Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To regret all the time I spent worrying about breastfeeding?

32 replies

Feefooo · 12/05/2023 12:08

It's coming up to my DDs 10th birthday so reflecting on my parenting journey so far. One of my regrets is how I felt so guilty about combi feeding. I just couldn't cope with the constant cluster feeding. If I could go back I would comfort myself that you are doing well and it's OK.

My DD today is turning into a beautiful kind lady she's doing so well in school work , excellent at art and has good manners. She's tall, healthy weight.
I think I did well and I'm so proud of her. I regret spending so much time worrying about it when it didn't really matter as much as people said 10 years later.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Feefooo · 12/05/2023 14:54

TiredOfCleaning · 12/05/2023 13:52

My older one is about to turn 13 and I recall very clearly how much pressure there was at the time. It was awful. These are some of the things that happened to me ;

  • when we did our pre-birth hospital tour it was never mentioned at all that if you thought you might bottle feed you had to bring your own formula in. I was in for 4 days due to a massive pph and DS was screaming the first night with hunger. I rang the buzzer asking for some formula and was told sniffily; 'It's expected that you try and establish breatsfeeding'. A night cleaner ended up going to get me a bit of formula and told me to not tell anyone. Next day i got DH to bring in as much of the aptimel forumla packs as he could carry
  • constantly being told that breastfeeding was best and ff being spoken about with such disapproval it was like you were trying to feed your posion
  • I said from the start I wanted to mix feed (bf never got established for me.... one memorable day I pumped for nearly 3 hours in front of a star wars movie and got less than 20 mls of milk). Yet the hv always wrote down 'exclusively breastfed' on my notes and in the redbook. Totally incorrect.
  • had a neighbour actually tell me with disgust that I was 'lazy' for formula feeding. And tell me with pride that HIS Dils of course pushed trhough the pain barrier. Fuck off neighbour.
  • Had a (now former) friend who used to be a breastfeeding counsellor take it as her personal mission to 'encourage' breastfeeding which apparently meant texting me gtwice a day to say 'have you tried harder to feed yet?'. Literally.
  • Queen Bee of the local baby and toddler groups would say loudly that she made sure she kept gong through the early days of bf as she only wanted to the best for her baby. It took me longer than it ought to realise she was oddly competitive about everything... over this and various milestones. My son is autistic and has learning difficulties (the latter due to a birth injury) and this even as a toddler was clearly obvious yet she would be competitive over whose child spoke first (hers.... mine was non-verbal until 5) whose was weaned first (hers), whose walked first (hers, mine could not walk until nearly 2) etc. On one occasion she asked me if I thought my lack of breastfeeding might be the cuase of his developmental delays. (No, that would be the lack of oxygen at birth).

These are only some examples that stand out in my memory. But looking back it seemed that every time I met someone new they would ask if i was breastfeeding. It seems so odd now.

I was overwhelmed, scared and just could not bf. I felt such a failure. It used to wind me up so much that when DS would wake up I would start to sob becaue I could not bear the thought of trying to feed again. I had terrible PND and this definitely was a contributing factor.

Second child- I said from the start I was not even going to try bf. Just grey rocked anyone who thought otherwise. The whole experience was better, calmer, more relaxed, happiner.

I do regret that i was so stressed about it with DS1. I regret the time I lost. But I did not know any better- and certainly did not have the advantage of experience at that point.

I am so pleased for women who were able to bf and more to the point- love / loved it. That is wonderful for them. I hope it is a lesser thing nowadays but I did feel in 'my day' that there was a stigma to ff. Hopefully that is not the case anymore. I also hope that any woman who feels shame, guilt or sadness over not breastfeeding for any reason knows that actually- like most mothers we are all just muddling along trying to do out best.

Interesting my friend has just had her second baby 8 year age gap and she says there was no mention of BF at all. She said I'm combi and that's that the midwives and HV didn't try to push it at all. The first time was yes very OTT I'm not sure if it's because she's a second time mum or they don't bother as much anymore.

OP posts:
Iknowthis1 · 12/05/2023 13:54

Use this perspective to reassure and encourage any new mums that you come across.

TiredOfCleaning · 12/05/2023 13:52

My older one is about to turn 13 and I recall very clearly how much pressure there was at the time. It was awful. These are some of the things that happened to me ;

  • when we did our pre-birth hospital tour it was never mentioned at all that if you thought you might bottle feed you had to bring your own formula in. I was in for 4 days due to a massive pph and DS was screaming the first night with hunger. I rang the buzzer asking for some formula and was told sniffily; 'It's expected that you try and establish breatsfeeding'. A night cleaner ended up going to get me a bit of formula and told me to not tell anyone. Next day i got DH to bring in as much of the aptimel forumla packs as he could carry
  • constantly being told that breastfeeding was best and ff being spoken about with such disapproval it was like you were trying to feed your posion
  • I said from the start I wanted to mix feed (bf never got established for me.... one memorable day I pumped for nearly 3 hours in front of a star wars movie and got less than 20 mls of milk). Yet the hv always wrote down 'exclusively breastfed' on my notes and in the redbook. Totally incorrect.
  • had a neighbour actually tell me with disgust that I was 'lazy' for formula feeding. And tell me with pride that HIS Dils of course pushed trhough the pain barrier. Fuck off neighbour.
  • Had a (now former) friend who used to be a breastfeeding counsellor take it as her personal mission to 'encourage' breastfeeding which apparently meant texting me gtwice a day to say 'have you tried harder to feed yet?'. Literally.
  • Queen Bee of the local baby and toddler groups would say loudly that she made sure she kept gong through the early days of bf as she only wanted to the best for her baby. It took me longer than it ought to realise she was oddly competitive about everything... over this and various milestones. My son is autistic and has learning difficulties (the latter due to a birth injury) and this even as a toddler was clearly obvious yet she would be competitive over whose child spoke first (hers.... mine was non-verbal until 5) whose was weaned first (hers), whose walked first (hers, mine could not walk until nearly 2) etc. On one occasion she asked me if I thought my lack of breastfeeding might be the cuase of his developmental delays. (No, that would be the lack of oxygen at birth).

These are only some examples that stand out in my memory. But looking back it seemed that every time I met someone new they would ask if i was breastfeeding. It seems so odd now.

I was overwhelmed, scared and just could not bf. I felt such a failure. It used to wind me up so much that when DS would wake up I would start to sob becaue I could not bear the thought of trying to feed again. I had terrible PND and this definitely was a contributing factor.

Second child- I said from the start I was not even going to try bf. Just grey rocked anyone who thought otherwise. The whole experience was better, calmer, more relaxed, happiner.

I do regret that i was so stressed about it with DS1. I regret the time I lost. But I did not know any better- and certainly did not have the advantage of experience at that point.

I am so pleased for women who were able to bf and more to the point- love / loved it. That is wonderful for them. I hope it is a lesser thing nowadays but I did feel in 'my day' that there was a stigma to ff. Hopefully that is not the case anymore. I also hope that any woman who feels shame, guilt or sadness over not breastfeeding for any reason knows that actually- like most mothers we are all just muddling along trying to do out best.

bellinisurge · 12/05/2023 13:47

My dd is 16. Academically very strong, fit and healthy. Still feel a twinge of heartbreak at what I can't call anything other than my failure.

Scalessayeek · 12/05/2023 13:43

I’ve had two breastfeeding failures. First ended at six weeks and the second at eleven weeks. With my first I had horrendous guilt I’d given up too early, second I regretted not giving up sooner.

The regret for my second born was a lot easier to swallow and I would chose that any day.

Feefooo · 12/05/2023 13:39

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 12/05/2023 13:15

How awful to be short, obese and thick. My Mum breastfed me and I've ended up all of the above. Oh well. I'm sure she had a wonderful 'parenting journey'.

Actually I didn't say those things , those things were said to me while I was struggling.

OP posts:
Gtsr443 · 12/05/2023 13:39

YANBU I was very upset that I couldn't breast feed satisfactorily particularly out of one breast. We struggled on for ages until I opted for bottle. It transpired I had breast cancer. A lot of time wasted feeling very guilty.

finallygotospeaktoSky · 12/05/2023 13:31

My seven dc were all bottle fed, I didn't want to bf, all are now healthy well adjusted adults.
I was berated quite harshly for not bf by various people, who were in turn, told to jog on and mind their own business.
Always do what feels right for you and your baby, it doesn't matter what other people, esp judgy women, say on the matter.

Maray1967 · 12/05/2023 13:22

Sissynova · 12/05/2023 12:17

YANBU because we all have regrets particularly when we look back and the topic is so unimportant! But ultimately all you can do is move on and focus on the present.

I also had an awful time BFing. I just hated it but felt this insane pressure that I had to keep doing it, reinforced by midwives, DH, my social group and anywhere I looked for support, particularly my local feeding hub and lactation consultants. In hindsight I should have switched to combi sooner or even fully FF. As soon as I started properly combi feeding it was light a weight had been lifted off me, I felt so much happier.

This is such an important post. It is absolutely unacceptable for those people to have put pressure on you, Sissynova. BF didn’t work for me - DS just refused to engage … but my mw and HV were great. MW told me very clearly that her middle DC had behaved the same and she had not bf him although she did her other two - and it would be fine.
Now that DS of mine is nearly 23 - absolutely fine and healthy. My honest view is that this pressure to bf is very damaging to many women and needs to be kicked into touch. What is far more important is a healthy diet in pregnancy and how you wean. What happens in the 6 months in between is of least importance in my experience.

FooFighter99 · 12/05/2023 13:21

DD is 11 and I STILL get upset that I only managed a week of breastfeeding. She just wouldn't latch and I had zero support Sad

She's turning out to be pretty awesome though Grin so the bottle obviously didn't do her any harm

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 12/05/2023 13:15

How awful to be short, obese and thick. My Mum breastfed me and I've ended up all of the above. Oh well. I'm sure she had a wonderful 'parenting journey'.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/05/2023 13:04

Totally agree.

I felt awful for years about this (I did manage mix feeding for about two months but I hated it and it didn't work for me or my daughter). I felt for years that there was something defective about me for not having achieved this.

When I look back at the guilt, the arguments with judgy friends who had emailed me some well-meaning article about why "breast is best" (no shit, Sherlock), all the other shit I put myself through over this and how well my 12 year old DD has turned out I feel really quite angry about the propaganda around breast feeding.

Topseyt123 · 12/05/2023 12:52

Good post, OP.

I gave up breastfeeding after only a few days with DD1. I hated it, she couldn't latch at al and I wanted my body back anyway.

I felt slightly guilty at the time. She was born during National Breastfeeding Week too, which didn't help at all!! However, when I look back now, 28 years later, I see that it hasn't mattered one iota. My only regret now is that I ever allowed myself to be persuaded to give it a try at all, very much against my better judgement.

I didn't make the same mistake again with the next two. They were exclusively formula fed right from the start and we were all so much happier for it. All are now happy and healthy twenty somethings.

Camillasfagwrinkles · 12/05/2023 12:44

There are some health benefits to breastfeeding but it's not going to affect whether you're child is tall or intelligent. Only genetics plus an overall picture of a healthy upbringing with nutritious food will do that. I'm pregnant and pretty unbothered about breastfeeding.

Xenia · 12/05/2023 12:43

I always say the only aim is to get a live baby out of a pregnancy and to ensure they survive with whatever you feed them (I say that despite having breastfed all mine including twins and the fact for me the wonderful hours doing it including in dead of night with a twin on each breast are some of the most magical lovely experiences of my life). Had I not wanted to or not managed to breastfeed - so what? It would probably not have affected the children.

Do what you feel is right. i was lucky to have no friends with children when I had my first so I just did what I wanted to do and my parents were hundreds of miles away and my husband was happy to go along with what I wanted.

However across a whole life things that are important to all of us do change. it is just part of going through life. I remember when our child 2 did not get into child 1's school at age 4 or 5 and she was very upset but they went to different but very different schools through to 18 and it didn't matter at all in hindsight (other than having 2 different school sports days etc for years and years)

trampoline123 · 12/05/2023 12:42

100% I don't regret it because it's what I thought was right at the time, but honestly why do we get so hung up on it?!

I made myself so physically Ill breastfeeding (underlying health issues) for as long as I could and gave in after 4months and honestly, as soon as I did I wish I'd done it sooner.

My friend is a teacher and she said you could look at a class of kids and you'd not know who was breast or formula fed. It really stuck with me and it's so true.

Sissynova · 12/05/2023 12:39

@SparklyBlackKitten Maybe spend your time spreading the "fed is best" motto into the world to prevent other emotionally insecure women from thinking they are failures when they have to supplement their milk (or choose to)

I think this is unnecessarily snarky. Most new mothers are exhausted and trying their best, sometimes people can be really quite brutal about pushing breastfeeding and how awful formula is. They don't need to be emotionally insecure to be upset by it.

Feefooo · 12/05/2023 12:38

SparklyBlackKitten · 12/05/2023 12:35

? 🤔
Honest to god I cant believe women still let other women tell them to think that breastfeeding is the only way to properly feed your baby.

Honestly. Who cares. Feeding your baby is Feeding your baby. You arent a better mum for ebf or a bad mum for bottle feeding.

This is ten years ago. You can't go back in time so time to forget about it. Maybe spend your time spreading the "fed is best" motto into the world to prevent other emotionally insecure women from thinking they are failures when they have to supplement their milk (or choose to)

I don't spend all my time worrying about it it hardly crosses my mind. I just saw a thread about a newborn and I started to think about those early days especially as its DDs birthday soon. But this is true, we shouldn't let others make us feel guilty most likely everything will turn out fine.

OP posts:
Mumtobe2023 · 12/05/2023 12:37

HeadNorth · 12/05/2023 12:21

Well I exclusively breastfed to the max and my youngest had terrible asthma and bowel problems (and she is short!). I lamented this at one of our appointments and the consultants response was - it might have been even worse if you hadn't. How lucky you are with your tall healthy daughter - do tell us in what others ways you 'did well' to produce such an outcome.

Snarky comments like yours is why I hate mumsnet sometimes! She is trying to re assure other mothers who probably worry/ get anxious that it's okay to combine feed! If I was a first time mother and feeling concerns about my child, I would feel better reading this! Regardless of her choices, she feels proud, so do not piss on her parade! If you dont like it, go elsewhere! Happy Friday 👍😃

callingeveryone · 12/05/2023 12:36

So much of what we stress out about in the early years turns out not to matter that much. I regret the angst and worry.

SparklyBlackKitten · 12/05/2023 12:35

? 🤔
Honest to god I cant believe women still let other women tell them to think that breastfeeding is the only way to properly feed your baby.

Honestly. Who cares. Feeding your baby is Feeding your baby. You arent a better mum for ebf or a bad mum for bottle feeding.

This is ten years ago. You can't go back in time so time to forget about it. Maybe spend your time spreading the "fed is best" motto into the world to prevent other emotionally insecure women from thinking they are failures when they have to supplement their milk (or choose to)

RoseslnTheHospital · 12/05/2023 12:32

Virtually no one is relaxed about their first born child!

Feefooo · 12/05/2023 12:31

HeadNorth · 12/05/2023 12:21

Well I exclusively breastfed to the max and my youngest had terrible asthma and bowel problems (and she is short!). I lamented this at one of our appointments and the consultants response was - it might have been even worse if you hadn't. How lucky you are with your tall healthy daughter - do tell us in what others ways you 'did well' to produce such an outcome.

I am saying there's lots of things that scare new mums. Like your child will have a lower IQ, be obese, be sickly if a drop of formula touches their lips. I should have just relaxed about it all a bit more .

OP posts:
Fiddlerdragon · 12/05/2023 12:29

HeadNorth · 12/05/2023 12:21

Well I exclusively breastfed to the max and my youngest had terrible asthma and bowel problems (and she is short!). I lamented this at one of our appointments and the consultants response was - it might have been even worse if you hadn't. How lucky you are with your tall healthy daughter - do tell us in what others ways you 'did well' to produce such an outcome.

No need to shit all over a parent being proud of her child. She clearly didn’t mean it in that way

Whiskeypowers · 12/05/2023 12:26

Motherhood is one long series of episodes where you feel guilty for something

i wouldn’t dwell on this for a second longer and say that as someone who was made to feel like a freak for still breastfeeding my four year old child occasionally 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread