Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yet ANOTHER woman killed by a man

66 replies

tiredsofingtired · 13/05/2023 23:15

34 year old woman in Bournemouth.

31 year old arrested. (On suspicion)

Yesterday it was Suma Begum killed by her husband.

Literally wouldn't surprise me if there's another tomorrow.

So tired if this but we must not become desensitised to this.

Men need to stop killing women.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Usetherightgearforthehill · 16/05/2023 12:24

kettlebellchips · 16/05/2023 00:42

I’ll admit, I’m biased. I have two young boys and as I said, this attitude doesn’t sit well with me.

If a 20 year old woman is killed by her ex-boyfriend, it’s an awful awful crime and it should never happened. If, god forbid, one of my boys reach 20, and get stabbed and killed on a night out or in the city centre, I don’t think it would be less of a crime.

As for the claim that women can’t talk about crime on women, there’s a whole forum dedicated to feminism where this topic is discussed regularly.

There is a section on feminism where this topic is discussed regularly. And regularly posters (including one of the ones on this thread) pop up to minimise the issue, moan about how we don't talk about mens issues enough and try to stop the conversation. Its tiresome and predictable that women are not allowed to talk about women without being told to centre men in the discussion.

The posters who do kick up a fuss about us discussing women are often asked to start a thread that does centre men so that that can be discussed separately but for some reason they never do.

If God forbid anything ever happened to one of your boys, and I hope it doesn't, and you came to mumsnet to post about it then you would be right to be equally frustrated if the thread was over run by posters saying but what about women.

This is a thread about sorrow for women who have died and its turned into 'but men die too why aren't you talking about them instead'

MovinGroovinBarbie · 16/05/2023 07:30

OnSusansFloor · 16/05/2023 06:44

Yes, perhaps you're right. When I last looked at that thread it was pretty civil, so it was frustrating to see that it had been deleted. Sometimes I feel like the moderation here is quite controlling, but I guess I shouldn't have assumed that was the case with that thread - perhaps it took a racist turn during the night.

It was discussing the statistics that showed that asylum seekers account for significantly more sexual crimes than their representation in the population - e.g. 1% of the population in France but committing nearly 20% of serious sexual crimes including rape. And the 1200 sexual assaults in one night in Germany.

Uncomfortable reading but I found it interesting. Shying away from facts due to political correctness is how the trans situation has become so bonkers IMHO.

OnSusansFloor · 16/05/2023 06:44

Timesawastin · 15/05/2023 21:11

Too much racist garbage, I'm sure you meant to say 🙄

Yes, perhaps you're right. When I last looked at that thread it was pretty civil, so it was frustrating to see that it had been deleted. Sometimes I feel like the moderation here is quite controlling, but I guess I shouldn't have assumed that was the case with that thread - perhaps it took a racist turn during the night.

suburbophobe · 16/05/2023 01:38

Ds is year 9 at school, they had a talk from local community police officer last week on domestic violence. They covered controlling coercive behaviour, red flags etc.. This is part of how we have to tackle it, educating our young people.

I agree. Great to read this.

Nat6999 · 16/05/2023 01:32

There was a lady murdered by her partner in the block of flats I live in a few years ago. It was awful to see the police searching her flat & picking her life apart. I feel for any family who have to go through this

kettlebellchips · 16/05/2023 00:43

Aah, typos and grammatical errors!

kettlebellchips · 16/05/2023 00:42

Ktime · 15/05/2023 18:46

Come back when 97% of killers are women, not men.

I’ll admit, I’m biased. I have two young boys and as I said, this attitude doesn’t sit well with me.

If a 20 year old woman is killed by her ex-boyfriend, it’s an awful awful crime and it should never happened. If, god forbid, one of my boys reach 20, and get stabbed and killed on a night out or in the city centre, I don’t think it would be less of a crime.

As for the claim that women can’t talk about crime on women, there’s a whole forum dedicated to feminism where this topic is discussed regularly.

Floralie · 15/05/2023 22:09

Sockloon · 15/05/2023 19:40

🙄So how many lives do you suggest would be saved, by men calling other men out.

Do you think some one intent on murdering another human being is going to stop because another chap said its not a nice thing to do FGS.

And yet there are plenty of examples where men even had nicknames at work like 'the rapist', 'the bastard' and yet no one said anything. I would take a wild guess that men who kill their partners have shown snippets of who they are beforehand, it often escalates from other behaviours. There is also the fact that a lot is societal and takes all men to help eradicate it.

littleripper · 15/05/2023 21:33

onefinemess · 15/05/2023 09:32

The 0.0001% of men who kill women need to stop.

There, fixed it for you OP.

32 million men in the UK. Rounded up figure of 170 women killed by men each year since 2009. Times x10 for the past decade is 1700.

So yeah, 99.999% of men don't kill women.

And the men who do, don't generally advertise the fact before hand, so the "good men" can't "call out bad behaviour".

Not all men murder women, but almost every woman that is murdered by a man.

How's that for you?

Conkersinautumn · 15/05/2023 21:31

Men who murder women don't generally murder first. There's usually a patterns and signs that they are dysfunctional and it escalates so saying oh not all men, no no it's ONLY rare it's only x y z means women are silenced. Crimes are not taken seriously as the man "only" exposed himself, "only" lashed out etc etc. "Only" got in a fight. Etc etc. Until a woman is dead and THEN everyone focuses on why didn't she say etc etc and blame the women. Again snd again the women blazers talk about how rare, how unlikely these poor mens are misunderstood etc. I actually feel sick when I see these minimising posts. Someone has you on a very tight leash. It's male violence, its deliberate and it never ends.

Timesawastin · 15/05/2023 21:11

OnSusansFloor · 15/05/2023 10:10

Too many posts that violated the censorship rules talk guidelines, apparently

Too much racist garbage, I'm sure you meant to say 🙄

Panteranoir · 15/05/2023 21:06

jeffgoldblum · 15/05/2023 18:55

What the bloody hell has this extensive load of old cobblers have to do with this poor woman being murdered?
And bold to presume all the women reacting to this terrible crime are all feminists!
Women are allowed to discuss women's issues without centering and prioritising men's feelings and egos !

Yeah it was one hell of a leap from yet another poor woman being murdered at the hands of a male abuser to well women are basically privileged and men do al the hard work anyway and it's al the feminists fault.

Old cobblers is spot on.

Usetherightgearforthehill · 15/05/2023 20:45

Sissynova · 15/05/2023 20:27

Why? It was a very calm and balanced post.
Silencing perfectly appropriate comments just because you don’t agree is not a route to aim for.

Because they want to talk about men when we are talking about women. The only people trying to silence people are the posters who are insistent that we are doing wrong by not talking about male suicide or violence against men by men in every frigging thread about violence against women.

It would be nice to have just one thread where posters didn't actually try to silence conversations about women tbh

Sissynova · 15/05/2023 20:27

PainfulAnkles · 15/05/2023 18:37

Perhaps you should join male support/acticist/rights group barbie, since you’re always so passionate about male rights and what their going through.
It could be usefull for the men and you. We’d also would be much happier to hear less from you 😌

Why? It was a very calm and balanced post.
Silencing perfectly appropriate comments just because you don’t agree is not a route to aim for.

SpringIntoChaos · 15/05/2023 20:23

onefinemess · 15/05/2023 09:32

The 0.0001% of men who kill women need to stop.

There, fixed it for you OP.

32 million men in the UK. Rounded up figure of 170 women killed by men each year since 2009. Times x10 for the past decade is 1700.

So yeah, 99.999% of men don't kill women.

And the men who do, don't generally advertise the fact before hand, so the "good men" can't "call out bad behaviour".

The word you are looking for is MURDERED! So here, I'll 'fix it' for you...

'1700 women, who should STILL BE ALIVE, have been murdered in the UK by men in the past decade!'

HTH 👍

Usetherightgearforthehill · 15/05/2023 20:18

MovinGroovinBarbie · 15/05/2023 18:18

Male violence is a big issue but I'm not really sure feminists help by trying to frame women as the main victims. It distracts from what could be perhaps the biggest incentive for men to stand together and sort it out - the fact it has a huge impact on them as a demographic.

I also agree with the posters saying that people tend to view men as less innocent - basically what people call victim blaming. This is usually done by lumping all men together so that if they dare speak out on their experiences people will say "stop moaning, you're a bloke. It's you guys that are responsible."

As I said in another recent thread, this group culpability doesn't really hold up. You can try and lump men into a big homogenous group but they can't simultaneously be the victim and the perpetrator. It's ludicrous to expect a gay male to be culpable for the violence visited on him by a homophobic thug. Or a black male to be responsible for racist violence against himself from white police officers. It's also probably quite pointless talking to Eton schoolboys about knife crime in Hackney, or white middle class accountants about radical Islamic violence.

Violence against men is always dismissed. We hear a lot about the two women a week but nothing about the 80 men a week who kill themselves. If it's mentioned the first reply is always that 'women attempt it more'.

However, this line of reasoning seems to usually be employed selectively because when we talk about women being murdered nobody ever points out that in 70% of cases involving one sided violence the women is the perpetrator. What matters is the severity, the fact that women are actually dying. But when it comes to male suicide it's all about the frequency of attempts, not the fact that 40x more men are killing themselves weekly than are killing women.

But usually you won't even get that far because somebody will say "as feminists we focus on women, not men". I've never understood this attitude. How can you focus on gender equality but only care about one sex? Personally I'd never respond to somebody talking about racism with something like "as a white person I prioritise white people's problems, not black people."

I think what gets me going is when feminists claim to be focused on women rather than men but then invest loads of effort proclaiming how much worse off they are and how comparatively easy men have it. It's like starting a big campaign to tackle police violence against white males. It wouldn't take long for people to point out that black males have it much worse. Imagine then telling POC to pipe down because it's not all about them.

And I don't get all these white middle class university educated women who moan on about the evil straight white males. These are literally the men they usually end up marrying and creating more straight white males with.

These women are second in privilege only to their husbands, and many end up being facilitated in working part time long after the kids have grown up, with the man shouldering the mental load of being the main breadwinner whilst being told by feminists he's the privileged one for being able to have the career. I'd much rather be going to the gym and working in an easy job than having a load of corporate stress, especially if the money is shared and I still benefit from my husband's great privilege of breaking his back until 65yo (by which time many women won't have worked full time for 35 years!).

Obv we also have a lot of disadvantages inherent to our sex too, but everybody already knows and acknowledges these in a way that men's problems rarely are.

Male violence is a big issue but I'm not really sure feminists help by trying to frame women as the main victims. It distracts from what could be perhaps the biggest incentive for men to stand together and sort it out - the fact it has a huge impact on them as a demographic.

So basically you are trying to say that we have to incentivise men to stop killing women by making it about them? I mean you probably aren't wrong but maybe men could make it about them, they are pretty good doing that after all, and women could just have a little space to make it about themselves. Also this is a thread in AIBU not feminist. It's likely a lot of the posters are feminists, but not necessarily all of them so why are you blaming feminists for 'framing the problem wrong by centering women"

Violence against men is always dismissed. We hear a lot about the two women a week but nothing about the 80 men a week who kill themselves

Oh we do, we hear about it in almost all threads about male violence. What you seem to be missing is that the two things are probably connected and fixing one might fix the other. Also again, why can women not have a space to talk about things affecting women without having to include men. Because the thing I have never seen is in spaces where men are discussing male suicide, men being berated for not talking about things affecting women.

But usually you won't even get that far because somebody will say "as feminists we focus on women, not men". I've never understood this attitude. How can you focus on gender equality but only care about one sex? Personally I'd never respond to somebody talking about racism with something like "as a white person I prioritise white people's problems, not black people."

I actually had a man explain this really well to me last week. It's about centering the people who are most affected by a problem. No one says 'black lives matter' because they believe all lives don't matter. They say black lives matter because black people are the ones impacted. And you seem to be equating the position women are in to the position white people are in. They reality is in many ways women do not have full equality. Therefore in your badly drawn analogy it would be more accurate to say when discussing racism 'as a black person I prioritise black people's problems not white peoples'. Do you still have a problem with that?

It's like starting a big campaign to tackle police violence against white males. It wouldn't take long for people to point out that black males have it much worse. Imagine then telling POC to pipe down because it's not all about them.

It's like starting a big campaign to tackle police attitudes to domestic violence against women. It wouldn't take long for people to point out that men have it much worse. Imagine then telling women to pipe down because its not all about them. Oh wait no, you don't have to imagine that you just did it.

And I don't get all these white middle class university educated women who moan on about the evil straight white males. These are literally the men they usually end up marrying and creating more straight white males with.

Can you point to the proof that we are all white middle class university educated women please? I for example am a mixed race working class woman. I am university educated. I am first generation university educated and my grandmother was a prostitute so I've don't pretty well. I'm not sure how that means I'm not allowed to have an opinion on male violence especially given my university education didn't stop me from being in an abusive relationship when I was at uni.

These women are second in privilege only to their husbands, and many end up being facilitated in working part time long after the kids have grown up, with the man shouldering the mental load of being the main breadwinner whilst being told by feminists he's the privileged one for being able to have the career. I'd much rather be going to the gym and working in an easy job than having a load of corporate stress, especially if the money is shared and I still benefit from my husband's great privilege of breaking his back until 65yo (by which time many women won't have worked full time for 35 years!).

Shut up and put up because some women work part time? No thanks.

Obv we also have a lot of disadvantages inherent to our sex too, but everybody already knows and acknowledges these in a way that men's problems rarely are.

And one of those disadvantages means that men are more likely to kill us than we are to kill them. We have a right to talk about those. If men don't want to talk about their problems women don't have to stop talking about theirs. We aren't all over pistol heads telling men not to talk about suicide because women get raped. The only people trying to stop anyone talking about their problems are people like you

Usetherightgearforthehill · 15/05/2023 20:02

onefinemess · 15/05/2023 09:32

The 0.0001% of men who kill women need to stop.

There, fixed it for you OP.

32 million men in the UK. Rounded up figure of 170 women killed by men each year since 2009. Times x10 for the past decade is 1700.

So yeah, 99.999% of men don't kill women.

And the men who do, don't generally advertise the fact before hand, so the "good men" can't "call out bad behaviour".

Then after that you can add in the men who beat women but don't get to the point of killing them. Or the ones who financially or emotionally abuse women. The ones who rape, or sexually assault. Then the ones who sexually harass women. The flashers. The men who prey on single women with children so they can abuse the children.

But sure not all men of course. Mustn't forget to add that just in case.

You didnt fix anything for the OP despite your patronising little sentence. The OP said nothing wrong

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 15/05/2023 19:51

A woman I know was told repeatedly by her husband that he wouldn't kill her.

Because if he did he would no longer be able to batter her on an almost daily basis.

Thankfully she managed to escape a couple of years ago.

PainfulAnkles · 15/05/2023 19:45

pigsDOfly · 15/05/2023 19:31

How does a thread about yet another woman being killed at the hands of a man turn so rapidly into a thread about how many men are killed at the hands of other men?

Because women’s rights and violence againts women is forbidden.

Don’t you know, everything is about men.
Why won’t anyone think of the men?!?!?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/05/2023 19:42

Ktime · 15/05/2023 09:57

Anyone know why the Suna Begum thread was deleted?

Because it degenerated into cut and paste jobs all saying pretty much that only Muslim men kill women.

Sockloon · 15/05/2023 19:40

🙄So how many lives do you suggest would be saved, by men calling other men out.

Do you think some one intent on murdering another human being is going to stop because another chap said its not a nice thing to do FGS.

pigsDOfly · 15/05/2023 19:31

How does a thread about yet another woman being killed at the hands of a man turn so rapidly into a thread about how many men are killed at the hands of other men?

purpleboy · 15/05/2023 19:15

JFC moovin
All that twaddle and you could've just said "the poor menz"

Seriously though coming onto a thread about MVAW and talking about male suicide stats or Eton boys is so depressing. Go and start a thread about those topics if your so passionate about them, leave the rest of us who give a shit about these murdered women alone to keep raising awareness.

jeffgoldblum · 15/05/2023 18:55

MovinGroovinBarbie · 15/05/2023 18:18

Male violence is a big issue but I'm not really sure feminists help by trying to frame women as the main victims. It distracts from what could be perhaps the biggest incentive for men to stand together and sort it out - the fact it has a huge impact on them as a demographic.

I also agree with the posters saying that people tend to view men as less innocent - basically what people call victim blaming. This is usually done by lumping all men together so that if they dare speak out on their experiences people will say "stop moaning, you're a bloke. It's you guys that are responsible."

As I said in another recent thread, this group culpability doesn't really hold up. You can try and lump men into a big homogenous group but they can't simultaneously be the victim and the perpetrator. It's ludicrous to expect a gay male to be culpable for the violence visited on him by a homophobic thug. Or a black male to be responsible for racist violence against himself from white police officers. It's also probably quite pointless talking to Eton schoolboys about knife crime in Hackney, or white middle class accountants about radical Islamic violence.

Violence against men is always dismissed. We hear a lot about the two women a week but nothing about the 80 men a week who kill themselves. If it's mentioned the first reply is always that 'women attempt it more'.

However, this line of reasoning seems to usually be employed selectively because when we talk about women being murdered nobody ever points out that in 70% of cases involving one sided violence the women is the perpetrator. What matters is the severity, the fact that women are actually dying. But when it comes to male suicide it's all about the frequency of attempts, not the fact that 40x more men are killing themselves weekly than are killing women.

But usually you won't even get that far because somebody will say "as feminists we focus on women, not men". I've never understood this attitude. How can you focus on gender equality but only care about one sex? Personally I'd never respond to somebody talking about racism with something like "as a white person I prioritise white people's problems, not black people."

I think what gets me going is when feminists claim to be focused on women rather than men but then invest loads of effort proclaiming how much worse off they are and how comparatively easy men have it. It's like starting a big campaign to tackle police violence against white males. It wouldn't take long for people to point out that black males have it much worse. Imagine then telling POC to pipe down because it's not all about them.

And I don't get all these white middle class university educated women who moan on about the evil straight white males. These are literally the men they usually end up marrying and creating more straight white males with.

These women are second in privilege only to their husbands, and many end up being facilitated in working part time long after the kids have grown up, with the man shouldering the mental load of being the main breadwinner whilst being told by feminists he's the privileged one for being able to have the career. I'd much rather be going to the gym and working in an easy job than having a load of corporate stress, especially if the money is shared and I still benefit from my husband's great privilege of breaking his back until 65yo (by which time many women won't have worked full time for 35 years!).

Obv we also have a lot of disadvantages inherent to our sex too, but everybody already knows and acknowledges these in a way that men's problems rarely are.

What the bloody hell has this extensive load of old cobblers have to do with this poor woman being murdered?
And bold to presume all the women reacting to this terrible crime are all feminists!
Women are allowed to discuss women's issues without centering and prioritising men's feelings and egos !