Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not paying for extra curricular activities when DD is 18?

84 replies

tyrhes · 13/05/2023 20:56

Hi DD is 18 and has done swimming since she was a toddler and I have obviously always paid for swimming related things and still do, such as her membership, etc. I have no problem paying for this until she finishes sixth form and starts doing whatever it is she decides to do after her education. We are not a high income family and if she goes to uni, she will be entitled to the maximum loan. We will obviously try to help where we can but it really couldn't be any more than what we currently spend on her, etc, so swimming could potentially still be included if she doesn't need that money elsewhere, etc. if she even still wants to.

She has recently wanted to start a martial art though (while we are at it, any best ideas for which one for her as she isn't sure?) but I personally think any new thing she wants to do now really isnt my responsibility? Obviously I don't mean that in a horrible way but even when she was younger and we were tight for money that month, it felt my duty to still ensure she could do extra curricular activities and never really miss out of things her peers did, that kind of stuff doesn't really feel my responsibility now she is 18 but truthfully, morally, should it be? Especially while she is still in sixth form? Thing is, she will obviously be leaving sixth form very soon and as it's a new activity, I feel it also falls out that bracket.

She doesn't have a job and obviously again to clarify, that's not a problem with me, she is in school but if it comes to her wanting things now, I do think she should start thinking about potentially funding them herself.

Is this completely unreasonable?

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 15/05/2023 10:04

My son is a musician and I paid for his piano lessons and youth theatre/NYMT fees (he dropped his singing lessons to concentrate on his other stuff) until the August just before he went to university. In his case he now gets them free as part of his degree but anything else he does he pays for himself. He didn't work last summer partly due to his commitments with NYMT but the contacts he made there have since got him other paid work. He has lots of work lined up for this summer

He did get a place this year with NYMT and we did agree to fund his fees for that as it is quit special, but he will fund his travel & other expenses for it.

His friend who is currently on a gap year and working funds all his own drum lessons etc although his nan helped pay for some extra ones in the run up to his uni auditions.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/05/2023 10:03

Skilled work like lifeguard or swim teacher is £20 a hour near up (north) and very in demand.
Students with a hobby then can monetise often do very well. DD’s friend gets over £100 for refereeing football on Saturday am.
A household income of under £25,000 will mean things very tight. Mum is paying everything at minute.

BatFaceOwl · 15/05/2023 09:56

I would pay for this no problem but then my income would allow it

If my income didn't allow it I would encourage her to get a small job - just an 8 hour a week shift in sainsburys would pay the best part of £90 a week as they pay staff the same hourly rate whether you're 17 or 70 - and that would more than cover it for her

Madickenxx · 15/05/2023 09:53

Sounds like a perfect opportunity to encourage a summer job to pay for her new hobby. If it was me, I'd probably offer to pay for a few weeks to see if she takes to it and then expect her to fund it on an ongoing basis. Everyone's different but from my experience having a part time job gave my children more financial freedom as well as a broader perspective on life (working with people of different ages / walks of life) and it was 100% beneficial for them. I pay for my 18 year old's mobile and that's it, she pays for everything else including weekly jiujitsu classes.

Bunnycat101 · 15/05/2023 09:36

It’s sensible to wait until university anyway as she might be able to join a society and learn cheaply but also realistically starting something new while she’s in the middle of exams doesn’t seem that sensible and it may be that even if she finds a class it might stop for the summer.

From what you’ve said re family income, she should really be thinking about a summer job especially if she can find one that turns into a job she can do while a student. A lot of posters have mentioned lifeguards but swim teachers are also massively in demand. If she’s with a club can she pick up coaching. One of my daughter’s swim teachers is a student and she’s brilliant. Sadly now coming to the end of her degree but it sounds like it’s been a great job for her re something that fits around her studies and pays pretty well.

Nononononoyes · 15/05/2023 08:04

I don’t understand why an 18 year old doesn’t have a job. We are a very high income family and my 16 DS has worked since he received his NI number.

Kokopenny · 15/05/2023 07:00

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/05/2023 02:56

And why on earth would you not want to contribute to the safety of your dd (re martial arts)
I would pay for that and eat dry bread if i had to.

Because she might struggle to afford it and DD is 18 and can pay for it herself

OctaviaPole · 15/05/2023 03:11

My kids do karate and classes are cheap. £4 for 90 minutes. The outfits are readily available second hand. If you can't afford it though then she'll need a job. She could easily teach swimming which has an hourly rate far in excess of most 18 year olds. I would investigate any qualifications she needs to teach swimming because it could be a great sideline for her over the next few years.

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/05/2023 02:56

And why on earth would you not want to contribute to the safety of your dd (re martial arts)
I would pay for that and eat dry bread if i had to.

SparklyBlackKitten · 15/05/2023 02:55

Bit harsh imo

MrsAvocet · 15/05/2023 02:19

Assuming she is about to do her A levels I would say that new hobbies need to wait until those are out of the way. Then maybe she can get a holiday job to fund it. Plus if she is going to University in the Autumn might it not be more sensible to wait until she is there and sees what clubs are available? If she picks a particular thing now and finds there isn't a University society she could of course find an outside provider but University clubs are usually cheaper, plus it would be a good way to make friends with other students.

Murdoch1949 · 15/05/2023 02:12

I'd be encouraging her to take up a martial art, and paying for it, she's going to be living alone in a city soon, anything to help her feel safer!

Spanielsarepainless · 14/05/2023 19:33

Another vote for a part-time job. In sixth form I worked in a kennels and my best friend served in a baker's shop on Saturdays. Mine funded my sailing.

LynetteScavo · 14/05/2023 16:08

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 14/05/2023 15:06

Pretty much every uni I've come across has societies for martial arts with free taster sessions. Membership is very cheap!

She should wait until she goes to uni, sign up to the mailing lists at freshers fair, try some taster sessions then pick one which she pays for out of her student loan.

I just checked out the uni DD is going to - they have a Women's Self Defense Society. It's free. I shall be suggesting it to DD.

AllegraWalterJones · 14/05/2023 16:06

Also OP do you live in an area with loads of options? There's no point in any of us suggesting things that don't exist.
The atmosphere of the coach (and gym itself) is more important than the type of sport, so have a look and see what's available, then we can help you narrow it down.

AllegraWalterJones · 14/05/2023 16:04

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 15:13

But this is a scenario that you've completely made up. It's martial arts, probably not that expensive, and brilliant for teenage girls. The OP doesn't make it clear whether she actually can't afford it, in which case there was very little point in starting the thread, or whether she feels she shouldn't have to, in which case she'll be in good company on here.

Household income for full loan is under 25K. Most people are capable of joining the dots and don't need the OP to say 'I can't afford it' in big neon letters.
Especially as she refers to being tight on money, but making sure her daughter doesn't miss out.

Kokopenny · 14/05/2023 15:47

Must be nice to have the choice not to work at 18

Dixiechickonhols · 14/05/2023 15:32

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 15:01

Fucking hell. Yes definitely more important to be a wage slave immediately rather than having any fun in life.

It’s unusual not to work at all at 18 especially if household money tight. Household income is under £25,000 if girl will qualify for a full loan.
Plenty of time for study and hobbies plus a few hours a week. Lifeguarding I mentioned earlier is very indemand and can pay really well.
The girl will be finished in a month for 3 months if she’s going to uni. Not unreasonable to expect her to work for some of that time to fund her fun and hobbies. I doubt mum has money for ‘fun’ on such a low income.

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 15:14

UndercoverCop · 14/05/2023 15:06

@Harkonen it's possible to do both. I had to work my parents didn't earn much more than minimum wage, I couldn't exactly ask them to find my travelling, holidays, car, socialising etc. I always really enjoyed working back then whilst studying, lots of fun to be had working in bars and restaurants and the social life that comes with it.
If the OPs DD is eligible for full loan the household income is very low, but sure they should pay for her to take up a new hobby on a whim at 18...

Of course it's possible to do both- all my dcs have done this. The post I was referring to said she she get a job, not a hobby.

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 15:13

Liorae · 14/05/2023 15:10

That poster would obviously remortgage the house. One must sacrifice for ones children's hobbies and whims.

But this is a scenario that you've completely made up. It's martial arts, probably not that expensive, and brilliant for teenage girls. The OP doesn't make it clear whether she actually can't afford it, in which case there was very little point in starting the thread, or whether she feels she shouldn't have to, in which case she'll be in good company on here.

Liorae · 14/05/2023 15:10

LookOutBandits · 13/05/2023 22:12

What if it was expensive like skiing or horse riding or she needed a grand piano and it was stretching your family finances?

That poster would obviously remortgage the house. One must sacrifice for ones children's hobbies and whims.

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 14/05/2023 15:06

Pretty much every uni I've come across has societies for martial arts with free taster sessions. Membership is very cheap!

She should wait until she goes to uni, sign up to the mailing lists at freshers fair, try some taster sessions then pick one which she pays for out of her student loan.

UndercoverCop · 14/05/2023 15:06

@Harkonen it's possible to do both. I had to work my parents didn't earn much more than minimum wage, I couldn't exactly ask them to find my travelling, holidays, car, socialising etc. I always really enjoyed working back then whilst studying, lots of fun to be had working in bars and restaurants and the social life that comes with it.
If the OPs DD is eligible for full loan the household income is very low, but sure they should pay for her to take up a new hobby on a whim at 18...

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 15:01

Lcb123 · 14/05/2023 14:55

Definitely don’t pay. Can’t believe she’s 18 and doesn’t have a job - that should be a priority before new hobbies

Fucking hell. Yes definitely more important to be a wage slave immediately rather than having any fun in life.

UndercoverCop · 14/05/2023 15:01

Why isn't she working? I worked as soon as I had my NI number, low income family. I also went to uni. If she plans to go she may as well wait until she does to pick up a new sport, most will have a huge variety of clubs and they are much cheaper than those based in the community. She may also find it more fun to try out different sports with friends/housemates. I rowed coxed 4s at uni, wouldn't have been able to do that on the estate I grew up on!
If she's not going to uni, she still needs to get a job, part time while she's studying and full time after and she needs to pay for her own hobbies.
I always give bar and waitressing work plentiful and waitressing you also got tips.

If money were no issue and you wanted to, you could continue to fund whilst she is in education, but if she will get maximum loan it clearly isn't. She needs to start supporting herself a bit more.