Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the person that hit my car should pay for it?

85 replies

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 11:25

I don't understand car insurance - I'll start with that.

So my car was parked - and hit by a van - who just drove off!
Luckily it was outside my house so I have clear CCTV of it.

I only had third party party insurance (I now know that was silly)

Anyway - I contacted my insurance to notify them. I couldn't claim with them, but they were very helpful and passed me onto Enterprise (the rental company) who said they would pursue a claim against the van divers insurance.

I've just chased them up, (Its been a month), and they've said that they contacted his insurance company - but they haven't responded, so its now "out of their timeframe"

So .. he just gets way with it? :-(

OP posts:
Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 13:48

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 12/05/2023 11:42

I just copied the advice on the RAC website to everyone saying i was wrong

You’re confusing the two issues. Being third party only has relevance if you cause an accident and damage someone else’s vehicle. It means that the insurance will pay to repair the other persons car but not yours.

even if the lady had fully comprehensive, it wouldn’t make any difference to what’s going on

the person who caused the accident is the person who’s insurance is claimed against. And even if they are 3rd party only, you are the 3rd party and the insurance pays to repair your car but not the other car.

you only involve your own insurance is there is a dispute about fault, or you are at fault and are being claimed against or it’s 50/50z you do have to notify your insurance even if you’re not at fault, but you don’t make a claim against your own policy.

Banditdog · 12/05/2023 13:46

SavBlancTonight · 12/05/2023 13:43

The rental company thing is a real pain in the arse. We've had that. But usually it's when you hire a car.

I'd go back to your insurance company and tell them you don't need a rental company so they must please track this guy down. I can assure you that, assuming he is insured, if you have his registration they can track down not only th owner, but who he is insured by.

See my post above. It is nothing to do with her insurance company, they don’t need to do anything as she doesn’t have any cover with them with respect to damages to her own vehicle.

They are not putting her onto Enterprise in their capacity as a vehicle hire provider but because they can offer claim management services.

LadyJ2023 · 12/05/2023 13:43

I hope you've changed your insurance from 3rd it barely covers anything these days. Good luck getting sorted out tho.

Banditdog · 12/05/2023 13:43

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 12:00

You need to go back to your insurance company and explain that the van was not rented and that you want them to contact the van drivers insurance to organise a payout.

Someone has simply got confused somewhere along the line.

Make sure you take notes of the date, time and outcome of all phone calls

No it is nothing to do with her insurance company, she only has third party cover, so they do not need to get involved with this claim because it is a claim for damages to her vehicle not to a third party.

This is why they have passed her onto Enterprise, they are being kind as they don’t need to help. Enterprise as well as running a vehicle rental business, are a claim management company so rather than OP chase up the other drivers insurance, they can provide this service. However from the first post, it sounds like they tried and have given up and don’t want to provide their claim management service anymore. As such, OP needs to go this alone, if she can get insurance details from the police then she needs to contact the other drivers insurance herself.

SavBlancTonight · 12/05/2023 13:43

The rental company thing is a real pain in the arse. We've had that. But usually it's when you hire a car.

I'd go back to your insurance company and tell them you don't need a rental company so they must please track this guy down. I can assure you that, assuming he is insured, if you have his registration they can track down not only th owner, but who he is insured by.

vivainsomnia · 12/05/2023 13:25

Enterprise is also a credit hire company
And they are RUBBISH. All they are is after money. All insurance companies that deal with their own claims hate them.

5 years ago, a car hit my parked car. No witness but they accepted liability. I contacted the insurance who passed me straight to Enterprise. They told me I had to take my car to a repair place 1/2h away when there are about 20 in my bigger town. That place gave me a quote that seemed extremely excessive and told me that any issue, it was my problem and fir me to deal in court. I refused to sign any such papers. They were extremely rude about it.

In the end, I called the person's own insurance directly. Got a quote at my local repair place that was 1/2 that quoted by the other place and the insurance agree to deal with them and pay them directly so I had nothing to do.

Enterprise then kept calling me about hiring expensive cars even though I told them I didn't need to, and kept on about using their legal services when again there was no need.

I vowed after that to never get car insurance with those insurance company which only sell you a policy but doesn't deal with any of your claim.

Entreprise and the likes are the reason why fees are going up so much.

Call the other party insurance directly and avoid Enterprise at all cost.

ejbaxa · 12/05/2023 13:00

We do live in such a scummy society. People and companies wriggle out of anything and everything possible.

Someone recently drove into our car, completely their fault and caught on camera. Yet they still told their insurer that they were stationary and that we drove into them.

You have CCTV so once you have his insurer and they view that, they have no excuse not to pay up. They still may try to avoid it though.

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 12:47

@honeylulu , thank you, that's really helpful x

OP posts:
Reugny · 12/05/2023 12:42

OP just occurred to me because you got Third party insurance it indicates your car is old?

If so find out how much an exact replacement of your car would cost using reputable car sites e.g. exchange and mart and take screenshots.

His insurer may argue that instead of paying you the cost of the repairs they will pay you the cost of getting an exact replacement as it is cheaper.

honeylulu · 12/05/2023 12:30

Now that you've cleared up Enterprise's involvement (I was thinking a hire van too) it sounds like it's best they aren't going to handle for you. You aren't out of time to make a claim against the driver, Enterprise's probably just have one go at getting a quick answer before giving up because none of your insurer's money is at stake. Follow the links posters have added to identify the driver and insurer. I don't think the police will just hand over these details. Then promptly write a letter of claim referring to any evidence (police report number etc) and inviting inspection of the damage to your car by x date before it is repaired. By all means send photos with the letter. The insurer should deal and you can start an online court claim if they don't. You need to claim against the driver rather than the insurer (subrogation). The insurer won't (or is unlikely to) arrange to repair directly but will consider quotes you obtain. If all goes well they may promptly make an acceptable settlement payment so you get the money before you have to pay for repairs. But it can take ages and you may have to repair first and settle later. Sorry for lack of paragraphs- stupid phone.

UpTheAnte · 12/05/2023 12:28

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 12/05/2023 11:42

I just copied the advice on the RAC website to everyone saying i was wrong

No, PP's are correct. This says '...if you cause the accident..' only the third party's costs will be covered.

OP didn't cause this so would recover her costs from the person that hit her. This is where she is struggling now.

PinkCast · 12/05/2023 12:23

Thank you Sue Perb for explaining why Enterprise came into it, the fact they are also a car rental co confused me.
Best of luck @BunnyMum2000, sounds like you have a solid case & TG for CCTV.

Margarita45 · 12/05/2023 12:15

Also, I’d you do use enterprise, prepare yourself for a very painful process. They are truly awful.

Margarita45 · 12/05/2023 12:13

loudbatperson · 12/05/2023 11:46

Enterprise wouldn't be handling your claim against the third parties insurers for you. It's very strange they have offered that, unless they passed you over to a claim management company.

If so, there are a lot of shady operators in this field and you could end up with a large bill.

You can look up the vans insurer yourself and contact them to directly make a claim.

Enterprise are also a credit hire/claims management company!

I have fully comp insurance with a reputable insurer and they use enterprise for non fault claims rather than have an in house team. I believe it’s a relatively new arm to enterprise though.

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 12:08

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 12/05/2023 12:07

I can explain a bit.
You can't claim from your insurers as you know as you are not comp.
In those circumstances the insurer may refer you to an accident management company, in this case Enterprise. They will usually put you in a credit hire car and negotiate repairs with the at fault insurance company. They will only take on cases where they are 99% sure to get their money, for the repairs and the hire. One of their criteria will be that they have to have a response within x time from the insurer.
They are no longer interested.
In your shoes, ask either your insurer or enterprise for the contact details for the insurer. Call them directly and submit your claim directly to them. If you have cctv with the clear reg number they should deal with your claim directly.

Yes, thank you. That makes sense x

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 12:07

GCWorkNightmare · 12/05/2023 12:01

Hard to see why Enterprise would. They wouldn’t get anything out of this arrangement?

Enterprise may well be set up to hire op a car whilst hers is repaired then claim back cost of hire along with the repairs from van insurance - credit hire - rates are very inflated.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 12/05/2023 12:07

I can explain a bit.
You can't claim from your insurers as you know as you are not comp.
In those circumstances the insurer may refer you to an accident management company, in this case Enterprise. They will usually put you in a credit hire car and negotiate repairs with the at fault insurance company. They will only take on cases where they are 99% sure to get their money, for the repairs and the hire. One of their criteria will be that they have to have a response within x time from the insurer.
They are no longer interested.
In your shoes, ask either your insurer or enterprise for the contact details for the insurer. Call them directly and submit your claim directly to them. If you have cctv with the clear reg number they should deal with your claim directly.

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 12:06

Thank you for all your replies x

my heart hurts!

so .. I think my course of action now is:

  • contact the police and ask them to provide me with the van drivers details.
  • contact his insurance to ask them to cover the costs of the repairs
  • get three quotes for the repairs, and get the car fixed myself

?

OP posts:
Oldnproud · 12/05/2023 12:05

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 11:32

I did report it to the police and they are pursing it - so hopefully he gets charged / fined.

I didn't really understand why I was referred to the rental company - but they said they would pursue a claim against his insurance on my behalf - because they could see on a database that he had insurance.

Believe me, the driver will almost certainly not get off with this. As you've reported it to police and have proof, they will more than likely get a summons, and potentially have many stressful and expensive months ahead of them leading up to at least a fine and points on their licence.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 12:02

Ignore enterprise.
Just get in touch with van’s insurer and sort yourself.
Their insured has damaged your car. You have cctv proof/police ref. They can either inspect car and repair or will ask you to supply a quote for repair.
Be alert to anyone offering you a ‘free’ hire car whilst yours is repaired (credit hire)

GCWorkNightmare · 12/05/2023 12:01

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 11:49

No it was my personal car (not a rental).

but my insurance referred not to Enterprise (who didn’t give me a rental) .. nos said they would pursue the claim against his insurance.

Hard to see why Enterprise would. They wouldn’t get anything out of this arrangement?

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 12:00

You need to go back to your insurance company and explain that the van was not rented and that you want them to contact the van drivers insurance to organise a payout.

Someone has simply got confused somewhere along the line.

Make sure you take notes of the date, time and outcome of all phone calls

Reugny · 12/05/2023 11:59

I’ve not had a rental, and my car has not been fixed yet - it’s still sat there looking very sad, as I was hoping his insurance company would take care of the repairs.

You don't want his insurance company to take care of your repairs.

Only because if they screw up you have no legal come back against them. You want to sort out your own repairs out with their written agreement that they will pay the bill. You will probably need to get 3 written quotes for the damage now so if you take it to Court you can state you want the middle amount.

I was hit by a large van while parked years ago. A witness saw it and so the driver admitted it. Anyway I looked up the difference between them sorting out the repairs and my insurance doing it, as I have comprehensive insurance, and that's the info I found out.

BunnyMum2000 · 12/05/2023 11:57

parietal · 12/05/2023 11:55

i'm also confused by the rental.

I think the situation is
OP's private car with third party insurance is parked in the street
Rented van from Enterprise hits the car

OP first contacts Enterprise because they own the van (rented out to a bad driver).

OP needs to find a way to claim from VanDriver's insurance policy because her own doesn't cover anything.

@BunnyMum2000 - is that right?

No the van that hit me was not a rental ( I don’t know who owns it)

my insurance company passed me over to Enterprise saying they would pursue a claim for me.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread