Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any grandparents here who look after their grandchildren? If so...

135 replies

iopll · 12/05/2023 15:21

Do your dc impose ‘rules’ for you to abide by for the grandchildren (what they can eat, wear, anything really…) and do you abide by them?

OP posts:
Sphagnummoss · 12/05/2023 17:01

I used to look after my grand daughters two or three days a week from very very young, and now they are at school and nursery I have them for occasional weekends. What sort of rules? My daughter and I have similar ethics and views on child rearing. We agree on safety and avoiding food for allergy reasons. I said to the parents that these are their children and they make decisions. I can't think of any 'rules' that have been imposed. We run on trust and respect. They possibly have some more dangerous activities at my home with cooking over an open fire in the garden but I have shown the parents how I manage this and they were surprised I felt I needed to tell them as they trusted me to keep the babies safe.

FreestyleInTrance · 12/05/2023 16:58

My parents looked after my daughter 1 day a week, but I felt comfortable that they'd follow my rules - the main one being that I am raising my daughter as a vegetarian - because they raised me as a vegetarian!

They also used the car seat I requested, and knew all the up to date rules about no honey under 1, no whole nuts under 5, cutting up grapes and so on.

They have different rules to me on minor things, and my daughter understands that Nanny & Grandad allow some things that Mummy doesn't and vice versa, but I wouldn't leave her with anyone who didn't respect my rules on meat and car seat safety!

Oldnproud · 12/05/2023 16:58

Yes, whether or not you are being reasonable / unreasonable depends what your rules are, though either way you are perfectly entitled to find professional childcare instead for whatever reason you wish.

I follow the 'rules' that my dgc come with, but they are reasonable things, like what sort of drinks they can have, when and how long to let them nap.
My lovely dils have always said that there is plenty of flexibility allowed anyway, but I would never take the p*.

But I've heard of other gps ordered not to even leave the house with the dgc. No taking them to the park, the shop or anything. That sort of rule is completely unreasonable would have been a complete deal breaker for me. They would have had to find paid childcare instead. It would have been me insisting on it, not them!

CKL987 · 12/05/2023 16:54

What are your rules? I'd say there are some which should be followed for consistency benefits but others that should be flexible.

saraclara · 12/05/2023 16:53

The only rule we had (for ad hoc care about thirty years ago) was the car seat one. And that was because my FIL just couldn't get his head around "imprisoning" children in a car seat! Fortunately my MIL had more sense.

I now do bits of childcare for my GCs and my DD has never given me any rules. But I'm probably more safety conscious than she is (I find it a huge responsibility to keep someone else's child safe!) and she's just generally a chilled mum who trusts me.

User17865 · 12/05/2023 16:51

The only thing I can remember being specific about was grapes must be cut up for snacks. I trust my parents to be sensible and careful though.

bookworm44 · 12/05/2023 16:51

I would absolutely follow any rules my daughter asked me to, it's her child and i wouldn't dream of going against her wishes.

WeightoftheWorld · 12/05/2023 16:50

MightyEagle · 12/05/2023 15:38

My dad has my kids a couple of afternoons a week. He follows all my big rules (like the kids have to be in their proper booster seats in the car - he probably wouldn't bother if I didn't insist), but other than safety issues, I leave him to it. One of my kids will just watch TV for the full 3 hours he's here (which I wouldn't let her do if I were home!) but that's a compromise that keeps everyone happy.

We have the same set up except we don't get any regular childcare from them now as sadly my poor DM who used to do it, is now disabled.

However, my DF (and to a lesser extent sometimes with DM too) does have the kids for an hour here or there sometimes for appointments and stuff or might take eldest for an afternoon sometimes if the little one is unwell. And same rules. So for example car seats, sun cream, sunhats (or sunglasses for eldest), vegetarian diet are all absolutely non-negotiable. Other than that I have always let them get on with it really. DF is terrible for feeding them tons of rubbish and DM terrible for allowing eldest to spend hours and hours watching Netflix. But they're safe and happy, it's only occasional and they're doing us a huge favour. Also kids have different relationships with their grandparents anyway and that's how it should be imo. They can easily learn there are different rules with different people/different places, even babies can get used to that kind of thing easily.

Dacadactyl · 12/05/2023 16:46

Depends on your rules tbh.

I would agree with your mum that she's doing you a favour and if you had a myriad ludicrous rules then I wouldn't be listening to them either.

Im intrigued to find out the rules now.

Nanny0gg · 12/05/2023 16:44

iopll · 12/05/2023 15:33

@Bogggle which paper would be interested in this…?

Can’t seem to start any thread these days without some sort of witch hunt.

I ask because my mum tell me she won’t abide my rules if she’s doing me a favour looking after dc. I’ve said it’s disrespectful to not follow what I’ve asked… it’s exhausting and has led me to now find alternative childcare.

What are your wishes that she won't follow?

To be fair, nothing onerous was expected in my case anyway

Nanny0gg · 12/05/2023 16:43

iopll · 12/05/2023 15:21

Do your dc impose ‘rules’ for you to abide by for the grandchildren (what they can eat, wear, anything really…) and do you abide by them?

Rules - When babies, sleep and to a degree eat.

Now they're all much older I feed them what they'll eat.

I don't over-indulge in the sweet treat department anyway.

Wear - they came in what they're parents dressed them in and they supplied spares.

There was nothing I wanted to do that went against what their parents would have done I don't think.

eddiemairswife · 12/05/2023 16:43

No rules when I looked after my grandchildren. My own rule was 'no TV until dressed in the morning' when they had school, as my daughter would pick them up after her night-shift and take them to school. Her husband would drop them off in pyjamas.

Noodlepoodles21 · 12/05/2023 16:42

And she doesn’t respect our ‘rules’. E.g giving ds an ice cream when he was about one (he hadn’t had any at that point), didn’t tell us and then loved telling me a few years later that she had gone behind our backs. It thrills her!

UndercoverCop · 12/05/2023 16:42

I would also add that we were happy to pay for childcare and do on other days but grandparents insisted they wanted time with DS

PaintingTheSky · 12/05/2023 16:41

I've looked after mine daily since their mum returned to work after maternity leave and I've never been given any rules.

Ovaeasy · 12/05/2023 16:41

Depends what the rules are.

I have always taken the view that if I trust them enough to look after my dc, that’s enough. If I felt I had to give them a load of rules, they wouldn’t be the right people to care for my most precious things.

UndercoverCop · 12/05/2023 16:40

Grandparents have mostly looked after DS at our house, so in terms of food etc they use what's available which is what we would give him anyway, we are strict with sweets etc, he drinks milk or water, if they're going to the beach hat/long sleeves preferred or keep on top of the factor 50, we live by the coast and he's very fair like me, even on a breezy day it can be easy to burn.
Car seats are non negotiable but we provide one. We don't like screen time where avoidable but luckily all grandparents are quite outdoorsy and there is lots to do locally. We provide parking permits for the local area and annual passes for farm park, soft play and aquarium for DS and for them.
I think if you have certain expectations you facilitate/pay for them

Noodlepoodles21 · 12/05/2023 16:40

Argh. My mil does this. “Grandma’s house, Grandma’s rules”. I think she might actually get high from saying this! 15 years of it! 😂 I think it makes her feel good about herself, so I let her get on with it.

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · 12/05/2023 16:35

My DS and DIL have never given me rules as such, but I know what their general boundaries are (limited tablet time, only occasional sugary treats etc) and I obviously try to stick to them. I love looking after my DGC and would hate them to feel they couldn't trust me.

takealettermsjones · 12/05/2023 16:32

It really depends on what the rules are.

Thinking about it, I suppose I have 'rules' for my DC but it was never a case of handing MIL a list of instructions, it was more that she was around us a lot while we were parenting the way we do and she carries on doing it that way now that she's looking after DC once a week. If she's not sure she will ask.

I've also mentioned a couple of things to her that I wanted her to change (politely, obviously - but e.g. she had no idea about the advice on cutting grapes as that wasn't a thing when her kids were young). She's happy to go along with it because they're reasonable 'rules' and they're all about safety. So e.g. car seats, sun safety, caring for DD's eczema, never being unsupervised in garden (they have a pond), choking etc.

In terms of food, drink, TV time, toys etc - she can do whatever she wants. It's once a week, she's doing us a favour, and DC love spending time with her. I'm not going to ruin that by making her impose 'home' style rules on them!

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 12/05/2023 16:32

Does your mum want to look after me?

Dunno. Will you expect a present every week? Devise complex games involving princesses and witches and change the rules every 5 minutes? Expect to win at board games? Want to do messy things involving glitter and glue on the carpet not the table? If the answer to those things is no...then possibly!

I think the similarity in parenting styles is key. My mum may have faults but she's not one for excess other than in presents. I wouldn't want my mil (who I adore) looking after my dc because she lets them snack on whatever they want...4 creme eggs in a row..no problem! She also has very different ideas about responsibility. 4 is apparently old enough to go to the park alone. I'm sure if I gave her rules she would mostly follow them but the idea of trying to cover every scenario is too much like hard work and I'd never relax.

MakesMeFeelSad · 12/05/2023 16:31

No they don't, they tell me what food they like and nap times etc then leave me to it

Same as I do with my mum and gp when they look after my dc

Badbudgeter · 12/05/2023 16:30

I think there is a line in here somewhere. This Is what we do, let’s keep everything roughly the same, is a common sense approach.

Treating your Mother like an unpaid nanny won’t go down well. If you want to dictate everything pay for childcare. I would say unless you are paying a nanny a child care giver often has to balance out the needs of multiple children simultaneously so you will also need to be flexible.

AngelinaFibres · 12/05/2023 16:28

We have our 1 year old grandson at our house one day a week for 10 hours. He has visited every week with my DIL ,or I visited them , since he was born. I watched what she fed him for breakfast and lunch from 9 months ish and how she interacted with him. I have reproduced that in my house. We have stair gates etc. They provide the nappies that they are happy with. He has lots of scruffy clothes here that DIL wouldn't take him out in but are brilliant for messy play/ water/ gardening. I went on a first aid course with her before he started coming to us.I have huge affection and respect for my DIL and would absolutely fit in with whatever she requested. He is her precious child and I want her to feel totally confident about leaving him with me. I send her lots of watts app videos during the day so that she can see that he is happy.I know it saves them money but I regard it as a huge honour that they trust me with him and would never do anything to jeopardise that.

Skybluepinky · 12/05/2023 16:22

U want to impose rules pay for childcare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread