Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about my wedding cake?

218 replies

Woolloomooloo · 10/05/2023 20:11

We got married a few weeks ago and had a perfect day with just one exception - the wedding cake wasn’t really what we had agreed with the supplier in terms of design.

I had sent her an example photo of a cake that we liked the style of but it had one subtle design feature on the top tier which we didn’t like. We asked her to copy the cake but omit this detail and it said this on the invoice.

We also asked for the same finish as the cake in the photo but with more vibrant, stronger colouration to it.

On the day we ended up with a lovely looking cake, but the colours were not vibrant and the detail we wanted omitting was included!

The cake cost us in the region of £500!

So my question is AIBU to raise it with her?

Or do I just accept the rest of the day was perfect and get over it?

OP posts:
CindyCrawfoot · 12/05/2023 09:32

Could have had a whole pile of Colins 😭

FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman · 12/05/2023 09:30

SparklyBlackKitten · 10/05/2023 23:44

@PinkyFlamingo
No matter the skill or the time
No cake is worth that much money😅

I'll politely disagree with you.

A cake may not be worth £500 to you personally, but that's not the issue. Cake is important to a lot of people and they're happy to pay for it.

As a baker and cake decorator I have a decent knowledge of the cost in money, time and specialist skill that goes into making a cake. Not to mention the consultation(s), time taken researching options, ordering specific materials, health and safety paperwork, cleaning, liaising with wedding coordinators and florists, transporting the cake to the venue... then there's the cost of insurance, rent on premises, gas/electricity/water, wear and tear on equipment etc etc.

Most of us aren't even earning minimum wage for our time since the cost of ingredients skyrocketed - it's a fine balance between keeping prices low enough that customers can afford to order a cake, and making a wage out of it.

OP, if I'd made a cake that you weren't totally happy with, I'd want you to tell me. It's for you and the individual baker to come to a satisfactory resolution - nobody on here can tell you what that is (acknowledgment that it wasn't quite what you wanted? Partial refund? Goodwill gesture on your next cake order?) but please be polite in how you go about it - any baker will take negative feedback to heart regardless, but the way you raise it with them will make all the difference in terms of a resolution.

anotherside · 12/05/2023 09:27

I wouldn’t mention the colours - as you said yourself it was a lovely cake, so unless you specifically and clearly mentioned you wanted super bright colours (not “vibrant” which is subjective) it’s not worth mentioning.

I would however send a quick email saying, thanks for the cake the guests said it wss delicious etc and it looked lovely - but we did specifically ask in our email on the X that Detail Y be omitted and instead it was included.
That is a significant error and they should be made aware of their mistake IMO.

anotherside · 12/05/2023 09:23

Asking for more cake is always a good plan.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 12/05/2023 09:20

Pinkfluff76 · 12/05/2023 07:58

£500 for a cake is ridiculous! And as for the baker saying if you want a cheap cake go to M&S… you could buy ten cakes and still have a WHOLE lot of change so what a daft thing to say!

So what’s ridiculous about what the baker said? She agrees you can get cheaper cakes from shops. That’s the whole point. You pay for a personalised one. Just like it costs more to get a tailored suit than buy one off the rack. Obviously lots of people want bespoke cakes for weddings and they’re free to do it or not. £500 is pretty standard for a wedding cake.

Also it’s not the point but it’s not even that cheap from supermarkets. Waitrose do a 3 tier plain white undecorated wedding cake for £175.

MitchellMummy · 12/05/2023 08:36

The word 'vibrant' is subjective I guess but to include the detail you wanted omitted isn't acceptable. Bespoke wedding cakes are expensive I know ... if I had baked the cake and you'd raised the issue with me I'd probably have offered to bake a cake for you as an apology.

GCWorkNightmare · 12/05/2023 08:08

Pinkfluff76 · 12/05/2023 07:58

£500 for a cake is ridiculous! And as for the baker saying if you want a cheap cake go to M&S… you could buy ten cakes and still have a WHOLE lot of change so what a daft thing to say!

Yet it’s pretty common to spend £1k on a dress to wear for one day.

I spent £1k on a cake that made us happy for years after the weekend and £300 on a dress.

I’ve made wedding cakes for friends - one a 7 tier chocolate cake which they used for dessert. I think I charged £500 - the chocolate cigarillos cost about £100 of that. They fed 250 people a generous slice with fruit coulis and cream for less than £2.50 a head.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/05/2023 08:05

But OP wanted this particular cake, @Pinkfluff76 .

She doubtless knew she could get a cheaper one from M&S but didn't want a cheaper one.

However, the cost of personalised wedding cakes isn't the issue - the issue is can they draw it to the baker's attention.

Yes - let her know that you were disappointed with some of the features that you'd specifically asked be changed from the example in the photograph. She may offer a discount.

Her response would inform my review (though I wouldn't leave a nasty one in these circumstances - just factual) on her website,

Pinkfluff76 · 12/05/2023 07:58

£500 for a cake is ridiculous! And as for the baker saying if you want a cheap cake go to M&S… you could buy ten cakes and still have a WHOLE lot of change so what a daft thing to say!

dottiedodah · 12/05/2023 07:55

Pictoosh We were getting quotes of £ 250/£300 for a wedding cake when we got married over 20 years ago! Luckily my SIL /MIL made us a beautiful one , The time and expertise needed are second to none ,for a special cake !

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/05/2023 07:54

Halsall · 12/05/2023 07:45

I've made cakes semi-professionally and I think Cap89's replies are very thoughtful and sensible. Measured feedback is the way to go, and the cake-maker should be glad to have it for future experience in listening to clients.

(On a side-note, I can’t resist saying that I hooted out loud on reading your first couple of posts about the unwanted 'subtle design feature' on the cake topper, OP, because as soon as the first post arrived asking for a photo, what should spring up immediately but the MN video with that godawful sheep on top of the hat. I’m sorry to laugh but it just tickled me)

HAHAHAHAHA!

That spider-legged sheep makes me cringe, too!

😂

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/05/2023 07:53

PinkyFlamingo · 10/05/2023 20:33

As a Baker myself I'm sick of comments like this. If you want a cheap cake go to M and S or Cost Co. £500 is about average for a tiered bespoke wedding cake.

I'm not a baker, but knowing how long it takes to make a Teenage Ninja Turtle cake for a kid's 6th birthday party, I'm on your side here!

Wedding cakes are complex - All those teeny flowery decorations etc, having to wait until some bits dry before you put the next bits on (taking up all of your bench space so you can't do anything else), carefully constructing it, very carefully transporting it and building it up at the venue . . . it takes days, not hours.

Plus, of course, the customer pays for the skill involved - the training and the hours and hours of practise.

Bespoke cakes can't just be churned out.

Halsall · 12/05/2023 07:45

I've made cakes semi-professionally and I think Cap89's replies are very thoughtful and sensible. Measured feedback is the way to go, and the cake-maker should be glad to have it for future experience in listening to clients.

(On a side-note, I can’t resist saying that I hooted out loud on reading your first couple of posts about the unwanted 'subtle design feature' on the cake topper, OP, because as soon as the first post arrived asking for a photo, what should spring up immediately but the MN video with that godawful sheep on top of the hat. I’m sorry to laugh but it just tickled me)

ThomasinaLivesHere · 12/05/2023 07:36

@Woolloomooloo I think you’re being completely reasonable to give feedback. You paid for something and it wasn’t as it should have been.

HoofWankingSpangleCunt · 12/05/2023 07:24

My wedding cake was blown up in the Soho bombing in 1999, the day before my weddings . But I didn’t complain as people actually died and I’m not a total dickhead. My Ddad drove around London to buy the cake from another branch (patisserie Valerie, when they were still good 😀)

Looking back, if that cake wasn’t an omen of a disastrous marriage I’m a monkey’s uncle.

GCWorkNightmare · 12/05/2023 07:17

adriftabroad · 11/05/2023 21:53

My friend had a cake from Choccy Woccy Doo Dah (back in the day) It was easily 500 pounds, 20 years ago.
Such an anticlimax, tiny tiny cake.

Really? Mine was 4ft tall, weighed 8 stone. Took 2 staff to carry it to the kitchen to be cut. 😂

We used about a fifth of it for 80 day guests and 50 evening. It was incredibly rich. We were eating it for years (from the freezer).

Marmite27 · 12/05/2023 07:17

PinkyFlamingo · 10/05/2023 20:33

As a Baker myself I'm sick of comments like this. If you want a cheap cake go to M and S or Cost Co. £500 is about average for a tiered bespoke wedding cake.

Mine was £490, 10 years ago and it was on the cheaper side then!

GCWorkNightmare · 12/05/2023 07:14

littleblackcat27 · 12/05/2023 07:08

Our wedding cake was from Choccy Woccy Doo Dah (back in the day ie 25 years ago) and it was completely fabulous.

I hope you're not one of my friends!! Grin

Mine too! 19 years ago. £1k well spent. (£130 of that was transport from Brighton.)

Roselilly36 · 12/05/2023 07:11

I can imagine how disappointing it was for you.

I don’t know why so many posters are surprised by the cost or want to see a photo of your cake.

I don’t think £500 is unreasonable for a tiered wedding cake, I think ours was around £180 nearly 30 years ago.

I would explain to the baker why I was dissatisfied with the cake, but I wouldn’t expect more than an apology.

I am sure your guests thought the cake it looked lovely and it was enjoyed. They would have assumed it was the cake you ordered.

littleblackcat27 · 12/05/2023 07:08

adriftabroad · 11/05/2023 21:53

My friend had a cake from Choccy Woccy Doo Dah (back in the day) It was easily 500 pounds, 20 years ago.
Such an anticlimax, tiny tiny cake.

Our wedding cake was from Choccy Woccy Doo Dah (back in the day ie 25 years ago) and it was completely fabulous.

I hope you're not one of my friends!! Grin

ZoraMipha · 12/05/2023 06:37

The only people who give a toss about the wedding cake is the bride and perhaps her mother. Other than that, guests barely look at it. It is only a cake after all.

@pictoosh Well I suppose you could say that about a lot of things at a wedding. The dress, the flowers, the decor - does anyone really care about any of it?

I think they all come together to make the day, and people actually care/ notice more than you might think.

If you don't have any of these things, it's just be a party. At my wedding, we got lots of comments from people saying it was the best wedding they'd ever been to, everything was so thoughtful etc - that doesn't just happen - it's a combination of all the effort and planning we put into everything. And yes, that included a cake, and we gave the baker a specification as to what we wanted. The cake was beautiful and people did admire it as they walked in. It was special.

And at the end of the day, it doesn't really matter if you think anyone else cares about it or not - it's the bride and groom that are paying for it and if they care then it's important.

Cap89 · 12/05/2023 05:03

Amareta · 12/05/2023 04:37

It is too late to make changes and you really should have been paying more attention before it was completed BUT you can leave a less than good review and not recommend that baker. You need to own up to the fact that if you had checked on the cake beforehand it would have been perfect. Don’t let a less than adequate cake ruin your perfect day.

I really don’t think OP needs to take any blame for this. I never see the bride or groom at a wedding cake setup as I’m usually there in the morning. They never receive it or sign off on it and don’t see it till the day is in full swing. So it’s pretty impossible for them to reject it on the day.

I would also encourage anyone in this or similar situations to speak to the baker privately rather than leave a review. Mistakes happen, but poor reviews can be exceptionally bad for a small business. Of course, if the baker turned out to be really difficult/rude to OP then maybe, but that shouldn’t be the first response. One error shouldn’t potentially cost her her livelihood.

Amareta · 12/05/2023 04:37

It is too late to make changes and you really should have been paying more attention before it was completed BUT you can leave a less than good review and not recommend that baker. You need to own up to the fact that if you had checked on the cake beforehand it would have been perfect. Don’t let a less than adequate cake ruin your perfect day.

Antisocialfluffmonster · 12/05/2023 01:02

I really get annoyed when people make out like you’re being petty if you order something and it’s not right. What the actual fluff is the point of ordering something to be custom designed, and paying for it to be custom designed, if you’re actually perfectly happy with anything they are going to crock up with?

send a polite message explaining you were disappointed when you saw it, and no one is going to return a cake on the day because hello…:: you still need a cake!!!

it did get eaten so I wouldn’t ask for a refund, but you might as well at least tell them.

ejbaxa · 11/05/2023 23:45

I would just let it go and don't use that baker again.

If the baker didn't read the brief, then I'm not really sure what good feedback is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread