Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ID of Starbucks non binary Southampton manager revealed

269 replies

Birthdaygirltoday33 · 13/05/2023 12:42

Their name is Luna Spain

DM link:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12077475/Starbucks-manager-sacked-transphobia-rant-activist-terrifies-neighbours.html?ico=related-replace

OP posts:
RufustheSpecuIatingreindeer · 14/05/2023 12:28

Absolutely gail

I don’t know why I’m still surprised by it…its constant

GailBlancheViola · 14/05/2023 12:24

Always got to find a way to blame the woman, Rufus never, ever, ever, blame the violent, abusive male for being violent and abusive. No surprise that VAWG is endemic, posters on here excusing the behaviour of this male are an intrinsic part of the problem.

Effieswig · 14/05/2023 12:22

SchoolShenanigans · 14/05/2023 10:29

To be honest, Mrs Thomas sounds like an utter twat. Complaining about it being cashless, and then when the manager stepped in (Luna), she said "I wasn't talking to you, I was talking to this lady" which is just rude. Luna was presumably stepping in as Mrs Thomas was being a stroppy bitch.

Sorry, but this was all clearly a blown up situation, in which Mrs Thomas was antagonistic and Luna was unprofessional.

What proof do you have of the woman being antagonistic?

Because she complained they don’t take cash? Or because she didn’t need Luna interrupting when she had already told the person serving her that she wasn’t happy.

Customers are allowed to express that they dislike something about the service provided.

Luna wasn’t just unprofessional and pretending that’s all it is really playing down the aggression. Luna was aggressive and threatening. Luna assaulted the man and smashed the glass door on the way out. That’s not just unprofessional. That’s aggressive and Luna acted illegally.

RufustheSpecuIatingreindeer · 14/05/2023 11:52

So saying that you don’t like cashless cafes and restaurants makes you a stroppy bitch does it?

none of us have any idea how vanessa said it, i’ve said i don’t like it in the odd restaurant when I’ve come across it…

StarbucksKaren · 14/05/2023 10:43

SchoolShenanigans · 14/05/2023 10:29

To be honest, Mrs Thomas sounds like an utter twat. Complaining about it being cashless, and then when the manager stepped in (Luna), she said "I wasn't talking to you, I was talking to this lady" which is just rude. Luna was presumably stepping in as Mrs Thomas was being a stroppy bitch.

Sorry, but this was all clearly a blown up situation, in which Mrs Thomas was antagonistic and Luna was unprofessional.

Not sure how we can presume why Luna stepped in? All we know at this point is that before the video was filmed by her partner, Vanessa Thomas had moaned about card only but paid by card, and that Luna had accused her of misgendering the colleague behind the counter

Brefugee · 14/05/2023 10:43

Timesawastin · 13/05/2023 19:54

This. Bigoted thread has been reported by me too. The fact that it's still up confirms a lot of people's poor opinion of MN.

rubbish. Only people who can't handle debate think this.
There are PLENTY of posts on this thread saying that the article is totally unnecessary and mean.

But what you mean is that a lot of people don't like that many posters on MN don't blindly follow TWAW and have their own opinion. That isn't transphobia. That is women, who as a sex class have always been oppressed because of it, relating their own opinions. Lots of TRAs don't like that at all.

SchoolShenanigans · 14/05/2023 10:29

To be honest, Mrs Thomas sounds like an utter twat. Complaining about it being cashless, and then when the manager stepped in (Luna), she said "I wasn't talking to you, I was talking to this lady" which is just rude. Luna was presumably stepping in as Mrs Thomas was being a stroppy bitch.

Sorry, but this was all clearly a blown up situation, in which Mrs Thomas was antagonistic and Luna was unprofessional.

Jibo · 14/05/2023 09:38

@marapournumber4 "Non-binary" has no legal status so I would hope that these individuals' crimes are recorded under their legal sex. Some police forces do (wrongly) allow suspects to self-ID as the opposite sex, but there's no box they can tick for non-binary. Unless any police officers can tell us different?

marapournumber4 · 14/05/2023 08:35

I asked this question but was deleted as someone must have reportedit. Simple question needs a simple answer. Are they going to be a 3rd gender?

StarbucksKaren · 14/05/2023 08:32

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 14/05/2023 08:07

@marapournumber4

Trans people are already messing with crime statistics. Any crimes committed should be recorded against their biological sex which was assigned, I mean OBSERVED, at birth. The whole thing is a fucking shit show.

Also, just thinking about crime statistics, how are crimes by non binary trans people recorded?

StarbucksKaren · 14/05/2023 08:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Also the former Starbucks manager uses they/them. Not sure why anyone is using ‘she’ instead of ‘he’ or his preferred pronouns

OMG12 · 14/05/2023 08:15

Eminybob · 13/05/2023 12:55

Why are so many of them like this? It doesn't do their cause any good to be seen as shouty violent misogynists, but so many are.

Good on Starbucks for standing up to him. They could have easily taken the woke route so many other companies do.

You mean why are so many shouty misogynists intentvan undermining women, being verbally abusive towards women and making them feel (and actually be) less safe and taking away their achievements? It’s almost like this is the reason they identify this way

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 14/05/2023 08:07

@marapournumber4

Trans people are already messing with crime statistics. Any crimes committed should be recorded against their biological sex which was assigned, I mean OBSERVED, at birth. The whole thing is a fucking shit show.

marapournumber4 · 14/05/2023 05:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

marapournumber4 · 14/05/2023 05:31

Effieswig · 13/05/2023 15:12

A 6 year old self reporting study by stonewall?

Firstly that doesn't make all trans people and incredibly vulnerable group. Secondly, that's not down to GC people. Thirdly, alot of these 'trans' children will not be trans within a few years. Because they are not trans. They are children that are struggling with a variety of different issues.

An alarming amount of gay teenagers are being convinced they are trans. Same for autistic girls.

That study doesn't prove anything. You could also say that a large amount of vulnerable teenagers are being groomed into thinking they are trans. And the real issues are being ignored and not dealt with, and it's causing high instances of suicide attempts.

Yep that sounds like a load of shite. A survey of who?

NotTerfNorCis · 14/05/2023 01:05

Mail reported on it because they thought it'd attract readers, no other reason.

On Twitter there have been calls to expel this person from the Open University, which is definitely taking it too far. I know TRAs have form for this kind of life-destroying harassment, but it doesn't mean the GC side should do the same.

literalviolence · 14/05/2023 00:39

BishyBarnyBee · 13/05/2023 19:39

Not a TRA, but someone who feels there actually is a middle ground between "TWAW"and "all transwomen are a threat to women/a ridiculous parody".

I suspect many people have left the thread because it's pretty pointless, as none of us are going to change each others minds anyway.

But, for what it's worth, I see this very differently to you. I do think it matters what happened before the video, as it starts with the customer being much louder and more aggressive than the employee. The employee sees themself as defending another employee. They are taller than the customer but slightly built. If the person videoing is the man pictured with the customer, he looks much physically stronger than the employee.

The employee is absolutely out of order and needed to be sacked. It is never acceptable to lose your temper with an unreasonable customer. However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

But obviously we will have to agree to differ as it is so hard for those at either extreme of this debate to allow a shred of nuanced discussion.

I can't believe you're serious! You think a very chubby man, probably in his late 50's looks stronger than a tall young male in his physical prime? are you serious? You doubt that a small 55 year old woman did not feel in danger from the ravings and use of their body to intimidate from that same young male?

All TW who say they are women are a threat to women IMO through their erosion of women's spaces and lack of respect for their boundaries. All those who do not say that and do not try and use any women's spaces are not a threat IMO. In terms of more overt action I believe that there many TW who do not directly assault women, just like there are many other males who don't assault people. Is that a middle ground you accept? I don't believe that any erosion of women's spaces is any sort of middle ground. It's just granting TRAs wishes

GailBlancheViola · 13/05/2023 23:47

Timesawastin · 13/05/2023 19:54

This. Bigoted thread has been reported by me too. The fact that it's still up confirms a lot of people's poor opinion of MN.

Ah, it's bigotry to call an abusive violent male being abusive and violent an abusive and violent male now is it. How progressive.

Swrigh1234 · 13/05/2023 21:36

ilovesooty · 13/05/2023 14:27

Agreed.

Says someone who doesn’t realize that the guy in question is not a woman. He is a man.

Clymene · 13/05/2023 20:38

@BishyBarnyBee - the victim's husband was outside the whole time and I'm guessing if Luna had felt intimidated by him, Luna wouldn't have stormed outside and smacked the phone out of his hand.

Luna is a violent person who physically assaulted two people. And some posters are falling over themselves to defend them because of their trans identity, not in spite of it.

And I suspect the only reason they want people to stfu about it is because it doesn't fit with the victim narrative.

I'm struggling to think of any media coverage that does fit with the victim narrative. Which makes me think it's not founded in reality

Baldieheid · 13/05/2023 20:18

I'd have been intimidated by Luna looming over me and smacking hands together just in front of my face. It's a direct threat, anyone who refuses to see that is simply privileged.

Its the "next time it'll be your face" crap that men pull.

It's the "next time I'll do sometbing much worse" threat.

It's the "next time, I will REALLY hurt you" promise.

Don't recognise it?

Lucky you.

Mentalheath · 13/05/2023 20:09

BishyBarnyBee · 13/05/2023 19:39

Not a TRA, but someone who feels there actually is a middle ground between "TWAW"and "all transwomen are a threat to women/a ridiculous parody".

I suspect many people have left the thread because it's pretty pointless, as none of us are going to change each others minds anyway.

But, for what it's worth, I see this very differently to you. I do think it matters what happened before the video, as it starts with the customer being much louder and more aggressive than the employee. The employee sees themself as defending another employee. They are taller than the customer but slightly built. If the person videoing is the man pictured with the customer, he looks much physically stronger than the employee.

The employee is absolutely out of order and needed to be sacked. It is never acceptable to lose your temper with an unreasonable customer. However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

But obviously we will have to agree to differ as it is so hard for those at either extreme of this debate to allow a shred of nuanced discussion.

I would have been terrified of the clapping. .

want to know why?
This was something my abusive ex would do to intimidate me. It was used to control me into submissions. When the clapping didn’t work he put his hands on me. And guess what a slap sounds like… clapping.

So what was the trigger to go after the camera man? He hadn’t said anything. He stood quietly outside the store and filmed. The customer also reminded the manager several times about cameras around. Had she done something vile to provoke the managers reaction she would also be aware it would be on camera.

StarbucksKaren · 13/05/2023 19:58

Sevenbells · 13/05/2023 19:49

However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

I disagree. For a start the customer said she feared for her life.

My inclination is to believe her, because I know how frightening such a situation can be.

Luna is big and appears completely out of control with narcissistic rage. One punch to the head may have meant a life changing brain injury to that woman, and that is not "ineffectual" - the clapping could have escalated into a punch, it was certainly heading in that direction.

Maybe the long history of male violence towards women is clouding my judgement here. Or I'm just not capable of "nuanced discussion."

But to me, Luna is a serious threat to women and I'm laughing at your claim that at any point the customer was the more aggressive party.

That's patently absurd.

Maybe this thread is all "pretty pointless" to you but I think it's very helpful and hopefully makes sense to others.

Fearing for her life wasn’t due to clapping and shouting but being forced out physically after the video, before the door was slammed and glass smashed

Effieswig · 13/05/2023 19:58

BishyBarnyBee · 13/05/2023 19:39

Not a TRA, but someone who feels there actually is a middle ground between "TWAW"and "all transwomen are a threat to women/a ridiculous parody".

I suspect many people have left the thread because it's pretty pointless, as none of us are going to change each others minds anyway.

But, for what it's worth, I see this very differently to you. I do think it matters what happened before the video, as it starts with the customer being much louder and more aggressive than the employee. The employee sees themself as defending another employee. They are taller than the customer but slightly built. If the person videoing is the man pictured with the customer, he looks much physically stronger than the employee.

The employee is absolutely out of order and needed to be sacked. It is never acceptable to lose your temper with an unreasonable customer. However, the shouting and clapping is pretty ineffectual and I seriously doubt the customer felt in danger for her life.

But obviously we will have to agree to differ as it is so hard for those at either extreme of this debate to allow a shred of nuanced discussion.

No you won’t change my mind. I can’t understand the mental gymnastics to come up with what you have.

You assume the woman is lying for no other reason than the person being aggressive is trans.

You assume the non binary member of staff wanted to be defended or felt offended that the customer assumed they would be fine with the term ‘lady’.

The woman is defending herself from being called transphobic and is ‘loud’ so she must be wrong and have done something else’s and definitely can’t have felt threatened.

You mention Luna is slight built, ignoring the fact that biologically they are a male and taller and younger than the woman they are being aggressive too. Ignoring biological facts that far our weigh being slighter built than the woman.

The woman couldn’t be a scared because defended herself? Women don’t ever argue back and try and defend themselves when feeling threatened? Bad woman, defending herself against an aggressive biological male.

You then mention the build of the man videoing. I assume you believe Luna couldn’t have been intimated as they then assaulted the man videoing. So what does the build of the man matter? By your logic, Luna can’t have felt threatened because they assaulted the man? So why did they assault the man?

Threatening behaviour isn’t threatening behaviour only when the person on the receiving end fears for their life. Why does this woman have to fear for her life for this to be serious or upsetting?

Funny how you say ‘but no point discussing it because everyone else is too extreme’, after you put your points over, which is ridiculous and just an attempt to stop people replying and challenging what you wrote. What you wrote was essentially excuses for a trans identifying male to be aggressive and assault someone.

StarbucksKaren · 13/05/2023 19:55

AnonyMenOhPee · 13/05/2023 13:13

I really do think you have to take the reporting with a pinch of salt on this. The woman says she just wanted to pay by cash but in the video is asking for a refund - clearly there’s more to it than the video shows. Anyway whatever happened Luna has been sacked - what is there to be gained by sharing her identity? Hoping for a pile on? People to take the piss out of her appearance? What’s your motivation OP?

Customer originally wanted to pay by cash but wasn’t allowed to so paid by card.

Asking for a refund was a separate issue. She asked for a refund after Luna told her to leave (without the drinks and food she’d paid for) due to alleged transphobia

Swipe left for the next trending thread