Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the pope has a point??

247 replies

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 13/05/2023 00:07

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-65572153

I was in Italy recently and visited several large towns in the North. More dogs being walked than babies in buggies.

Pope Francis blesses a pregnant woman at the national conference looking at Italy's demographics in Rome

Pope Francis warns pets must not replace children in Italy

Pope Francis warns only the rich can afford to start a family, as Italy's birth rate hits new low.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-65572153

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 13/05/2023 07:10

The Pope is probably thinking about the future supply of priests for the church as well.

EmpressaurusOfCats · 13/05/2023 07:03

I absolutely agree society needs to support mothers more - free childcare and a cultural shift to 50/50 parenting rather than women taking the brunt of the work for a start - but personally no amount of policy change would make me have a kid. You could offer me £1million in cash and I still wouldn’t because I simply don’t want to. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with choosing to prioritise yourself and your wants/needs over the sacrificial nature of parenthood.

Yes, absolutely this. Cats, yes. Children, no.

Prescottdanni123 · 13/05/2023 07:02

It sounds like that woman that he told off needed compassion, not a telling off. There is a very probable chance that she can't have children, either physically or financially. So she is using a dog as a baby to try to satisfy her craving to be a mother. While pets are an important part of the family, I don't think that they should be treated the same way as human babies, and I am saying that as a big softie of a dog owner. But for people who desperately want children and can't have them, the pain must be horrific and I can understand why they may resort to this. So I treat them with compassion, not condemnation. This is a woman who may have had miscarriage after miscarriage or been told that she would never be able to physically have a child. And he is scolding her in front of a crows about how there are starving children in the world? Wow, just wow. This man is supposed to be a Christian. And I'm saying that as a Christian myself, too.

PriOn1 · 13/05/2023 07:01

I think the current pope seems to be a genuinely decent man. He has made quite a lot of good points on various contentious topics and seems generally very tolerant. So yes, this sounds like he is both knowledgeable about this situation and has spoken about it rationally.

Simonjt · 13/05/2023 06:52

GrumpyPanda · 13/05/2023 00:20

Maybe they could open a creche at the Vatican as their own small part in helping mothers get back to work. On a cross-country basis, the percentage of SAHPs tends to be inversely proportional to the birthrate. Or in others words, the easier it is for mothers to get back to work, the more children. Hence Japan dying out, or as good as. But of course Francis prefers to push his tired old complementarianism doctrines.

A creche in the vatican, parents might as well leave their children with rolf harris.

lljkk · 13/05/2023 06:43

People choose to have smaller families when ...
Child mortality is low
Social welfare net is good

We should aspire to those things and then people have maximum choice how many children they have; this is what informs my views on why fewer humans is good thing. We don't need to decide to create fewer humans, we need to create great conditions for nearly all babies (that they will become healthy adults with good prospects) and nearly all old people (then they don't need large families as pensions).

Declining population would be an Outcome of equitable fair healthy societies. That's why "fewer humans" is a good thing. It doesn't have to be coerced at all, too.

I am not sure Pope is saying anything in conflict to what I'm saying; he seems to be talking about choice, too.

W0tnow · 13/05/2023 06:34

I don’t think the Catholic Church has any business expressing an opinion on children. Given their track record.

Awumminnscotland · 13/05/2023 06:32

GarethSouthgatesWaistcoat · 13/05/2023 01:09

If I was being cynical I'd query how much of this stance was rooted in control. People are leaving religion in droves (in the West at least). Procreation is a great way of growing your flock (and tithes, if applicable), evidenced in modern day US fundamentalist and orthodox religions.

I wonder how many children would be considered acceptable to the Catholic church, 2-4? Or would it be a slippery slope pressuring women to have as many children as possible, dismantling rights and discouraging personal autonomy?

How many of these (allegedly) celibate, old, religious men rather enjoyed it when lesser men and women looked to the church for guidance and permission to live their lives? Incredible power trip.

Not cynical at all. I think you've nailed it with it all being rooted in power. It's always been this way with the Catholic Church attempting to control by laying down the law re all aspects of family. It was very much a thing in the 70s when I was a child that the 'family' was everything but the parish priest was very much seen as the person who had to approve your way of living.

mathanxiety · 13/05/2023 05:20

HiggleDyPigGeldy · 13/05/2023 00:32

Now I’m genuinely curious - to all of those who push the “the world needs fewer humans” line: do you actually live a green existence? Or are you part of that privileged minority of people (who typically live in North America or Europe) with a disproportionately large carbon footprint?
and is it because you are wealthy that you are unconcerned about the impact if shrinking population on your quality of life? Perhaps you think you will still be able to afford a decent old age despite labour and healthcare becoming increasingly expensive?
It just feels so hypocritical to me, all these people who expect everyone else to be deprived of family and comforts when they are living their best life driving cars, eating imported food, and flying around the world for fun - but hey, babies are bad for the planet.

Well said.

frankgu · 13/05/2023 05:20

The impact of aging populations can be seen already in places like Japan and it’s not pretty.

thing is Japan has at least planned for it & has put certain things in place.

frankgu · 13/05/2023 05:15

Now I’m genuinely curious - to all of those who push the “the world needs fewer humans” line: do you actually live a green existence? Or are you part of that privileged minority of people (who typically live in North America or Europe) with a disproportionately large carbon footprint?
and is it because you are wealthy that you are unconcerned about the impact if shrinking population on your quality of life? Perhaps you think you will still be able to afford a decent old age despite labour and healthcare becoming increasingly expensive?

It just feels so hypocritical to me, all these people who expect everyone else to be deprived of family and comforts when they are living their best life driving cars, eating imported food, and flying around the world for fun - but hey, babies are bad for the planet.

Quite!

frankgu · 13/05/2023 05:13

You're right its a major issue, I can't see how will we turn things around economically from the situation we are now.

I'm astonished that no-one seems to have clocked on to it. Politicians seem to be just ignoring it.

I'm pretty sure D Cameron had started to look at it but then Brexit derailed plus there's a lot of people in the UK who refuse to acknowledge the issue & think everyone has too many kids, bizarre!

frankgu · 13/05/2023 05:11

The point of his speech was that there isn't enough support and that people can't afford to have families.

which is an excellent point

frankgu · 13/05/2023 05:11

Yes more people in the over populated world, that is exactly what we need

🙄 we are over populated in the west because people are living longer. An ageing population is a sign of progress but it's not particularly fiscally rewarding.

evuscha · 13/05/2023 05:07

I’m generally of the “people can have as many or as few kids as they like, or not have kids at all” opinion, however I don’t really agree with the “we don’t need more humans on this planet” narrative (although I get the ecological idea behind it).
The impact of aging populations can be seen already in places like Japan and it’s not pretty.

Mercurial123 · 13/05/2023 05:07

He just wants more Catholics so that numbers grow. He couldn’t care less about birth rates in predominantly non Catholic countries.

greenspaces4peace · 13/05/2023 03:54

the article is good, as is the concept the headline is click bait.

MintJulia · 13/05/2023 03:28

Where do you think the catholic church gets its money? From large congregations and collection plates. They can't do that if the population is falling. Don't be fooled that the Pope gives a toot about women. That hasn't happened in the last two thousand years.

The very idea that people be paid to have children is sick. The people to suffer will be the women pressured into having more children than they want or should physically give birth to, and the children who are nothing more than a source of revenue to men.

Yes, of course childcare should be more accessible and yes women should have greater rights and more protection in the workplace. But financial incentives are not the way to go, and if we are to retain body autonomy then women must decide when/if to have a child.

4plusthehound · 13/05/2023 03:12

MintJulia · 13/05/2023 03:07

Given the level of vitriol and abuse handed out to single mothers and women in general by the catholic church over the generations, I think the Pope should shut up, cut the hypocrisy and mind his own business.

Many women choose to have fewer children because it protects their health, their financial freedom and their independence. I chose to have one happy, loved, well-provided-for dc, rather than five largely ignored, jumble-sale-dressed street kids (my parents).

The catholic church wants to return to a time of large, poorly educated families who relied on the catholic church and were therefore under its influence. Thankfully those days are gone and won't be back.

The planet needs fewer humans. And fewer bigoted old men.

The catholic church wants to return to a time of large, poorly educated families who relied on the catholic church and were therefore under its influence. Thankfully those days are gone and won't be back.

The planet needs fewer humans. And fewer bigoted old men.

He is saying the complete opposite though. He recognises that costs are too high for families, people cannot afford to have a family. He clearly states that only rich people can afford children now. He says that is wrong.

He is not advocating large, poor families. He is advocating for governments to support families/ people who want children.

MintJulia · 13/05/2023 03:07

Given the level of vitriol and abuse handed out to single mothers and women in general by the catholic church over the generations, I think the Pope should shut up, cut the hypocrisy and mind his own business.

Many women choose to have fewer children because it protects their health, their financial freedom and their independence. I chose to have one happy, loved, well-provided-for dc, rather than five largely ignored, jumble-sale-dressed street kids (my parents).

The catholic church wants to return to a time of large, poorly educated families who relied on the catholic church and were therefore under its influence. Thankfully those days are gone and won't be back.

The planet needs fewer humans. And fewer bigoted old men.

givemecoffeenow · 13/05/2023 02:39

Loria · 13/05/2023 01:28

Yea I'm thinking Vatican creche won't have many takers.

