Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Absolute stupid question about asexuality and sexuality.

214 replies

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 11:19

Hi, I totally understand that this isin’t exactly the place to come and talk about asexuality, but I swear every single online space I have found and been part of, have kind of gone crazy.

Things seem to have gone strange in the past couple of years where a lot of people are now using the label asexuality.
I’m in online places to find people like me and talk about obstacles in our lives, but these days
they are pretty much filled with people who do have sex (mostly seem to be young girls/women having sex with boys/men) who say that they are ”aesthetically and emotionally attracted to” their partner / people and like the physical feeling of sex.
Isin’t this just the very average, very basic, very ’normal’ sexuality?
They want and have sex, they have libidos and they put them to use.

What makes this asexuality / part of asexual spectrum?

And now they are in asexual spaces telling pwoplw who are actually asexual, that they belong there, and if you question them, you are aphobic and excluding people.
In our own space.

What is this? Do they not realize they’re taking place from people who it actually belongs to?

Again, I can’t talk about this in these communities, because I get an angry mob after me, so I brought my beef here, I’m sorry 😅!

OP posts:
slashlover · 11/05/2023 18:52

Ptarm · 11/05/2023 18:48

Some people today have a need to put themselves in identity boxes, which is rather odd and restrictive. I believe it’s often used by young women who perhaps don’t fully understand their reluctance to have sex with porn sick young men.

Asexuality has been backed and pushed by charities such as Stonewall, which has led to a theory that there is an agenda to create an identity that will fit the growing numbers of detransitioners who, because of puberty blockers and wrong sex hormones, will never desire sex, or have destroyed their ability to have sex. However you look at that angle is heartbreaking.

Except all the asexual people I know are 30+ years old, I'm almost 45 and realised I was asexual at about 12, although I didn't have a name for it then.

But, yes, it's actually all Stonewall and transgender people's fault.

Ptarm · 11/05/2023 18:52

I also know women who assumed they were asexual but later in life realised they were lesbians, and the problem all along was sex with men.

Ptarm · 11/05/2023 18:51

slashlover · 11/05/2023 18:42

If most people are like that then please explain sex symbols, the Dreamboys and the many "who do you fancy?" posts on here?

But that doesn’t mean it needs its own label does it?

Also you can fancy people but if you were with them at that moment you might not want to have sex because you do t know them.

Sexuality is a spectrum. Being L G or B was unacceptable for a long time, and people could lose their jobs, be discriminated against etc.
No one’s lost their job for not wanting sex with someone, it’s all a nonsense.

slashlover · 11/05/2023 18:50

That’s what it used to mean.

(I hope this doesn’t come off the wrong way, but I literally laughed out loud to the ”because I’ve been married three times” part😀)

Asexuality has never meant that you didn't want sex, it means that you are not sexually attracted to anyone. Sex drive is libido.

I believe in the split model attraction theory. There is sexual attraction and romantic attraction, they are different and separate. In the same way you can be sexually attracted to someone without romantic attraction - ONS, fancying someone you don't know etc - you can be romantically attracted to/love someone without being sexually attracted to them.

Ptarm · 11/05/2023 18:48

Some people today have a need to put themselves in identity boxes, which is rather odd and restrictive. I believe it’s often used by young women who perhaps don’t fully understand their reluctance to have sex with porn sick young men.

Asexuality has been backed and pushed by charities such as Stonewall, which has led to a theory that there is an agenda to create an identity that will fit the growing numbers of detransitioners who, because of puberty blockers and wrong sex hormones, will never desire sex, or have destroyed their ability to have sex. However you look at that angle is heartbreaking.

slashlover · 11/05/2023 18:42

NeedToChangeName · 11/05/2023 11:30

People do seem quick to label themselves and others

A member of my family announced that they are demisexual ie only sexually attracted to someone when they have an emotional bond with them. I thought most people were like that, and it doesn't require a label

If most people are like that then please explain sex symbols, the Dreamboys and the many "who do you fancy?" posts on here?

bellinisurge · 11/05/2023 18:02

@AceNotInSpace , oh, come on. This identity is part of the TQ+ alphabet soup. Isn't that what the AA bit is?

HotPenguin · 11/05/2023 16:30

OP if you met a guy on an asexual dating website and he told you he wanted sex I would say he was purposefully exploiting you and gaslighting you. He knows damn well he isn't asexual but gets a kick out of testing your boundaries. It's unfortunate that people act like this but you don't have to "accept" them, just tell them to do one.

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 15:40

bellinisurge · 11/05/2023 14:31

By all means, talk with people who want to about not fancying it much. I don't, really.
But realise that giving yourself a label and constructing some oppression myth is, at best, a bit self obsessed.

I’ve never seen an asexual person to claim that they are opressed.
Only non-asexual who like to, for whatever reason, go on a huff about it and claim that asexuals are saying non-sense like that.

OP posts:
MaccyD100 · 11/05/2023 14:38

I'm asexual. I didn't know I was until around 5 years ago because I just hadn't really given much thought to putting a label on it. All I knew is that I'd never, in my 35 years of being an adult, ever been physically attracted to another human being. I was physically capable of going through the mechanics of sex and only ever did it to please a man. That's still the case and I've been married for over 20 years. I suppose I experience it in the same way a straight person would experience sex with a same sex partner. No attraction, no arousal. Just love and happy to hold the person close and go through the motions.

bellinisurge · 11/05/2023 14:31

By all means, talk with people who want to about not fancying it much. I don't, really.
But realise that giving yourself a label and constructing some oppression myth is, at best, a bit self obsessed.

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 14:24

Camillasfagwrinkles · 11/05/2023 14:14

All these labels are ridiculous and attention seeking. No one cares if you do or don't have sex or who you do or don't do it with, so no need for any announcements.

And thank you for that beautiful demonstration on why we actually need our own space where we can talk about things involving around being asexual.

OP posts:
Camillasfagwrinkles · 11/05/2023 14:14

All these labels are ridiculous and attention seeking. No one cares if you do or don't have sex or who you do or don't do it with, so no need for any announcements.

BertieBotts · 11/05/2023 14:08

Young girls is quite commonly used in that context to mean older teenagers - 16-20 or so - I don't think it's a WTF phrasing here. Like "young people" doesn't mean three year olds.

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 14:00

AmuseBish · 11/05/2023 13:22

mostly seem to be young girls/women having sex with boys/men

Wtf? I'm assuming this was a mis-type?

Oh, yes teenagers.
Sorry, my bad.
I meant as in young people - not small children.

OP posts:
peachgreen · 11/05/2023 13:28

Beamur · 11/05/2023 12:22

I'm not asexual. But I really don't understand how someone can say they are and yet be sexually active. Makes no sense to me!
Also means their experience as an asexual/sexual person is just not the same surely?

A friend of mine is asexual because she doesn’t have any desire or need to have sex, but she does so for her partner’s benefit. She’s not disgusted by sex, she’s happy enough to do it but if he didn’t want to she would happily never have it again. She’s still asexual. She compares it to a woman going to a football match with her partner - she goes because it’s important to him and she doesn’t mind going, but that doesn’t make her a football fan.

AmuseBish · 11/05/2023 13:22

mostly seem to be young girls/women having sex with boys/men

Wtf? I'm assuming this was a mis-type?

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 13:12

Gettingbysomehow · 11/05/2023 12:53

I always thought being asexual meant you didn't want sex with anyone but apparently there are grades of them, those who only want sex occasionally - greys, those who want a romantic relationship but little or no sex.
I put myself at the most extreme end aromantic asexual which is a person who doesn't want a romantic relationship and doesn't want sex either.
But that's only because I have been through the menopause and I've been married three times.
So I wasn't born asexual. I became asexual due to the menopause and not wanting any more relationships.

That’s what it used to mean.

(I hope this doesn’t come off the wrong way, but I literally laughed out loud to the ”because I’ve been married three times” part😀)

OP posts:
AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 13:10

Jellycats4life · 11/05/2023 12:56

I’m absolutely certain this fake adopting of a marginalised identity is all social media driven. In fact I’ve seen it myself on Tiktok.

You can identify asexual and still have sex with people every night - that’s valid!

You can be transgender but make no effort to change your appearance whatsoever - that’s valid!

Being or feeling marginalised is so highly prized amongst young people they’ll fake it if they have to.

This seems to a thing that is going around these days.

Reading your comment brought into mind how many are now ’fluid’ or ’non binary’, while nothing have seemed to change, but at the same time everyone has to carefully tip-toe around so they don’t cause offence.

OP posts:
Jellycats4life · 11/05/2023 12:56

I’m absolutely certain this fake adopting of a marginalised identity is all social media driven. In fact I’ve seen it myself on Tiktok.

You can identify asexual and still have sex with people every night - that’s valid!

You can be transgender but make no effort to change your appearance whatsoever - that’s valid!

Being or feeling marginalised is so highly prized amongst young people they’ll fake it if they have to.

Gettingbysomehow · 11/05/2023 12:53

I always thought being asexual meant you didn't want sex with anyone but apparently there are grades of them, those who only want sex occasionally - greys, those who want a romantic relationship but little or no sex.
I put myself at the most extreme end aromantic asexual which is a person who doesn't want a romantic relationship and doesn't want sex either.
But that's only because I have been through the menopause and I've been married three times.
So I wasn't born asexual. I became asexual due to the menopause and not wanting any more relationships.

AceNotInSpace · 11/05/2023 12:46

IWilloBeACervix · 11/05/2023 12:18

I can see why you’re frustrated OP. The rise in everyone needing to acquire an identity or label (instead of a personality and so they can be special imo) is leading to a lot of disruption communities where people who actually are that thing. Rather than using a word to describe something, they now describe peoples identities.

Its similar to people with autism finding that there are now a lot of people identifying as autistic taking up space, possibly resources, and changing the narrative around what it is to be autistic.

Or, dare I say it, Lesbian communities being full of men.

Yes.
This is the crux of it.

You put it into words better than I could in my angry haze😃, I appreciate it, thank you!

OP posts:
Gtsr443 · 11/05/2023 12:41

How can someone be asexual if they enjoy sex?
How is this a spectrum? Surely it is the least spectrumy thing there is?

BadNomad · 11/05/2023 12:34

As far as I know, asexuality is just the inability to feel sexual attraction for others. Plenty of people can and do have sex without being sexually attracted to their partners.

BertieBotts · 11/05/2023 12:29

I don't know OP but this isn't the only thread I've seen on this topic, and I find it quite confusing.

AVEN used to be a really supportive space, I definitely found it accepting there when I was younger. People who liked some sex but had a very low drive or in specific circumstances only tended to call themselves grey-a or demisexual or use it as a discussion on the nature of sexuality / asexuality itself, not say "THIS is how it is and if you disagree, you're being phobic!" That is just shutting down discussion and doesn't seem helpful.

The only thing I can think is that it sort of reminds me of a really interesting (long) podcast interview with trans man Beau Brink, really opened my eyes to some of the appalling discrimination against LGBT+ people in some parts of the US, but it also addressed the conflict between some aspects of women's rights and some aspects of trans rights. They were talking about for example women feeling that they are no longer allowed to use the word "mother" or that the word "woman" is being erased. He was kind of sceptical about it, claiming nobody is banning any words, but the interesting point that he said was that under traditional gender roles, someone's sex or gender is basically defined as whether a person is in a "sexual target" class or "sexual competitor" class (this is a very male centric way to view it, but run with the theory for a moment) - and it's basically all about other people defining who is "man" vs who is "woman", especially "you're not a real man if you cry" / "you're not a real woman if you can't have children" kind of invalidation, but the trans movement is about people defining their own identity for themselves, and he reckons that benefits everybody, because it carries over to cis people too, being able to define themselves without being subject to invalidation by others.

That was the point where I disagreed, because I don't feel that being a woman is a case of identification. I agree about the fact that sex roles are placed on us based on whether we are "fuckable" vs "competition" and this is a problem that all sexism has roots in. But I think this is important because patterns of male violence and exploitation follow these lines. Your sex also has medical relevance, and therefore "woman" (or "female", I don't really mind) must necessarily be a protected characteristic, and therefore there needs to be some universal definition as to what that means, not just something that people can decide for themselves. I get the idea of defining yourself rather than being defined by others, I just think there are areas where it's important that there is a measurable definition. Like doctor. You wouldn't want any old random person to be able to identify as a doctor, you need to know that a medical doctor has the right qualifications and experience to be treating you. Or nationalities. I know there are arguments that nationalities should be abolished, but at least for the moment there are reasons that nationality needs to be proven and obtained through official means.

So anyway - I know that "asexual" has never been something that's legally defined, only self-defined, but it seems almost like the same conflict here? Your need/expectation that a category has a set meaning, and somebody else saying but that isn't inclusive, I want to be in this category but I also want X (or, sex!)