Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are there so many job vacancies??

392 replies

Manyanaish · 11/05/2023 16:25

Where we live businesses are sending fb messages to say that they are having to reduce opening hours due to lack of staff .. they are paying well above minimum wage ( £ 16 ph) , and are doing this to protect staff they have as they are pushed all the time.
the businesses that are sating this locally to us did not rely on pre brexit conditions . So .. what is going on ?

OP posts:
Furiously · 12/05/2023 14:53

Maverickess · 12/05/2023 14:21

I wish I could afford to live closer to work! I'm priced out unfortunately and I'm on more than nmw. I couldn't afford private rent and there's nothing SH wise - there's a few empty SH places in the village I live in though, but nothing where the jobs are.

The bus service is good on paper and used to be, but due to a shortage of drivers mainly (not to mention the buses being poorly maintained and therefore breaking down regularly) it's now hit and miss.
I set off 90 minutes before I start work, sometimes the bus turns up and I'm an hour early (25 min journey on the bus and supposed to be a service every 30 minutes) sometimes it doesn't and I scrape in on time. Sometimes it takes me up to 2 hours to get home. I'm lucky I have an understanding employer and I don't have small children needing dropping off/picking up at certain times or other commitments (because even wrap around childcare closes at some point) so I can afford the extra couple of hours each end of an 8 hour shift should I need them.

I worked nights for around 15 years because it was better childcare wise, but then I was lucky enough to have a family that would have my child 4/5 nights a week - and I now have health issues thanks to so long working permanent nights . There was no childcare that enabled me to work day shifts starting at 7am or finishing at 10pm that included weekends. Childcare opened at 7am and closed at 6pm.

There's plenty of jobs advertised in the two tourist towns local to me, retail, care and hospitality - but not the infrastructure to support people actually working there, and not paying enough to live locally and walk to work. So they go unfilled.

These are the real issues that people face - but nope, it's just because people want to be lazy and pick their kids up from school and just live off benefits.

I wish every Tory would read this.

Maverickess · 12/05/2023 14:21

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:58

But why should they take into account your location? If you choose to live very rurally, or cut off from transport links, it’s obvious jobs will be in shorter supply and hard to reach. You accept that when you live there. It feels like some people just feel entitled to a job that is only 100% convenient to them, when even most of us in employment don’t have that.

Ditto childcare. Working mums use breakfast clubs and annual leave and so on. Why should their taxes go to somebody who feels entitled not to work so they can pick their kids up at 3pm?

The entitlement of some people astonishes me. Working shouldn’t be a ‘nice to have if it suits your life’, benefits should be a last resort and stop funding some people to have a better pace of life or more convenience.

I wish I could afford to live closer to work! I'm priced out unfortunately and I'm on more than nmw. I couldn't afford private rent and there's nothing SH wise - there's a few empty SH places in the village I live in though, but nothing where the jobs are.

The bus service is good on paper and used to be, but due to a shortage of drivers mainly (not to mention the buses being poorly maintained and therefore breaking down regularly) it's now hit and miss.
I set off 90 minutes before I start work, sometimes the bus turns up and I'm an hour early (25 min journey on the bus and supposed to be a service every 30 minutes) sometimes it doesn't and I scrape in on time. Sometimes it takes me up to 2 hours to get home. I'm lucky I have an understanding employer and I don't have small children needing dropping off/picking up at certain times or other commitments (because even wrap around childcare closes at some point) so I can afford the extra couple of hours each end of an 8 hour shift should I need them.

I worked nights for around 15 years because it was better childcare wise, but then I was lucky enough to have a family that would have my child 4/5 nights a week - and I now have health issues thanks to so long working permanent nights . There was no childcare that enabled me to work day shifts starting at 7am or finishing at 10pm that included weekends. Childcare opened at 7am and closed at 6pm.

There's plenty of jobs advertised in the two tourist towns local to me, retail, care and hospitality - but not the infrastructure to support people actually working there, and not paying enough to live locally and walk to work. So they go unfilled.

These are the real issues that people face - but nope, it's just because people want to be lazy and pick their kids up from school and just live off benefits.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 12/05/2023 13:17

That would be a struggle to live on in some parts of the country - eg London and the South East.

Mooshamoo · 12/05/2023 12:59

Brexit

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/05/2023 12:58

Tailfeather · 11/05/2023 23:00

Maybe that explains it! People can't work out that £16ph is at least £30k per year!

It's £ 33k

https://www.startpage.com/do/dsearch?query=%C2%A316+per+hour+as+annual+wage&cat=web&pl=ext-ff&language=english&extVersion=1.3.0

Shinyandnew1 · 12/05/2023 12:40

jgw1 · 12/05/2023 12:02

Rishi has a plan for that.
Give lots of money to a company owned by his wife, who will then pass a small amount of that on to childcare providers.

Fabulous-problem solved 😂.

Unfortunately, Labour’s future whole plan for education seems to have no focus on education but on forcing schools to all run more breakfast and after school clubs to get people back in work. As schools can’t hire TAs to work between 9-3 (as they can get better paid jobs), the chances of finding anyone willing to work 7.30-9 and 3.30-6 on minimum wage is not looking good.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 12/05/2023 12:37

The reality is that some people can't work because the childcare doesn't exist. No amount of rhetoric, slogans or stupid comparisons are going to tackle that. Other working mums having a breakfast club to use doesn't magic one up in an area that lacks them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 12:28

Ditto childcare. Working mums use breakfast clubs and annual leave and so on. Why should their taxes go to somebody who feels entitled not to work so they can pick their kids up at 3pm?

I’d rather taxes went to create decent childcare. In my town 3 after school clubs closed post Covid, a number of childminders retired or found other work - it’s not a case of wanting childcare to cater for all needs, I’d be happy with after school provision of any kind. We have one after school club (which I had to remove my kids from following a serious safeguarding breach), and 3 childminders who pick up from my kids school. All are fully subscribed, I’m currently cobbling together enough provision to work part time. And as I’ve described up thread, it’s about to get much harder for me.

My town is a good sized commuter belt town, with a number of medium sized employers and good links to two major cities - hardly the arse end of nowhere but childcare options are limited and poor quality.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 12/05/2023 12:12

Chowtime · 11/05/2023 16:54

£16 an hour not enough to live on. You need £30k a year to live comfortably.

Or else why bother? If all you're gonna do is work and struggle you may as well just not work.

£16 an hour is roughly 33 k a year

Spendonsend · 12/05/2023 12:06

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:58

But why should they take into account your location? If you choose to live very rurally, or cut off from transport links, it’s obvious jobs will be in shorter supply and hard to reach. You accept that when you live there. It feels like some people just feel entitled to a job that is only 100% convenient to them, when even most of us in employment don’t have that.

Ditto childcare. Working mums use breakfast clubs and annual leave and so on. Why should their taxes go to somebody who feels entitled not to work so they can pick their kids up at 3pm?

The entitlement of some people astonishes me. Working shouldn’t be a ‘nice to have if it suits your life’, benefits should be a last resort and stop funding some people to have a better pace of life or more convenience.

My town/villlage is in a high employment area with great transport links but childcare is a real isissue it just doesnt exist in the type or way people need. Nurseries are closing, schools are struggling to staff breakfast and afterschool clubs.
Its really does need tackling at a society level.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 12:03

Brrrrrrrrrrrr · 11/05/2023 21:33

Brexit really fucked up our workforce

Long Covid taking people out of the workplace, Covid itself made people rethink their careers

The youngsters don’t want to do casual menial jobs they want to be influencers

I mean it’s almost as if we are being encouraged to blame other ordinary for all of our problems instead of blaming a massively corrupt system based on massively outdated economic policies which have been proven over and over again not to work.

You claim young people don’t want to work when there are millions of them working for peanuts, being robbed off with crappy modern apprenticeships which are practically exploitative instead of what an apprenticeship used to mean.

its actually incredible that some people have found a way to make money on their own terms. Heck there is this lovely and hard working younger woman making mega money on only fans. If o didn’t look like a troll that had lost its bridge I’d be well up for that. Kids are finding ways to make money from nothing, bitcoin mining, using data to make money, playing games to make money. It’s bloody ingenious and as more jobs are replaced by AI the world will need that kind of flexible thinking for anyone to stay employed.

m this attitude is just as dangerous as blaming boomers for our struggles when the truth is they had their own, the world moved on, and their only true action they can be judged on is their voting record.

If we stopped turning in each other, life would be a lot more pleasant.

jgw1 · 12/05/2023 12:02

Shinyandnew1 · 12/05/2023 09:12

A large local employer here has always had an on-site crèche which has been very highly thought of. I know a number of parents at the school who work there and have used it. It is closing in the summer (citing inadequate funding from the government and changing expectations for early years), leaving 90 kids and 20 members of staff looking for something else. It’s been quite a big story in the papers alongside several other local nurseries closing due to rising rents/energy charges/mimimim
wage when the given funding per child hasn’t increased.

