Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any grandparents here who look after their grandchildren? If so...

135 replies

iopll · 12/05/2023 15:21

Do your dc impose ‘rules’ for you to abide by for the grandchildren (what they can eat, wear, anything really…) and do you abide by them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dikwad · 13/05/2023 22:26

Both sets of my sons grandparents look after my son multiple times a week and have done since I went back to work when he was born 11 years ago when he was 12 months old. It's always been the case that when he is in their property and under their care, they set the rules and he abides by them. My only ask was that they didn't encourage him to have danger naps!

Liorae · 13/05/2023 22:23

maidmarianne · 13/05/2023 16:34

I do sometimes wonder if this assumption isn't at the heart of lots of the arguments about grandparents.
The problem is presumably that lots of adults don't actually feel like their parents did a great job with them so that trust isn't there. And they haven't been brought up to be comfortable with having difficult conversations or sharing their feelings, so it becomes a confrontation.

Why would anyone ask a parent that they felt did a bad job with them to provide unpaid childcare to the next generation?

Greenfree · 13/05/2023 16:38

My mum had my DD before she started school for 2 days a week and still has her for sleepovers etc. I didn't have any rules other than no hard sweets and to make sure grapes etc are cut before giving them to her. My mum has 12+ grandkids so I didn't have any concerns about DD been in her care and our rules may be different but I think it's nice that DD basically gets away with anything when she's there, they have a very special relationship. If I had imposed lots of rules like no TV, cakes etc then my mum would have just ignored me and I wouldn't have said anything as she's providing free child care.

maidmarianne · 13/05/2023 16:34

Swrigh1234 · 13/05/2023 10:36

You trust your parents to look after your children presumably because they did a half decent job with you. And now you want to impose despite them helping you out. Serves you right that they refuse because of your diva like attitude.

I do sometimes wonder if this assumption isn't at the heart of lots of the arguments about grandparents.
The problem is presumably that lots of adults don't actually feel like their parents did a great job with them so that trust isn't there. And they haven't been brought up to be comfortable with having difficult conversations or sharing their feelings, so it becomes a confrontation.

Dustyourselfoff · 13/05/2023 15:13

He’s far too indulgent in general, although he has no clue how to manage a tantrum.

but why haven’t you advised and advised? Would make his and more importantly your child’s life when they are together so much better.

Dustyourselfoff · 13/05/2023 15:11

When I’m a grandparent I very much hope to be asked to be involved in the care of my grandchildren. And I would relish “rules”. Why? Because a) I want to support my adult children and make their lives easier and, more importantly b) I would want my grandchildren settled and comfortable and, with young children, that means consistency and routine

Backtonormalatlast · 13/05/2023 15:07

Tandora · 12/05/2023 20:12

what “rules” exactly? My dad watches my toddler once a week, and I’ve never set “rules”. There’s the question of respect - he’s my father, and my mum and he raised me and my 3 siblings. There’s also the consideration of the fact that he’s doing me a massive favour. Some things he does I roll my eyes at- there’s always icecream and when he gets tired he puts her in front on the tv. He’s far too indulgent in general, although he has no clue how to manage a tantrum. On the other hand there’s the fact that they adore each other to the bones- Hanging out makes them both so happy. My dd keeps my dad going, and my dad teachers my dd so much , and it does wonders for her self esteem to have that close relationship with a doting grandparent. I have free childcare for the afternoon. Swings and roundabouts.

Great post . A lot of MN posters on various threads are so bloody disrespectful towards their parents or ILs who are just being helpful. Obviously there are extremes!
My GC absolutely adores my husband who sounds similar to your father and it’s lovely to read how much you respect him for being a much loved Grandad .

Mischance · 13/05/2023 14:55

On the other hand, it is not possible to impose your rules on a nursery - they do it by their rules, which have to have a certain universality as they have so many children and cannot adjust to the needs of each child, which GPs can in the one on one situation.

HazyDragon · 13/05/2023 13:24

I don't think you can impose rules no, but that's why I pay for childcare.

I think the problems come from GPs wanting to have a fun, generous grandparent role, but you can't do that when you are providing regular childcare.

You can soil grandchildren when you only see them once a week/ month for the day, it's a different story when you are caring for them several times a week. It's more of a parenting role.

MIL recently took the kids out for breakfast, followed by shopping. They then had McDonald's/ice-cream for dinner and sweets while watching a film! DS was actually sick when he got home, it was ridiculous and I wasn't happy, but I let it go for one day. No way I could trust her to do regular childcare, because she isn't prepared to say 'no' to her grandchildren. So as a responsible parent, I pay for childcare as it's what is best for them. I also don't want the stress of having to police grandparents and all the family fallout it brings.

Swrigh1234 · 13/05/2023 13:00

NowItsSpring · 13/05/2023 11:47

I regularly look after grandchildren to support their respective parents going to work - started when they were babies and now after school pick ups/school holiday care. I have always been happy to go with routines and preferences to meet their needs, however would have drawn the line at being set 'rules'.

A friend gave up caring for her grandchild after a falling out about rules - the main one being that she was never to leave her house when caring for the baby so that the parents knew where they were at all times.

Wow batshittery of the highest order. How do people like this get through life.

PaintDiagram · 13/05/2023 13:00

I’m thankful for this thread as I’ve realised that I just don’t trust certain people to babysit my kids.

but on the other hand I’m not desperate/needing childcare.

fancyfrogs · 13/05/2023 12:18

My parents (mainly DM) look after my 2yo 3 days a week, have done since he was about 8m old. I have no 'rules' as such, but am totally happy with the way they look after him. Only thing I think I've ever said to them is around naps eg asked them to no let him nap longer than an hour or so. I'm extremely grateful for them looking after him and they enjoy having him

SunnySaturdayMorning · 13/05/2023 11:49

iopll · 12/05/2023 15:33

@Bogggle which paper would be interested in this…?

Can’t seem to start any thread these days without some sort of witch hunt.

I ask because my mum tell me she won’t abide my rules if she’s doing me a favour looking after dc. I’ve said it’s disrespectful to not follow what I’ve asked… it’s exhausting and has led me to now find alternative childcare.

Then she shouldn’t be looking after my child unsupervised.

It’s not a favour to me if she cannot abide by my wishes.

NowItsSpring · 13/05/2023 11:47

I regularly look after grandchildren to support their respective parents going to work - started when they were babies and now after school pick ups/school holiday care. I have always been happy to go with routines and preferences to meet their needs, however would have drawn the line at being set 'rules'.

A friend gave up caring for her grandchild after a falling out about rules - the main one being that she was never to leave her house when caring for the baby so that the parents knew where they were at all times.

Mischance · 13/05/2023 11:24

I am very careful but last September my granddaughter had a very slight redness on one arm ( sunburn). I was sent a photo and asked to explain myself.

Heavens above! - asked to explain myself! They were totally out of order. A tactful comment about it would have sufficed, accompanied by lots of thanks for all you do.

As some other care grandparents have pointed out, people do slow down a bit physically as they get older and what they do with the children will reflect that. That is not a bad thing - a quieter day is a good thing. When my GC were smaller I would not do anything out of the house that required me to be nimble and speedy in ensuring their safety - now they are bigger and able to reason that has changed. But those lovely peaceful days at home together are treasured by them and by me.

And if I am tired I do bung them in front of the TV now and again with the blessing of their parents - they know I am far stricter than they about what is suitable to watch!

It does children no harm to have slightly different rules in different places and with different people. My GC know that the rule is that they wash their "school hands" as soon as I bring them home and they now do this unprompted as a matter of course. On one overnighter I gave them flannels to wash their faces and they turned to me like two startled meerkats and said in unison "We don't wash our faces!" ... OK ! Nowt so queer as grandmas!

It is all part of the rich pattern of their lives.

5128gap · 13/05/2023 11:13

I think there's a difference between rules for your DC and rules for your parents.
If your DC isn't allowed to eat meat or stay up after 9, I don't think its a problem asking your parents to enforce those rules with DC, for consistency.
Thats quite a different matter from setting rules for your parents themselves; that they must play with DC in the garden for 20 minutes a day and can't fail to attend toddler group, and you enforcing them. Particularly when there's the threat of withdrawal of time with the DC as a sanction.

Flossflower · 13/05/2023 11:12

We do 2 days childcare a week. This is one day each for each of my children. We haven’t been given many rules. However, I am quite strict regarding regarding things like TV, sugar, snacks etc and aim to provide a healthy diet for our grandchildren. When we chose car seats we discussed it with our children. If I am asked to to something by one of my children, regarding their child I will aim to do it. I have on a couple of occasions got minor things wrong but my child was not upset. I can’t be perfect!

DragonbornMum · 13/05/2023 10:49

My parents do follow my rules, but I don't dictate the entire day. I drop him off with his food for the day including snacks, so he eats what I want him to eat. My mum follows my nap routine because it works best for getting him to nap. If I say he's not allowed to do a specific thing she abides by that.

For the rest of it, they have free reign to do as they like. I know they wouldn't do anything dangerous or not age-appropriate. A lot of their days are filled with stuff that I wouldn't do but don't have anything against.

Swrigh1234 · 13/05/2023 10:36

You trust your parents to look after your children presumably because they did a half decent job with you. And now you want to impose despite them helping you out. Serves you right that they refuse because of your diva like attitude.

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 13/05/2023 10:32

What rules are you trying to impose?

pbdr · 13/05/2023 10:28

My parents look after my toddler two days a week. My only 'rules' are things that are important to me (so no shouting or hitting for example, although they never would anyway). I leave healthy meals ready for her, but if they give her the odd treat (she had some McDonald's chips with them yesterday) I try not to nitpick. It's only 2 days a week, she adores them and they are doing me a huge favour. If I pushed for them to stick to healthy foods only, they absolutely would respect that, but I feel like it's part of the job of a grandparent to treat their grandkids and I don't want to take that away. She can eat super healthy the other 5 days a week.

5128gap · 13/05/2023 10:22

JoDolce · 13/05/2023 10:17

My dd does not give rules for dgc, as we have similar parenting styles. I'm probably a bit stricter than her. If she did impose rules I'd soon remind her that we've managed to bring her & ds up & they're both happy & well, & I don't need to be told how to look after my dgc. Sometimes I think some young parents of today have forgotten that their own parents managed to raise them well.
And if their own parents didn't manage to raise them well then why trust them with their dgc?

Exactly this. Agreeing aspects of routine is one thing. Setting 'rules' is quite another. Either the person looking after your child is in your opinion capable of it, or they're not. If you feel you need to micromanage the situation then either they're not fit for the role or you need to reflect on your own control issues. What you don't do is treat a person doing you a favour as staff to instruct.

JoDolce · 13/05/2023 10:17

My dd does not give rules for dgc, as we have similar parenting styles. I'm probably a bit stricter than her. If she did impose rules I'd soon remind her that we've managed to bring her & ds up & they're both happy & well, & I don't need to be told how to look after my dgc. Sometimes I think some young parents of today have forgotten that their own parents managed to raise them well.
And if their own parents didn't manage to raise them well then why trust them with their dgc?

DelilahJane · 13/05/2023 10:04

My DM takes DC one full day a week and MIL half a day. I really appreciate it and didn't have any rules other than strict nap times but they both figured out themselves why we're so strict about when they decided to skip it. The meltdown isn't worth it.

We had to impose some rules, I thought were common sense, on MIL based on situations that have arisen while she's had DC. Examples are don't feed a 5 month old polo mints or never leave them in the car while you nip to the shop for 20 minutes with only her four year old cousin for supervision.

Liorae · 12/05/2023 20:59

I am very careful but last September my granddaughter had a very slight redness on one arm ( sunburn). I was sent a photo and asked to explain myself.
That would be the last chilcare they got from me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread