Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Harder for Gen Z to build a good career which pays the bills?

81 replies

CalmAndCosy · 13/05/2023 18:32

Mid-20s, satisfied and very grateful with life but very lost in my career. My question is, is it more difficult these days to start building a career you truly enjoy AND which pays you enough to live a good life?

Background: I dream of working in the arts but the cost of living crisis and state of the sector right now make this very difficult financially. I love working with children so thought about pursuing childcare or teaching - both quite creative and in-demand roles - but I've had rubbish experiences with some awful nanny agencies, and most of my friends who have trained as teachers regret doing so!
Tbh I could've done a law or engineering degree, but I wouldn't have been happy. And not necessarily financially viable either - some of my friends in the legal sector earn the equivalent of minimum wage.

So, is it harder these days to secure a career you love AND which also pays adequately?! Or has it always been like this?

Would appreciate any well-meaning advice!

YABU - No, it has always been this hard
YANBU - Yes, it is harder these days

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 13/05/2023 21:06

The housing issue is crippling the uk.

I was thinking of this from the point of view of the ease of finding a job and pursuing a career but even if people do that, it doesnt afford them a good standard of living.

The wage stagnation is so notable too. Was that a result if the 2008 crash. I feel like i left school (im the last of gen x) and had 8 or 9 good years. Got made redundant on 2008 and have been treading water since.

I recognise those coming after me didnt get those 8 or 9 early good years to launch in. And housing just got worse and worse.

midgemadgemodge · 13/05/2023 21:04

Homes used to be around 3 times the average household income

Now 9 times

And rents matching

You might as well spend your money on nails because no amount of saving will help - unless your parents die and leave you money

Yours truely

Most definitely not a young person

Reugny · 13/05/2023 21:02

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:00

Well I have to say that if today’s 20 somethings didn’t pay people to do their nails, wax their legs, dye their hair, piss around with their eyebrows, inject their lips with filler etc, and didn’t expect to buy new clothes, designer handbags, fancy phones for the best part of a grand, and coffee for a fiver a time - they might have more money for rent!
I know you’ll all slag me off for this opinion though, but life as a 20 something for me was shared houses, charity shop clothing, and reduced price groceries - and I was a junior doctor.

20 somethings I know don't do that.

On the other hand my sisters and SILs ranging in age from 40 to 60s live that life style. Then again some earn a lot and have no/cheap mortgages.

Jonniecomelately · 13/05/2023 21:00

Housing has gone up but almost everything else has come down in cost since the 70s/80s. Wages were much lower too.9

Food and clothing cost 43% of the average household budget in 1957 compared to less than 20% now.

Bargellobitch · 13/05/2023 20:58

@KittyAlfred did you read that in the daily mail? There are many 20 somethings struggling to eat and heat their homes. Why have you decided that what they are spending their money on?

Springissprunging · 13/05/2023 20:57

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:52

Well a nice phone costs many hundreds so it does make a difference

Average cost of house deposit has gone up 41% compared to 10 years ago, adjusting for inflation

Average salary has gone up less than 5k adjusting for inflation

That's without the cost of living rises, how horrifically rent has increased etc etc

The phone is so not the issue

Bargellobitch · 13/05/2023 20:55

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:52

Well a nice phone costs many hundreds so it does make a difference

Aye cos the 50 quid a month for an I phone vs a tenner for a sim is what's causing all the problems for the younger generation. 😂😳

MotherOfRatios · 13/05/2023 20:53

gegs73 · 13/05/2023 20:50

I’m gen x but definitely agree. We don’t have problems with housing because of our age, but our DSs are nearing adulthood and they are going to have it much harder than we ever did.

Even renting is hard, I have older millennial friends still stuck in house shares

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:52

Springissprunging · 13/05/2023 20:29

So people are only allowed to complain about the cost of living rises vs wage stagnation if they are older or don't have their legs waxed?

30-49 year olds are the group for spending the highest on clothes in the UK not 20 somethings.

It's boring. It's the same arguments that have been used against millennials for over a decade now being used on a younger generation. People can talk intelligently about inflation and cost of living until a 20 something joins the conversation and then it's all 'well stop having a nice phone' as if that makes a difference

Well a nice phone costs many hundreds so it does make a difference

midgemadgemodge · 13/05/2023 20:50

So much has changed

But Housing costs are madness which makes things much harder

I'd be banning second homes and unoccupied homes to try and get the market back under control and currently there is a false lack of supply that's pushing prices and rent sky high

gegs73 · 13/05/2023 20:50

MotherOfRatios · 13/05/2023 20:46

OP I'll be honest Mumsnet isn't the place to ask this, I have found Mumsnet to be quite , unsympathetic to young people, I will wages do not match inflation like previous generations where they could buy a home house prices were lower so yes, we have it harder.

But, older generations (gen x/boomers) don't want to admit this.

I’m gen x but definitely agree. We don’t have problems with housing because of our age, but our DSs are nearing adulthood and they are going to have it much harder than we ever did.

MotherOfRatios · 13/05/2023 20:47

MotherOfRatios · 13/05/2023 20:46

OP I'll be honest Mumsnet isn't the place to ask this, I have found Mumsnet to be quite , unsympathetic to young people, I will wages do not match inflation like previous generations where they could buy a home house prices were lower so yes, we have it harder.

But, older generations (gen x/boomers) don't want to admit this.

*our wages

MotherOfRatios · 13/05/2023 20:46

OP I'll be honest Mumsnet isn't the place to ask this, I have found Mumsnet to be quite , unsympathetic to young people, I will wages do not match inflation like previous generations where they could buy a home house prices were lower so yes, we have it harder.

But, older generations (gen x/boomers) don't want to admit this.

InOrderDisorder83146 · 13/05/2023 20:43

Before the Internet, there was much less information available

People relied on their friends & family more
Personal recommendations

Sometimes, it is about being in the right place, at the right time

A few years ago, I recommended a friend for a job & received an employee bonus & my friend has done well. So the same applies now

Springissprunging · 13/05/2023 20:29

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:00

Well I have to say that if today’s 20 somethings didn’t pay people to do their nails, wax their legs, dye their hair, piss around with their eyebrows, inject their lips with filler etc, and didn’t expect to buy new clothes, designer handbags, fancy phones for the best part of a grand, and coffee for a fiver a time - they might have more money for rent!
I know you’ll all slag me off for this opinion though, but life as a 20 something for me was shared houses, charity shop clothing, and reduced price groceries - and I was a junior doctor.

So people are only allowed to complain about the cost of living rises vs wage stagnation if they are older or don't have their legs waxed?

30-49 year olds are the group for spending the highest on clothes in the UK not 20 somethings.

It's boring. It's the same arguments that have been used against millennials for over a decade now being used on a younger generation. People can talk intelligently about inflation and cost of living until a 20 something joins the conversation and then it's all 'well stop having a nice phone' as if that makes a difference

shivawn · 13/05/2023 20:25

I don't think it's hard to secure the career itself I think what's hard is the price of everything now.

This.

I think most people have always had to make career choices between what they enjoy and what is more financially viable. The cost of housing makes things harder for young people today but there's plenty of career opportunities.

gegs73 · 13/05/2023 20:21

Sissynova · 13/05/2023 19:44

I don’t know why so many people love to be contrary. People always seem so insecure and desperate to point out that they worked hard too!!!
The reality is wages have not increased at anywhere near the same rate as basic needs like housing, energy, food, transport. The result is careers that were regarded as well paid a generation ago, teachers, nurses, social workers etc actually cannot offer you the same lifestyle anymore.

Agreed, I worked in recruitment until the year 2000 and average type jobs don’t pay much more now than they did then. Most definitely not in line with the increased cost of living.

CalmAndCosy · 13/05/2023 20:15

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:00

Well I have to say that if today’s 20 somethings didn’t pay people to do their nails, wax their legs, dye their hair, piss around with their eyebrows, inject their lips with filler etc, and didn’t expect to buy new clothes, designer handbags, fancy phones for the best part of a grand, and coffee for a fiver a time - they might have more money for rent!
I know you’ll all slag me off for this opinion though, but life as a 20 something for me was shared houses, charity shop clothing, and reduced price groceries - and I was a junior doctor.

I don't think that's fair, there are people in every generation who live beyond their means. I cut my own hair and have never bought anything designer! I don't look down on my friends who get their nails done, and the fact I don't get mine done doesn't change the fact of lack of affordable housing for most people my age.

OP posts:
Springissprunging · 13/05/2023 20:12

CalmAndCosy · 13/05/2023 19:11

Yep have heard similar from my dad about the 80s. He says even if it's rubbish pay and stressful work, count your lucky stars that there's jobs at all!

Tbf I replied to that because it resonated with me, please don't think I'm trying to say it's worse than you have now. It was bad in different ways.

I managed to buy a house cheap because it was a recession and there were repossessions driving down the housing prices. Although I didn't buy a repossession it did mean I could buy a small house for cheaper than you could nowadays. And food prices, electricity, gas were all cheaper.

I think you have to find your compromises. I wouldn't work the job I was just doing if I had had the choice but I didn't hate it, it was just boring. I have managed to get a promotion to something more stressful but more interesting which I think I am going to be happy with.

Instead of an amazing job, maybe choose an amazing place to live, or a great hobby or a good lifestyle and then pick the least worst job you need to do to get you there.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 13/05/2023 20:11

SootspriteSearcher · 13/05/2023 20:04

Going against the grain, I would find a career you love. We should all value our mental health more.

I work in a nursery, I qualified to do this and earn minimum wage. I am very happy, and look forward to work each day, knowing I am making a difference in those children's lives.

We live in a high cost area (South east), most of our wages go on rent, bills etc. But we live frugally otherwise, it's almost a challenge now! There are days I am sad that we haven't been on holiday or can't just buy whatever we like, but we have everything we need. New experiences and fun doesn't have to cost much.

Our children are 14 and 11 now, my advice to both of them has been to pursue careers that bring you joy, there's no point earning a huge wage if you are miserable, or end up having a breakdown due to stress. They have grown up appreciating the small things, how to cook from scratch and hunting free sites and charity shops for clothes etc.

This is the exact opposite advice to what I gave above. I find human nature fascinating; that people make such different choices but are both happy with their choices and encourage their children to go the same way. I guess this just shows OP, follow your gut and above all else shoot for what will make you the most happy 😊

SootspriteSearcher · 13/05/2023 20:04

Going against the grain, I would find a career you love. We should all value our mental health more.

I work in a nursery, I qualified to do this and earn minimum wage. I am very happy, and look forward to work each day, knowing I am making a difference in those children's lives.

We live in a high cost area (South east), most of our wages go on rent, bills etc. But we live frugally otherwise, it's almost a challenge now! There are days I am sad that we haven't been on holiday or can't just buy whatever we like, but we have everything we need. New experiences and fun doesn't have to cost much.

Our children are 14 and 11 now, my advice to both of them has been to pursue careers that bring you joy, there's no point earning a huge wage if you are miserable, or end up having a breakdown due to stress. They have grown up appreciating the small things, how to cook from scratch and hunting free sites and charity shops for clothes etc.

daffodilandtulip · 13/05/2023 20:01

That's a shame - there are a lot who rent though but I can see it makes it tricky.

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 20:00

musicalold · 13/05/2023 19:29

This smacks of "if you didn't eat so much avocado on toast you'd be able to buy a house" unfortunately.

Well I have to say that if today’s 20 somethings didn’t pay people to do their nails, wax their legs, dye their hair, piss around with their eyebrows, inject their lips with filler etc, and didn’t expect to buy new clothes, designer handbags, fancy phones for the best part of a grand, and coffee for a fiver a time - they might have more money for rent!
I know you’ll all slag me off for this opinion though, but life as a 20 something for me was shared houses, charity shop clothing, and reduced price groceries - and I was a junior doctor.

CalmAndCosy · 13/05/2023 19:57

daffodilandtulip · 13/05/2023 19:41

Have you considered being an independent childminder? (The government were on about funding new ones, don't know if anything happened with that.)

Yes, I think they have a grant for new ones. I would enjoy it, but because it's home-based I don't think it would be practical as I am a renter. I would need to be able to afford to rent somewhere which has enough space for the children, and I'd need permission from the landlord to base my work in the home - and renting can be pretty insecure generally so not sure I'd want my workplace tied up in all that too.

OP posts:
RosettaTheGardenFairy · 13/05/2023 19:54

gogogoji · 13/05/2023 19:12

What is new though is that a teacher's salary won't afford you anything. In the past, a teacher could get on the property ladder

And that is a travesty , a genuine national disgrace. But my advice was essentially to follow the money; find something you're good at that can earn you good money. If the money isn't in teaching any more, don't bother (nightmare for schools but that's a different conversation).

I don't know which 'Gen' I am, but I was born 1988. I'm married, 3 kids, earning a six figure salary in a finance job that is off-the-charts boring. But I (and my husband) need to provide for my family, and following my passion, writing, was never going to let me do that as I love it, but I'm not good enough to ever make serious money and would spend my life struggling which is soul destroying, even when you love the work.

So that was my advice:
Job you love + are good at, + with high earning potential = jackpot most people can't hit.
Job you are good at + high earning potential + hobbies you love = best case compromise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread