Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to remember your bags!

93 replies

Irritatedcashier · 10/05/2023 23:16

At work. The same people every single day buy a plastic bag for their 3 items, moan about the cost of bags, never bring one with them. Always "hehehe I've got loads in the car"
fucking use one then? Obviously can't say that 😂
Each and every time they moan about the price I tell them it's to discourage plastic waste but they just carry on.
Same conversation every day.

AIBU to expect people to bring a bag when they know they're going to a shop?

Probably am, I'm just grouchy cause I just finished a late 🙈

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 11/05/2023 11:10

I rarely forget my bags but live in Wales who were the first to start charging for plastic bags. The only exception to this might be when we are on the way back from a holiday or break and need to do a shop and then we pay for bags (which will get reused).

HurryShadow · 11/05/2023 10:26

I have a pile of bags everywhere. Some in my desk at work, some in the car, some in the house and I'll still occasionally discover I don't have enough with me and have to buy more.

We went to America last year and out of habit in Walmart I got out my bags and started packing my shopping. You'd have thought I'd grown two heads or something the looks I was getting from the cashier and other customers!

Yes, there's lots of people that could do better in this country, but really the whole world needs to get a grip.

Packaging from the supermarkets is annoying though. I bought some bread rolls the other week and they came separated with a cardboard insert. Yes, fine it's recyclable, but is it really necessary?!

I wish our council recycling would take the plastic off of packaging and bags, not just plastic bottles, etc. Hopefully this is something that will change in the future.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 10:13

That's another thing, why are they referred to as "single use"? That's just branding to justify the lack of trust in the public.

Very good point - it's deliberately defeatist.

pickd · 11/05/2023 10:12

Davros · 11/05/2023 10:06

That's another thing, why are they referred to as "single use"? That's just branding to justify the lack of trust in the public. Mine are far from single use. Someone earlier said their DH is the one who forgets and buys new ones, so does mine, it drives me mad. They need to target male shoppers!

Meanwhile my husband would say they need to be targeting the wives like me since he always remembers the bags and it's me who always forgets them 😂 So targeting everyone is probably simplest lol

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 10:10

The inventor of the plastic bag thought they'd be an environmental alternative to one use paper bags.

And they worked for a great many people who understood this and instinctively re-used them lots of times.

They may have stuffed them in their bag or pocket for when they next went shopping, used them for charity shop donations, put their muddy boots in them after a country walk (and thus eliminated the need for more planet-harming chemicals to clean the car) or instead of buying bin liners for non-kitchen bins. Yes, they ended up binned, but not before they'd been fully used for various purposes.

The problem is that the tiny minority of bags that selfish idiots just dropped on the floor, and which then blew around car parks and into rivers, were glaringly plain to notice, whereas the sensibly-used and disposed-of majority were not seen out in the wild.

I find it ironic when the government/councils lecture us on waste and environmental littering when you see these undercover exposes of them shipping off thousands of tons of waste (including separated recycling) to massive great rubbish dumps in poor countries without bothering to ask questions as to where it ends up or its long-term impact.

Davros · 11/05/2023 10:06

That's another thing, why are they referred to as "single use"? That's just branding to justify the lack of trust in the public. Mine are far from single use. Someone earlier said their DH is the one who forgets and buys new ones, so does mine, it drives me mad. They need to target male shoppers!

DobbysTeaCosy · 11/05/2023 09:57

The inventor of the plastic bag thought they'd be an environmental alternative to one use paper bags.
Irony.
https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/plastic-bags-pollution-paper-cotton-tote-bags-environment-a9159731.html

But yes, my multiple neurodiverse conditions mean I always forget bags despite having several strategies to try and remember them. I also can't just pop back for them now as with children under three I'm on a bit of a time limit and going back is an absolute mission.
I would like to be a person who remembers things like that but a lifetime of trying shows its in vein.

Plastic bags were created to save the planet, according to son of engineer who first created them

‘To my dad, the idea that people would simply throw these away would be bizarre,’ claims Raoul Thulin 

https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/plastic-bags-pollution-paper-cotton-tote-bags-environment-a9159731.html

Schroedingersimmigrant · 11/05/2023 09:56

Asda went through a period where they made their bags for life so very thin (didn't reduce the price, mind), that they were effectively single-use bags again, as you would be lucky if they survived the journey home
We had to get new one already in the shop 4x!!! They were terrible and we got new ones free. Maybe that's why they stopped doing the thin bastards. Even the small ones before were stronger

Cooroo · 11/05/2023 09:51

I have 8 or 10 reusable plastic bags from years ago. If you learn how to fold them up they hardly take any space. I keep one in my rucksack for emergencies and we always pick some up before shopping. DP and I are lucky enough to have 2 supermarkets in walking distance so never buy more than we can carry home.

Gymithoughtyousaidgin · 11/05/2023 09:47

It’s not to discourage plastic waste. It’s to make money. If they wanted to discourage plastic waste they wouldn’t be selling so many items in plastic wrapping and the carrier bags wouldn’t be plastic 🤷‍♀️ I don’t know anyone that actually pays for carrier bags either so it’s a lose lose situation

BlackeyedSusan · 11/05/2023 09:45

And I shall blame it on lack of coffee and sleep.

pickd · 11/05/2023 09:44

Noseylittlemoo · 11/05/2023 07:33

@Irritatedcashier I am another irritated cashier! I work in a shop - not a supermarket - and we are able to give out our bags because they are paper/cardboard. But I still get annoyed when people ask for excessive amounts- often it is because they begrudge paying for a bag so come in arms full of stuff from other stores. They often say do you know I spent £££ and they still want to charge me for a bag?! Like their wealth cancels out the environmental issue. Or they want the bag to show off that they've bought something from our shop. If someone buys a lip balm or similar I just hand it over and it really bugs me if they ask for a bag!
Paying for a bag must have been a thing for about 10 years now so I don't know why people are still surprised/unprepared!

You don't charge for your bags because they're not plastic? Seriously? Wondering where you live because where I am all single use bags are chargeable other than the little tiny flat paper ones you might get in a card shop/sweet shop (not sure if I've described that very well lol)
Certainly in Scotland we pay for all single use bags whether paper or plastic. I know cos my old work did paper bags only and the amount of verbal abuse we got when the bag charge started was awful 🙈

BlackeyedSusan · 11/05/2023 09:44

pickd · 11/05/2023 09:35

@hereiamagainn that's a good tip, and thank you it does help.

@BlackeyedSusan that's exactly what I do when I'm at the supermarket! Put it all in the trolley, put it all in the boot then deal with it when I get home. I was meaning when I go maybe clothes shopping or somewhere like that where I don't have the option of a trolley, like if I'm in the city centre kinda thing and left my car at the train station. But I do agree, it works when there's a trolley available.

Well that just shows how often I go shopping not at a supermarket!

SunnySaturdayMorning · 11/05/2023 09:43

Nope. You should still provide them for free.

A reusable bag is of no use to me. I don’t want them cluttering up my house, I don’t want to have to take them with me everywhere and I do not like the attempt to force me into it “for the environment”.

It’s much easier to buy a plastic bag and chuck it after.

towriteyoumustlive · 11/05/2023 09:39

If I forget my bag, I just carry my stuff as a reminder not to forget my bag next time.

I would never purchase a plastic bag as they just end up in landfill.

In France, they haven't had plastic bags in supermarkets for decades! If you forgot your bags, you had to go and find some empty boxes to put your shopping in.

I still think our attitude in the UK towards single use plastic is disgraceful!

Perhaps consider reading The Big Plastic Count:

https://thebigplasticcount.com/

Join The Big Plastic Count

The UK’s biggest investigation into household plastic waste. Together let's push the government to tackle the plastic crisis.

https://thebigplasticcount.com

pickd · 11/05/2023 09:35

@hereiamagainn that's a good tip, and thank you it does help.

@BlackeyedSusan that's exactly what I do when I'm at the supermarket! Put it all in the trolley, put it all in the boot then deal with it when I get home. I was meaning when I go maybe clothes shopping or somewhere like that where I don't have the option of a trolley, like if I'm in the city centre kinda thing and left my car at the train station. But I do agree, it works when there's a trolley available.

LolaSmiles · 11/05/2023 09:30

Yet the only thing in my recycling is packaging from the shops that don't trust me with a plastic bag
This! I remember my bags usually but it annoys me that the loose fruit and veg costs more than the plastic wrapped ones.

greenspaceplace · 11/05/2023 09:27

BarbaraofSeville · 11/05/2023 06:40

Paper bags aren't without their own issues, it takes a lot of energy to make or recycle paper, so they shouldn't be regarded as single use either. People forget that they should be reusing before recycling, whatever the bag is made of.

I did see a sign in the car park in Sainsburys the other day telling people not to forget their bags, which would help those who keep them in the car.

People need to try harder with this and build it into their routine. I bet just about everyone shopping in a supermarket has remembered to pick their phone up when they left the house, so they should treat shopping bags with the same level of importance.

Well that's it isn't it? There is a consequence when you forget your phone or coat. There isn't one when you forget a bag (except spending a couple of pence)

I'm surprised supermarkets haven't set up a little bag exchange, looks good, is good, great for people who forget their bags

LakieLady · 11/05/2023 08:07

beguilingeyes · 11/05/2023 07:56

I've got one of those plastic nylon folding bags that I keep in my handbag. Really useful.
This one is from London Transport, but Waitrose so a great one for about a fiver.
https://www.ltmuseumshop.co.uk/london-underground-folding-bag

Wow, they've shot up in price! They were only £1 or £2 when I got mine. I've had mine ages though, they appear to be indestructible.

M&S do them too, they squish into a little cone shaped drawstring pouch, which I find strangely satisfying, for some reason.

hereiamagainn · 11/05/2023 08:03

Firstmonthfree · 11/05/2023 07:29

A few signs in the car park would help.

when someone says would you like a bag, you almost have to laugh it off and say I forgot to bring one -what else would you like the person to say? If they just say “yes” you’ll think that were rude

between finding a space, paying for a ticket, wrangling kids etc people forget things, you need to chill

Eh? If somebody asks me if I want a bag, I just say “yes please” and say “thank you” when they give it to me. Not rude, and no need to laugh or give excuses, which is wholly unnecessary.

beguilingeyes · 11/05/2023 07:56

I've got one of those plastic nylon folding bags that I keep in my handbag. Really useful.
This one is from London Transport, but Waitrose so a great one for about a fiver.
https://www.ltmuseumshop.co.uk/london-underground-folding-bag

BlackeyedSusan · 11/05/2023 07:55

hereiamagainn · 11/05/2023 07:22

If it helps, I don’t think this experience is unique to people with autism. I find that storing the bags for life near the back door and putting one in my handbag before leaving the house works better than keeping them in the boot.

Or just roll the trolley to the car and pack there.

MamaDollyorJesus · 11/05/2023 07:47

Daffodilwoman · 11/05/2023 07:10

I know this isn’t the point if the thread but…..My favourite bags are the ones from Poundland- cost a pound!
I have to really rein it in at Christmas and stop myself buying a new one each year.

I have a special set of Christmas bags & buy a new one every year. My favourite are the old jute type ones from Tesco but you can only seem to get the plasticky ones now. I've had some for years & they come out mid-November.

I have lots of non-Christmas bags too & if I ever forget to take a bag or pop into a shop when I hadn't planned to I buy a new shopping bag to add to my collection never a bag for life because they're shit & I wouldn't re-use them but that's extremely rare that I don't have bags in the car or a couple of the folded up ones in my bag.

As for the co-op bags they're all well & good but they're shit if you want to buy more than a loaf of bread as they're too small & too flimsy.

Our LA provided the food waste bags when it was first introduced but stopped after about 6 months citing supply issues as the reason but that was at least 10 years ago and they seem to be having the same supply issues today 🤔

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 07:47

I agree that it seems strange for the government to fixate on supermarket carrier bags and drinking straws, but then ignore bananas in plastic, supermarkets using food pallets wrapped tightly in plastic, instead of using metal cages multiple times, disposable coffee cups.... so many things.

Asda went through a period where they made their bags for life so very thin (didn't reduce the price, mind), that they were effectively single-use bags again, as you would be lucky if they survived the journey home. I've never trusted the paper bags from Morrisons - I don't mind the ones in Boots, where you're buying a couple of light packets or a bottle or two, but our supermarket shopping tends to have heavy bottles, cans, root veg and similar in it.

I get that the bags - whether plastic or paper - use resources to provide, but so does everything else in the shop and in a consumer society. That's just how life is - we can try our best, but the only way to properly get rid of human-caused pollution is to get rid of the humans.

One thing that bugs me is when things are proclaimed as recyclable, but then there are never any facilities or encouragement to actually recycle them.

Ihaveshitfriends · 11/05/2023 07:46

I get loads of plastic bag as partner always but have found out my local food bank loves them so we donate food and bags monthly.