Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ID of Starbucks non binary Southampton manager revealed

269 replies

Birthdaygirltoday33 · 13/05/2023 12:42

Their name is Luna Spain

DM link:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12077475/Starbucks-manager-sacked-transphobia-rant-activist-terrifies-neighbours.html?ico=related-replace

OP posts:
Timesawastin · 13/05/2023 19:54

Sissynova · 13/05/2023 13:03

Very poor taste. These public outings are totally unnecessary.

This. Bigoted thread has been reported by me too. The fact that it's still up confirms a lot of people's poor opinion of MN.

Sevenbells · 13/05/2023 19:49

However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

I disagree. For a start the customer said she feared for her life.

My inclination is to believe her, because I know how frightening such a situation can be.

Luna is big and appears completely out of control with narcissistic rage. One punch to the head may have meant a life changing brain injury to that woman, and that is not "ineffectual" - the clapping could have escalated into a punch, it was certainly heading in that direction.

Maybe the long history of male violence towards women is clouding my judgement here. Or I'm just not capable of "nuanced discussion."

But to me, Luna is a serious threat to women and I'm laughing at your claim that at any point the customer was the more aggressive party.

That's patently absurd.

Maybe this thread is all "pretty pointless" to you but I think it's very helpful and hopefully makes sense to others.

YouSetTheTone · 13/05/2023 19:47

I can’t get remotely upset for Luna’s identity being revealed to the nation. Trans rights activists regularly and openly say absolutely disgustingly violent things about women, intimidate women speaking in public about matters relevant to women. They are violent, they hound people out of their jobs and they are usually allowed to get away with whatever they like as they’re part of a ‘sacred caste’. If the DM actually wants to hold one of them up as an example of inappropriate behaviour this is actually highly unusual and might be a good reminder that antisocial, violent, misogynistic, homophobic and aggressive behaviour generally isn’t seen as acceptable….

One can only hope that Luna himself checks himself slightly the next time he is perturbed in public as a result…

BishyBarnyBee · 13/05/2023 19:39

Sevenbells · 13/05/2023 19:03

Luna is big. And seems to feel completely entitled to intimidate and threaten that woman. It's actually terrifying to me that this is now the reality we live in - speak the words I tell you to speak, even when they go against what you can see with your own eyes, or get in the bin, Karen.

Punch a terf, kill a terf. Get called a terf for even accidental "misgendering."

It's vile and aggressive and pure, old fashioned misogyny.

You never, ever see men being treated like this woman was. And you never see trans men demanding capitulation, either.

People who are buying into this without question need to think long and hard about their behaviour. What else would you stand by and let happen because groupthink told you to?

(I notice all the TRAs have wandered off....)

Not a TRA, but someone who feels there actually is a middle ground between "TWAW"and "all transwomen are a threat to women/a ridiculous parody".

I suspect many people have left the thread because it's pretty pointless, as none of us are going to change each others minds anyway.

But, for what it's worth, I see this very differently to you. I do think it matters what happened before the video, as it starts with the customer being much louder and more aggressive than the employee. The employee sees themself as defending another employee. They are taller than the customer but slightly built. If the person videoing is the man pictured with the customer, he looks much physically stronger than the employee.

The employee is absolutely out of order and needed to be sacked. It is never acceptable to lose your temper with an unreasonable customer. However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

But obviously we will have to agree to differ as it is so hard for those at either extreme of this debate to allow a shred of nuanced discussion.

Jibo · 13/05/2023 19:37

Effieswig · 13/05/2023 16:49

We haven’t been for a while. A few years ago I got a post deleted and warned because I referred to Fallon Fox as a male when talking about the fact that FF (trans woman) fractured the skull of a woman during an MMA fight and how it shouldn’t be allowed.

Ugh how depressing. So to be clear, we can't call violent males what they are if they have pink hair and special pronouns? If someone posts that their husband hits them but he identifies as a woman (whatever that means) will their posts be deleted too? Disgusting.

mydoghasanattitude · 13/05/2023 19:25

If it had been a matter of name calling and a purely verbal exchange, equal on both sides, I'd feel differently about it. However, this person became physically violent and took a threatening posture even during the verbal altercation... All caught on camera. Personally, I don't think of this as doxxing, under the circumstances...

MastersSun · 13/05/2023 19:19

Because people need to understand there are consequences for their actions. Name and shame for behaviour like this will warn future prospective employers of their basic attitude.

Atishoos · 13/05/2023 19:14

Full Luna recently. May 5th I think.....

Sevenbells · 13/05/2023 19:03

Luna is big. And seems to feel completely entitled to intimidate and threaten that woman. It's actually terrifying to me that this is now the reality we live in - speak the words I tell you to speak, even when they go against what you can see with your own eyes, or get in the bin, Karen.

Punch a terf, kill a terf. Get called a terf for even accidental "misgendering."

It's vile and aggressive and pure, old fashioned misogyny.

You never, ever see men being treated like this woman was. And you never see trans men demanding capitulation, either.

People who are buying into this without question need to think long and hard about their behaviour. What else would you stand by and let happen because groupthink told you to?

(I notice all the TRAs have wandered off....)

AutumnCrow · 13/05/2023 18:38

Clymene · 13/05/2023 17:48

And let's face it, if someone is that aggressive, it's never a one off. It's a pattern of behaviour.

How profoundly depressing that on a feminism board, we have people minimising and excusing violence against women.

I think this thread is still in the AIBU board. But yeah, depressingly predictable that Mumsnet gets these MRA posts all over the shop these days.

OTOH, the reason that MN is like a magnet for such nonsense is because it has been a spectacularly successful 'town hall' for women to talk about stuff that other platforms haven't been allowing.

It's women's fault that a man went off on one ... it's women's fault that a man from MailOnline wrote that article ... it's women's fault that something something ... at least MN allows some discussion of this phenomenon of blame.

Outofthepark · 13/05/2023 18:35

The reality is, if someone is trans and was born a man, and is now a woman through having transitioned, etc, she will still have the muscularity, frame, effects of a puberty awash with testosterone, etc, that will make them far more scary, basically, when they are getting in your face or trying to grab your phone (i.e. in the video) than someone who was born a woman and has ten times less testosterone, far smaller muscle mass and height,etc.

That's not a trans issue that's just science. I'm thinking that when my DH tried to sort out some crap with our insane neighbour (she was scary), he took a calm approach (more calm than me) as he is a big old tall rugby player, and couldn't charge in like I did (a small woman) because it would be unfairly phzysically intimidating and that would be excessive - talking did just as good of a job.

This is what I feel when I watch the video of Luna tbh. To have the physical male privilege to intimidate while having also the privilege of being referred to as she.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 13/05/2023 18:07

7Worfs · 13/05/2023 13:38

To all those saying the article is unnecessary, I say - do you want such people in women’s spaces, with access to vulnerable girls and women?

It is necessary to demonstrate the rampant aggression, violence and misogyny in the self-ID community.

This.

Sevenbells · 13/05/2023 18:03

Exactly, Cymene. There is no way Luna is a victim in this scenario.

The woman stood her ground, but it would have been absolutely terrifying, and something that will stay with her.

I don't care that Luna's identity is now known. It's a good thing. It means that women will know to approach them with caution. It's so very easy to not end up in the Daily Mail threatening a woman. Maybe Luna should try it.

Clymene · 13/05/2023 17:48

And let's face it, if someone is that aggressive, it's never a one off. It's a pattern of behaviour.

How profoundly depressing that on a feminism board, we have people minimising and excusing violence against women.

Gothambutnotahamster · 13/05/2023 17:25

Completely agree @KittyAlfred

Effieswig · 13/05/2023 16:49

Jibo · 13/05/2023 16:44

... Why was my last post deleted? Are we not allowed to refer to males as“he” any more?

We haven’t been for a while. A few years ago I got a post deleted and warned because I referred to Fallon Fox as a male when talking about the fact that FF (trans woman) fractured the skull of a woman during an MMA fight and how it shouldn’t be allowed.

Jibo · 13/05/2023 16:44

... Why was my last post deleted? Are we not allowed to refer to males as“he” any more?

Jibo · 13/05/2023 16:42

All this fuss over an attention seeker getting attention. By the way went was my last post deleted? Because I deres to luna as

ZittingBiting · 13/05/2023 16:36

Really? You can't understand English? Even if not conforming to your standards?

Is it the case that educated people like you assume can't possibly read text that doesn't fit with what you were taught?

It must be so difficult for you going through life not understanding really clear English. Sad face 😞

That's not really an intelligent or educated person though is it?

Intelligent and educated people can understand clear English when it's written.

P.S it's also very lower class to attempt to be superior in terms of education or grammar. You seem like the kind of person who thinks that is important.

KittyAlfred · 13/05/2023 16:32

Pluvia · 13/05/2023 16:21

Does it? Do coffee shop managers routinely assault members of the public?

It doesn't happen round where I live.

Not round here, either.

Nor round here. And that’s why this should be big news, because if we brush it under the carpet then aggressive treatment of women will become even more normalised than it already is. I want Luna to rue the day he clapped and shouted at that customer, and for other angry men to think twice before they do the same.

HRTQueen · 13/05/2023 16:30

relived that the Daily Mail has outed one bad manager in a coffee shop

no because they have done the job that they set out to do

limitedperiodonly · 13/05/2023 16:24

Whatever we think about identity politics, surely we can all agree that Luna is not suited to a management or customer-facing role and the intervention of the Dally Mail has helped relieve all of us, including Luna, of this burden.

Pluvia · 13/05/2023 16:21

Does it? Do coffee shop managers routinely assault members of the public?

It doesn't happen round where I live.

Not round here, either.

Effieswig · 13/05/2023 16:17

HRTQueen · 13/05/2023 15:58

This was an incident between a few people and the company acted appropriately

it happens every day

if Luna was charged as a woman then this is newsworthy that is the news

pictures of Luna with a child have deliberately been published to fire people up and what is the reason to ask Lunas neighbours what Luna is like

shame of those who have fallen for this it’s deliberate to stir up anger the them and us, look at what they are like it’s used again and again

No, what stirs up anger in me is that a woman can be intimidated by a man and people will try and excuse it with ‘I wonder what the woman did’, because the man is trans.

What stirs up anger is that a trans identifying male believes aggressive behaviour is on, because someone called someone she and not ‘them’. Even if the woman involved is GC, Luna thinks it’s ok to be physically aggressive to a woman for not using the correct pronoun.

What angers me is that a trans identifying man can assault a man and people argue ‘but we don’t know what the man’s wife said’. Or justify it with ‘Luna comes across as someone who stands up for their friends and that what they were doing’ or ‘trans people are vulnerable and drawing attention to poor behaviour from trans people is hurting them’

i can 100% believe if Luna was a man presenting as a man, not one person would believe there was a problem naming the misogynist bully.

Swipe left for the next trending thread