Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really regret getting the cat?

135 replies

Reallyhatingcat · 12/05/2023 18:26

I’m not the source of all evil I’ll doubtless be dubbed as here, but I really can’t STAND the cat.

He is obsessed with food. Has had five pouches already today but is under my feet constantly demanding more. It’s like he’s insatiable.

I’ve put him out - I have to for my own sanity when he’s like this. But it means we can’t have doors or windows open.

He is fine health wise, not thyroid or anything. It’s just sodding relentless and it’s making me SO frustrated that I can’t relax in my own home, every time I move he goes thundering through to the kitchen!

OP posts:
Coffeetree · 12/05/2023 20:24

Huge sympathies OP. I love my little cat but she pesters me for food when she's bored. Try some catnip toys.

The other week I had flu and woke up coughing at 4AM with a coughing fit. I tried to get back to sleep but my cat decided it was Breakfast Time so was literally walking around on me meowing. I was so sick and annoyed that I squirted my water bottle at her to make her go away! I felt terrible afterwards (but got more sleep).

Righteouswarrior · 12/05/2023 20:22

As someone who has had cats all my life I can tell you this is quite normal. They are chancers who will happily take more food if given the opportunity especially if the behaviour is constantly reinforced by food always being given when they beg. I have learn to ignore (or in my case talk to my cat as if she understands, and tell her she can plead all she likes but she's been fed enough and can now bloody wait). This doesn't stop her trying but she will occasionally walk away as if knowing she not going to be lucky everytime she begs. By the way my cat is a normal weight and I feed her 2-3 pouches per day, plus a few treats a month.

febrezeme · 12/05/2023 20:16

I wonder if this is what's going on with my cats as well! Ex husband - the feeder - (filled bowls to the brim after one squeak at him) - left unexpectedly last year and since then my male cats appetites have seem to have trebled overnight - ex didn't give them loads of affection but I am massively busier now running around after kids (and cats!) on my own and they don't get the attention they used to......so maybe they are comfort eating 😳

LadyAstor · 12/05/2023 20:15

Try a high protein food (£££).

Some tinned cat food is grain and rubbish and so, doesnt satisfy them.

Make sure it says 70% from meat protein on the tin.

SoTired12 · 12/05/2023 20:14

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/05/2023 20:08

The answer as I think a couple of other posters have touched on, is enrichment.

Your cat, as a wild animal, would spend hours each day hunting, stalking, consuming and sleeping off food.

In your home, food is inhaled in seconds, and then what is there to do - fuck all in most homes.

Provide enrichment, cat trees, food dispensing toys - a simple one for solid treats (if they wont eat kibble) is to rinse out some of those small juice bottles (the itty bitty tropicana ones are good), make some holes in it and fill it with treats/kibbles as appropriate.

Once they learn how to shove that around for food, then up the ante and stick it inside a small sock so now they have to skin it and get the food out.

Once they can do that, then you start to hide it, starting out easy, making it harder as they get better at it.

There are lots of interactive puzzles and food dispensing toys, but simply having cat trees and hiding food around instead of plopping it in a bowl will work wonders.

Do not just feed dry food, its not good for cats and can cause some pretty nasty health issues.

ABSOLUTELY do not play with laser pen toys, they are awful things, honing a cats hunting ability but with no tangible reward or 'prey' caught at the end no matter how good the cat is. A recipe for neurological issues if ever there was one.

I had two cats (my girl passed away last year), they both have had everything a cat could want but my boy has always been like Op's when it comes to food. My girl just ate at set times and didn't harass me for anymore. Not all cat's are the same.

randomuser2020 · 12/05/2023 20:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Loupenny25 · 12/05/2023 20:12

I'll put my head over the parapet on this one!

I have 2 cats and they drive me insane, I love how much my family loves them but I am totally ambivalent towards them.

DH has always owned cats and adores them but I just cannot find it in me. They drive me mad with the pestering, scratching, meowing, peeing, the random headbutting at 2am. And don't get me started on putting kids to bed and finally sitting down for 2 minutes peace to have 2 furry dictators try and squeeze onto my lap.

I give them all the care they need to be happy healthy cats (maybe because all the pet grunt work falls to me??) But I've come to accept that I'm not a pet lover and wouldn't choose to have them in my life.

They get plenty of love from the rest of the family and I am just their food dispensing/vomit cleaning/ flea treatment lackey!

90stalgia · 12/05/2023 20:09

Been there, OP! You need to give him more boring food. Kibbles rather than pouches. He will be cross if the pouches stop, and harass you night and day for a couple of weeks but then he'll gradually forget about the pouches and just eat the kibbles.

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/05/2023 20:08

The answer as I think a couple of other posters have touched on, is enrichment.

Your cat, as a wild animal, would spend hours each day hunting, stalking, consuming and sleeping off food.

In your home, food is inhaled in seconds, and then what is there to do - fuck all in most homes.

Provide enrichment, cat trees, food dispensing toys - a simple one for solid treats (if they wont eat kibble) is to rinse out some of those small juice bottles (the itty bitty tropicana ones are good), make some holes in it and fill it with treats/kibbles as appropriate.

Once they learn how to shove that around for food, then up the ante and stick it inside a small sock so now they have to skin it and get the food out.

Once they can do that, then you start to hide it, starting out easy, making it harder as they get better at it.

There are lots of interactive puzzles and food dispensing toys, but simply having cat trees and hiding food around instead of plopping it in a bowl will work wonders.

Do not just feed dry food, its not good for cats and can cause some pretty nasty health issues.

ABSOLUTELY do not play with laser pen toys, they are awful things, honing a cats hunting ability but with no tangible reward or 'prey' caught at the end no matter how good the cat is. A recipe for neurological issues if ever there was one.

Crunchymum · 12/05/2023 20:04

We have a very "food motivated" boy. He's not constantly on the ask for food per se but if he smells something he likes he's relentless (he has to be banished now when I cook or make lunch. Even if there is no meat. He's just too interested and will happily eat non meat food - he loves avocado, hummus, any tomato based sauces and whilst he doesn't like bread to eat he likes to play with it so all bread products have to be kept in a cupboard!!) He isn't enough of a CF to steal once it's plated up but I've caught him on walking across the hob / face in saucepan / covered in bolognese sauce before we started to banish him.

He was one of a litter of 7 and when we got him - he was unwanted - he wasn't in great shape (weeny, he couldn't have been 8 weeks. His face was also caked in dried food, he would go wild for food) He'd been fed with all his siblings from the same plate and as a PP mentions he just wasn't secure about being fed.

We have always done 3 meals a day (1.5 pouches, going up to 2 shortly as he's bigger now) and dry food overnight. We feed greedy cat away from our other cat I thought older cat was greedy before we got little cat we rarely do cat treats and we stopped all human food, unless they are ill, once we realised little cat would eat anything. We feed at same time everyday. Have to be honest little cat has been with us 8 months now and is still much more food motivated than any other cat I've ever known.

I can't see @Reallyhatingcat saying how old your cat is, how long he has been with you and where he came from.

** Just to add, I don't think my little.cat was mistreated but he was an accidental litter (mother was meant to be spayed after a previous litter.... thankfully she was definitely done after having the litter my boy came from) so he wasn't looked after properly.

Soproudoflionesses · 12/05/2023 20:04

My cat is like this too. Love him but he does my head in every single day

Coffeetree · 12/05/2023 20:03

Have you got toys etc for her?

JudgeRudy · 12/05/2023 20:02

Like humans animals sometimes seek comfort or stimulation from food. Is there much else going on in its life to bring it joy?

Reallyhatingcat · 12/05/2023 20:00

Thanks all - just needed a vent! It’s weird how on here you can admit your kids are driving you batshit and get nothing but solidarity but say the same about a cat and you’re morally reprehensible 🤣

OP posts:
AnnaMagnani · 12/05/2023 20:00

If your cat gobbles it's food in 2 seconds and then vomits, I'd really recommend a slow feeder.

My food monster initially stared at it in horror but when she realised it was figure it out or starve, she got on with it. Takes her so much longer to eat and engages her brain.

ChristmasFluff · 12/05/2023 19:56

@Ontheperiphery79 I can't bleieve you are making your cat competitively undereat.

The suggestions on the packs are 3 pouches per day for your average moggie. Unless your 'some' dry food means a substantial amount of carefully balanced dry feed, maybe he's not a manipulative prick. Maybe you're just starving him.

DreamingOfRest · 12/05/2023 19:55

Yep, high quality food makes a huge huge difference. Our cat was initially on crappy pouches and wouldn't eat any of the cheap dry food, and was always ravenous for the pouches. Changed her to the Hill's Science Plan dry food and she was a different cat. Loves the high quality dry food, never ravenous, never overeats, and much more content. Also after a few weeks of the high quality food, her whole coat changed, much more glossy. It seems expensive, but they eat a lot less of it, and it's well worth it for their health, and yours!

MrFlobby · 12/05/2023 19:55

Ohh OP, I feel your pain. I’ve had cats all my life as a kid and adored them. We moved to a house with a huge garden and thought a cat would be lovely for us & the kids…

She was a rescue 3 years old & she really is lovely (to me & DH) but she swipes at the kids if they even walk past her and they’re not rough to her at all never have been! She pisses on the bed (whilst we’re in!) despite having been outside 10 minutes earlier, she constantly whines for food (& I loathe the smell of it!)

I have had wobbles and considered re-homing her but I do have a bit of love now for the annoying little shit bag. Until the next time she pisses on us… But sympathies, huge sympathies.

ChristmasFluff · 12/05/2023 19:50

I'm with those who say you need to spend more time loving and playing with your cat.

I sympathise, as I have an extremely disturbed rescue cat who is frankly bulimic - he will gobble down food then vomit it back so fast it goes striaght back into his feeding bowl.

I only feed him a third of a sachet each time he asls for a feed - so he gets the comfort of eating, without the volume. Nowadays I always stroke him before feeding him, but when he was 'new' I stroked him after his feed. He's always let me pick him up and cuddle him, but you may need to build up to that.

The people who are for chucking him outside and 'stop pandering'- yeah, way to sort a distressed and eating disordered animal. Although I'm sure they'd have similar opinions regarding human eating disorders (as seen regularly on Greedy Husband threads on MN).

Your cat may also be bored.

So yeah, same drivers of overeating as humans. It shouldn't be such a shocker, given that humans are animals who talk.

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/05/2023 19:48

🤯 That is a lot of wet food: is he a large breed?! 😯
My monster of a Maine Coon has 1 pouch and some dry food in a 24 hour period.
He's also food obsessed and a manipulative twat, who drives me mad, but I adore the fluffy prick and his annoying ways.

SushiSuave · 12/05/2023 19:47

I complete sympathise OP. My cat is also a dick. Miaows constantly for food despite always having dry food available, and is always, ALWAYS the wrong side of a door. She could have just miaowed to be let through and then 30 seconds later miaows to be let back in again. Drives me mad.

Rhino94 · 12/05/2023 19:47

When you say pouches, what pouches are they as if they are whiskas or felix or anything of similar quality he is going require more as they are the worst on the market, If he won’t eat dry food then look for high quality wet food as pp suggested or even consider switching to a raw food

fetchacloth · 12/05/2023 19:44

As some of the posters have mentioned, some companies have reduced the pouch size from 100g to 80-85g and that makes a difference. Also, I've noticed that pouch food has become thinner and more watery in the last year or so, your cat might be feeling short changed. The feeding guide for an adult cat is 3-4 pouches per day. If he's consuming 5 or 6 it's not really satisfying him.

Have you tried him on tinned food? The consistency of tinned food is more dense and may fill him up better. It might be worth a shot and see how you get on.

Good luck😄

Irequireausername · 12/05/2023 19:42

We fed our cat a mix of meat and crap cat food since we got him and he's never been demanding. We leave the dry out and he will eat it whenever he gets hungry throughout the day. He doesn't gobble and isn't demanding. Have known cats that are and it is annoying.

quietnightmare · 12/05/2023 19:35

Reallyhatingcat · 12/05/2023 18:34

He won’t eat dry food - he’s an absolute dick!

😂