Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not paying for extra curricular activities when DD is 18?

84 replies

tyrhes · 13/05/2023 20:56

Hi DD is 18 and has done swimming since she was a toddler and I have obviously always paid for swimming related things and still do, such as her membership, etc. I have no problem paying for this until she finishes sixth form and starts doing whatever it is she decides to do after her education. We are not a high income family and if she goes to uni, she will be entitled to the maximum loan. We will obviously try to help where we can but it really couldn't be any more than what we currently spend on her, etc, so swimming could potentially still be included if she doesn't need that money elsewhere, etc. if she even still wants to.

She has recently wanted to start a martial art though (while we are at it, any best ideas for which one for her as she isn't sure?) but I personally think any new thing she wants to do now really isnt my responsibility? Obviously I don't mean that in a horrible way but even when she was younger and we were tight for money that month, it felt my duty to still ensure she could do extra curricular activities and never really miss out of things her peers did, that kind of stuff doesn't really feel my responsibility now she is 18 but truthfully, morally, should it be? Especially while she is still in sixth form? Thing is, she will obviously be leaving sixth form very soon and as it's a new activity, I feel it also falls out that bracket.

She doesn't have a job and obviously again to clarify, that's not a problem with me, she is in school but if it comes to her wanting things now, I do think she should start thinking about potentially funding them herself.

Is this completely unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
toobusymummy · 18/05/2023 11:39

this is absolutely the age where you need to start teaching her about money responsibility. Its time to crack out the income and expenditure form (google income expenditure free pdf) and have her work through what her expenses are going to be and what income she gets from grants etc and what is the fixed amount you are able to give her each month (don't break it down at this point, if you can afford a total of £100, that's the amount of 'income' she can add to the form). Now if the expenditure is greater than the income SHE needs to decide what SHE can cut back on or how SHE can add additional income - this is singularly THE most important life lesson you can give your child as they move into adulthood and they will be so much the better for it - I work in financial services and I have to say, if someone (ANYONE) had done this for the vast majority of adults at 18 and shown them what it ACTUALLY means to be financially responsible a good number of adults would have significantly less student and/or personal debt!

UsingChangeofName · 17/05/2023 19:07

I agree re student finance @Comefromaway

Hankunamatata · 17/05/2023 15:26

I think it's fine to say uou can't afford it.

Cyb3rg4l · 17/05/2023 15:24

I would encourage her to try new things but point out clothing and activities for new activities are expensive before you even get to the ongoing costs of classes, travel to events etc. If you want to go the extra mile do a spreadsheet that sets out anticipated expenses over the year. This will also help you be clear about what the cost is likely to be. You could then help her look at ways to earn money to meet the expenses either at home or through part-time work (life skills!) or if she is planning to go to University point out she could wait, concentrate on her studies now, and start her new interest at university at a very subsidised cost through Uni societies when it would also be a great opportunity to make new friends. Whilst we all want to do the best for our children it’s a hard truth that we have to parent within our means. Your daughter is almost an adult now And planning and budgeting are the next skills she needs for her development.

MakesMeFeelSad · 17/05/2023 07:21

I think a 18 if you can't afford a new hobby then she needs to get a job and pay for it herself

mainsfed · 17/05/2023 07:01

She needs to get a job and pay for her hobbies.

Copasetic · 17/05/2023 06:55

Harkonen · 14/05/2023 08:50

I've got enough money to pay for a hobby for my kids, yes, even though mumsnet assume it's every woman for herself once kids hit 18.

Dd2 is at uni and I've paid her sports club fees for the past two years. I have strong feelings about girls, sport and the links with good mental health though, it's important to me and I scrimp in other ways to pay for it. Obviously if you can't afford it you can't afford it.

I totally agree. Mine is second year at uni and does classes with the dance society. I’m very happy to pay for that and also paid for various classes (and instrument and singing lessons) during her gap year right up to going to uni. My financial commitment to her will end when she finishes education and starts working.

Agapornis · 17/05/2023 01:18

Re what to choose: I love jujitsu (Japanese not Brazilian). You learn to wrestle, strike, kick, strangle, use weapons, and do kata - most other martial arts only allow some of those. It's fairly cheap - a basic gi is £20-30 (the white pyjamas - about a tenner second hand, or message me if you're near London, I have small spares) and you don't need one initially. £25 annual insurance fee, £30/month student rate for up to 5 classes a week. That'd be £1.38 per 2 hour class if I actually went that often!

But I love the teachers and club first and foremost. I've previously enjoyed judo, but the teacher changed and it was shit. So shop around, if you like the first class, take the max amount of classes before you officially need to join (usually 3 classes). The first one should be free. Be mindful that if she moves from one club to another, they might not teach the exact same syllabus.

One warning: Some teachers make up their own bullshito - they may run a black belt factory aka McDojo. Avoid the cultist 'the teacher is always right" approach. There's an Instagram account, McDojoLife, that shows examples and explains what to look out for.

Finally... If she chooses a white gi sport, perhaps you could treat her to a good pair of period pants 😅

Comefromaway · 17/05/2023 01:01

its important to remember also it is household income so that includes new partners.

Comefromaway · 17/05/2023 00:59

Yes, I am pretty knowledgable about student finance. Had you not looked up the income scales to get an idea of what you might get.

Assuming it’s the most common live away from home outside London next year & the student is from England A family with an income of under £25,000 per annum will get the maximum loan. This is what I would call being on a limited income. I know quite a lot of families who live on between £25-35k.

A family with an income of £62,000 (which is not what I would call a limited income) will only get minimum loan.

(all figures are before tax/NI)

OP Has said her daughter will get the maximum, hence I assume she has looked up the scales or put her figures into one of the online calculators.

Hummingbird10 · 17/05/2023 00:42

I doubt that very much. I’m just suggesting caution as my daughter was shocked when she saw how little she got. Her dad died when she was six and there is no one else to help her. She’s worked since she wss 16. Unless you are an expert on student finance , in which case I would love to speak with you, then I suggest caution in giving advice. I assure you I have a limited income.

Comefromaway · 17/05/2023 00:37

Hummingbird10 · 16/05/2023 23:29

There is no guarantee OP’s child will get the maximum loan. I don’t earn much amd my daughter got the minimum loan. She works in a pub to supplement uni.

If your household income isn’t “much” but she gets the minimum then your definition of much is very different to mine.

paulthepython · 16/05/2023 23:44

We were probably similar family circumstances to yourselves and by 18 I certainly didnt expect my parents to pay for my hobbies. They still treated me a lot and were very giving of time and energy but I wouldn't have expected anything more. When I realised I needed money I got a job. There's no reason she can't work a part time job while studying, I started at college and worked (different jobs) all through uni and think it was a great life experience and invaluable in instilling an understanding and respect for value. My advice would be to praise the hobby, drive her there but don't fund it. And speak about her earning some spending money as a separate thing then it's up to her what she does with it.

Checkmymoves · 16/05/2023 23:42

My dd is yr12 and has been swimming since a toddler also. If your dd swims competitively then I know the commitment form both of you over the years - you'vw supported her massively! Competitive swimming is an expensive sport, my dd trains 12hrs per week (and then there's kit, travel etc).
At her age she needs to be contributing and appreciating what things cost. My dd did her lifeguard training for £250 as soon as she hit 16 and gets paid 12 p/h. Before that she worked in a cafe to pay for any extras she wants. She knows I will support her but also has a sense of responsibility for herself. Swimming or any sport is great for discipline and mental health but whims are a different matter - if she really wants to give a martial art a go then she will go the extra mile and get a job to make that happen. See if she does.

Hummingbird10 · 16/05/2023 23:29

There is no guarantee OP’s child will get the maximum loan. I don’t earn much amd my daughter got the minimum loan. She works in a pub to supplement uni.

UsingChangeofName · 16/05/2023 21:45

Presumably, if she is 18, then she is in Yr13, so has 6 weeks of revising for, and sitting exams - so clearly not the best time to start a new hobby - and then will have 10 - 12 weeks when she can go out and earn her own money. she then can choose whether to save this / use it for something like driving lessons / put it aside for University if she plans to go / work for a shorter length of time and spend it on a holiday / or use it to start a new hobby.

If she is hoping to go away to University, it would seem an odd time to start a club / hobby at home though.

Of course you shouldn't be expecting to fund hobbies and interests once she is an adult.

If she's been swimming all her life though, she is presumably of a standard where she could do a lifeguard course and earn quite well across the Summer. Potentially even going on to do swimming teaching, which will earn her even more.

Imisssleep2 · 16/05/2023 20:59

Completely reasonable, if she wants to start a new hobby at this age, she can get a job and fund it herself. When i was 14 i had a pony which my mum paid for, i wanted a second one and i was told at 14 if i wamted another i would have to pay for his stable rent myself, so i got a job at the local stables on a Saturday, more in holidays, and that paid for my second horse. Taught me the value of money too.

Katey83 · 16/05/2023 11:18

If you can’t afford it, you can’t afford it! That’s your answer. I would
it break the bank for an 18 year old to try something new (and martial arts can be expensive, there’s classes, licences, uniform, completions, gradings etc. how much of this are you committing to paying for, and for how long?)

I think you should also start getting DD to think about a part time job for now and while she is at uni. This will help her begin having some financial independence, and freedom to pick up new hobbies without having to rely on you. It was 20 years ago but I worked through A’levels and all my university degrees up to PhD level. I have definitely found a broad experience of the workplace from mid-teens to be beneficial in many ways as I’ve progressed through life. I used to love working as a teen as it made me feel grown up and responsible for my own stuff.

If she is going to uni, there are likely to be subsidised sports societies where she can try out martial arts a lot more cheaply than at a local club. So perhaps the answer is she waits until she starts uni to try this new hobby.

Fraaahnces · 16/05/2023 04:06

Sounds like she needs to learn the difference between a want and a need. She wants to do a new hobby? She needs to get a job to pay for it.

MintJulia · 16/05/2023 03:55

As soon as her exams are over she needs to get a part time job, there are plenty around, and start helping with money. Good practice at budgeting too.

Mustardforest · 16/05/2023 03:41

Teaching teenagers the value of money and work is a great lesson, and doesn't mean you're unsupportive.

Example, I was encouraged to get a part-time job (literally one 4hr shift a week) to pay for my increasing love of cinema and expensive DVDs back in the day as a 17yo. It helped me learn to budget and appreciate the money so much more than simply being handed a twenty pound note I didn't earn.

Always been grateful that my mother taught me the value of money and how great it feels to enjoy things you've earned. Friends around me (early thirties now) who got given everything on a plate are still awful with money, in overdrafts, can't budget etc, and still get handouts from parents even with decent jobs.

And as an 18yo, your DD should understand :)

Doone21 · 15/05/2023 22:38

Why you still paying for swimming? I mean she can swim well enough by now. If she wants a new hobby switch the money to her new hobby or stop paying for any of them.
Judo is nice but pulls your hair. Thai boxing hurts and makes your shins swell up. Jujitsu is a good mix, that's all the ones I know.

Comefromaway · 15/05/2023 10:30

It cost ds's friend a lot (well over £1,000) to do his lifeguard training but the local leisure centre paid for it on condition he worked 1 day a week plus summer holidays for 2 years.

Dobby123456 · 15/05/2023 10:28

As it's so late in the year, I'd suggest sye wait a few months and join a student class at uni. Personally, I would pay for sports/hobbies until they leave school. Then there's so many free/subsidised activities at uni I'd not expect to pay at that stage.

Harkonen · 15/05/2023 10:05

Bunnycat101 · 15/05/2023 09:36

It’s sensible to wait until university anyway as she might be able to join a society and learn cheaply but also realistically starting something new while she’s in the middle of exams doesn’t seem that sensible and it may be that even if she finds a class it might stop for the summer.

From what you’ve said re family income, she should really be thinking about a summer job especially if she can find one that turns into a job she can do while a student. A lot of posters have mentioned lifeguards but swim teachers are also massively in demand. If she’s with a club can she pick up coaching. One of my daughter’s swim teachers is a student and she’s brilliant. Sadly now coming to the end of her degree but it sounds like it’s been a great job for her re something that fits around her studies and pays pretty well.

It cost my dd 200 to do her swim teacher training.

Swipe left for the next trending thread