Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are there so many job vacancies??

392 replies

Manyanaish · 11/05/2023 16:25

Where we live businesses are sending fb messages to say that they are having to reduce opening hours due to lack of staff .. they are paying well above minimum wage ( £ 16 ph) , and are doing this to protect staff they have as they are pushed all the time.
the businesses that are sating this locally to us did not rely on pre brexit conditions . So .. what is going on ?

OP posts:
luckylavender · 13/05/2023 13:01

@PinkCherryBlossoms - we need to get back to a position where benefits are a safety net & where people realise how society works

PinkCherryBlossoms · 13/05/2023 12:59

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:52

"Choosing to not work" should not be a viable option. Everyone should work.

Sounds a bit commie, that. And what would you do about people who don't need to work?

Spendonsend · 13/05/2023 12:58

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:52

"Choosing to not work" should not be a viable option. Everyone should work.

I dont understand how this fits with the vision if AI doing all the basic work and relatively few people doing higher paid work.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 13/05/2023 12:54

luckylavender · 13/05/2023 12:51

Because that's great for society right?

As if people faced with low wages that don't allow them to live comfortably will factor that into their decision.

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:52

"Choosing to not work" should not be a viable option. Everyone should work.

luckylavender · 13/05/2023 12:51

Chowtime · 11/05/2023 16:54

£16 an hour not enough to live on. You need £30k a year to live comfortably.

Or else why bother? If all you're gonna do is work and struggle you may as well just not work.

Because that's great for society right?

jgw1 · 13/05/2023 12:50

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:46

We don't need as many workers with automatization and AI etc. Companies are just going to have to deal with it, find ways to make it work, or close down. We can't keep bringing in immigrants to do shit jobs forever. We need to modernize and become a sleek, modern country with relatively few well-trained people all doing good jobs for high wages.

One of our recent Tory PMs promised us a high wage high skill economy, which is of course why they are so keen to increase the pay in line with inflation of highly skilled workers like teachers, doctors and nurses.

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:46

We don't need as many workers with automatization and AI etc. Companies are just going to have to deal with it, find ways to make it work, or close down. We can't keep bringing in immigrants to do shit jobs forever. We need to modernize and become a sleek, modern country with relatively few well-trained people all doing good jobs for high wages.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 13/05/2023 12:40

The wages are part of it, but also the labour force has shrunk and pretty much the easiest way for people to join it has gone away. That's obviously going to have an impact.

Florenz · 13/05/2023 12:34

It's the low-paid that is the issue. Pay more and you will find applicants. Brexit didn't fuck the country, employers who expect workers to work for low wages fucked this country.

maranella · 13/05/2023 11:50

It seems the huge shortages are in low-paid work with antisocial hours - cleaners, care assistants, hospitality, etc. Those jobs were filled in the past with lots of people from the EU. Many of them went home after Brexit and during the pandemic. They now can't come back, even if they wanted to, because thanks to Brexit they've lost the right to live/work here. Brexit fucked this country.

3BSHKATS · 13/05/2023 11:48

@mrsnec I worked as a job coach during the pandemic, most of my colleagues were teachers, no training in job coaching whatsoever. Take their advice with a pinch of salt.
Take the role that works for you and the children. I was required to discuss increasing hours with claimants, they called in, I said can you increase your hours, they said no i havent got childcare, i wrote it down. End of conversation. Once you are in some kind of job they back right off, you will be treated a lot better. It's absolute luck of the draw who you end up with.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/05/2023 11:30

Maybe the government needs to help people abandon those physical locations (e.g. buy and demolish housing) and relocate to the places with jobs?

It’s not easy to move locations, what about people having a support structure around them - family, friends, schools and communities? There’s also a huge disparity in house prices, so leave the home you bought in Wales to move somewhere much more expensive to access a job paying the same salary? Or the government could invest in those locations, support local industry and small businesses. People aren’t pawns to be moved around at the convenience of businesses who will ultimately show no loyalty to staff who uproot themselves for a job.

mrsnec · 13/05/2023 10:36

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 23:39

I really feel for you. Can I suggest that you totally ignore most of the advice on job hunting given by the work coaches as they haven’t got a clue. Keep applying for whatever nonsense they are touting. But make sure your linked in profile is good, do some volunteering for local organisations for things related to what you’d be comfortable doing to add to your cv, make sure the cv is spectacular. I have a single page cv, very brief with just basics, and personality filled covering letters, only put the max effort into the jobs you really want, but take time on them. If you’re applying for anything you’re not giving yourself enough time and mental space to put in the effort for a great application.

also work with specialist recruiters. It’s not easy at all. But I really wish I could banana peel your job coach’s car for you.

take care and good luck

They've never even suggested anything! I have applied for that many jobs in that many fields because I was so scared of them pushing me into doing something I didn't want to do.

They offered to help me with my CV. Gave them a copy. They sat on it for ages and sent me a notification saying 'reviewed ' I got no feedback whatsoever.

I considered volunteering but they wouldn't consider it as part of the hours I'm expected to look for work so I don't have time to work search and and look for unpaid work too. Also I spend half my life filling in forms and preparing for interviews.

Every job I've applied for the process has been worse than ever.

One NMW retail job interview involved shadowing staff and practical exams and took 3 hours.

I've had discrimination over my age and single mum status that upset so much I wrote to my MP about it.

The job I accepted last week the employer is so disorganised I've not had an official start date and they've changed the induction venue twice. And they got very stroppy with me when I said I couldn't start immediately.

I kept my options open and I have two more interviews next week. Both I've already had telephone interviews for and done online assessments and one has sent me homework to do.

I've been so despondent about the whole process I genuinely Don't know who I am and what I want anymore and if I end up having to decide between 3 jobs I don't know how I'd decide.

The two other roles are the same hours and pay. 25/30 hours for around 23k. One is a hybrid marketing executive and one is a local authority finance Officer.

I know the other one fits in with the kids but it feels like it's not enough and it's mostly because of the job centre that I'm thinking that.

I've had no guidance whatsoever just constant threats and psychoanalysis from the re-start people. That felt like an extra layer of pressure not support. The online courses they sent me to prepare for interviews were a complete waste of time so I haven't requested any more for my next two interviews.

So I'm not gonna stand in anyone's way with the banana skins!

Get this, I've got all that going on and they're still telling me to put in more applications!

RosaGallica · 13/05/2023 10:07

Also there were concerted efforts to push the reserve army of labour, ie women with kids, out of the workforce. They suddenly need us back but a lot of the pushing out relied on lying, manipulation and ‘nudge’ work. I’m not sure the people in charge even know what truth and practical reality is now, let alone how to approach real change in our favour without exposing their lies.

RosaGallica · 13/05/2023 10:05

Not difficult is it? Because they are asking too much for the wage they are offering. Boomers have retired and taken their economy and wage / living costs ratios with them. Suddenly all that stuff they forced us xennials to swallow about positive change shit is on the other foot, and unsurprisingly it was always a load of bollox built on the reality of power-based relations. They have made work not worth doing and now the new economy and new ratios cannot stand, it has no reality. Dont expect change any time soon though, it will involve the inheriting rich having to give something back.

JudgeRudy · 13/05/2023 10:01

The jobs you are quoting at £16/hr is not my experience of job vacancies. The majority of vacancies I see advertised locally (East Midlands) are part time under £12/hr and seem to want a great deal of flexibility. Many jobs don't even advertise the rate or hours, it just says eg 24hrs per week Monday to Sat between 8 and 8....

ThisOldThang · 13/05/2023 09:55

"maybe ask why the job market is so unbalanced that the available workforce isn’t where it’s needed?"

Perhaps part of the problem is too many people expecting the jobs to come to them? For example, people moved to Wales due to the coal boom. The pits closed and the people remained in isolated communities.

In an ideal world, other industries would provide employment, but in the real world that hasn't happened and may never happen.

Maybe the government needs to help people abandon those physical locations (e.g. buy and demolish housing) and relocate to the places with jobs?

Or maybe better internet provision will make those communities more viable with home working?

The entire economy is in a state of transition - brexit, home working, net zero (for better or worse), the war on cars, etc. We're in the eye of the storm, but things may improve very quickly as the country adapts.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 13/05/2023 08:50

Fundamentally, people either need to be able to work remotely or they need jobs they can physically get to. If the latter, that means the combination of proximity, housing and transport has to be right.

If this doesn't happen, the mismatch between available jobs and people will continue.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 13/05/2023 08:19

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 11:58

But why should they take into account your location? If you choose to live very rurally, or cut off from transport links, it’s obvious jobs will be in shorter supply and hard to reach. You accept that when you live there. It feels like some people just feel entitled to a job that is only 100% convenient to them, when even most of us in employment don’t have that.

Ditto childcare. Working mums use breakfast clubs and annual leave and so on. Why should their taxes go to somebody who feels entitled not to work so they can pick their kids up at 3pm?

The entitlement of some people astonishes me. Working shouldn’t be a ‘nice to have if it suits your life’, benefits should be a last resort and stop funding some people to have a better pace of life or more convenience.

you’re really not in the loop of how things are are you 🤦‍♀️

hate to tell you. A huge number of those vacancies, especially in health and social care and hospitality ARE in rural locations. Why should someone apply for a job in a place where they cannot afford accommodation and if the job is minimum wage and public transport isn’t good enough why on Earth would someone want to live there?

If I wanted a different job, I could have one in 20 minutes rurally. They are begging for staff, but if you’re paying minimum wage no one can afford to live on that and live here and it’s too far from where the affordable housing is to travel. Thanks airbnb

we can’t even get health professionals, no one can find a place to stay, and then people whine because they come here on holiday, stay in an air bnb and half the restaurant is closed and there’s no out of hours service if they get Ill as there’s physically not enough people living full time in the location to staff all the services.

in terms of childcare, you’re thinking Monday to Friday. My job involves travel. Anyone working as a nurse or carer, or hospitality, or even in a pub has this issue. Do you know how many childcare sites and nurseries offer over night care? Do you know how hard it is to find over night care and not end up in hot water with social work?

not everyone has family, some of us have to figure stuff out on our own, and rely on sheer luck and determination to get by. I would never criticise anyone for choosing a different path than I did.

sure I have money, but I ruined my life and health working and probably won’t live to see retirement. It’s not a competition on how much we self flagellate. And every job I got was down to having a privileged background and sheer luck. I didn’t do anything better than someone who is stuck on benefits.

having a job doesn’t make me better than anyone else and instead of huffing and puffing because there’s “all these jobs” maybe ask why the job market is so unbalanced that the available workforce isn’t where it’s needed? Ie housing

3littlerabbits · 13/05/2023 08:13

Manyanaish · 11/05/2023 18:00

You are not special . I was also at the top of my career .. but i accepted that I was needed in the office / place of work as lives depended on it .
do you really think shop workers can vote with their feet ?? And decided they can work from home ?? Ha ha , real
world ?

Some jobs are able to be done fully at home (a lot of office/admin/IT work for example) Some are not (like front line medical or supermarkets for example). The pp doesn’t want to move from a working from home office job to a working in the office job (extra travel time/cost etc). Seems straightforward? It would be strange if she was a surgeon or a refuse collector demanding to work from home for example, but if she works on maintaining computer systems and sits looking at a screen or on the phone all day then her location makes zero difference to the work. Some jobs are different to others.

briansgardenshed · 13/05/2023 07:56

Housing is a problem. Employers got round that in other countries and other times by providing homes with jobs. (Especially for young and single people). The culture and legal position has changed and it's not currently a viable prospect.

Maverickess · 13/05/2023 07:52

ThisOldThang · 13/05/2023 07:35

it’s NOT that no one wants to work

Come on? Seriously? There are millions of people that don't want to work.

Why do you think the Lottery is so popular?

I mean fair point, I don't want to work, of course I'd rather spend my life walking my dogs, watching TV and having lunch with my friends or sitting on a beach.

Unfortunately in order to do that for 5/52 I need to work 47/52.

I don't merely exist to work, I quite enjoy it as in it's something that I have to do, so I might as well find somewhere that's remotely enjoyable, and because I want to keep my job I turn up and work hard, but if I had a choice, no I wouldn't be getting up at 5am some mornings and not getting home until 11pm other evenings or being awake all night.

But I still do work, ft, and always have done. I don't think that you can insist that people want to give their whole lives over to the benefit of other people, I mean I suppose you can but you're going to be disappointed.

briansgardenshed · 13/05/2023 07:50

Those saying "Brexit" seem pleased that previously we could exploit (usually) poorer Eastern Europeans to do jobs on low wages while Brits couldn't get a job at all. (Especially those "lazy Brits" who'd invested in their businesses or careers and trained to be builders or plumbers or early years childcare providers)

Now that supposedly all these employers have lost their supply of cheap workers we're in a transition stage. Employers will sooner or later have to pay workers properly. Quite rightly. And the benefits system will need to be reformed as it's obvious that no society is sustainable with a huge proportion of people not contributing , ( to tax, to consumption, to increasing the collective skill base etc).

Antisocialfluffmonster · 13/05/2023 07:43

Garethkeenansstapler · 12/05/2023 00:09

Shit! That’s the entire population of Scotland. Why are so many people on benefits when there are so many vacancies?

Because you can’t just slot people in like Lego bricks. Lots of hospitality roles in locations people can’t afford to rent a house, so no good for families, lots of social care jobs that don’t pay enough to cover the travel costs, lots of manual working jobs that aren’t suitable for people with health issues, lots of jobs that only offer part time hours but demand flexibility from staff but won’t allow working parents the security of knowing shifts in advance.

when cost of living is so high, and some of these employers are demanding things that are totally unreasonable then it doesn’t work. Or you treat your staff like crap and no one wants to work for you.

I’ve been advertising a job for more than 6 months, but it’s highly specialise and it’s got a language requirement that’s non negotiable, We are paying a decent salary for it, but some of the interviews (most to be fair) are car crashes. Probably better paying myself to learn the bloody language at this rate as I’m already doing the job plus my own.

whatever advice is being given out about how to interview is vastly off the mark and you can spot the job centre cvs a mile off they are that bad. They are not genuinely helping people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread