Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
SabbatWheel · 14/05/2023 08:34

IAmTheWalrus85 · 14/05/2023 07:32

This is so laughably pompous and misses the point entirely 🤣

Pompous? Why yes, I’ll take that, thank you! I’m glad you understand that I know my job so well.

With a 34 year career as a music teacher in an ordinary (non-academy specialism) 11-16 school with opportunities for all to sing in lessons (and be taught HOW to sing) I know:
a) how to get all kids singing and to enjoy it; and
b) how to run selective / non-selective ensembles to a standard that can then perform in large venues in the UK and to tour abroad.

Pompous? I think you mean proud.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 14/05/2023 08:34

Fancylike · 14/05/2023 08:12

I’m with you, OP. How is she meant to learn how to be a “good” singer if the school won’t let her take part in the group classes. Like most things, music can be learned with practice, and choir is an ideal setting for this. Ed Sheeran was famously not a natural singer but got better with practice.

if sports teams, maths clubs etc don’t require selective auditions, then the creative groups need to follow the same inclusivity.

Choir isn't a group class though - it's a selective activity where you need to pass an audition to join.

Sports teams also work selectively - only the best children will attend matches, for example, or be selected for the squad.

It also works in academics - when I was at school, you couldn't do selective subjects at GCSE if you consistently got bad grades, and for subjects like maths, you'd only be entered for the foundation papers so the highest grade you could get was a C, but the content would be more straightforward.

MrsMiagi · 14/05/2023 08:34

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

No! She will be good at something else. That's the point of an audition, to select the best. This is why people go on those x factor auditions despite being terrible; they weren't told how bad they are, usually by parents. Very entitled to think she just be given a place anyway.
A choir is only as good as its worst singers. She will be sad of course but that's life and its a good lesson.
I know you say they should help people to improve.... that's singing lessons. If the school offer that then great but a choir isn't designed to improve the voices of people in it who can't sing.
If she is passionate about it why not pay for her to have singing lessons?

crikeycrumbsblimey · 14/05/2023 08:32

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 07:10

And as for posters calling a disappointed child a spoilt madam and similar names, you should be ashamed of yourselves. The guff about an entirely misconceived ide a of 'resilience ' is just that, guff. Resilience is not .magically switching off disappointment, or having armour-pla ted confidence.

Definitely - what a bunch of nasty pricks on this thread honestly. Have you all woken up with a hangover? Anyone calling an 11 year old names or saying they have a voice like a cheese grater have a bloody word with yourself.

I'm especially “enjoying” the people with seemingly have no background in music telling those who do what it is all about.

This is a choir which at 11 years old should be about developing talent and nurturing a love of music. Not ensuring someone goes through life thinking they can’t sing.

OP please see if there is a community choir or something to build you daughters confidence.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 08:32

CabbagePatchDole · 14/05/2023 08:31

Actually, most people are mediocre at most things. It is quite rare for people to be exceptional so why we give the concept so much prominence (especially at school) is beyond me. I speak as someone who was supposedly "gifted" when young.

Haha snap! Yea most of us are just average but an average person can achieve great things if they are willing to persevere and not accept the everyone in their place narrative

Asteric · 14/05/2023 08:32

I think this is mean. At my secondary school the choir was for all comers, kids primary school is the same. Church choirs often except everyone, community choirs often do as well. We should be encouraging kids to participate, same with sport (which I often feel also excludes kids who aren’t very good). I totally get there is a place for elite (or possibly just competent) levels, but a lot of activities should be just about being able to have a go at something you enjoy.

SmileyClare · 14/05/2023 08:31

There’s nothing wrong with competition, and accepting not everyone can win.

Theres everything wrong with a parent reacting like this when their dd expresses their disappointment at not “winning” at something.

Anger at the school? Making complaints? Fuming that your dd is experiencing a “sad” emotion.?

Children are increasingly growing up thinking that any negative emotion is to be avoided at all costs and if they do feel sad, worried or disappointed, it’s down to the people around them to make it better.

The number of secondary school pupils who are claiming they have “anxiety” when they’re a little nervous before exams as if it’s a terrifying disease rather than a normal emotion is unprecedented.

They all expect to be accommodated and get angry and blame others because they’re experiencing an uncomfortable emotion.

They simply expect someone else to take their feelings away. Many can’t handle any uncomfortable emotions and have the misconception that when they don’t feel “good/happy” there’s either something wrong with their mental health or they’re a victim of “non inclusivity”

Its ok to feel sad and disappointed she didn’t get a place in the choir. That’s a normal everyday emotion she doesn’t need shielding from.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 08:31

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/05/2023 08:20

This.

I disagree. Not everyone excels even at one thing. You have to decide what you want to work on. And try. Most people in the world are one shade of average at best. And better yet can improve. There is a false attitude here that if you will be good at something you always show a natural aptitude straight away. Due to different upbringings and opportunities that isn’t always the case. A child never encouraged to read or write may not discover they are good at it when they try and are given a chance to improve.

CabbagePatchDole · 14/05/2023 08:31

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/05/2023 08:20

This.

Actually, most people are mediocre at most things. It is quite rare for people to be exceptional so why we give the concept so much prominence (especially at school) is beyond me. I speak as someone who was supposedly "gifted" when young.

Treeonahill · 14/05/2023 08:30

I started off in a school choir and then joined a church choir, it was a very decent one and we took Royal school of church music exams. Have been in adult choirs as well. Some were audition and some were not. It is unfortunate but if a voice or two aren’t good it changes everything. The school choir I was in was entered for the district competition every year so you had to be a certain standard.

It’s a real shame for your DD. Do you actually know what’s up? DH isn’t much of a singer but we joined a ships choir on a cruise, well he came along and joined in and he loved it. So he practiced using an app and is much improved.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 14/05/2023 08:29

Why not let a child compete and fail if they want to, enjoy the experience etc? Plenty of long distance running things are like that

For major endurance events, like Ironman length triathlons, the longer Audax cycling events, and ultra-marathons, just finishing within the time limit is deemed a major achievement.

LolaSmiles · 14/05/2023 08:28

How do kids who are good at everything develop resilience? Maybe we should exclude kids from things at random just to teach them that life isn't fair? (I suppose we do, it's called the class system)
In my experience the kids who are 'good at everything' aren't naturally good at everything. People mistake being a nice rounded child for them being good at everything.

I've taught a lot of 'good at everything' students and they're often very pleasant, general all-rounders and have a particular skill in one or two areas. They typically will spend their time on the things they're good at and not on others (eg they might have flute lessons but not join the orchestra because there are better flautists, and they would rather put their energy into netball). They have subjects they're more talented at than others, so will have to put more effort into the ones they're not as good at. They experience disappointment with a lower test score, or if they don't make the team/only make the B team and they were hoping for the A team, they didn't get the role in the play they hoped for, didn't get through county trials, didn't get into regional music ensembles.
They typically have quite a bit of resilience and have, from younger ages, been brought up to know nobody is great at everything, disappointment is a normal part of life, and they can always try something else or work at something to get better.

Dacadactyl · 14/05/2023 08:27

Bless your DD, OP.

But I do think the school are fine to only want the best singers in the choir. I am surprised that it's taken until year 7 for her not to be selected for something. This is a good opportunity for you to learn how to manage her disappointment and teach her that this is a life lesson.

JenWillsiam · 14/05/2023 08:27

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 08:20

Why not let a child compete and fail if they want to, enjoy the experience etc? Plenty of long distance running things are like that

Would you tell a child who likes running not to bother because they're shit? Nevermind the benefits of it, you won't win so don't bother

That's not actually the resilient spirit that makes people succeed in business. Ever heard of the tortoise and the hare?

No I would not but I would be realistic about where they’re going to end up. Running for fun. Long distance running as an aside is not running for people are are slow. That’s also a competitive sport in its own right. if you aren’t a naturally good runner you aren’t competing and if you aren’t a naturally good singer and performer the choir is not the place for you.

Learning you aren’t good at everything is absolutely about building up resilience.

Gtsr443 · 14/05/2023 08:25

This is why schools should never be the centre of a child's universe.

She honestly won't give a toss about the school choir if she's having a great time doing performing arts out of school with inclusive organisations.

This isn't about whether she can sing or not, it is about realising she has a desire to do something and facilitating it because she's 11 and just wants to join in and have fun.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 08:25

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/05/2023 08:03

The misconception of resilience on this thread is really annoying me. Resilience is NOT about not having or showing emotions such as disappointment. It's not a new term for a stiff upper lip. It's not even really about a (urgh) growth mindset. It's about drawing on the internal and external resources we have to manage our life experiences. By talking to her mum about her sadness (and I get how personal it can feel to be told something as inherent to you as your voice is allegedly not up to scratch) OP's dd is drawing on her resources. I'm sure she'll find a way to handle the disappointment in herself.

Exactly!

Kazzyhoward · 14/05/2023 08:23

@Fancylike

if sports teams, maths clubs etc don’t require selective auditions, then the creative groups need to follow the same inclusivity.

They do select on ability. Maybe not for the "fun" sessions, after school club, etc., but certainly the school's "proper" football team that competes with other schools will be based on ability, as will be the school's entries to the Maths Olympiad competitions.

Back to the OP, I'd imagine the school choir will be involved in local music/singing competitions with other schools, so having members who can't sing will impact on their ability to compete.

What is missing is an informal/fun choir as an after school club, and I'm sure the school would welcome parents wanting to help set one up.

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/05/2023 08:20

Aquamarine1029 · 14/05/2023 01:28

You tell them that no one is good at everything, and we all have to discover what it is we excel at. That's life.

This.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 08:20

JenWillsiam · 14/05/2023 08:16

Let’s put it another way if she was terrible at running would you encourage her to compete and everyone see her railing behind?

and with the singing, a choir works because people can sing. If they can’t the choir is rubbish and just awful to listen to. Why humiliate her like that? Are you going to go through life telling her she’s wonderful at everything when she’s not? When do you actually start being honest? The issue here isn’t that the choir has been honest. This issue is you haven’t been. That you haven’t taught her that everyone has different talents and skills. Focus on what is good at.

Why not let a child compete and fail if they want to, enjoy the experience etc? Plenty of long distance running things are like that

Would you tell a child who likes running not to bother because they're shit? Nevermind the benefits of it, you won't win so don't bother

That's not actually the resilient spirit that makes people succeed in business. Ever heard of the tortoise and the hare?

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 08:17

How do kids who are good at everything develop resilience? Maybe we should exclude kids from things at random just to teach them that life isn't fair? (I suppose we do, it's called the class system)

'just pay for singing lessons' not everyone has the money to spare

JenWillsiam · 14/05/2023 08:16

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:32

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing. I don't think she is even bad, she sounds like an 11 year old singing. Don't get me wrong, she doesn't have an amazing natural talent but nor is she someone who is completely out of time.

Let’s put it another way if she was terrible at running would you encourage her to compete and everyone see her railing behind?

and with the singing, a choir works because people can sing. If they can’t the choir is rubbish and just awful to listen to. Why humiliate her like that? Are you going to go through life telling her she’s wonderful at everything when she’s not? When do you actually start being honest? The issue here isn’t that the choir has been honest. This issue is you haven’t been. That you haven’t taught her that everyone has different talents and skills. Focus on what is good at.

knowthescore · 14/05/2023 08:16

it makes me sad for the state of music education.

Music education is in a perilous state nationally. My LA went from free instrumental lessons and a network of Saturday morning music centres to play in orchestra etc, to paid instrumental lessons, to no instrumental lessons and no music centres, during the last 30 years. Some of the kids on free lessons went on to become internationally-renowned soloists. There's a national shortage of amateur brass players. Ochestras, jazz bands, and wind bands struggle to recruit brass and colliery-type brass bands are folding because they cannot replace retiring players. Schools are using group lessons in recorders, guitar, and ukelele to tick the "instrumental music provision" box as cheaply as possible because of lack of funding, which is better than no provision, but it's killing grassroots ensembles.

electriclight · 14/05/2023 08:16

She knew it wasn't a club that took everyone, with a focus on improving.

She knew it was an audition and would have been fine with that if she had passed and others had failed.

So it is a bit hypocritical of you both to be complaining about the competitive element now, only because dd was rejected.

I'm also wondering why you didn't warn her that this could happen.

Honestly, must we tell kids they are good at everything now? Either focus on what she is good at or channel her energy into joining a more inclusive choir to improve.

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 14/05/2023 08:15

CabbagePatchDole · 14/05/2023 07:44

I can't believe that people on here are saying about how it's OK for someone to be excluded from a choir.

In real life, in the adult world anyone can join most choirs (unless they are professional) and quite rightly so because singing is so good for wellbeing and everyone should have the opportunity to do it, especially at this time given how crazy the world is and that music will really help with people's mental health.

I don't think the school should be holding auditions for the choir. I think anyone should be able to join and the more naturally talented be given the solos. I actually think that those who aren't naturally talented should be given solos as well. It's a school choir ffs! If a kid has a desire they should be given every opportunity to explore it because I have noticed that, apart from football, there is just not as much for kids to do that involves being in community with others. So many kids don't pursue interests apart from social media. As they get older OP's child might find that they enjoy helping behind the scenes or prefer to play an instrument than sing. Or continue singing for enjoyment in choirs for the rest of their life. Why not?

Last night I saw a group of kids who were all congregated outside McDonalds - as their recreation! McDonalds! Because the youth centres of my youth have disappeared and there seems to be fuck all for them to do. We should be encouraging kids to have interests/hobbies.

OP is there a community choir in your area that you can both join? Those choirs don't exclude anybody.

No, BTW. I sing in an amateur choir that has an audition process; none of the big London choirs, like Royal Symphony Chorus/ London Philharmonic Choir, which are all open to amateurs, let people in without an audition.

However, it's not always about being in tune; I've known people be rejected for excessive vibrato, for example. It's about choosing voices that blend for a uniform sound. If your daughter has what I'd call, a 'stagey' voice - overly nasal in other words - she might not have the right sound.

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 14/05/2023 08:13

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

Yes. Imagine teaching children that we can't have everything in life and can't always 'win'. Absolutely ridiculous. I suggest calling the police!

Swipe left for the next trending thread