This thread got dark quick … But yes have to agree don’t think the Vatican crèche will catch on somehow! 🤔🤣

In all seriousness I think it’s up to people as individuals as to whether they choose to reproduce or not. I can understand with todays cost of living crisis (although not sure how things are in Italy) peoples decisions to not have children, probably to save extra financial strain on them, and also because what sort of future would their children have?

Times are a bit depressing at the moment so I can’t criticise people who don’t want to bring more people into the world right now.

4plusthehound · 13/05/2023 02:35

Like him or dislike him we need more leaders addressing this. And actually, we need more men on the case.

Getting women back into the workplace with ease it would go a long way to mitigation of this problem. But corporates don't want that.

The cost of having a family is silly bugger land at this point. Add to that the fact that we live in neuclear units, extended family help is unusal for most etc etc etc.

One thing that strikes me - they always say the economic contribution of women in the past is hard to quantify. Not any more - care costs in the billions for most developed countries is a very revealing story.

TedMullins · 13/05/2023 02:19

Precipice · 13/05/2023 01:29

I think there has been a huge shift in values for most Europeans and western nations.

There has, but the biggest shift in respect of falling birth rates has been the liberation of women. This hasn't been total and there is still a significant problem with sex-based oppression, violence against women, etc., but there have been massive gains. Women in most of Europe and the West can now largely control their fertility. Women can choose not to have children or to have fewer children.

The women having large families in the past often didn't want them; they just had no other option. They couldn't prevent themselves from falling pregnant through sex and they couldn't stop their husbands having sex with them. That's the other part of it: that when women spent so many of their reproductive years pregnant, it wasn't just that they had no access to contraception, but that their husbands too were placing having sex with their wives over their wives' health.

Sofia Bers, wife of Tolstoy, wrote about trying to make herself miscarry by jumping from furniture and taking scalding baths. She gave birth thirteen times.

That’s a really good point. The higher birth rate of the past probably didn’t have much, if any, element of choice in it.

TedMullins · 13/05/2023 02:17

chilliplant634 · 13/05/2023 00:52

OP I agree with you and I do see where the pope is coming from. I know a lot of people like to repeat "the world is already overpopulated" line, but there isn't solid evidence for this. Indeed, there are a lot of researchers who think that we are actually headed for the opposite.

Asides from increased costs of living and lack of support, I think there is also a cultural element to this. Perhaps this is what the pope is also alluding to? I think there has been a huge shift in values for most Europeans and western nations. Individualism taken to an extreme level. And at the same time the role of motherhood has been denigrated and is portrayed so negatively. Even if someone does have the income, they would rather spend it on extra holidays or other luxuries, rather than bring another child into the world. That is where the preference of the average European lies. As it stands the birth rate is below replacement level in most European countries.

I have felt for some time that parenthood and having children just isn't aspirational anymore for most young people now.

I also think that once a culture adjusts to smaller family sizes, everyone gets used to it and its hard to imagine anything different. We often hear of our grandparents generation when it was normal to have 4-6 kids. That is pretty much unthinkable now. I think China is having a similar problem due to having previously implemented the one child policy. I mean if you and everyone you know has grown up without siblings in a one child family, it must feel strange to now think of having 2 or 3 children.

What’s actually wrong with wanting to have a luxurious and indulgent life rather than children though? I’m not talking one with a high carbon footprint either before anyone jumps in. Just a life where you can please yourself and pursue your passions. That isn’t an inherently bad or amoral choice. Make things better so people who want kids can have them, but why the need to try and change the minds of people who don’t want kids?

I absolutely agree society needs to support mothers more - free childcare and a cultural shift to 50/50 parenting rather than women taking the brunt of the work for a start - but personally no amount of policy change would make me have a kid. You could offer me £1million in cash and I still wouldn’t because I simply don’t want to. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with choosing to prioritise yourself and your wants/needs over the sacrificial nature of parenthood.

This is a society, policy and infrastructure problem, not an individual one. The pope was so close when he talked about high cost of living, low wages etc…then he made it about pets.

Precipice · 13/05/2023 01:29

I think there has been a huge shift in values for most Europeans and western nations.

There has, but the biggest shift in respect of falling birth rates has been the liberation of women. This hasn't been total and there is still a significant problem with sex-based oppression, violence against women, etc., but there have been massive gains. Women in most of Europe and the West can now largely control their fertility. Women can choose not to have children or to have fewer children.

The women having large families in the past often didn't want them; they just had no other option. They couldn't prevent themselves from falling pregnant through sex and they couldn't stop their husbands having sex with them. That's the other part of it: that when women spent so many of their reproductive years pregnant, it wasn't just that they had no access to contraception, but that their husbands too were placing having sex with their wives over their wives' health.

Sofia Bers, wife of Tolstoy, wrote about trying to make herself miscarry by jumping from furniture and taking scalding baths. She gave birth thirteen times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread