Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Possessive in-laws or AIBU

119 replies

Cliffordthedog · 13/05/2023 10:40

hi Everyone, looking for some rational perspectives.

Backstory. My husband and I have a 19 month old. DH’s parents live close by and visit us practically every single day to play with our daughter and bathe her. She’s quite attached to them, especially FIL who clearly loves her a lot. they themselves live with SIL, her boyfriend and daughter who is only marginally older than my DD.

my mom is visiting from a very distant country and is only here for a couple of weeks. Last time my DD saw her was about a year ago. DD is not super used to my mom so I’ve been trying to help them build a bond. In laws kept coming to my house everyday even when my mom was here and didn’t even consider giving us some space. Yesterday we asked them if it’s okay if me and my mom bathed and played with DD just the three of us to help them develop a bond. In laws got really offended and responded in a passive aggressive way. DH first got mad (he had to be the one to ask them not to come) but then saw my perspective.

Eventually, after a long conversation with DH, they sort of got un-offended. But I’m still furious with their sense kf entitlement and just general cluelessness. AIBU thinking I don’t need to ask for permission to spend ONE quiet evening with just my mom and daughter?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AllBlackEverything · 14/05/2023 11:08

Have you said anything to your in laws yet @Cliffordthedog? I've been wondering how it went, better or worse than you anticipated?

SmirnoffIceIsNice · 14/05/2023 08:15

I think this has done you a favour in a way as it's brought about a situation that allows you to raise the issue. Once your DM has left you can have a discussion that it was wrong that you felt you had to ask permission about allowing your DM to spend time with YOUR child, and their reaction to the request was poor.

Gazelda's response above is very good. It's a time to start setting some boundaries and teaching your DD about body autonomy too. Good luck OP.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 14/05/2023 07:39

You really need to put some boundaries in. They have none.

How can you stand them descending on you every single day?

Are you quite young?

Geppili · 14/05/2023 01:02

Also read up on family enmeshment.

Geppili · 14/05/2023 00:54

Ffs stop them bathing your child! Put your big girl pants on and protect your child. They sound absolutely suffocating and a bit sinister.

Runaway1 · 13/05/2023 21:52

You’re saying nothing disturbing has happened because the door is open. But think what your daughter is being raised to think is normal. Three grown adults present at her bathing. FIL present at her bathing. As pp have said, at what age will
this stop? You need to raise her to have bodily autonomy. Google pantasaurus and the NSPCC.

Runaway1 · 13/05/2023 21:42

SchoolTripDrama · 13/05/2023 12:51

I find it really disturbing that your FIL insists on bathing her 😳

So do I. Massive red flag. Especially along with your functioning alcoholic dh. Protect your daughter.

billy1966 · 13/05/2023 20:12

Treesoutsidemywindow · 13/05/2023 20:00

OP if you find it too much to tell them face to face, then just text them and say 'I realised after you got upset when I asked you to give me and my mother some time alone with DD, that we've allowed feeding and bath time to become a habit which doesn't actually work for us, and prevents DH spending as much time parenting his DD as he should have. Out of respect for you he's reluctant to say anything, but I've decided that the visits every evening have to stop NOW! Maybe after my mother goes home we can discuss a regular day when you can spend time with DD, but for now, please don't come round until we invite you.

If they start guilt tripping you, just say, I've told you that this habit is not good for our family, and if you insist on trying to make us feel guilty, I'm afraid we'll have to stop ALL contact, as I can't allow this to continue!

Texting this is a good idea.

Sort out your contraception and dont inflict this alcoholic and his awful family on another poor child.

Your boundaries are askew that you think any of this is normal.

They couldn't care less about you.

All his creepy parents care about is what they want.

If his mother dies, his father will be living with you in 5 minutes and that bullied alcoholic you live with won't be able to say no.

Treesoutsidemywindow · 13/05/2023 20:00

OP if you find it too much to tell them face to face, then just text them and say 'I realised after you got upset when I asked you to give me and my mother some time alone with DD, that we've allowed feeding and bath time to become a habit which doesn't actually work for us, and prevents DH spending as much time parenting his DD as he should have. Out of respect for you he's reluctant to say anything, but I've decided that the visits every evening have to stop NOW! Maybe after my mother goes home we can discuss a regular day when you can spend time with DD, but for now, please don't come round until we invite you.

If they start guilt tripping you, just say, I've told you that this habit is not good for our family, and if you insist on trying to make us feel guilty, I'm afraid we'll have to stop ALL contact, as I can't allow this to continue!

Monkeynuts57 · 13/05/2023 19:32

SunnySaturdayMorning · 13/05/2023 11:24

Christ I would not be putting up with that. You need to set boundaries now.

Who cares if they get upset? They don’t care about upsetting you.

Once a week would be too much for me nevermind everyday.

Totally agree with this ^^

imjustanerd · 13/05/2023 19:22

I really feel for you, I had similar with my in-laws but nowhere near as bad. That's just absolutely suffocating no way could I see someone everyday like that, let alone bathing my child everyday.

The constant pushing boundaries and guilt tripping sounds very familiar, they don't care about upsetting you at all do they?

You're dp needs to grow a pair and put some serious boundaries in place now as it will only get worse.

Cliffordthedog · 13/05/2023 19:12

GabriellaMontez · 13/05/2023 11:59

You might have to cause ww3...

Better than having them hovering all the time.

Asking permission, to not have them over for one evening... that's awful.

Go out with your mum. Come back late. Tell them not to come round again, until she's left.

I will do exactly that tomorrow

OP posts:
Cliffordthedog · 13/05/2023 19:11

ExtraOnions · 13/05/2023 13:00

As often gets said … you have a DH problem.

He’s an alcoholic (saying “issues” doesn’t really cut it), and gets drunk in the evenings. He blames his Alcoholism on his upbringing, but isn’t doing anything about it.

So what do his parents see? A woman with a young baby, who struggled with PND, who also has an alcoholic partner … so I wonder if (in a clumsy way) think that they are supporting you ?

Your DH needs to get his act together.. which includes managing his parents, stopping drinking, and supporting you.

You are right. DH, although he loves DD to bits, isn’t always on top of his parenting duties. So they saw a gap and filled it. To be fair to him, his parents have always emotionally dominated him and he doesn’t know how to deal with them.

OP posts:
Cliffordthedog · 13/05/2023 19:05

StarbucksKaren · 13/05/2023 15:17

Could you see more of your SIL and niece and (much) less of PIL?

Thank you Karen, both your comments are insightful. I will try to see more of them

OP posts:
Cliffordthedog · 13/05/2023 19:01

Gazelda · 13/05/2023 12:13

If I were you, and to keep the drama to a minimum, I'd say something like

"I was upset the other evening that I felt I needed to ask for some time alone with DM and DD. And that in turn I felt bad for you being so upset.
Which is madness. I'm sure you agree.
I see DM so infrequently, I wanted some quality time where for us to help DM build a close relationship with DD which you've both got.
I think we've all got too intertwined and I'd hate for it to cause any fallout.
For everyone's sake, we'll be doing the bath/bed routine on our own most evenings. We can fix a weekly 'nanny and grandad' evening where you guys can play to your hearts content.
How about Fridays?"

But if they don't accept that, then you might need to go hardball.

And for goodness sake, your DH needs to step up.

That’s a brilliant response, thank you so much

OP posts:
Katherine1985 · 13/05/2023 18:07

billy1966 · 13/05/2023 17:42

OP,

You are utterly failing your child staying in this environment.

An alcoholic father.

Creepy dominating grandparents and a mother who doesn't think any of this is strange?

Unbelievable.

Your poor mother coming all that way and you allowed your creepy inlaws dominate her visit.

They were shit parents to your alcoholic partner and yet they are allowed to dominate your home.

Pack your bags and move away asap.

I would not trust these people.

There is something very off about a of this.

It is NOT normal.

I second every word of billy1966’s post

billy1966 · 13/05/2023 17:42

OP,

You are utterly failing your child staying in this environment.

An alcoholic father.

Creepy dominating grandparents and a mother who doesn't think any of this is strange?

Unbelievable.

Your poor mother coming all that way and you allowed your creepy inlaws dominate her visit.

They were shit parents to your alcoholic partner and yet they are allowed to dominate your home.

Pack your bags and move away asap.

I would not trust these people.

There is something very off about a of this.

It is NOT normal.

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 13/05/2023 17:26

Why do they come over to bathe her? That's really weird...

ClementWeatherToday · 13/05/2023 16:31

@HadEnough2023

If you find a way to get them to stop coming every day let me know, I've been trying for years.

Apologies if this comes across as rude, I mean it very genuinely - what exactly have you been trying all these years?

Because, "The daily visits are too much so we won't be having you over so often any more. Would you like to come for lunch on Tuesday or tea on Thursday?" would seem to suffice. What precisely can they do? Cry? Ignore them. Shout? Ignore them. Refuse to speak to you? Enjoy it. Threaten to withhold inheritance? Plan to live without it. Get violent? Ring the police. Really really, they can't MAKE you let them in. If they have a key, change the locks. If they bang on the door, tell them (through a closed door!) to go away. Then just ignore them.

My MIL can be a bit overbearing, we had to have very firm boundaries (especially when our eldest son was born). But we told her no to several things, and now we have a good relationship with her because she respects us as adults.

What have you tried to get them to stop coming? A locked door and some earplugs should do it.

SpilltheTea · 13/05/2023 16:17

You need to stop being so passive. Don't ask them, tell them it's not okay. They don't care about your feelings or your poor Mum's. They don't care about your daughter having a chance to bond with her grandmother. I'd move asap.

LindyLou2020 · 13/05/2023 16:16

@Cliffordthedog
I'm writing this from another angle - different circumstances to you, but a similar scenario in some ways.
My daughter lives in another country now, and is married to a man from that country.
His parents are friendly, caring, hospitable people, but.........they did indulge their son from when he was born, and he is the first to admit it.
I wouldn't describe them as controlling, but they can be quite overpowering, and still want to be very involved in his life.
Nothing wrong with wanting to be involved in your adult child's life of course, but not to the extent where you want to be with them all the time, or offer unwanted advice which suits their needs, not his.
He can now be very assertive and stand his ground, but it's still difficult.
I'm only posting this as a gentle warning regarding the present and future - if your PIL's behaviour is not nipped in the bud now, they will just carry on as they are, and it will become more complex as your DD grows up.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 13/05/2023 16:16

GrumpyPanda · 13/05/2023 15:41

Not in the UK so may be totally wrong - but don't grandparent's aquire certain legal rights of their own if they play such a central role in a child's life? At least that would be the case where I'm based. Something to consider in case the relationship with your alcoholic partner goes pear-shaped.

Grandparents don’t have automatic rights to their grandchildren. They can apply to the court to apply for permission to apply for access. But they have to prove they have had a good relationship with regular contact with the child.

aloris · 13/05/2023 16:16

2 hours a day is a lot and must interfere greatly with your family life with your husband and child. Them invading your time with your mother is unacceptable. I don't understand why you aren't angrier about it. Sometimes solving a conflict will require that you accept some hostile feelings from others - if everyone agreed on everything and had the same agenda, there would BE no conflict. You are the mother of this child, you have a right to say no to them invading your family life on a daily basis like this, and especially when they are preventing your mother from bonding with your child. Unless your husband is using coercive control on you, you can use your veto power as the mum and just say, no, you're not welcome until my mother leaves.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 13/05/2023 16:10

Fist of all you don’t ask your in laws for permission regarding your daughter. They don’t have exclusive rights to her, any interaction with her is via your invitation.
She is your child, you and dh are the parents and they need to respect this. Your little one is not there to provide them with entertainment or to fill a gap in their lives. It’s time to wean them off their dependence on her, start by limiting the number of times they visit.
I couldn’t have coped with them coming round for bathtime everyday, that needs to stop. You can do this, ignore the guilt tripping, be less available, go out more, join playgroups. I found it was easier to visit mine at their house as I decided when to leave.

azlazee1 · 13/05/2023 16:05

Why are they bathing and caring for your daughter daily. I would put a stop to it now. Every day visiting isn't a help in my book, it's an inconvenience. Discuss with DH and maybe you can agree to a couple of days a week where IL's have a play date. It will no doubt upset IL's but daily visiting is crossing a line in my book. Anyway, good luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread