Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friendship reimbursement limit?

37 replies

C1N1C · 12/05/2023 08:32

The same goes for friend, neighbour, family member of course...

If they damage an item of your property, say accidentally drop your phone in a puddle, reverse into your car, knock over an heirloom etc... pure accident, no carelessness, where is your forgiveness limit?

Obviously, a good person would volunteer the compensation immediately, and you may instinctively waive it because it's not lot of money... but if it is a moderate amount, where is your "I'm sorry, but..." limit for a pretty good relationship?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bunnichick · 13/05/2023 10:42

If I had to put a figure on I'd say anything over £100 is a lot

Bunnichick · 13/05/2023 10:42

I think it depends on the circumstances. How it happened, why they were there, why my property was where it was, whether I can easily afford to replace it, whether they can, whether they offered, the nature of our relationship otherwise...

while it's not nice to ask a friend to pay for something that was obviously an accident, it's also not fair on you if you're saddled with the expense.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 13/05/2023 10:23

We are insured against most accidental damage and canafford any excess.
I am both a klutz myself and naturally forgiving, due to having angry Dad who exploded with temper at anything being damaged.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/05/2023 10:22

If it was over about 50 quid I'd try and get payment and I'd think really badly of someone who didn't insist on this. But I've always insisted on paying for anything I've damaged or broken even if they initially politely decline. Yes accidents are a fact of life...but that doesn't mean you shouldn't take responsibility for your own actions.

I find it a bit weird that lots of people on this thread wouldnt expect payment...but threads where someone cancels an event because they are genuinely ill, people always say they should reimburse others lost costs. (Eg a group event where other people would end up paying more). An accident is usually more preventable than an illness.

Bk1000 · 13/05/2023 10:13

What if a friend genuinely can’t afford to reimburse you for the damage caused by the accident? Would you just give up on the friendship whereas if clumsy friend had been better off you would have kept the friendship? It doesn’t sound like a real friendship if that is the case.

Dishwashersaurous · 13/05/2023 09:36

That's what I meant. I can't see how driving into someone else's car is a pure accident, as opposed to careless driving.

Not on purpose but not paying full attention etc.

Newrumpus · 12/05/2023 20:17

unintentional = accidental

Newrumpus · 12/05/2023 20:12

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 09:51

If your lack imagination to that extent, it sounds clinical. You seriously can't picture saying to someone, anyone, "pass me my phone" and them dropping it?

I think you might have Aphantasia.

Hey! Aphantasia doesn’t mean that!

NumberTheory · 12/05/2023 19:05

wildfirewonder · 12/05/2023 13:28

This is hilarious, accidents very regularly involve human error Confused

OP made the distinction between a "pure accident" and one due to carelessness. And said she was only talking about accidents that weren't careless. The sort of human error involved in driving into something is almost always carelessness.

PegasusReturns · 12/05/2023 17:20

You must have some spare money! If our car was bashed we couldn't afford to fix it or absorb with the loss of value in not getting it fixed

Generally speaking a car that is damaged to the point that it needs to be repaired will be covered by insurance.

most other things if you can’t afford to replace you just live without.

wildfirewonder · 12/05/2023 13:28

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 09:51

I'm trying to imagine a scenario whereby someone drives into someone else.

They may not do it on purpose but to actually drive into someone else requires a human error. Eg swung onto driveway and drop into a parked car there. That's not an accident. That's bad driving.

Therefore insurance matter.

This is hilarious, accidents very regularly involve human error Confused

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 10:41

But to answer your actual question. Anything above £20 I would expect the person who caused the breakage to pay.

Thinkbiglittleone · 12/05/2023 10:30

OP there are so many things that can change the situation and how you would respond.

I am not sure what it would take for me not forgive a friend, but again depends on the situation.

Greentree1 · 12/05/2023 10:18

Simianwalk · 12/05/2023 10:04

You must have some spare money! If our car was bashed we couldn't afford to fix it or absorb with the loss of value in not getting it fixed. A smashed glass I would ignore!

I thought we were talking a dink on the bumper when manoeuvring on the driveway or something, that would probably be less than the excess on your insurance so not worth claiming, not a serious crash, which would definitely go through insurance. Phones can be really expensive if you like to have the latest model so might have to come to some arrangement with that, although home insurance might cover it.

Simianwalk · 12/05/2023 10:04

PegasusReturns · 12/05/2023 08:54

I cannot imagine a single circumstance where I would expect a friend to reimburse me in the event of an accident.

Phones getting dropped, cars getting bumped, glasses getting smashed, these are all part of the risk of participation in normal life.

that said if a friend smashed into my car I would expect an apology, an offer to reimburse my expenses - which would be immediately batted away. On top of that a bunch of flowers would be well received, but no I cannot imagine accepting reimbursement for an accident

You must have some spare money! If our car was bashed we couldn't afford to fix it or absorb with the loss of value in not getting it fixed. A smashed glass I would ignore!

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 10:03

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 09:55

Accident is someone holding a glass and tripping over a loose paving stone and dropping the glass.

We could argue all day about semantics of the word Accident.

But someone driving into another car is a matter for insurance and full reimbursement. Not a shrug and sorry.

And again I can't imagine a situation whereby someone would drop someone else's phone in a puddle and then not automatically offer to pay for all it.

We don't need to argue about, its just clear that you don't really understand it.

Dropping a glass, accident. Driving a car into another car, not on purpose: also an accident. You may have heard of the term "car accident" before?

The pp didn't say they couldn't imagine someone dropping a phone in a puddle AND not offering to pay for it. They said they couldn't imagine anyone dropping a phone. Full stop.

I think if you try you can imagine someone doing it and not offering to pay....imagine they don't have any money to pay. There you go.

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 09:55

Accident is someone holding a glass and tripping over a loose paving stone and dropping the glass.

We could argue all day about semantics of the word Accident.

But someone driving into another car is a matter for insurance and full reimbursement. Not a shrug and sorry.

And again I can't imagine a situation whereby someone would drop someone else's phone in a puddle and then not automatically offer to pay for all it.

SquigglePigs · 12/05/2023 09:53

I've had a friend drop my phone in a washing up bowl. It was an accident! Luckily we managed to dry it out and it carried on working. I'd already turned down their offer to pay if it didn't though.

Glasses get broken etc. It's just a fact of life.

In our friendship group I can't imagine asking, or being asked, to pay for something damaged in an accident (although I would offer if it was anything more substantial than a glass). Cars are a bit different because there's insurance to deal with that.

I think it could be different if money was very tight though.

I can't for a minute imagine there being a limit on when I would forgive a friend. To be honest I don't even see it as forgiving - broken things are an accident!

Quitelikeit · 12/05/2023 09:53

Why not say what it is?

£10 is my limit!!!! Is that tight? 🤣🤣 then so be it

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 09:51

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 09:51

I'm trying to imagine a scenario whereby someone drives into someone else.

They may not do it on purpose but to actually drive into someone else requires a human error. Eg swung onto driveway and drop into a parked car there. That's not an accident. That's bad driving.

Therefore insurance matter.

Most accidents involve human error. What do you think the word accident means?

Dishwashersaurous · 12/05/2023 09:51

I'm trying to imagine a scenario whereby someone drives into someone else.

They may not do it on purpose but to actually drive into someone else requires a human error. Eg swung onto driveway and drop into a parked car there. That's not an accident. That's bad driving.

Therefore insurance matter.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 09:51

Banditdog · 12/05/2023 09:45

I am sure precious posters knows people drop things. But actually no, I cannot imagine a scenario in which a friend would drop my phone.

If your lack imagination to that extent, it sounds clinical. You seriously can't picture saying to someone, anyone, "pass me my phone" and them dropping it?

I think you might have Aphantasia.

bellsandwhistles333 · 12/05/2023 09:48

Omg I've been bit here.... i borrowed a friends very old lawnmower as mine died mid cut and the garden looked a state.

She told me all it's quirks and faults and made it clear they really needed to replace it but it should finish the job for me. It did just about but then the motor starting smoking and it packed up. As soon as I told her she completely changed her tune and was like 'oh my husbands really angry o lent it out he wants to cut the grass next week and it needs replacing' so I had to go and buy two new lawnmowers!!

No offer for money or anything I was so angry.
On the flip side my step mother was having a party and wanted a gazebo I kindly asked my sister in law who had 2 for business if she could borrow it and she agreed. We were away that weekend but when we came home I went to collect the gazebo she had left it up for 3 days during a storm and the gazebo had ripped and torn beyond repair. The bag it all came in she had let just blow away also and was so flippant about it I was so angry and embarrassed.
Luckily my sister in law said don't worry about ot and didn't ask me to replace it

Barelyable · 12/05/2023 09:48

Banditdog · 12/05/2023 09:45

I am sure precious posters knows people drop things. But actually no, I cannot imagine a scenario in which a friend would drop my phone.

Oh, I think if you used your imagination you could...what about if you asked a friend to pass you your phone and they accidently dropped it? Or you were showing them something on it and they waved their hand and it span across the floor? Ad Nauseum...

Banditdog · 12/05/2023 09:45

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 09:32

Really? You don't think cars get driven into or people drop things? I'm sure you can actually imagine it, really easily, if you try.

I am sure precious posters knows people drop things. But actually no, I cannot imagine a scenario in which a friend would drop my phone.