. I still had more than enough GCSEs to go to sixth form. I used the time to funnel effort into English, which I was also on track to fail and is an essential subject. Result: I passed English.

Sometimes, being told "no" is the best outcome for the child.

AngelineGarcia · 14/05/2023 07:31

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

Sorry, but no, singers do not all sound the same in a group. I sing in a group of 100 and one rogue voice would stand out among 99 others singing in tune.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:30

usernother · 14/05/2023 07:26

When I was at primary school we each had to stand up behind our desks and sing a song solo. It was then decided who would be in the choir. I wasn't. And that's the way it was. No idea if anyone was upset by it, but there is no point in your daughter thinking she's a good singer if she isn't.

And have you sung in a choir since our did that kill singing for you, aged 7 or whatever, based on someone's else's one minute judgement of you?

SabbatWheel · 14/05/2023 07:30

Why tolerate the mediocre when the pursuit of excellence is what actually gives a true sense of fulfilment and pleasure (to participants and teachers)?

I have run a variety of musical ensembles over many years, including choirs. Some have been all-access and some by audition. The layers of musical subtlety you can add to an auditioned group can be thrilling. The sheer amount of extra work you have to put into an all-access group to get even near similar standards can be overwhelming.

Crafty09 · 14/05/2023 07:30

But singing like PE has many and far reaching benefits. Anyone could join school choir when I went to school. Admittedly a long time ago. I guess if they go in for competitions it might be different?

90stalgia · 14/05/2023 07:28

I think there's a difference between not being able to sing because the quality of your voice is poor, and not being able to sing in tune.

I have the latter, and I doubt it can be fixed. I can hear the right tune in my head; I can even in a rudimentary way pick out a melody I've heard on a keyboard; but whatever should link my voice to my brain for singing just isn't there so if I sing it comes out as a completely different note.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 07:28

octaurpus · 14/05/2023 07:15

I've run a Junior Choir for years. Years 7 & 8. All girls It's a training choir for the upper years' choir, which is selective. Most of my girls have zero singing experience. I do run auditions, just to get a vague idea what I've got to work with. We rehearse weekely, and run an intense 3 day camp at the beginning of Term 2 to prepare for the main school music concert. I think anyone keen enough to endure an audition with a complete stranger and an accompanist deserves a place in the choir. Excellent attendance is compulsory if you want to attend camp, which is hugely popular among the students. Some years are better than others, but we all work bloody hard and by the middle of the year they are always sounding fabulous. Retention into Year 8 is over 90%, and the girls just get better and better.

It is my job to train them. Their job is to show up, and be committed to working together.

I'm very sorry for your DD's experience, OP.

This is a much better approach. Having parents who fork out for singing lessons shouldn't be a requirement.