Childcare going forward is going to be a massive problem unless funding is addressed pretty sharpish.

Rishi has a plan for that.
Give lots of money to a company owned by his wife, who will then pass a small amount of that on to childcare providers.

DogInATent · 12/05/2023 11:58

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:55

In general, no. I think if you did a survey of claimants versus non claimants. Non claimants are more likely to be qualified for their job to some degree.

What's this 5m figure?

And what relevance has it got to the sort of job that uses panel interviews?

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:58

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 11:54

Encouraged is different from being hounded. The current system takes no account of caring responsibilities, location, availability of public transport, your physical capabilities.

all of the evidence you need to submit online, applying for jobs you’re not even capable of doing just so you don’t get sanctioned.

being forced to apply for jobs you can’t do due to the childcare, being forced to apply for jobs that have terrible terms and conditions. Half the jobs on the universal job search are mlms…. Or zero hours contracts

m it’s not easy at all for parents these days. I’m very fortunate I have always worked and found jobs that with extreme effort I could make work with having kids.

m but I’m going to be brutally honest, my experience came down to sheer luck, being in the right place at the right time. I think a lot of people confuse their luck and advantages they may have had in the past with earning something. I didn’t do anything other than be lucky to get where I am. It could easily have been me struggling to get by on UC

But why should they take into account your location? If you choose to live very rurally, or cut off from transport links, it’s obvious jobs will be in shorter supply and hard to reach. You accept that when you live there. It feels like some people just feel entitled to a job that is only 100% convenient to them, when even most of us in employment don’t have that.

Ditto childcare. Working mums use breakfast clubs and annual leave and so on. Why should their taxes go to somebody who feels entitled not to work so they can pick their kids up at 3pm?

The entitlement of some people astonishes me. Working shouldn’t be a ‘nice to have if it suits your life’, benefits should be a last resort and stop funding some people to have a better pace of life or more convenience.

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:55

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 11:27

But they’re not. That’s why we have 5 million claiming.

Strong candidates aren't claiming, are they? They're snapped up almost immediately.

The last time I switched jobs, I had two banks in a bidding war for my skills.

In general, no. I think if you did a survey of claimants versus non claimants. Non claimants are more likely to be qualified for their job to some degree.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 11:54

Garethkeenansstapler · 11/05/2023 22:22

Why shouldn’t you be encouraged to get a job if your kid is in school?

Encouraged is different from being hounded. The current system takes no account of caring responsibilities, location, availability of public transport, your physical capabilities.

all of the evidence you need to submit online, applying for jobs you’re not even capable of doing just so you don’t get sanctioned.

being forced to apply for jobs you can’t do due to the childcare, being forced to apply for jobs that have terrible terms and conditions. Half the jobs on the universal job search are mlms…. Or zero hours contracts

m it’s not easy at all for parents these days. I’m very fortunate I have always worked and found jobs that with extreme effort I could make work with having kids.

m but I’m going to be brutally honest, my experience came down to sheer luck, being in the right place at the right time. I think a lot of people confuse their luck and advantages they may have had in the past with earning something. I didn’t do anything other than be lucky to get where I am. It could easily have been me struggling to get by on UC

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 11:48

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 11:34

My dc is 17 and lots of her peers would be great at that type of role. They are mature sensible girls often with volunteering experience like brownies/guides and first aid qualifications. Or a childcare college student. The local primary after school club employs some of them (pays £5 an hour to 16 yr olds) so watching tv/making a snack with one child would be a much more attractive job.

The issue with hiring someone to sit at home, is not the age. It’s employment law. You’re employing them, that means you need to pay their tax and NI, provide a workplace pension, have insurance, pay holiday, sickness and maternity pay.

it’s why hiring a nanny is normally done through an agency.

then of course if checks haven’t been done social work will have a blast.

I did use au pairs as the rules are different, but equally you can’t ask them to work over night, it’s in the rules, so a work trio away was impossible.

It really isn’t easy.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 11:45

kitsuneghost · 11/05/2023 17:02

We need to look at the benefits system for the able to work.
I would rather see free transport and childcare to allow people to work rather than giving them a generic sum for not working.

The benefits system needs an overhaul so that people are encouraged to work where they can, but not penalised for being sick, being caters, having no childcare or not being able to take on any job. Every single person should have enough money to be safe, housed and fed. When you start assessing a human beings value based on their financial contribution that’s a slippery slope.

with the rise of AI, lots of lower level jobs will eventually go and without a drastic change in attire a lot of people will be homeless and starving. There’s no reason at all we couldn’t have a universal basic income, the savings alone from it being universal and not means tested helps pay for it. There is more than enough money in the system if we aren’t paying billions for private companies to harass the sick and disabled.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/05/2023 11:34

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 11:27

Depending on your child’s needs is it something a sixth former could do? Lots want caring experience for medicine applications.
An acquaintance who was a single parent Dr had a former nanny pick hers up from school and care for her at home with nanny’s own baby in tow.

Thats not a bad idea tbh re senior students.

I did try to find a nanny/nanny share with no luck - it would be costly but I could afford it if I returned to work full time. It would mean a nanny picking up my DS from school at 3 and then getting my DD at 3.30 from her school which is literally across the road from my DS school. My sense is there’s a high demand for childcare in my area so anything out of the norm or that looks a bit complex just isn’t attractive enough compared to straightforward pick ups and kids with no additional needs.

I’ll have a look at high schoolers though because they’d literally just need to sit with my DD at home for an hour or two.

My dc is 17 and lots of her peers would be great at that type of role. They are mature sensible girls often with volunteering experience like brownies/guides and first aid qualifications. Or a childcare college student. The local primary after school club employs some of them (pays £5 an hour to 16 yr olds) so watching tv/making a snack with one child would be a much more attractive job.

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 11:31

If you aren't interviewing strong candidates within a week you will lose them because they are attending other interviews.

I applied for a job recently, it took 5 weeks after closing date for them to shortlist, I was invited for interview 3 weeks later and it took them 2 weeks after that to let me know the outcome by which time I wasn’t interested. A friend applied for a job in the same project, interviews were finally held 12 weeks after the closing date by which time she too had lost interest.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/05/2023 11:29

@Garethkeenansstapler whilst I know what you are saying I myself am kind of in that position - luckily we have a business and are good earners and I can do my bits from wherever at my own pace- if I had to apply externally I would def be underperforming

I developed nasty neurological stuff post covid/4th vaccine (don't know which as they timed close together) blooming daily migraines, nerve/muscle twitching, neck pain, one weak leg , coeliac , - it's affected my ability to actually focus and makes you very anxious- I'm afraid post viral illness has given a fair few older people I know the equivalent of ME/MS even. It's being vastly underreported too. If you go onto the health boards here in general health and look at those bringing up sudden neuro or heart issues- with no explanation after bloods, MRIs etc. not all old either or fat or diabetic

I am the kind of person that hadn't seen a doctor for 22 years .

It's almost a bit easier if you have a defined condition that can be treated or a physical disability that doesn't affect mental ability - this shit offers no respite, no treatment

Jellycatspyjamas · 12/05/2023 11:27

Depending on your child’s needs is it something a sixth former could do? Lots want caring experience for medicine applications.
An acquaintance who was a single parent Dr had a former nanny pick hers up from school and care for her at home with nanny’s own baby in tow.

Thats not a bad idea tbh re senior students.

I did try to find a nanny/nanny share with no luck - it would be costly but I could afford it if I returned to work full time. It would mean a nanny picking up my DS from school at 3 and then getting my DD at 3.30 from her school which is literally across the road from my DS school. My sense is there’s a high demand for childcare in my area so anything out of the norm or that looks a bit complex just isn’t attractive enough compared to straightforward pick ups and kids with no additional needs.

I’ll have a look at high schoolers though because they’d literally just need to sit with my DD at home for an hour or two.

ThisOldThang · 12/05/2023 11:27

But they’re not. That’s why we have 5 million claiming.

Strong candidates aren't claiming, are they? They're snapped up almost immediately.

The last time I switched jobs, I had two banks in a bidding war for my skills.

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:23

DogInATent · 12/05/2023 11:20

Over the last 5 years I have seen the new thing of people cancelling interviews on the day, or simply not showing up.

What's not helping is employers sticking to the old ways of recruiting. You can't wait until the end of the advertised deadline period or until you've 20 applicants to convene a panel for an interview. If you aren't interviewing strong candidates within a week you will lose them because they are attending other interviews.

But they’re not. That’s why we have 5 million claiming.

DogInATent · 12/05/2023 11:20

Over the last 5 years I have seen the new thing of people cancelling interviews on the day, or simply not showing up.

What's not helping is employers sticking to the old ways of recruiting. You can't wait until the end of the advertised deadline period or until you've 20 applicants to convene a panel for an interview. If you aren't interviewing strong candidates within a week you will lose them because they are attending other interviews.

Swipe left for the next trending thread