Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
FOJN · 14/05/2023 09:20

Don't do this to your daughter. She wasn't good enough for the choir so wasn't selected, she hasn't become an inferior human as a result, it's not the end of the world so do not give her the impression it is.

We all remember childhood disappointment but disappointment is a fact of life and it's not kind or caring to protect children from that truth.

Give her a cuddle, suggest some singing lessons if she's interested and encourage her in the things she does have a natural talent or aptitude for.

MavisBeacon1234 · 14/05/2023 09:19

This makes me cringe so hard. It's the same cringe I get when you see those teenagers on xfactor who think they can sing because their parents told them. We need to normalise telling children in situations like this that they aren't good at things it would save them so much embarrassment

Theydontknowthatweknowthattheyknow · 14/05/2023 09:17

Singing well is a combination of things, most of which can be improved on. I have pretty much perfect pitch. If you play me a note I can tell you what it is. I can pick out tunes from a mile away and pick up most musical intruments and play a basic tune without ever having learned to play that instrument.

I am not a very good singer though. I can just about hold a tune but I'm definitely not Beyonce. This is because I was never really trained to sing. The number of people who are genuinely 'tone deaf' is incredibly small

I can see why you're upset OP. I do think a love of music should be nurtured in the same way a love of reading/maths/sports should be. I went to school in the 90s when we were a lot less 'woke' than we are right now and I don't remember anyone not being allowed in the general choir right up to 6th form. As pp have said it's a community experience as much as anything. I also sort of agree with other pp though that say it's a lesson in resilience. The resilience lesson doesn't come from being OTT upset about it though or chastising dd over her valid emotions around it though IMO. It comes from acknowledging she's upset and helping her find a social acceptable way of dealing with that upset. Is she really keen to sing? In which case she dries her tears and you do some research together on how she can do this be this singing lessons, joining a different choir etc. She maybe asks the choir leader if there'a anything she can do to improve too.She could write an assertive letter to the school explaining how dissappointed this is and how brilliant an all-inclusive choir would be but I wouldn't go crazy at the school or encourage her to as this isn't teaching resilience it's teaching her to over-react whenever things don't go her way. Or if she's not really that into the singing and just went to be with her mates for example then you just have a cry and let it go. There's nothing wrong with kids and even parents being upset over this kind of experience. It's how you deal with it that breeds true resilience and happiness.

ShowUs · 14/05/2023 09:17

ImthatBoleyngirl · 14/05/2023 09:10

My DD is a gymnast and was selected for the competition squad at 6 years old. All the other girls, bar one, were rejected. Her first competition at 6 years old she placed 26th out of 27 girls. Yes it was upsetting but she carried on training and is now consistently placing in the top 6 and often coming 1st.

She's 11 now and it's taught her to work hard, to not be afraid of rejection and to not give up. I have so much respect for her determination and mindset.

This is amazing but I wonder how well the ones that were rejected did.

Your DD got a place which would have built her confidence.

The girls that got rejected would have had their confidence knocked and perhaps not kept trying.

That is what OP is saying.
If they are rejected then does it knock their confidence so much that they don’t want to do it anymore.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 14/05/2023 09:17

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:26

Do you really go around telling young kids they aren't good at something? That seems so sad...

My daughter (12) is not a great singer. Not the worst ever but she's certainly not the next Adele and I've told her as much (in a nice way). Instead I highlight all the things she is good at. If you tell kids they are amazing at everything, when in fact they are bad or just average, you are setting them up for a hard time IMO.

Kokopenny · 14/05/2023 09:16

Ffs 🙄, my son tried out for the footy team, he didn’t get in as he can’t play very well. That’s life

ShowUs · 14/05/2023 09:14

The fact that there is an audition tells you that they only want the best singers.

Your DD needs to understand that she cannot get everything she wants.

However, I do think there should be a choir that anyone can take part in.

They should encourage being involved in extracurricular activities and everyone needs to learn somewhere.

I know this is a big issue with things like football teams as they only want the best players to play against other schools and win.

They could have 2 teams - 1 voluntary and 1 auditioned and then everyone can take part.
It also benefits them as they’ll be able to see who is good and who isn’t.

Butchyrestingface · 14/05/2023 09:12

Well seen you haven’t enabled the voting, you complete wet blanket. Grin

OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 09:12

ImthatBoleyngirl · 14/05/2023 09:10

My DD is a gymnast and was selected for the competition squad at 6 years old. All the other girls, bar one, were rejected. Her first competition at 6 years old she placed 26th out of 27 girls. Yes it was upsetting but she carried on training and is now consistently placing in the top 6 and often coming 1st.

She's 11 now and it's taught her to work hard, to not be afraid of rejection and to not give up. I have so much respect for her determination and mindset.

That is impressive! Congratulations to your daughter :). Most people do not become great without effort and setbacks. How awesome she persevered.

Timesawastin · 14/05/2023 09:11

@horseymum

Yes, some people really are utterly tone deaf. And tone dumb.

ImthatBoleyngirl · 14/05/2023 09:10

My DD is a gymnast and was selected for the competition squad at 6 years old. All the other girls, bar one, were rejected. Her first competition at 6 years old she placed 26th out of 27 girls. Yes it was upsetting but she carried on training and is now consistently placing in the top 6 and often coming 1st.

She's 11 now and it's taught her to work hard, to not be afraid of rejection and to not give up. I have so much respect for her determination and mindset.

DeeCeeCherry · 14/05/2023 09:10

Can you pay for Singing lessons for her, so she'll feel better?

You should've given a big smile, hugged her said oh never mind why don't you try this...

It is horrible to be rejected. Adults remember it for years from their childhood. As you can see here several grow up into 'lets stick the boot in' types as they were likely told to 'toughen up' so they did, and ended up disappointed in life which manifests into harshness.

Honestly tho I'd get her into Singing lessons, she can enjoy learning. Don't make a big deal of what happened just provide alternatives.

horseymum · 14/05/2023 09:09

That's so sad. Singing is good for the soul. Schools shouldn't be turning away people who want to sing, they should be working with them to help them improve. No one is tone deaf really, telling someone they can't sing can put them off for life. A tiny percentage of people cant sing. It's different if this was for a high level chamber choir with only 12 people and they all have to hold their own but I doubt this is what a school choir is like. If she wants to sing, maybe look for a community choir outside school. They will probably have longer rehearsals anyway so more time to work on warm ups, technique, learning the tune. Sometimes they provide backing tracks to learn the parts at home too which would help if it's that she finds hard.

Timesawastin · 14/05/2023 09:09

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 03:41

I'm actually on your side. My gran had the worst singing voice ever, and a professional voice coach once said "I could make you sing - anyone has the ability to sing if they're taught correctly."

School's for learning and encouraging, if her singing isn't good enough for the choir, she needs extra support, not told she's not good enough.

To put it into perspective, if you do a maths or georgraphy test in year nine and get a grade D, the teacher doesn't say "Not good enough, give up."

The director of music at DHs church said something similar (she is an award winning musician and teacher with her own Wiki page). After a few sessions with him she changed her mind...

ringsaglitter · 14/05/2023 09:07

ElmTree22 · 14/05/2023 08:55

Very different situation. A voluntary choir isn't there to teach individual children to sing, anyone who has been in a choir could tell you that, it's for teaching a group of people how to sing together in perfect harmony.
You can't compare part of the curriculum to a extra after school activity 🙄

Singing lessons on the other hand, they are for teaching individuals how to sing. Like you said your Nan had a "voice coach", not a choirmaster, to teach her how to sing.

Okay. Thanks for explaining. My school didn't have a choir, just a few sports clubs like netball anyone could join as no girls at my school wanted to do sports lol.

My gran didn't have a voice coach, she knew a voice coach - my gran preferred wiskey and bingo to singing lol

TallerThanAverage · 14/05/2023 09:06

I remember Sheila in our school choir, very loud and confident, terrible voice.

FoxCorner · 14/05/2023 09:05

My kids' school goes the opposite way and lets anyone who wants to sing a solo do it. It can be pretty painful to listen to. I'm OK with them letting anyone in the choir though as that sounds fine, so I agree with you op

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 14/05/2023 09:03

Lessons if she's serious about putting in the time and energy could be a good shout

Timesawastin · 14/05/2023 09:02

CrapBucket · 14/05/2023 01:27

A school choir should accept everyone! Gareth Malone wouldn’t tell an 11 year old they aren’t good enough. He’d teach them ways to improve.

Nonsense. Also there are some people (DH and his entire family) who simply cannot hold a tune,however much they improve they will sound terrible. Just as I will never be any good at pole vaulting.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 14/05/2023 09:02

And agree it's not comparable to a kid who isn't excelling at an academic subject for example, maths.

Violinist64 · 14/05/2023 09:01

*for the choir.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 14/05/2023 09:01

It's a nice sentiment in theory to say (quite rightly) most people can have help and lessons to sing better.

But this is a choir not a singing club so there's surely the expectation that members have a minimum standard already?

And teachers and adults helping aren't there to develop everyone from a zero ability level, I'm guessing they have plans to stage a concert so are focusing on that therefore want actual talent?

It's not year 1 where watching a play with awful singing is cute an endearing, unfortunately.

Agree that this is definitely a Life Teaching Moment OP.

Violinist64 · 14/05/2023 09:01

Your daughter is eleven. She knew that there were auditions the choir and that there was a chance that she might not be chosen, which is the case here. She is quite old enough to understand that, while she is disappointed not to have been chosen, it is just one of those things and to get over it. I presume that she can always try again another time. This is exactly what you should be saying to her. You are not helping her by rising to her defence on every little - and this is extremely little - disappointment. This is a good opportunity to learn some resilience. I was never picked for sports teams (with good reason!) but that was fine. I have not passed every audition or interview l have attended but, again, that’s life and the same for everyone. There has been far too much “prizes for all” mentality and it is not a good thing for anyone. Eleven is a good age to learn this lesson in a safe environment over a small thing. As for saying she will be embarrassed to see her music teacher because she failed her audition - for goodness’ sake! The music teacher won’t think any more or less of her because she was not good enough for the choir. They will be pleased she had a go - it shows she has an interest. Instead of supporting her misapprehension you can tell her this and then the subject should remain closed.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/05/2023 09:00

ElmTree22 · 14/05/2023 08:57

This!

Arrghhh again no, it may not mean she is bad. It may mean she needs practice. Few people in the world excel at anything most are average but with time, practice and opportunity may improve. Letting one rejection put you off isn’t resilience. Some of the students she competed with may have had private lessons, training that you don’t even know about.

She can also try finding a community choir to sing in, there are benefits even if you are not brilliant.

Most people are not terrible or excellent; just somewhere in the middle.

CabbagePatchDole · 14/05/2023 08:59

Having lived through a global pandemic I would have hoped that schools would prioritise participation in group activities, ensuring that as many kids as possible could be involved. A lot of kids have just disappeared from the system since the pandemic. Why not give those that want to take part the opportunity?