Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding invitation - please give us your money (basically)

585 replies

Truestorypeeps · 10/05/2023 21:51

Received a second wedding invitation in a row which mentions words to the affect of, we would very much appreciate money towards our honeymoon as a gift. I personally couldn't physically write this in an invitation as it just feels presumptuous and tasteless.

Maybe this last invite got my back up as this couple have been together well over ten years, already have children, earn c.150k between them, massive house and already go on countless holidays at home and abroad. They could have easily omitted such a line from the invite. I understand they don't want toasters and towels, but surely there's another way?! E.g. heading, 'wedding gifts', below - 'your presence at our wedding would be more than enough, but if you'd like to gift us something to mark this day, please give a donation to XYZ charity which is close to our hearts because of XYZ??? Owing to the fact they are bloody rolling in it.

OP posts:
DappledThings · 11/05/2023 15:15

Wedding gifts are for setting up new households, not for greedy twats.
I mean sure, you can think that and be reall

lap90 · 11/05/2023 15:11

I think the poems are cheesy. If i received an invitation which no mention of gift or cash, i would gift cash regardless. Think the last wedding i went to had some kind of variation of 'no boxed gifts'.
I think the mentioning of cash on evening invitations is especially tacky.

ohdamnitjanet · 11/05/2023 15:08

Please ignore everyone who says’ ‘ you don’t like them, you’re jealous’ blah blah blah. It IS rude and tacky to ask for money, whether you are comfortable financially or not. If you can’t afford a fucking holiday then don’t have one. No way would I pay for someone else to go away. And NO FUCKING WAY would I expect presents when I have everything I need already. Wedding gifts are for setting up new households, not for greedy twats.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 11/05/2023 15:05

Truestorypeeps · 11/05/2023 14:51

Ok, no one is allowed to talk about anything that people would have been talking about 40 years ago. Thanks for clearing that up.

It's more that this has been the convention for so long that to call it rude and grabby etc etc is effectively a comment on society in general now...and perhaps you mean it to be, but do you have the same criticism of all the other cultures that openly give money, even pinning it to the bride or having a large pot in the reception for it?

The point of convention and etiquette is so that people know how to behave and don't accidentally cause offence. You do it because that's how it's done. Of course things change over time but gift lists and requests for any gifts to be as money just aren't new and they're established conventions now.

And unless you object to giving a couple a wedding gift as an invited guest, or don't care about what would be actually useful to them - and to be fair, this is actually how a lot of posters seem to feel - it's hard to see what's so offensive. Human cultures the world over and throughout history have marked weddings and made gift giving a part of them. It's just downright bloody weird that Britain nowadays seems to be the only place where this is so objectionable to some people.

Yes, CoL crisis etc but that's not what these people are complaining about. They're objecting to the very idea of there being any expectation at any level that if you go to a wedding, you bring something for the couple, or that the couple should answer the very obvious question of "what would you like?".

PurelyBelter · 11/05/2023 15:03

I don't understand how it's any more tacky than a 'buy me this material shite' list tbh, but each to their own. And there's never cheap options for those less well off on these lists.

Easier, faster, more budget appropriate. I can't see the problem tbh.

Truestorypeeps · 11/05/2023 14:51

midsomermurderess · 11/05/2023 14:05

You say you’re glad it’s not just you. Of course it’s not. This has been standard for decades now. Some people don’t care, others like you get worked up. How is this still a talking point after 40-some years?

Ok, no one is allowed to talk about anything that people would have been talking about 40 years ago. Thanks for clearing that up.

OP posts:
Truestorypeeps · 11/05/2023 14:47

Everanewbie · 11/05/2023 13:14

Hi OP. My husband and I lived together for 6-7 years before our wedding and had no need for photo frames and a toaster etc. We had an amazing honeymoon booked. Slight difference to this scenario though, we had a gift list with the travel provider that guests could, if inclined, contribute towards. Essentially vouchers. Would this be more agreeable than just asking for the cash?

Still wouldn't do it myself but each to their own.

OP posts:
KSCheshire · 11/05/2023 14:46

This was a huge discussion topic when we were planning our wedding invites (get married next week!). We both agreed that it was tasteless so we wrote this on our wedding website “We don't have a gift registry. Your presence is enough but if you really insist on a gift or money, whatever you choose we will appreciate it” but people keep asking us what we want 🙈 we have lived together for 6 years so there is nothing that we need for the house so money is probably the best choice if people really insist on a gift (which people have been doing). One nice idea that a friend asked for when people asked what they wanted as a gift was restaurant vouchers for some nice restaurants around London. The couple have been having lots of lovely date nights since!

Whatonearthisgoingonnnn · 11/05/2023 14:36

I’d prefer to give money to be honest - I think then you can actually give what is within your budget.

I’ve known one invite that had a number of ‘experiences’ on it for on the couples honeymoon. Not one was under the £150 mark!!! Some £300-400 each. Meal on the beach, that sort of thing. They split up literally weeks after the honeymoon and the groom has since remarried and surprise surprise, had exactly the same request on his new wedding invite 😂

Lottapianos · 11/05/2023 14:29

'but then I don't think either wording is grabby, just practical and realistic'

I agree, just avoid tacky poems! I don't get the angst over this. You've been invited to a wedding, OF COURSE you should be planning to get them something, and it's entirely understandable that they don't want 'stuff'. I think it's really helpful to be told what they would like, whether it's honeymoon donations or John Lewis vouchers or whatever

AlmostWife · 11/05/2023 14:16

Haven’t RTFT but my partner is from (Eastern) Europe and it’s customary to gift money there. Are they British?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 14:14

Ha! Most definitely not! In some people's eyes I might be tacky, but I am not THAT tacky! 😂

Booo, you're no fun Grin

midsomermurderess · 11/05/2023 14:05

You say you’re glad it’s not just you. Of course it’s not. This has been standard for decades now. Some people don’t care, others like you get worked up. How is this still a talking point after 40-some years?

Coffeeandcards · 11/05/2023 13:58

Truestorypeeps · 10/05/2023 22:57

"we specifically said No gifts"

Much more classy and shows that a gift is not expected. Yes, as you say, you will still get gifts as people often do really want to give something but if it is unwanted, a friend/family member/charity shop will gladly take things off your hands. It's the thought that counts.

What a ridiculous response. You’re just encouraging more waste and tat in the world.

Present giving isn’t just about fulfilling a need, it’s about showing love and wanting the recipient to have something nice in their life. Just do that for these friends you claim to like, instead of wanting them to receive stuff they don’t need or want and then have the hassle of passing it all on.

Kaz88 · 11/05/2023 13:39

AhNowTed · 11/05/2023 09:27

Say nothing and guests will gift you money anyway.

There's absolutely no need to debase yourself by asking for it.

I agree. We mostly got money but also some really thoughtful experience gifts which my husband and I would never have done otherwise. We have such fond memories of when we went to classes and certain niche restaurants and they helped kind of extend the honeymoon period.

Kaz88 · 11/05/2023 13:33

JandalsAlways · 11/05/2023 12:02

See now I find that tacky, that you'd just show up empty-handed. Even if I received an invite that said no gifts, I'd still take an expensive bottle of bubbles or a bottle of good whiskey or something. Afterall you're celebrating someone's wedding, why wouldn't you want to give them somehhing, afterall what a provilage to share in such a special day. A lot of miserable people on this thread

We had one or two who turned up to our wedding empty handed (not struggling financially at all). The only awkward part was that we thought their card/gift might have gone missing and we didn’t want to come across as rude by not acknowledging it in a thank you card. We ended up just thanking them for making the effort to come etc.

HurryShadow · 11/05/2023 13:29

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/05/2023 10:16

We put a note in our invitation along the lines of "Your presence on our special day is what is most important to us, so we don't expect any gifts. If you would like to give us something, a contribution towards our honeymoon would be wonderful". It was better worded than that in reality, but you get the gist.

But did it rhyme?! It HAS to rhyme Grin

Ha! Most definitely not! In some people's eyes I might be tacky, but I am not THAT tacky! 😂

prescribingmum · 11/05/2023 13:29

Cherry35 · 11/05/2023 12:55

I also hate giving money, it puts people on the spot and then they may have high expectations if they know you have a good financial position.

I think that this can break friendships if you're close to them and don't give them as much money as they would expect.

Just go with a gift, you can say you bought it prior to receiving the wedding invitations (if you knew about it earlier).

Someone who expects more than they were gifted isn’t a true friend. They are inviting you to celebrate with them, not selling tickets to an event with a minimum contribution.

Equally someone who deliberately ignores their friends wishes and gifts them tat they specifically said they don’t want isn’t a friend either.

Kaz88 · 11/05/2023 13:26

Controversial opinion but I would never ask on an invitation, regardless of income. We didn’t mention gifts at all. I just couldn’t. Even seeing on another person’s invitation makes me cringe. Sorry but I’m just being honest.

My two favourites over the last few years have been:

  1. “There will be a cash pot at our reception for gifts.” No beating around the bush.
  2. After some usual cliched preamble, “We would like donations.” I wasn’t acting stupid but I genuinely said to my husband , “How generous of them. I wonder which charity is their preference.” Turns out the charity of their preference was… er, them. 😂 Lovely euphemism.
Everanewbie · 11/05/2023 13:14

Hi OP. My husband and I lived together for 6-7 years before our wedding and had no need for photo frames and a toaster etc. We had an amazing honeymoon booked. Slight difference to this scenario though, we had a gift list with the travel provider that guests could, if inclined, contribute towards. Essentially vouchers. Would this be more agreeable than just asking for the cash?

Otterock · 11/05/2023 13:08

I don’t see anything wrong with advising cash if people do want to give something. It saves the hassle of people asking or risking getting a bunch of stuff that will clutter up your house that you don’t need. A family member did exactly that last year, I was perfectly happy slipping some cash into a card to pop in the postbox at reception. Job done and everyone is happy.

Cherry35 · 11/05/2023 12:55

I also hate giving money, it puts people on the spot and then they may have high expectations if they know you have a good financial position.

I think that this can break friendships if you're close to them and don't give them as much money as they would expect.

Just go with a gift, you can say you bought it prior to receiving the wedding invitations (if you knew about it earlier).

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 12:54

I know the UK has a different culture, but there is still a gift giving culture and people don't like to turn up empty handed. Cash is preferable to mindless consumption on shit the couple don't need.

I think this is a great way of putting it.

The UK is a present giving culture, and like in many societies weddings are important. The circumstances that gave rise to the more traditional etiquette no longer exist, but the importance of gifts and weddings have persisted. That part hasn't changed. So there's this halfway house at the moment, until a new etiquette that accurately reflects 21st century society fully embeds.

JimJamJo · 11/05/2023 12:45

SpongeBob2022 · 10/05/2023 22:30

It doesn't bother me at all.

Is it a generational thing? I am 40 and don't know anyone of my generation who would be bothered by this and have been seeing it on invites/putting money in cards at weddings throughout my wedding reference period (about 15 years).

Are those who object to it older than me? Or is it just that everyone I know must be crass and tacky? Am genuinely interested.

I think traditionally in the generation a bit older than me, it was rude to mention gifts at all but people knew to contact the mother of the bride (in the days when parents did the inviting), to ask for the wedding list. It would now be a bit random to contact the bride's family (unless you already know them) so people are more direct?

FernGully43 · 11/05/2023 12:41

I don't see the big deal. I don't mind contributing to their first holiday as a married couple as a gift. Such experiences are much better than salt and pepper shakers.