Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding invitation - please give us your money (basically)

585 replies

Truestorypeeps · 10/05/2023 21:51

Received a second wedding invitation in a row which mentions words to the affect of, we would very much appreciate money towards our honeymoon as a gift. I personally couldn't physically write this in an invitation as it just feels presumptuous and tasteless.

Maybe this last invite got my back up as this couple have been together well over ten years, already have children, earn c.150k between them, massive house and already go on countless holidays at home and abroad. They could have easily omitted such a line from the invite. I understand they don't want toasters and towels, but surely there's another way?! E.g. heading, 'wedding gifts', below - 'your presence at our wedding would be more than enough, but if you'd like to gift us something to mark this day, please give a donation to XYZ charity which is close to our hearts because of XYZ??? Owing to the fact they are bloody rolling in it.

OP posts:
isthisit83 · 11/05/2023 12:23

Only in Britain is it "tacky" to ask for money or gifts. In many many cultures, this is expected. If you don't want to give money then don't. They probably wont notice! It's hard to keep track of who gives what unless you write it down. Or just give a bottle of champers/whisky. Also people know that it often costs money to go to a wedding and just want you to celebrate with them.

Things have changed a bit but when my parents got married in New York (american here) in 1978, my mother had a wedding shower prior to the wedding. This is when you shower the bride with gifts. Then on the wedding day, they had bag which was for the money. (Think goodfellas) they literally got wads of cash in envelopes. Not everyone does this but there is even a formula for how much to give at a wedding, bar mitzah etc based on how much you think it cost the host to put on the event per person 😂😂 I know the UK has a different culture, but there is still a gift giving culture and people don't like to turn up empty handed. Cash is preferable to mindless consumption on shit the couple don't need.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 11/05/2023 12:20

Well if they don't, they will have 100 people saying "where is the gift registry/do you want cash".
Most people expect to buy a gift or give cash. It saves hassle around. I'm far happier popping cash in a card and sticking it in the post box thing at the reception. My nephew got married recently. He is in his 30s, no kids, needs nothing. Happy to give them some cash to spend on a honeymoon or just to offset some of the wedding costs.
But then I don't go looking for things to be offended by.

DappledThings · 11/05/2023 12:14

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:11

To be honest if someone is so rude and entitled as to demand a certain type of gift I would be tempted to get them the opposite. Its actually fairly common consensus reaction to rude gift requests on wedding forums... seems your guests felt exactly the same and their actions say volumes you just missed it.

But you are choosing to see guidance as a demand. I don't see it that way and thousands of others don't either. I see it as a polite steer from the couple that if you would like to get us something here's what we would really like. Perfectly sensible, much easier for the guest and it isn't a demand.

This insistence on faffing about and making your guests guess what you want under the guise of etiquette is just silly.

Lampzade · 11/05/2023 12:12

ConcernedMum22 · 10/05/2023 22:02

It's tacky. We didn't put any poem or list or anything referencing gifts and most people gave us money anyway.

Me too. We didn’t ask for anything.
It is very tacky to ask or hint at money.
However, I always give money as presents but I don’t like people putting the request in the invitation

TedMullins · 11/05/2023 12:07

JandalsAlways · 11/05/2023 12:02

See now I find that tacky, that you'd just show up empty-handed. Even if I received an invite that said no gifts, I'd still take an expensive bottle of bubbles or a bottle of good whiskey or something. Afterall you're celebrating someone's wedding, why wouldn't you want to give them somehhing, afterall what a provilage to share in such a special day. A lot of miserable people on this thread

lol why is it a privilege to go to someone’s wedding? The whole thing is entirely for their benefit not mine! And I take people at face value, I wouldn’t say “no gifts” unless I genuinely didn’t want a gift, in the same way I don’t do the whole “oh we MUST meet for coffee” if I don’t actually want to meet up with someone again. That’s something I hate about British culture, the double meanings and not saying what you actually think, and I won’t do it. I don’t really care whether other people think that’s rude or tacky, I think it’s annoying and rude to say things you don’t mean. In all honesty I’d turn up empty handed regardless of what the invite said because I believe gift giving should be entirely the choice of the giver, not something you demand of people.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/05/2023 12:03

Last such invitation didn’t bother me at all. Young couple basically stating that they only had a very small flat with everything they needed (I.e..no room for more ‘stuff’) but if anyone would like to contribute to their honeymoon it would be very much appreciated.
Cash in a card is IMO the easiest option.

JandalsAlways · 11/05/2023 12:02

TedMullins · 11/05/2023 10:42

Personally yes I do think asking for anything at all is tacky. It should be up to the guests whether they want to give them anything. If I got an invite saying “no gifts” I’d take that at face value and not give them anything (and u find it really weird and rude that people ignore that request and give them stuff anyway!)

that said, I’d turn up empty handed even if the invite did ask for gifts or money, unless I genuinely wanted to give them something.

See now I find that tacky, that you'd just show up empty-handed. Even if I received an invite that said no gifts, I'd still take an expensive bottle of bubbles or a bottle of good whiskey or something. Afterall you're celebrating someone's wedding, why wouldn't you want to give them somehhing, afterall what a provilage to share in such a special day. A lot of miserable people on this thread

Mamaneedsadrink · 11/05/2023 11:57

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 11:53

Indian weddings often say, "no boxed gifts" - I like that, it doesn't sound grabby.

I'm not convinced it sounds any less grabby than what's already been mentioned on here - but then I don't think either wording is grabby, just practical and realistic.

As I've seen on other similar threads on here, though, it does cause confusion amongst some people who aren't used to the 'no boxed gifts' phrase, as they sometimes assume they just don't want the box for whatever reason, but DO want the gift - so they remove the packaging and just leave an opened item on a table near the door!

Oh that is hilarious 😂

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 11:53

Indian weddings often say, "no boxed gifts" - I like that, it doesn't sound grabby.

I'm not convinced it sounds any less grabby than what's already been mentioned on here - but then I don't think either wording is grabby, just practical and realistic.

As I've seen on other similar threads on here, though, it does cause confusion amongst some people who aren't used to the 'no boxed gifts' phrase, as they sometimes assume they just don't want the box for whatever reason, but DO want the gift - so they remove the packaging and just leave an opened item on a table near the door!

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 11:49

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:11

To be honest if someone is so rude and entitled as to demand a certain type of gift I would be tempted to get them the opposite. Its actually fairly common consensus reaction to rude gift requests on wedding forums... seems your guests felt exactly the same and their actions say volumes you just missed it.

Be a laugh if it all got regifted back to them. Especially the personalised Mr and Mrs stuff.

nidgey · 11/05/2023 11:38

ClaraBourne · 11/05/2023 11:07

This would not bother me at all, a gift is a gift. I love a good wedding with all the trimmings!

Hope you never get invited to a Greek wedding where you pin cash onto the brides dress! Or an Italian one where you also contribute cash to the wedding costs in an envelope. 😆

Exactly re Greek and Italian weddings - British culture is changing around weddings and wedding gifts and maybe it will settle down into a new pattern.

nidgey · 11/05/2023 11:35

Have to say - asking for money is more and more the norm and the last three weddings I went to, that's all that was asked for. In some cultures money is absolutely the norm.

Sometimes the couple will specify different aspects of the honeymoon (eg, somewhere they'll have dinner, a particular guided tour, bike hire etc.)

I think your tone is really off and you just want to agree with whoever agrees with you! Do you usually not take other perspectives into account or just want to rant?

As so many people have said:

  1. People usually give wedding gifts
  2. Most people have what they need household wise so 'traditional' wedding gifts are not suitable
  3. People want to give gifts that the recipient will actually want
  4. Going on and on about people being 'rolling in it' is crass and weird, and you actually don't really know the full details - maybe they've overstretched themselves credit-wise.

If you have that big of an issue with it and you're that ill disposed to the couple then just don't go to the wedding.

greennotepad · 11/05/2023 11:31

TedMullins · 11/05/2023 11:26

It’s unlikely I’d want to buy a gift tbh. I’m not really a gift person (and yes that extends to receiving them too)

You do you! But I do think its quite unusual to not want to gift a couple anything at all on their wedding day- and means you are probably not the target audience for whether or not asking for money is acceptable.

AddieLoggins2 · 11/05/2023 11:27

Haven't seen one of these threads in ages. There used to be about one a week on Mumsnet when I first joined (which was back in the Cretaceous period)

I go to my fair share of weddings. I haven't seen a gift list with actual gifts since 2008. Every wedding has been money.

The poems are twee and naff, but I think it's just because we're entering a new 'era' and it's part of the transition to a new etiquette. Giving money will become the new norm I think, probably by the time my kids get married there won't be a need to mention gifts/money because it will have become the norm and everyone will just know to give money.

Personally I think the etiquette of 'gifts/money shouldn't be mentioned on an invite' is harking back to the olden days and things have moved on. It fits more with etiquette like parents of the bride pay for the wedding/send the invites etc.
Its really really normal to ask for money instead, on the invites, and people complaining it's 'crass' or 'tacky' just makes them sound like some sort of Hyacinth Bucket type.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/05/2023 11:27

There should be a rule about requesting things via terrible poetry. Also the phrase "let your hair down" in respect to childfree weddings. Don't mind either childfree weddings or being told what the guest would like in regards to presents but can't stomach the poems.

sherbertyellowteddy · 11/05/2023 11:27

When we got married we didn't mention gifts at all on our invite. We were getting married because we wanted to,not for the gifts or money. In the end we got mainly money/vouchers and then a few gifts, (only one Mr and Mrs mug set) then some people just wrote a card. We were over the moon with the generosity. We just wanted people to turn up and celebrate with us.

TedMullins · 11/05/2023 11:26

greennotepad · 11/05/2023 11:00

So if the invite says nothing, but you want to give a gift, how will you decide what to buy? Pick something at random that might be a waste of money if the couple don't want/need it, or bother them by being one of many people to ask them what they want?

For the latter, putting it on the invite just avoids being harassed by all your guests for details, the same reason you put the address of the venue on there. Surely?

It’s unlikely I’d want to buy a gift tbh. I’m not really a gift person (and yes that extends to receiving them too)

prescribingmum · 11/05/2023 11:17

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:07

In etiquette gifts should NEVER be mentioned. They are an optional extra for the giver to decide upon and should only ever be mentioned IF the giver chooses to ask you for your input.

It's grabby to mention them (says they are the forefront of your mind and thus you expect them and makes them a requirement of attendance regardless of wording). Especially if you are the host of your own party (as most weddings are now).

I'm from a pretty 'lower class' area and I have never ever seen gifts mentioned on anything around here. Maybe because everyones in the same boat finically so its not about 'stuff' but more camaraderie. It's when I move up the chain to the middle I have encounter it, going further up to the few 'old money' types I know it seems to stop again (would be deemed uncouth).

I find it strange that basic manner completely seem to have missed the middle classes (who have no need to have their hands out anyway).

One etiquette guidance cannot be represented across the country. The many threads about this show how much cultures differ where wedding customs and traditions are concerned. The couple also can’t get it right because of the different expectations.

If you’re close enough to be invited to a wedding, you know the B&G and therefore should know their personalities. If they are generally grabby people who are expecting too much and will speak badly of guests that didn’t meet their unreasonable expectations politely decline and leave it at that. Otherwise, just accept it as a difference of opinion and respect their wishes. The rudest people of all are those like the OP that assassinate their character, slag them off, intentionally do not respect their wishes yet still want to attend the wedding

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:11

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 11/05/2023 11:05

We asked for cash. I don't really care what people online think of that because 90% of our guests did the same or had a gift list.

Despite asking for it, we did indeed still receive 5 Mr & Mrs mugs, loads of photo frames, a set of 'posh', engraved spoons, wall plaques/live, laugh, love wall art and other stuff that we just didn't want.

To be honest if someone is so rude and entitled as to demand a certain type of gift I would be tempted to get them the opposite. Its actually fairly common consensus reaction to rude gift requests on wedding forums... seems your guests felt exactly the same and their actions say volumes you just missed it.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 11:10

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:07

In etiquette gifts should NEVER be mentioned. They are an optional extra for the giver to decide upon and should only ever be mentioned IF the giver chooses to ask you for your input.

It's grabby to mention them (says they are the forefront of your mind and thus you expect them and makes them a requirement of attendance regardless of wording). Especially if you are the host of your own party (as most weddings are now).

I'm from a pretty 'lower class' area and I have never ever seen gifts mentioned on anything around here. Maybe because everyones in the same boat finically so its not about 'stuff' but more camaraderie. It's when I move up the chain to the middle I have encounter it, going further up to the few 'old money' types I know it seems to stop again (would be deemed uncouth).

I find it strange that basic manner completely seem to have missed the middle classes (who have no need to have their hands out anyway).

Working class background, British but with cultural roots elsewhere, none of this remotely relates with my experience.

Honestly, the big problem with this issue is that people insist on generalising. It's obvious that we're in a situation where the wedding present etiquette in the UK is somewhat in flux, that's about the one thing everyone can agree on, and that there's no way of handling the issue that isn't going to peeve some people.

JusthereforXmas · 11/05/2023 11:07

In etiquette gifts should NEVER be mentioned. They are an optional extra for the giver to decide upon and should only ever be mentioned IF the giver chooses to ask you for your input.

It's grabby to mention them (says they are the forefront of your mind and thus you expect them and makes them a requirement of attendance regardless of wording). Especially if you are the host of your own party (as most weddings are now).

I'm from a pretty 'lower class' area and I have never ever seen gifts mentioned on anything around here. Maybe because everyones in the same boat finically so its not about 'stuff' but more camaraderie. It's when I move up the chain to the middle I have encounter it, going further up to the few 'old money' types I know it seems to stop again (would be deemed uncouth).

I find it strange that basic manner completely seem to have missed the middle classes (who have no need to have their hands out anyway).

ClaraBourne · 11/05/2023 11:07

This would not bother me at all, a gift is a gift. I love a good wedding with all the trimmings!

Hope you never get invited to a Greek wedding where you pin cash onto the brides dress! Or an Italian one where you also contribute cash to the wedding costs in an envelope. 😆

Comedycook · 11/05/2023 11:06

Awful behaviour imo. And no one buys the couple a toaster or dinner service anymore... it's a very dated thing to do so I don't think that's a concern. Personally I think you shouldn't even mention gifts on the invite. It's presumptuous and tacky. Most people if it's not mentioned will give money or vouchers anyway.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 11/05/2023 11:05

We asked for cash. I don't really care what people online think of that because 90% of our guests did the same or had a gift list.

Despite asking for it, we did indeed still receive 5 Mr & Mrs mugs, loads of photo frames, a set of 'posh', engraved spoons, wall plaques/live, laugh, love wall art and other stuff that we just didn't want.

BarrelOfOtters · 11/05/2023 11:04

Its traditional in this country to give a wedding present. Round our way £100 is seen as about right or buy off a list or give a present to that sort of value. (unless you are skint/student etc).

I have no problem with someone saying give me money instead of a gift.

We said no gifts as many of the guests had been at DH's previous wedding, my guests had paid a lot of money to travel to the wedding, we are old and comfortably off. We still got some money, some gifts, some very personalised lovely gifts....it was all ok. Some people were really uncomfortable with not giving a gift - some people were fine with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread