Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are there so many job vacancies??

392 replies

Manyanaish · 11/05/2023 16:25

Where we live businesses are sending fb messages to say that they are having to reduce opening hours due to lack of staff .. they are paying well above minimum wage ( £ 16 ph) , and are doing this to protect staff they have as they are pushed all the time.
the businesses that are sating this locally to us did not rely on pre brexit conditions . So .. what is going on ?

OP posts:
roundcork · 12/05/2023 11:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 11:09

In the past employers incentivised to take employees with a disability. There were also employers like remploy.
My friend worked in office at remploy and when they closed the factory she struggled to find another employer despite qualifications and experience eventually going to police.
Other than public sector and very large companies with proper policies it’s hard for people with a disability.
I do wonder how things will pan out for my DC who has a physical disability. Shes at sixth form and works pt in McDonalds who have been great.

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:05

SueVineer · 12/05/2023 11:03

I have worked in the past though when I would have been better off claiming benefits. It’s not acceptable to just live off the rest of us. Everyone should be contributing to society if they are able

I agree but I think people like you are in the minority to be honest. Depressingly.

SueVineer · 12/05/2023 11:03

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 10:50

Mumsnet posters genuinely do. They think the only group of people in the world who have zero ulterior motive and have purely honourable intentions are benefit claimants. They think they would ‘never claim benefits if they could work, I’m sure they would love a job’. It’s madness!

I have worked in the past though when I would have been better off claiming benefits. It’s not acceptable to just live off the rest of us. Everyone should be contributing to society if they are able

JandalsAlways · 12/05/2023 11:01

There's a world wide shortage of staff somehow an impact of covid, but surr what happened exactly maybe lots of people didn't return to the workforce or something

SueVineer · 12/05/2023 11:00

Windbeneathmybingowings · 11/05/2023 17:10

I’ve just done the benefits calculator for working my current hours vs not working at all. The amount is around the same (as obvs I pay childcare whilst working which otherwise I wouldn’t).

so no, no one is better off not working. Why is there still this assumption that people are desperate to get council houses and benefits and pretend to be sick so they can roll around like Scrooge McDuck in all their ill gotten gains off the government.

There’s no money or council houses or NHS left.

doesnt that prove the point though- you would be just the financially if you didn’t work at all. Not much of an incentive to work

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 10:58

TheThinkingGoblin · 12/05/2023 03:04

A big portion of those people will be unhealthy people that have been waiting for NHS treatment. Some for years now.

Thats why clearing the NHS backlog (7.3M procedures and rising now) is so critical.

Until that number starts coming down by treating people so they can start working again, those job vacancy numbers will remain high while the whole UK economy stagnates.

Yet another reason why it is economic lunacy to not pay healthcare workers better. Without them, there is no hope in hell of moving that 7.3M number as we have an aging society and the retired over 65s use up a lot of healthcare resources.

I don’t think I believe that. How are such vast swathes of the country suddenly so unhealthy they cannot work under any circumstances?

We have a lady at work with one arm, and a man with a musculoskeletal condition which means he’s in a wheelchair.

I think a lot of it is ‘mental health’. Suddenly everyone is pathologising normal feelings, pushing the GP for a diagnosis then deciding it means they can’t work. Perhaps they truly believe they feel worse than everyone else and need to do it, but objectively I would guess a lot of them don’t.

I know I’ll get flamed for that but that’s how I feel. It’s all very well blaming ‘the big corporations’ for not paying tax that they legally don’t have to, and saying ‘one person on benefits is a piddly amount compared to tax evasion’, but when you’ve a population the size of Scotland on benefits then that is unsustainable and a huge problem for both productivity and the people who have to work to fund them.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 10:50

Tax position needs looking at too. If you are at 40% point then dropping to 4 days can make a lot of sense. Hit on wage isn’t as big as you’d imagine due go tax and the one day off means you can do own gardening/cleaning/batch cooking etc so by time you’ve factored in all that you are actually net better off.

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 10:50

ThisOldThang · 11/05/2023 21:52

People act in their own best interests. Do you seriously think that people are going to bother working if they get zero extra money compared to benefits?

Mumsnet posters genuinely do. They think the only group of people in the world who have zero ulterior motive and have purely honourable intentions are benefit claimants. They think they would ‘never claim benefits if they could work, I’m sure they would love a job’. It’s madness!

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 10:46

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 09:23

Is there the possibility of your child attending breakfast or after school clubs to reduce the need for childcare?

Theres no wrap around provision at the specialist school she’ll be going to, no childminders will have her because she’ll be 12, no after school club picks up from her new school - and the school transport actively works against after school childcare in that they will only pick up and return to a home address and they need to hand her over to an adult at home. It’s a nightmare.

Depending on your child’s needs is it something a sixth former could do? Lots want caring experience for medicine applications.
An acquaintance who was a single parent Dr had a former nanny pick hers up from school and care for her at home with nanny’s own baby in tow.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/05/2023 10:38

@ThisOldThang my son earns that in IT (mind you he is only 25 and started at 16 with an apprenticeship) he has a huge skillset in networks , hardware and comms. He is inundated daily with recruiters- but he likes his company, likes the bosses and has a very interesting client site role at moment in a 'sexy' industry and is good with people and is about to start his formal PM training. As he said to me he could easily get 7k more but hate the job/company

emanresu000 · 12/05/2023 10:36

With respect to older people retiring early, I think the real situation is much more complex. According to Carers UK, the largest group of unpaid carers fall into the 46-65 age bracket. With difficulties finding social care provision, and people living longer, I suspect many people, like me , have not 'left' the workplace, but have taken rather insecure employment that can be done at home , with the flexibility for caring commitments to be undertaken.

Difficulties with social care and mental health resources may also mean that young people, like my son, have not been able to access the type of support and mentoring they need to transition to training and work.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 10:35

I also think there’s a huge problem that there’s been a shift in what age it’s acceptable for children to be left alone. NSPCC advice (not law) is under 12s shouldn’t be left for long periods.
Theres this grey area of too old/no childcare but society frowning on a 11 or 12 year old being left alone for hours.
If you are are working outside home with a commute or shifts then 11/12 yr olds could be on their own for several hours especially in school holidays.
You can’t blame people for wanting more flexibility or wfh to get through these years.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 10:28

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 07:27

A friend at university had a holiday job at a meat factory (1990s). He said there were 'mum shifts' where women would arrive after taking the kids to school and then work until 2pm, so that they could pick the kids up from school.

I suspect (educated guess based upon the UK labour market from early 2000s and current labour shortages in meat processing) that a lot of those jobs disappeared in favour of young Eastern Europeans working 12 hour shifts.

Companies will need to bring back that kind of flexibility to get staff in the post brexit world.

I did factory work as a student and those type of shifts and twilight shifts say 6-10 pm were norm picking up mum and in the evening student workers. They also ran usual 6-2, 2-10 shifts.
A biscuit factory near me offers 10-2and seems to have a reputation as an ok employer and doesn’t struggle for staff.

Sammyandtheboocas · 12/05/2023 10:26

I work in a University, and volunteer to be an interview panels.

Over the last 5 years I have seen the new thing of people cancelling interviews on the day, or simply not showing up.

These vacancies used to be incredibly popular, 80-90 applications for an entry level admin job just so people could get into the industry and be with a renowned good employer.

We are looking to get 20 decent applications now, and as I say, regularly get ghosted by people we have asked to an interview.

As far as I can tell, I'm guessing that the established wage bands are now simply not as attractive as they used to be. Something has definitely changed.

I would say the following things are true

  • Covid has made people re-assess their priorities . People of all ages are asking themselves do they really have to work? is that extra money earned working in a pub/cafe /restaurant really worth it?
  • People are not thinking about careers as much as they used to. People are living in the here and now.
  • Associated costs of working, such as travel, childcare, lunches etc make some jobs not worth considering and cut down the number of potential applicants.
  • Brexit - and you cannot deny this - has cut down the number of people available to work in the hospitality and tourist industry.

I think the vacancies we are talking about are affected by any or a combination of the above.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 10:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

I’d suspect 9 am start is an issue - unless school on your doorstep that’s breakfast club needed. Not always available and could cost 2 hours net pay a day if 2 children.
Then the sat unless you have another adult to cover you it’s very difficult. It means children can’t do any sat am activities for example.
I’d split it into 2 roles. One ‘mum’ hours 9ish - 2 and one sat am - even fortnightly would be attractive to a sixth form student with more hours in hols, when mum wants leave so win win. Set hours Saturday jobs are like gold dust.

SpeckledlyHen · 12/05/2023 10:06

peachespeachespeaches · 11/05/2023 18:40

@Manyanaish you're mad?! People can choose to do whichever job they want that suits their needs? I have never at any point written a pro and cons list for a job and included the caveat of "can paramedics also ask for this?".

What nonsense.

I agree with PP, I've just accepted a new job and I would have flatly turned it down if it had meant I had to be in the office 5 days a week, it's just not viable for my family needs and what I'm willing to sacrifice for the salary that is being offered. The new job is remote and flexible and involves flexi time so I can get the odd morning or afternoon off if needs be. But mainly I'm not travelling 1.5hrs each way to sit in an office all day.

This.

I recently left a job which was completely remote with a contract that was unique to me to say that my place of work was my home. Other members of staff had contracts to say their place of work was the London office so their WFH arrangement was purely discretionary. They could have been called into the office at any stage.

When I left my boss said I would be unlikely to get another job with such a great home working package. However, two weeks later I did just that and got a massive payrise to boot. No one I work with goes into the office, we are all remote and work in various locations all over the UK which means that commuting simply isn't possible. They are paying for talent and experience in a niche industry rather than worrying where those people are sat. I would refuse to go into an office now, not worth the time, money or hassle.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 09:43

I'm afraid I don't have any answers. Those seem like intractable issues except for those earning £100k+

There aren’t any answers to be fair, there’s just an expectation that if your child has a disability there will be a non-working carer available at all times. There are so many parents of children with mild to moderate learning difficulties, learning disabilities, developmental delay etc who want to work but can’t because the infrastructure just isn’t there and so they remain on benefits indefinitely.

DogInATent · 12/05/2023 09:42

With regards to seasonal tourist work, I'd have thought that students would be perfect given their 12 week summer breaks. They could have working holidays in, for example, Cornwall - but they'd need accommodation to be provided ether by employers or the local tourist board.
The season starts in Easter and runs to the end of September. It's longer than the student holidays. They've been advertising for immediate start for over a month already.

With the holiday let cleaning jobs I'm already starting to see the corners being cut. Jobs that clearly don't meet the HMRC definition are being advertised as 'self-employed'.

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 09:40

@Maverickess Agreed. It is a ridiculous situation where fat cats pay themselves obscene wages, while their staff live hand-to-mouth on minimum wage / benefits top-ups.

I'm just not sure how that would work for shyster companies like Starbucks that claim to make a loss to avoid paying tax.

3BSHKATS · 12/05/2023 09:36

“I grew up in the 30s with an unemployed father. He did not riot. He got on his bike and looked for work.”

And a man with limited family responsibilities can do that. The issue is we expect mothers to do that and they simply cannot.

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 09:34

"it's not as easy as "get on your bike" to go find another job in another area (for anyone that remembers Norman T.)."

What he actually said was in response to people suggesting that riots were due to unemployment.

“I grew up in the 30s with an unemployed father. He did not riot. He got on his bike and looked for work.”

https://wordhistories.net/2021/12/19/get-on-your-bike/

With regards to seasonal tourist work, I'd have thought that students would be perfect given their 12 week summer breaks. They could have working holidays in, for example, Cornwall - but they'd need accommodation to be provided ether by employers or the local tourist board.

‘get on your bike’ (exhortation to take action)

UK—since 1981, has been associated with a speech by the Employment Secretary, Norman Tebbit, at the Conservative Party conference, in which he exhorted the unemployed to go and find work, like his …

https://wordhistories.net/2021/12/19/get-on-your-bike

Maverickess · 12/05/2023 09:34

My profile on Indeed is still active and I'm getting lots of 'invitation to apply' emails (I'm not sure if this is a new function on Indeed or if employers are having to do a bit more now to try and get staff and it always existed and lots more are using it)
I've just had a look through the last 10 or so and not one is paying over the nmw, many are offering things like a free mandatory uniform or free/paid mandatory training as a 'perk' of the job! And they all say that it's an 'urgent' vacancy, and was posted 30+ days ago, most in care, retail and hospitality.
It's incredibly lazy and short sighted to believe that everyone is just too idle and would rather live on such generous benefits than to do one of those jobs, rather than the employers just simply aren't offering enough - and by enough I mean a wage that you can live on without scraping to survive and working conditions that don't take over your life.

The government aren't exactly famed for their generosity, but we have a situation where you can be getting the same income despite working - the issue there is not too generous benefits, it's too tight employers who have been allowed to get away with paying too little and the state subsidising their business with in work benefits.

I'd like to see a shift to full time work equalling an actual living wage and if an employer can't afford to pay that, then they are the ones who apply for top up benefits in order to be able to do so, not the employees. And they have to fullfil a set of strict criteria to be able to claim - one of which being they cannot be taking large profit while paying the minimum and then expecting government hand outs. I reckon that alone would cut the welfare bill because companies would be forced to pay the actual going rate and prove the reasons they can't - and if those reasons are massive profits then tough, you pay for your own staff and you take less profit.

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 09:27

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 09:23

Is there the possibility of your child attending breakfast or after school clubs to reduce the need for childcare?

Theres no wrap around provision at the specialist school she’ll be going to, no childminders will have her because she’ll be 12, no after school club picks up from her new school - and the school transport actively works against after school childcare in that they will only pick up and return to a home address and they need to hand her over to an adult at home. It’s a nightmare.

I'm afraid I don't have any answers. Those seem like intractable issues except for those earning £100k+

DogInATent · 12/05/2023 09:25

Then wages will have to rise in those sectors. The market will resolve the issue by allowing labour where it's needed at the wage required.

Unprofitable businesses will go bust and those workers will be relocated by the market to the businesses that provide goods/services that are in demand.

The theory of the free market doesn't work, because it assumes infinite mobility on the part of all actors in the labour market. In reality things are constrained by skills/experience, transport, and housing. Businesses can't move overnight, and it's not as easy as "get on your bike" to go find another job in another area (for anyone that remembers Norman T.).

When I look at what's happening locally, the hospitality sector is being struggling in popular tourist areas because there's a lack of affordable accommodation, public transport is poor, and the work is highly seasonal. The industrial sector (mostly food related) is struggling because post-Brexit/post-Covid the workforce is on average older and proportionately now has a higher percentage wanting fractional contracts for reasons of childcare, health, or just because they want a better work:life balance.