Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about my wedding cake?

218 replies

Woolloomooloo · 10/05/2023 20:11

We got married a few weeks ago and had a perfect day with just one exception - the wedding cake wasn’t really what we had agreed with the supplier in terms of design.

I had sent her an example photo of a cake that we liked the style of but it had one subtle design feature on the top tier which we didn’t like. We asked her to copy the cake but omit this detail and it said this on the invoice.

We also asked for the same finish as the cake in the photo but with more vibrant, stronger colouration to it.

On the day we ended up with a lovely looking cake, but the colours were not vibrant and the detail we wanted omitting was included!

The cake cost us in the region of £500!

So my question is AIBU to raise it with her?

Or do I just accept the rest of the day was perfect and get over it?

OP posts:
OrwellianTimes · 11/05/2023 20:29

CountryStore · 10/05/2023 20:19

£500 for a cake?!

For a multiple tiered custom cake that’s very reasonable.

I make party cakes for fun, a basic large one can cost me £150 in materials alone.

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/05/2023 20:25

Efficaciou5 · 11/05/2023 20:17

So, now the honeymoon's over, you're looking for something to complain about, and for something to gain ...

Having enjoyed your "perfect day" , in what way do you think you could benefit from complaining about your wedding cake.

You've already stated that you had the perfect day. Why not remember it as such and just leave it there.

Any protracted discussions about the cake could only marr the occasion, even if they resulted in a full refund, and since some of the points you mention are subjective this would very doubtfully be the outcome.

Paying £500 for a £20 cake is all part and parcel of the wedding malarkey which everyone goes through during the process.

Enjoy your happiness and try to focus on more positive things.

@Efficaciou5
how patronising

Efficaciou5 · 11/05/2023 20:17

So, now the honeymoon's over, you're looking for something to complain about, and for something to gain ...

Having enjoyed your "perfect day" , in what way do you think you could benefit from complaining about your wedding cake.

You've already stated that you had the perfect day. Why not remember it as such and just leave it there.

Any protracted discussions about the cake could only marr the occasion, even if they resulted in a full refund, and since some of the points you mention are subjective this would very doubtfully be the outcome.

Paying £500 for a £20 cake is all part and parcel of the wedding malarkey which everyone goes through during the process.

Enjoy your happiness and try to focus on more positive things.

jamdonut · 11/05/2023 20:10

I had a celebration cake from M&S for £45 for my recent wedding. It looked beautiful. Admittedly it was only a small cake, for a small party, but everyone commented on it and it was absolutely delicious!

I think you should tell the cake maker that you weren't happy, but leave it at that. It's in the past now. and something to talk about when you look back!

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/05/2023 19:58

Those saying that she accepted the cake, it got eaten etc so therefore she can’t complain…

bullshit! It was her wedding day of course she had to accept it. She can’t exactly give it back and get her sort it out for a couple of days time can she?! Also the bride probably didn’t even get chance to see the cake as too busy getting ready, having photos taken or whatever , I know I didn’t on my wedding day.

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/05/2023 19:52

Maddy70 · 11/05/2023 19:32

No one cares about the cake in reality. No one even notices it
I would let it go.

OP cares. And she’s the one who has paid for it so 🤷‍♀️

LuckySantangelo35 · 11/05/2023 19:49

If the cake genuinely wasn’t right, I don’t see why on earth you WOULDN’T complain?!

it’s a product you’ve paid good money for.

Maddy70 · 11/05/2023 19:32

No one cares about the cake in reality. No one even notices it
I would let it go.

Noononoo · 11/05/2023 19:14

I think you should tell them but not expect a refund. Just that you were a bit disappointed. They may want to compensate you or just say sorry.

MonderMomen77 · 11/05/2023 19:04

Oh my goodness, all these responses saying, just leave it, and what do you hope to achieve by complaining? This is exactly why some people like cake makers etc don't put in 100% effort. You gave specific instructions to omit a certain part of the design. So either she doesn't understand English or she didn't take the time to listen to what you the client wanted. I'd absolutely say something like, thank you for the beautiful cake, really enjoyed by everyone, however I was slightly disappointed you failed to omit the design we discussed. Was there any particular reason for this?
If you achieve nothing else, it will hopefully make them pay more attention next time and you'll have got it off your chest. Then move on and focus on your otherwise happy memories.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 11/05/2023 19:02

I now really want a thread where people share their wedding cake photographs! There was a great thread where people shared photos of their engagement rings.

Excited101 · 11/05/2023 18:48

Spot the people on this thread who’ve never made a proper cake before… 🤦‍♀️

I’ve made quite a few wedding cakes over the past 15 years. It’s impossible to gauge how much they should cost unless you’ve done that.

An 8” round cake will cost approximately £10 just in ganache ingredients. Sugarpaste will be about £7 per packet and a box and boards will cost about £7 too. That’s before I’ve got eggs, sugar etc. Thats for one 8” cake. A wedding cake is typically 12”, 10”, 8” and 6”, sometimes more and sometimes less. Now imagine that a fairly simple design with limited/no decorations is going to take a minimum of about 10-15 hours of work and funnily enough, it soon adds up. Has the baker got to deliver the cake? That’s got to be accounted for too. It can take an hour or 2 to set up a wedding cake, who pays for that time?

There’s no shame in getting a cheap supermarket cake, or having no wedding cake at all. But the vast majority of cakes are not at all overpriced, we make hardly any money when you factor our time into it, would you work for £2 per hour?

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/05/2023 18:21

We had a similar issue.

We didn't actually buy it, a friend did but we said we wanted classy and subtle, nothing bling or multi coloured as we are an older couple

Didn't see it until the day of the wedding at the reception. God almighty.

It was bloody awful. Literally, bright purple swirled with white. Huge, massive flowers on each side with diamante bits on. If TOWIE was a cake, this would be that cake.

It was also wonky, and melted in places.

To top it off, we bought a nice cake topper which was discarded for a huge bunch of the cheapest looking fake flowers you'd ever seen. Also blinged up.

There was naff all I could do, and suffice to say we don't have any cutting the cake photos.

Our relatives were asking what on earth we were thinking, or was it a joke. We had to smile and get on with it.

Suffice to say, we don't see that friend anymore. They picked the cake they would have if they got married, and entirely disregarded our choice. They also nicked two of the tiers when we went home. The rest I cut up and froze and the DCs had it in their lunch boxes.

Yes, you should say something, probably along the lines of you won't be reviewing because you paid no attention to what was requested and actually, if it's in the paperwork, I would be asking for a partial refund.

Blondeshavemorefun · 11/05/2023 11:06

Oh bless you @Cap89 That sounds nothing

Cap89 · 11/05/2023 10:52

Sorry that was in reply to @Blondeshavemorefun

Cap89 · 11/05/2023 10:51

As in what was the mistake? The cake had marbled fondant on one tier and she wanted a little bit of silver painting along the marble to highlight it which I forgot to do. It would have been really subtle even if I had done it, so made very little impact on the overall design of the cake and aside from that it was 100% to brief. But she noticed, and it had been in my notes and all our discussions so it was definitely my error and that’s why I responded like I did. A horrible feeling but it was resolved well in the end.

Blondeshavemorefun · 11/05/2023 10:32

@Cap89 what did you do ?

Op block out your name

Or show the cake you liked and what you wanted removed

Woolloomooloo · 11/05/2023 10:20

Well a fairly mixed response but I’m going to go with giving the baker some feedback rather than actually complaining.

It was never my intention to expect any money back, I was more after an explanation of why the brief wasn’t followed. I also at no point complained about the cost so not sure where that comment came from.

I’m not going to post any pictures as the cake has my name on it.

Also to the people saying we should have refused the cake at the time - we didn’t see it until we walked into the wedding breakfast room with about 70 guests so it wasn’t the time to raise an issue. Also we’ve been on honeymoon as somebody suggested so haven’t really thought about it too much until now.

I understand the point of view re letting it go and I think providing feedback rather than a complaint is probably a happy medium.

OP posts:
trisfreya · 11/05/2023 09:00

MaltedCow · 10/05/2023 21:49

And maybe posting the cake would be outing hence the OP not posting the pictures.

or the OP is thinking its not that bad after her OP
or its made up to annoy people

Until @Woolloomooloo comes back, we have no clue

Cap89 · 11/05/2023 08:31

pictoosh · 11/05/2023 07:40

However fancy the decor is, it’s just a cake to be sliced up and eaten.
No cake is worth hundreds of pounds.

The fact you wouldn’t be willing to pay for it doesn’t mean it isn’t worth it. People deserve to be paid for their time and skill. Because you would be happy with something simpler/no cake at all, doesn’t mean that those who want something more special shouldn’t pay what it costs. I didn’t want bespoke handmade wardrobes because I couldn’t justify the cost, so I went to IKEA. Doesn’t mean the artisan carpenter shouldn’t be charging thousands more for a superior product. It’s just different priorities, and the customer proprieties shouldn’t dictate what the artist charges for their work.

EasterBreak · 11/05/2023 08:31

Of course mention it seeing as you didn't get what you asked for. Just because it was an edible cake doesnt mean you have to put up with something you don't want. I'd be expecting some money back.

Cap89 · 11/05/2023 08:24

I’m a wedding cake maker and as much as I’d hate to receive that complaint, there is a case for raising it. Clearly a mistake was made, they didn’t double check their notes and because of the inspiration image they just had that in their head. These mistakes happen, but it could and should have been avoided. I’ve only done this once (a very minor thing) and the bride emailed me the day after. I was absolutely gutted. It was a stunning cake and I’d poured an enormous amount of love and time into it, but it was my error and I refunded her delivery charge as a good will gesture. I also appreciated the opportunity to apologise, and the bride was lovely about it in the end and sent me beautiful photos a few weeks later with a proper thank you. She clearly just needed to get it off her chest.

I have NEVER made the same mistake again, and now triple check everything, so while it was a horrible email to receive, it has probably improved my service.

So from that angle, if it would make you feel better, then a nice email that just flagged it for her to improve her processes would be fine. I wouldn’t be refunding anything as a baker if it was raised weeks later (my t&cs have a clear complaints window), so if that’s your aim, I think you’re way too late.

SilverBirchWithout · 11/05/2023 08:03

I think the point about cost is clouding the issue here. OP ordered a cake and had agreed to pay £500 for a bespoke wedding cake - indeed the cost reflects the fact a cake is being exclusively designed for the client. However this is not what the OP got, she was made a cake which sounds like it was part of the maker’s standard repertoire - nothing bespoke about this cake.
I too would be a bit annoyed and frustrated and would politely mention my disappointment to the maker, she has not provided a professional service and needs to be made aware. Personally I would not make a big deal about it as wouldn’t want to spoil the memories of the day, but I would expect an explanation and apology from the maker.

Toottooot · 11/05/2023 07:41

CountryStore · 10/05/2023 20:19

£500 for a cake?!

Standard for a wedding cake 🤷🏻‍♀️

pictoosh · 11/05/2023 07:40

PinkyFlamingo · 10/05/2023 21:21

Well we all are different eh. Some people dont mind paying a fortune for lots of things for a wedding and yet expect other things on the cheap.

However fancy the decor is, it’s just a cake to be sliced up and eaten.
No cake is worth hundreds of pounds.