Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a secondary school choir rejecting an 11 year old based on their voice is horrible?

612 replies

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:14

Just had DD come in upset. It's quite random as it's the middle of the night and a weekend and we had a nice day today, told me she is still sad about how she is a bad singer and she doesn't want to see her music teacher as she is too embarrassed etc etc

DD tried out for the school choir which is done by audition so obviously she was aware there was some kind of judging involved and so was I but I do think rejecting a year 7 into something they are interested in trying is harsh, especially when it's hard enough for year 7s.

AIBU to think a school choir should just be for whoever is interested? When kids are all singing in a group they do sound the same anyway! Obviously maybe solos could be kept for the particularly talented but I'm honestly just a bit sad and even annoyed.

OP posts:
Crazycrazylady · 14/05/2023 17:39

Op
I'm shocked that you're surprised that someone would advise their child that there not particularly good at something . At 11 you should absolutely be able to have an honest conversation with her about her abilities in what ever she does.
Her peers won't be long in telling her the truth and it's far better coming from you.

Thewitcherswolf · 14/05/2023 17:31

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:32

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing. I don't think she is even bad, she sounds like an 11 year old singing. Don't get me wrong, she doesn't have an amazing natural talent but nor is she someone who is completely out of time.

Ah, but is she completely out of tune?
Or maybe her audition went wrong - like she started singing on the wrong note and ended up sining in a different key to the accompanying music, even if she was in tune with herself.

LolaSmiles · 14/05/2023 17:06

The girls that got rejected would have had their confidence knocked and perhaps not kept trying.

That is what OP is saying.
If they are rejected then does it knock their confidence so much that they don’t want to do it anymore.
But that's for the parents to manage. We set the culture in our homes. Our children look to us to learn how to react to situations.

If we are open with them that everyone has skills and talents, that sometimes you'll make the team/get the audition and others you won't, they'll accept that and know we are with them through the highs and the disappointment. If we are full of praise and support for their efforts and celebrate their achievements, then we can be kind and loving in our guidance in the areas they're not strong at. If when they're disappointed we're there to be supportive, and we help them establish what they can do next, that's what they'll learn. They're more likely to work on the area they wish to improve, or decide they've got talents in other areas, or accept someone else was better this time and it might be their time next time.

If we fail to teach them that disappointment is part of life, if we instill in them the idea that every gets a prize, everyone should make the team, they are entitled to a place after every audition and then when they're disappointed we seek to blame others, blame the coaches, complain to the school, then at best we are failing help them build resilience in a safe and loving way, and at worst we're setting them with a sense of entitlement and an inability to appraise their strengths and weaknesses.

FarmGirl78 · 14/05/2023 14:54

And she can still be a bad singer without being completely out of time! They're looking for GOOD singers in a choir, not bad, and not even average.

Izzy24 · 14/05/2023 14:53

wehavenotomatoes · 14/05/2023 09:49

What's sad isn't that a child might not be the best singer in the world and make a career in pop music, but can't be in a school choir which is probably a few kids practising in a classroom at lunchtime with a teacher.
The child enjoys singing and wants to improve, and is seeking out activities to enable her to do so. Not everyone can just pay out for private lessons, school is the place for learning stuff and building confidence.
My kids' school talks a lot about the importance of building confidence in singing, not because most of us will ever be good enough to be professional singers, but because there is joy to be had in it. As someone who had a similar experience to OP's child and learnt at 11 that I was no good at singing and should mouth along at church, in assembly, at weddings, when encouraged by my family to join the non audition church choir I didn't, because I now knew something I didn't before, which was that I couldn't sing, and that I would spoil the sound of a group singing.
OP I'm really sorry for what happened to your child and I hope you are able to find a more welcoming and encouraging group for her to join, so that the joy isn't taken out of something she loves. Hopefully this will also lead to new friends and cool experiences for her. Xx

Kindness. What a great post.

FarmGirl78 · 14/05/2023 14:52

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:32

What do you suggest I do when my 11 year old comes and tells me they really want to be in the choir and has an audition the next days lunch break. Say oh absolutely don't bother, you're shit at singing. I don't think she is even bad, she sounds like an 11 year old singing. Don't get me wrong, she doesn't have an amazing natural talent but nor is she someone who is completely out of time.

What? Of course you tell her if she's not up to it! If she chooses to go on and audition anyway that's up to her but she needs to know if she's BAD. You can flower it up to break the news gently, but she needs to know. This is how you get AWFUL singers on XFactor and BGT, who are oblivious to the fact, who then get told so publicly. That famous one where the parents stomped onstage and told Simon Cowell off. Its THEIR fault their Daughter ended up humiliating herself on National TV, because they were either so deluded they couldn't see their little darling was bad, or knew full well like you do but shyed away from being the one to break the news.

If she's actually BAD who would you rather tell her? You, or a teacher who'll tell her without sympathy, a hug, and possibly in front of others?

coretext · 14/05/2023 14:17

The clue is in the word audition. Not everyone will be successful, especially if numbers are limited:
"An audition is a short performance given by an actor, dancer, or musician so that a director or conductor can decide if they are good enough to be in a play, film, or orchestra"

TheFireflies · 14/05/2023 13:33

Forfrigz · 14/05/2023 08:11

Not a lot of people know this but singing, like drawing is something you can learn. Some people have a natural tendency to learn it easier but those who can't do it can have lessons and become just as good. If you can, why not get her proper singing lessons if it's something she's interested in, or perhaps there are tutorials she van find herself online.

People keep saying this but it simply isn’t true. Nobody can learn to be “just as good”. Most people can improve, but lessons wont magically make them good singers. There was a programme on Sky Arts a few years back called Anyone Can Sing where poor singers were intensively mentored by world class vocal coaches with the premise as the title.

At the end, the majority were still poor singers, painfully so in a couple of cases.

That said, it’s a shame that creative pursuits aren’t treated the same as sports in schools, where competitive teams are provided separately to open lessons.

AuntieJune · 14/05/2023 13:28

Eleganz · 14/05/2023 12:43

And the funding for this comes from?

It is a fine ideal, but music for everyone is not funded properly in our education system. Would you say the same about a school that runs a football team rather than extra curricular football coaching for every single child in the school?

I would say that a choir that is auditioned is aiming for excellence in its singing, not inclusion therefore you can't dismiss it at failing at all as it's aims are different. Supporting children with a lot of talent in a certain area is no less important than giving all opportunity.

Well apparently there are plenty of parents who fork out for singing lessons for their kids. Why couldn't there be plenty of parents who pay a bit for a non-selective choir?

Agreed it's about kids having an opportunity to do something beneficial even if they don't have star quality. Like kids should learn to cook even if they're not cut out to run a restaurant or be a celeb chef or whatever. Because it's good for you and brings joy. It's sad when everything is made into a competition.

I don't see anything wrong with kids competing in some areas, but don't think singing should be one that's solely competitive.

MrsMitford3 · 14/05/2023 13:01

GingerCoi · 14/05/2023 09:30

This is a great example of how there has been a shift in parenting over the past 20-30 years. Nobody likes to see their kids sad and upset but you then have to manage this appropriately. As others have said, it's a life lesson and you could encourage her interest by getting her some lessons and supporting her to audition again next year, when she's improved, or by finding a singing / music group for everyone that she can attend out of school. Unfortunately, some parents seem absolutely unable to cope with their DC experiencing disappointment / sadness / upset, so instead of learning that these feelings are a normal part of life and developing the skills to cope with them, these DC learn that it is not acceptable for them to feel these things and that everyone should bend over backwards to ensure that they don't, in addition to not learning coping skills. The result? Entitled and emotionally immature young people.

Exactly this.

@GingerCoi You have said what I was thinking far better than I could have-and in a much nicer way!

Takoneko · 14/05/2023 13:00

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:36

Think a lot of people on here don’t seem to understand that singing for pleasure should be an option for every child who would like to do it. Not singing competitively. Singing for pleasure. If the school can’t offer that to a child who would love to do it then it’s a pretty rubbish school. No matter how many choir medals it wins it is failing at the thing that’s really important.

It possible for every child to have an opportunity to sing for pleasure and yet still need to have auditions for the main choir. In fact, I would say that the more opportunities a school gives for young people to sing for pleasure, the more likely it is that the school choirs will be oversubscribed.

In some schools scraping together a dozen kids across the whole school who want to sing in a choir is a challenge. In others there are multiple choirs with the main choir being hugely oversubscribed.

At our carol concert there are several choirs every year. The main choir, a gospel choir, usually at least a couple of smaller choirs from different age groups and then a “Christmas choir” that gets put together in the autumn term to encourage kids who don’t want to commit to a choir long-term to have a go and sing. Some of those then go on to join one of the other choirs.

All year groups have hymn practice regularly in assembly and during masses all students sing. It’s competitive because there is a culture of singing for pleasure.

Neopolitan · 14/05/2023 12:59

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:36

Think a lot of people on here don’t seem to understand that singing for pleasure should be an option for every child who would like to do it. Not singing competitively. Singing for pleasure. If the school can’t offer that to a child who would love to do it then it’s a pretty rubbish school. No matter how many choir medals it wins it is failing at the thing that’s really important.

You CAN sing without joining the formal school choir. You can sing at home. In your room, shower, lounge, car, backyard etc. It's not like the only option is school choir or never open your mouth to sing. School choirs, at least where I am, enter Eisteddfods. It is a formal actual school choir, not a lunch time school hobby which you seem to think it should be. OP's daughter can sing at home, it's not like she'll never be able to sing anywhere ever in her entire life!

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 14/05/2023 12:50

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:36

Think a lot of people on here don’t seem to understand that singing for pleasure should be an option for every child who would like to do it. Not singing competitively. Singing for pleasure. If the school can’t offer that to a child who would love to do it then it’s a pretty rubbish school. No matter how many choir medals it wins it is failing at the thing that’s really important.

Of course it would be lovely if schools could offer competitive and fun options for every extra-curricular activity, but in reality that's just not possible.

Who's going to fund all these clubs? Where are you going to find the staff and space to run them all? Who's going to pay for the extra electricity, the heating and all the running costs?

Eleganz · 14/05/2023 12:43

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:36

Think a lot of people on here don’t seem to understand that singing for pleasure should be an option for every child who would like to do it. Not singing competitively. Singing for pleasure. If the school can’t offer that to a child who would love to do it then it’s a pretty rubbish school. No matter how many choir medals it wins it is failing at the thing that’s really important.

And the funding for this comes from?

It is a fine ideal, but music for everyone is not funded properly in our education system. Would you say the same about a school that runs a football team rather than extra curricular football coaching for every single child in the school?

I would say that a choir that is auditioned is aiming for excellence in its singing, not inclusion therefore you can't dismiss it at failing at all as it's aims are different. Supporting children with a lot of talent in a certain area is no less important than giving all opportunity.

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:37

The same goes for sport.

If you only celebrate the winners, the only one celebrating will be the winner.

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:36

Think a lot of people on here don’t seem to understand that singing for pleasure should be an option for every child who would like to do it. Not singing competitively. Singing for pleasure. If the school can’t offer that to a child who would love to do it then it’s a pretty rubbish school. No matter how many choir medals it wins it is failing at the thing that’s really important.

Beebumble2 · 14/05/2023 12:33

I’ve not read all the posts, so sorry if lm being repetitive. Please give her all the encouragement you can and like others have said see if she’ll join a community performing club/ group.
When I was at secondary school, many moons ago, in our first music lesson we had to individually sing. My experience was similar to your daughters and I was made to feel shame. All my adult life I avoided singing, although I wished I could.
Seven years ago I very nervously joined a community choir with a marvellous director of music and with loads of encouragement, right teaching of breathing and voice control- I sang. Still not brave enough for a solo!

Famzonhol · 14/05/2023 12:31

electriclight · 14/05/2023 10:27

Don't go for something competitive that requires an audition if you're going to be sad about being rejected.

Plenty of 'everyone welcome' opportunities elsewhere im sure.

Where? You have to pay for it or travel to many of them. Out of reach for many children.

School is the one place where children should be able to try out things that interest them and be given a chance to learn and improve.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 14/05/2023 12:27

I mean... sorry but it is a choir. If she sounds like a foghorn or is totally out of tune/tone she could ruin the entire song.

Choirs have almost always been selective at schools. Would you consider getting her singing lessons?

Takoneko · 14/05/2023 12:26

nobody190 · 14/05/2023 11:14

It's a school choir for gods sake, they aren't going to be performing at the bloody opera house. They probably don't get many kids wanting to do it so the kids who want to and have a interest should be allowed to join. Schools encourage kids to join as many clubs as they like but to be knocked back is a kick in the teeth especially for year 7s when their still finding their feet and would of took a lot of courage.

There are a lot of assumptions there that could be way off. If there are auditions and some are rejected then clearly more people want to be in the choir than they have spaces for.
Our school choir has performed at the Royal Albert Hall on more than one occasion and there are plenty of other school choirs out there that do similar. We have huge numbers wanting to join in year 7 and there just aren’t spaces for all of them. If we let everyone who wanted to join be in the choir we’d have a choir of about 350… that’s just not manageable. I think they keep it to about 80 members, which is still a handful but means only 10-15 spaces for year 7 when 70-80 audition.

cestlavielife · 14/05/2023 12:18

tigerdrew · 14/05/2023 01:29

Most clubs at school are about improving, anyone can sign up for the netball or football clubs, not sure how the team things work but even if they are selected from the clubs, anyone can still do the clubs. So even if they wanted a choir to perform and be the best, they should surely have an option for the kids wanting to participate and improve, like they do for everything else. DD was just told no and that's that, no way for her to get to sing at all at school even though that's what she enjoys and is interested in. Does just seem unfair

Have her join a non audition saturday music school eg look at council run trusts and options.

Or stagecoach etyke musicql theatre saturday school.
Explain there are other options to (learn to ) sing. And the valuable skill is listening to herself and others. That can be learned.

Not being picked for choir is just that. A disappointment but not the end.
Move on and develop music skills elsewhere

twoshedsjackson · 14/05/2023 12:00

I think the key word is "audition"; I ran two choirs on that basis, plus everyone used their voices in class lessons which were part of the regular timetable, and it was clear that being one of the "crack troops" required more than enthusiasm. Three separate singing opportunities, but the chamber choir tackled far more demanding music. We entered competitive events, and they had to handle being beaten on the day by a better performance, and even when we did carry off the silverware, I would point out the winning aspects of our competitors - watch and learn!
I sometimes found myself commiserating with the teachers who ran sports teams; everyone had the chance to participate in class lessons, but when picking a squad for the tournament, they would pick the strongest players. Imagine for a moment being the player who affects the team's chances......other team members will be less than tactful.

Oopsididitagaintomorrow · 14/05/2023 11:38

My DD, 11, desperately wants to be an artist

Her drawings are very enthusiastic, but are not good.
She entered an art competition and didn't even get past the qualifying criteria, she was devastated

I told her she tried, she put in her best effort and she should be proud of that, like I am, and that sometimes there are people out there better at things than we are. Doesn't mean we give up, it means we try and take the knock backs to help us move forward

GingerCoi · 14/05/2023 11:24

Of course it's ok for her to cry and feel disappointed. I feel for the DD, but that doesn't mean that the school is in the wrong and that anyone should be able to join the choir.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 14/05/2023 11:19

electriclight · 14/05/2023 11:00

"Sadness and disappointment are normal, healthy human emotions. It's how you handle them that matters - do you kick off and refuse to ever apply for anything ever again, or do you have a cry, dust yourself off and try again?"

I do that last one. But I was referring to op's devastated child and op herself who questions the ethics of a school choir that selects on ability. If you can't cope - as opposed to building resilience, rising to the challenge etc - then don't do it. Because whining about the unfairness of it is ridiculous when you chose to enter the process.

But her DD is 11 - she's not going to have the resilience of a fully grown adult.

It's okay for her to cry and be disappointed about things - it doesn't mean she's ridiculous. It means she's a kid who's still learning how to cope with knockbacks and setbacks.

If she's never experienced rejection at school before (and it sounds like she hasn't), then she's not going to know how to cope with it, is she? It's something you learn with experience.

I agree that OP's reaction probably isn't helping but that's not the fault of the 11yo.