Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding invitation - please give us your money (basically)

585 replies

Truestorypeeps · 10/05/2023 21:51

Received a second wedding invitation in a row which mentions words to the affect of, we would very much appreciate money towards our honeymoon as a gift. I personally couldn't physically write this in an invitation as it just feels presumptuous and tasteless.

Maybe this last invite got my back up as this couple have been together well over ten years, already have children, earn c.150k between them, massive house and already go on countless holidays at home and abroad. They could have easily omitted such a line from the invite. I understand they don't want toasters and towels, but surely there's another way?! E.g. heading, 'wedding gifts', below - 'your presence at our wedding would be more than enough, but if you'd like to gift us something to mark this day, please give a donation to XYZ charity which is close to our hearts because of XYZ??? Owing to the fact they are bloody rolling in it.

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 11/05/2023 07:43

I prefer to gift money. When I got married, we received so many unwanted presents, we donated to charity. I wouldn't want my gift to go to charity. Also most couples already live together, and already have home wear and picture frames. You're spending x amount regardless, just giving it in cash.

midgemadgemodge · 11/05/2023 07:43

I would rather they say if you want t give a gift cash is best

It means that people can give what they afford rather than looking for the cheapest thing on a list ; it means they can get something they actually want that's too expensive to ask for ; experiences over tat any day ; I wouldn't want to go to a wedding - a celebration of something pretty major and with a lot of hospitality- without a gift

I understand culturally specify cash seems wrong but the world has changed and moved on from the idea that 27 toasters are a sensible set of wedding gift and use of peoples money and use of world resources

Crunchymum · 11/05/2023 07:42

DemonicCaveMaggot · 10/05/2023 21:56

I think it is tacky to include the gift registry or request a type of gift in the invitation. Wait for guests to get in touch and ask what they would like for a gift.

To be fair they may not have time to field all these queries. It's actually easier to include all the info on the invitation.

In all honesty who goes to a wedding totally empty handed?

I don't like actual money being requested but I prefer people being upfront. And I'd rather donate to a honeymoon than spend money on something they haven't asked for. If you are going to spend £20 / £50 on a gift anyway why not just donate?

We haven't been to many weddings though and the ones we have been to, haven't explicitly asked for money. I think we did John Lewis vouchers for one and money for another.

Sceptre86 · 11/05/2023 07:37

You have a choice to go to the wedding or not. It's an invitation not a summons as is often said on here. Weddings are expensive so maybe for them instead of gifts they probably don't want, need or have space for they'd rather spend the money towards their honeymoon. The invites with charity messages get peoples back up too. If you are going to a wedding you'd plan on taking a gift so why not just give them what they'd prefer?

MsWhitworth · 11/05/2023 07:37

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 06:57

Which is then liable to result in people getting you something anyway.

This is not a practical solution, because weddings are associated with gifts to the couple. It's a sufficiently strong association that people may not actually understand you genuinely don't want anything at all, and even if they do there's still a good chance they'll try and do something. It just isn't a sensible suggestion.

I get that it’s practical, I really do. There’s just something about asking for money - it feels so uncomfortable to me. There are very few situations where you ask a large number of people for money, for yourself. It goes against everything we are taught and are used to doing, in every other circumstance.

MXVIT · 11/05/2023 07:36

I couldn't write this in an invite for two reasons:

  1. attending weddings is expensive enough without insinuating a gift is required on top - I could never.

  2. a lot of people rely on credit these days. Presume friend A was always going to send 100 pounds, and is happy to do so but would rather put a gift on a credit card and pay it off over three months to keep finances manageable. This cash request asks for the whole amount upfront - dreadful.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/05/2023 07:31

The problem with gift giving etiquette in general is that it was written when vast amounts of easily affordable to the masses tat wasn't a thing. It doesn't work that well for modern people and needs a lot of updating.

Lots of people are short on living space, they have to be discerning about what goes into that space and many of us are conscious of being wasteful.

And yes, I've never understood the logic of not putting gift lists in the invitation and expecting every single person involved to take the time to get in touch and ask for it because etiquette. What an utterly pointless waste of time.

lurcherlove · 11/05/2023 07:27

We got married last year after a decade together and tried to get away without a list or anything. But the everybody asked about it 😂😂😂

nah I don’t mind giving cash if that’s what people want. However much they earn I’d give a gift.

GreenDressy · 11/05/2023 07:25

I don't think it's that bad really.
Aren't they allowed to choose what they receive? Doesn't mean you have to give anything at all.

Plus if there wasn't a terrible tacky poem, you got off lightly 😂

Mayorquimby2 · 11/05/2023 07:24

"We got a few gifts which would have been inexpensive, but the fact it was picked and some thought put into it added to the gift."

Omg you kept the gifts???!!!!

That's fucking mortifying. I don't think I could speak to friends again with everyone knowing I've accepted their charity, I can buy my own toaster thanks very much rather than taint my wedding day by making it some feudal barter system.

whatkatydid2013 · 11/05/2023 07:17

I see nothing wrong with stating what you’d like. Why are so many people anti giving a gift the recipient has said they’d actually like? You all say you were going to give something anyway. Also don’t get the idea you have to give more when it’s money given it’s pretty obvious how much most gifts cost so if you are only spending a small amount people will know regardless (& in most cases won’t care)

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 07:14

Snugglemonkey · 11/05/2023 07:10

I do see your point, but it is really inefficient for every guest to get in touch and who wants 100 gifts (or however many).

Yeah, just send me the bloody list instead of wasting my time and yours. We both know I'm getting you a present, let's make chasing one less mental load task.

Snugglemonkey · 11/05/2023 07:10

DemonicCaveMaggot · 10/05/2023 21:56

I think it is tacky to include the gift registry or request a type of gift in the invitation. Wait for guests to get in touch and ask what they would like for a gift.

I do see your point, but it is really inefficient for every guest to get in touch and who wants 100 gifts (or however many).

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 07:01

BUT I believe that there are original and definitely would be loved by the couple type gifts

Mmm, I'm sure you do believe that. Lots of people who like giving physical items as presents hold that belief. Many of them are deluding themselves.

And the problem with 'original' is its harder to usefully get rid of. At least with toasters the charity shop would probably be glad of them if you keep them unopened in the box.

BeefyWellington · 11/05/2023 06:59

We asked for money for our honeymoon (along with a disclaimer that we didn't expect gifts but if people did want to get us something...) as we had lived together for 7 years so had everything we needed.

We got a mix of money and some lovely thoughtful gifts (presumably from those people who didn't want to give money for whatever reason - fine by me).

We're not rich, and even less so years ago when we got married - so is that OK?

I honestly don't get the issue with this at all and why it pisses some people off so much!

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 11/05/2023 06:58

Believe it or not, I like these people!

I'm going with "not".

I know a lot of people get angry at the idea of buying wedding gifts after accepting wedding invitations if they think the couple doesn't "need" them, but that's not how gifts work.

I'm not bothered about giving money as a gift either; I'm spending the same however I give it and this way I know they'll make use of it rather than have something they don't want collecting dust in the loft. Money as a gift has always been very useful to me.

Poems are shite, but greetings industry poems of any kind usually are. No point getting worked up over that.

And now I see some people are offended by requests to donate to a chosen charity, which I hadn't realised happened. Could understand if it was a politicised charity but that doesn't seem to be the issue here.

There's something really mean-spirited about weddings on MN.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 11/05/2023 06:57

MsWhitworth · 11/05/2023 06:53

This has become the norm now but I think it’s awful to ask for money. If you don’t need anything, just say we don’t need anything thank you.

Which is then liable to result in people getting you something anyway.

This is not a practical solution, because weddings are associated with gifts to the couple. It's a sufficiently strong association that people may not actually understand you genuinely don't want anything at all, and even if they do there's still a good chance they'll try and do something. It just isn't a sensible suggestion.

MsWhitworth · 11/05/2023 06:53

This has become the norm now but I think it’s awful to ask for money. If you don’t need anything, just say we don’t need anything thank you.

whatkatydid2013 · 11/05/2023 06:50

recyclemeagain · 10/05/2023 22:33

@AnneLovesGilbert still none the wiser to what charities are polarising, can't think of a charity I would be against supporting.

Off the top of my head some people don’t want to donate to animal charities (particularly ones like peta), some are strong believers charity begins at home and don’t want to donate to charities that operate abroad, some object to donating to large organisations that have staff on relatively high salaries, some don’t want to donate to anything linked to a religion and some can be very anti charities aimed at reducing poverty/think everyone on benefits are chancers. Personally I never gift to any charity that has strong religious links as I’ve come across too many reports that those charities effectively use their giving as a way to promote their religious belief (like including religious pamphlets in the shoebox appeal admittedly by a U.S. based charity but widely reported) or limit the help they provide to exclude people or practices they disagree with (so things like operate health facilities but avoid signposting those accessing them to abortion or contraceptive services). Conversely some religious people wouldn’t want to support charities researching certain diseases that rely on stem cell research.

Doidontimmm · 11/05/2023 06:47

I kind of wish we had written this last year as we said please no gifts but ended up with countless mr & Mrs cups/books on marriage/ornaments/wine (DH doesn’t drink & I don’t like wine - everyone knows that!) that are now in a cupboard! I feel awful for this but we just won’t use.

Tourmalines · 11/05/2023 06:34

I really do not see an issue with their invitation. They have been together for so long that they don’t need anyone to buy them any more ‘stuff’ if you are invited to a wedding, it is normal courtesy to give a gift, of course you can be a real tight arse and not buy one ,that’s your choice . Suggesting a contribution towards their honeymoon isn’t tactless or greedy , it makes sense . Not sure what the problem is .

Pipsquiggle · 11/05/2023 06:27

The poem sounds shit, I will give you that, however, the giving of money is fine.

I think the tacky poem has framed the 'present' request really poorly which has got your back up.

The last wedding I went to, said no presents but if people wanted to gift something here's a list. It was a wedding list at Trailfinders. You were buying experiences e.g. swimming with dolphins, cocktails on top of a mountain etc. Both the bride and groom were really into travelling so this was perfect for them.

I am not a fan of going 'off list,' not many people did at my wedding. The off list gifts, I could tell the person had put effort into buying something that they thought was 'special' - in reality, it wasn't needed &/or not to our taste. It was literally a waste of their money, time and effort. I would have just preferred a card.

msisfine · 11/05/2023 06:18

Oysterbabe · 10/05/2023 21:55

Don't go as you clearly don't like them.

Haha yeah this is what I thought! What difference does it make it that's what they want?

Sissynova · 11/05/2023 06:17

I just think it’s a non issue. People on mumsnet get really ranty about the ‘entitlement’ but the social convention is to get a wedding gift.

The couple having money would not be a reason to not get a wedding gift imo. I base my gifts on how close I am to the couple not how little money they have.

Yerroblemom1923 · 11/05/2023 06:12

Tacky, grabby and cheeky AF. I think the same with gift lists. We deliberately said we didn't want gifts and their presence really was enough. People did still give us money and gift cards etc but it really wasn't expected.
And this was before I joined Mumsnet and realised that this was the general consensus!