Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really regret getting the cat?

135 replies

Reallyhatingcat · 12/05/2023 18:26

I’m not the source of all evil I’ll doubtless be dubbed as here, but I really can’t STAND the cat.

He is obsessed with food. Has had five pouches already today but is under my feet constantly demanding more. It’s like he’s insatiable.

I’ve put him out - I have to for my own sanity when he’s like this. But it means we can’t have doors or windows open.

He is fine health wise, not thyroid or anything. It’s just sodding relentless and it’s making me SO frustrated that I can’t relax in my own home, every time I move he goes thundering through to the kitchen!

OP posts:
JMSA · 12/05/2023 21:47

Our cat was put down a couple of months ago, and he was EXACTLY like this. I really, really struggled with it. I was absolutely devastated when he passed away, but I cannot lie, there has been an improvement in my quality of life. I feel so bad writing that, but it's true. Is your cat a rescue, OP? I'm convinced they're more food fixated than most.
RIP Bruce. I love you and I am so sorry Sad

VoluptuaSneezelips · 12/05/2023 21:44

Have you tried using a lick mat, a bowl designed to slow down feeding and/or different puzzle feeders? I found it helped alot with my greedy boy, he no longer eats too fast, overeats and doesn't pester anywhere near as much anymore.

You can freeze any kind of wet food (jelly, gravy, pate etc) and cat broth/soup in mini icecube trays to use with puzzle feeders if your cat doesn't eat kibble.

To really regret getting the cat?
To really regret getting the cat?
randomuser2020 · 12/05/2023 21:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Paperlate · 12/05/2023 21:26

Cats are furry little arseholes. Just chuck him out when he's being a pain.

PuppyMonkey · 12/05/2023 21:22

This cat sounds like a legend.

Sudokufail · 12/05/2023 21:17

Sounds like the cat would be much better off with a family that loves him. If he's not overweight then he's just asking for what he needs, like any other member of your family. Poor cat 😢

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/05/2023 21:15

My comment above was in reply to @randomuser2020 .

Claricestarling1 · 12/05/2023 21:15

Ours is a little piggy as well. He needed to lose weight so we divide his food into three bowls around the house and he has learned over a few weeks to go around and check each bowl at feed times (morning and night) which has stopped him begging for food and turned it into more of a game..this might help you!

silentpool · 12/05/2023 21:15

I think it comes down to routine, not giving in to bad behaviour and high quality food. Mine gets fresh water and (high protein, no filler) dry food topped up in the morning - it's always available.

Then some kind of raw meat in the evening - he came to me from the breeder eating a raw diet. A few times during the week he gets these treats made out of dried organ meat or dental chews. So he is well nourished.

He does nag me a bit when I'm late with it but if he was annoying me, I would just shut him out of the room I was in, which he hated, so it stopped.

At night he sleeps in another part of the house and knows that no one will pay any attention to bad behaviour (and certainly no feeding!) and so is quiet.

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/05/2023 21:14

He's an healthy weight and very well looked after, thus nowt 'cruel' in the amount he is fed. He sees our vet once a month, as he has CKD. Weighed twice a month and has really good quality food that I sourced from an independent supplier. Considering his limited life expectancy, he lived like a king. 😎

hereiamagainn · 12/05/2023 21:13

Ontheperiphery79 · 12/05/2023 19:48

🤯 That is a lot of wet food: is he a large breed?! 😯
My monster of a Maine Coon has 1 pouch and some dry food in a 24 hour period.
He's also food obsessed and a manipulative twat, who drives me mad, but I adore the fluffy prick and his annoying ways.

A cat needs 39cals per pound of bodyweight.

Male Maine Coons weigh 15-25 pounds

So your cat will need at least 585 calories a day and probably much more.

A pouch of cat food is usually 80-120 cals.

You really need to consider feeding him more, no wonder he is hassling you for food, poor thing sounds famished!

hereiamagainn · 12/05/2023 21:08

Floralys2 · 12/05/2023 18:56

I think you've made a rod for your own back

Feeding a cat five pouches a day is ridiculous

Our cat has two pouches a day and some dry food. Roughly the same time each day

You need to somehow try and bring five pouches right down to nearer two

The vet told us that wet food is lazy food and it isn't actually that good for cats

Wet food is much better than dry, cats are prone to dehydration which affects their kidneys with time. Dry food also often contains lots of grain and other fillers.
They key is to give them quality wet food, Whiskers and the like are rubbish, but there are lots of high quality foods available (at a price unfortunately), google grain-free wet cat food.

OP, might your cat be bored?
I think sticking to a very rigid 2-3 meals a day at set times is what’s needed here, so the cat learns that pestering doesn’t work.

Rightnowstraightaway · 12/05/2023 21:07

Billybagpuss · 12/05/2023 18:34

Has he been wormed?
the other thing you can try is switching to a high quality food, when we switched ours to canagan he was a completely different cat, he went from stealing anything that was left unguarded for more than 2 seconds to not even fussing for food.

This. We use Royal Canin but once we ran out and couldn't source any more for three days. So we bought Go Cat and a supermarket own brand and I don't think the cats ate for the whole three days. They just were soooooo unimpressed with the lower quality dry food!

Dmsandfloatydress · 12/05/2023 21:03

My greedy girl is a different animal since I switched her from pouches to grain free dry food mixed with cheap minced beef. Food bill has halved and her appetite is finally satiated. Cats eat meat and I don't think there was much of that in the pouches.

MonumentalLentil · 12/05/2023 21:00

ChristmasFluff · 12/05/2023 19:50

I'm with those who say you need to spend more time loving and playing with your cat.

I sympathise, as I have an extremely disturbed rescue cat who is frankly bulimic - he will gobble down food then vomit it back so fast it goes striaght back into his feeding bowl.

I only feed him a third of a sachet each time he asls for a feed - so he gets the comfort of eating, without the volume. Nowadays I always stroke him before feeding him, but when he was 'new' I stroked him after his feed. He's always let me pick him up and cuddle him, but you may need to build up to that.

The people who are for chucking him outside and 'stop pandering'- yeah, way to sort a distressed and eating disordered animal. Although I'm sure they'd have similar opinions regarding human eating disorders (as seen regularly on Greedy Husband threads on MN).

Your cat may also be bored.

So yeah, same drivers of overeating as humans. It shouldn't be such a shocker, given that humans are animals who talk.

Not wanting to derail the thread, but have you tried one of those puzzle feeders? Designed so that they have to lick it out of the grooves so it takes longer. I have one that is shaped like a cat head, it worked. Gives it a chance to go down slowly, and feed little and often.

WillaHermione · 12/05/2023 20:53

We have two cats and they get 65-75g of dry food a day each, no wet. One only eats when she is hungry the other is food driven. We bought a cat fishing line which comes with a selection of toys and it has been a mixed blessing. The food driven cat loves the fishing line to the point that she demands it every day from DH for over an hour. I would recommend it though as play is always good and this toy can be used while hearing a child read or watching tv. Tiny cat (Mog) is 3.4kg and food driven cat (Meg) is 3.9kg. They are indoor cats which makes play even more important.

Likewhatever · 12/05/2023 20:52

I’m looking after a cat long term for someone who’s ill. Ours is greedy fucker too. I was told she didn’t like dried food. Nonsense, she prefers wet food but she’ll happily eat both if they’re put down together.

Our routine is half a pouch and a measure of dried food twice a day, Dreamies at lunchtime, Felix soup at 9pm. I usually chuck a few more dried bits in her bowl before I go to bed in the vain hope it’ll see her through to a decent hour.

Her weight has stayed the same on this diet, but she s an indoor cat, an outdoor one would be using more energy and need more food. She gets lots of play but food at mealtimes only and she knows the timings now.

Be strong, OP!

randomuser2020 · 12/05/2023 20:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Katnissx · 12/05/2023 20:37

Our cat was similar, he used to wake us up in the early hours by scratching at our bedroom door 🤦🏼‍♀️ we have stayed strong with a routine and that has made a huge difference, we do two smaller meals spaced apart in the morning and then the same in the evening (like one when we have dinner and one when we go to bed) he kind of knows when to expect his food now and doesn't really bother us in between any more. You could also try the RCW Satiety food, it's designed to be more filling, we used to use it for our cat but now he's calmed down we've gone to regular cat food (mostly dry but sometimes pouches too).

CheeseDreamsTonight · 12/05/2023 20:35

Don't keep feeding a cat! They're relentless. Feed him twice. Stop and he will go out catching.

Hocuspocus99 · 12/05/2023 20:35

I had one exactly the same .long haired tabby , but just loved food , chicken cooking would sit by the oven ! Lived a long happy 19 years .

Pickingmyselfup · 12/05/2023 20:33

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Definitely agree with this. Mine get a mix of either Smilla, Animonda Carny or Macs and some Smilla dry (or high street stuff when I run out) and I'm sure we spend less than we would with pouches.

I buy 800g tins for 2 outdoor cats and they don't get through one in a day. I often add a bit of warm water into it too to make sure they are well hydrated.

It took my original cats (one I still have) absolutely ages to eat this stuff, I used to spend ages mixing it with gourmet mousse and sprinkling treats on top but eventually she gave in and now eats it happily. She is a lot better with the food obsession now as well, on pouches she appeared ravenous but not on this food.

janiebaby007 · 12/05/2023 20:31

Reallyhatingcat · 12/05/2023 18:34

He won’t eat dry food - he’s an absolute dick!

lol prob best for you to give him to cats protection league or a sanctuary to be rehomed.

I've had many cats all my life and non-have behaved like this. My cat will eat everything I feed him. I have to limit him to max 3 pouches of Sheba - he eats dry food as well. Every other week my dad will feed him fresh fish. White fish in the frozen aisle is cheaper than catfood believe it or not so he gets one a day split over two feedings. Make sure the food is high in protein and a good brand like someone else suggested.

If you are getting stressed and feel he's a dick - prob best to let him find a new home before he frustrates you any further. If the love isn't there - just call it quits. No harm in that.

It's very possible he's anxious in a new home .

Some cats are insatiable, like dogs you've got to give them just the right amount for them to not get fat.

Zimzimmaa · 12/05/2023 20:28

How is your cat weight wise?

I personally don't think 5 pouches is too much if he's not eating dry food. If he feels underweight you should get thyroid checked.

They all prefer wet food, but a good quality dry food should be out all the time IMO. Royal Canin, Science Plan, something that can be a offered as a standalone feed. A bowl might last a few days, but I bet he'd pick at it. Might reduce the constant demands for food.

nopenotplaying · 12/05/2023 20:25

I have the dog version of your cat 🥴 eats anything and everything. £4500 operation to remove impacted horse poo. 3 x additional trips to the vets for sick inducing injection to expel the toy/glove whatever he'd eaten. Each time on a weekend/bank holiday. Now lives in a plastic basket muzzle. The minute it's off he's hunting. 3 big meals a day, wormed, blood test screening etc. its relentless. He did have a very tough start in life, weaned far too early (unbeknown to us) and then several rounds of antibiotics for diarrhoea