Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I can't cook in my own home

808 replies

Bambambino1 · 10/05/2023 15:41

I am sympathetic to my DH here but, this is getting ridiculous. I'm just keen to hear what others think about this and how you'd handle it.

Bit of background, my DH hates all food smells. Is stresses him out just thinking about it. I think more so than normal people (you know what I mean). On that basis, we pretty much only have oven cooked meals and pretty much the same thing most nights. He likes to eat a lot of fruit and veg separately to his main meals, but I'm not personally very good at that (so I'm almost certainly not getting the nutrients I need!)

We've been together 11 years. So for 11 years now I've pretty much not been able to do anything at all that involves frying food or cooking anything that smells bad. I've suggested an air fryer but apparently that makes the house smell. Slow cooker definitely a no-go on that basis. I can put a pizza in the oven, but not really make anything from scratch! He's basically in charge in the kitchen.

To clarify, this isn't a control thing on his part. He's just insistent that food smells will give him a mental breakdown, and he says this is linked to his mental health. I don't believe it's as bad as he says (maybe that's unreasonable of me), I just think he's almost convinced himself of it. We've argued today because I want to cook something tomorrow when he's in the office. He got very worked up about this because of how the house will smell. I said he can open windows, use the extractor fan, burn incense...I don't care what we do, I just want to cook something!!

Just, I don't want to go though my whole life not using my kitchen and cooking anything ever?!

I was just planning on cooking tomorrow when he was out anyway, and see how he copes when he gets home. Is that wrong?

Sorry, I do appreciate how this sounds but it's a genuine problem!

OP posts:
Frazzledbynature · 12/05/2023 08:05

Aside from a MH assessment, the other key feature here is what does get cooked in the oven.

I've been studying nutrition for a while in respect of my diabetes and metabolic disease and if you cook a more low carb meal that has been known to improve mental health/thought process. So if you cook nothing but meat and fish with no veg for 30 days, your health won't suffer for it and after 4 days my mental clarity was markedly improved.

That aside, to save your relationship I can see the only compromise would be to get an outbuilding built if necessary and cook in there, extreme but you gain a room in the house and if he don't go for that, it's time to reassess the relationship.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/05/2023 08:03

PollyPut · 12/05/2023 06:54

Whatever you do, do it slowly. I'd work on the basis that there are either emotional or physical triggers from the smells and minimise the smells/reactions as much as possible.

"Mince" was a dish in my grandparents generation. Some form of mince and onions. I had it once and it was horrible (to me). I wonder if he had to eat it as a child?

Don't cook with onions for now. It's not worth it. There is a reasonable chance your child might not like them anyway. Some people find them hard to digest. They can be added in later and really smell. You don't need them now.

Garlic - the garlic press really smells until it's been cleaned by hand and then hands smell - avoid it for now. I'd suggest frozen crushed garlic - you can get it in some supermarkets. Taj crushed garlic is cheap and good, and you can put it straught into the dish - although you might need to only use half a cube at a time if you don't want it strong.

Bolognese for example you can make with mince (choose the lowest fat content you can afford so 5% or 10%, not 20%). Fry the mince, and then add canned tomatoes (passata gives it a smooth texture which DC might prefer).

You can add frozen garlic for flavour directly to the pot, it shouldn't smell if you just put it in straight from the freezer instead of chop and crush it on the counter.

Grated carrots can be added - no smell. That's a simple start to a meal.

Portions can be frozen and then reheated in the microwave,

I did a stir fry dish recently and I don't think it smelled much, but then I didn't use much oil. Certainly the kitchen doesn't smell today. A trick is to pre-boil the chicken and then add it to the stir fry at the end. This means you are not frying the chicken for long - it tastes good and will minimise smells. Look up "velveting" chicken here - although if short for time I don't actual coat the chicken before I par-boil it. https://www.kikkoman.co.uk/inspiration/a-guide-to-the-velveting-technique/

Chinese dishes sometimes wilt vegetables in hot water before serving (e.g. pak choi). This is a no-fry veg dish you might not have considered. Also edamame/soya beans from freezer can just be soaked in hot water to warm up - no smell.

What is this nonsense? sounds like you have food issues yourself, dont use onions or garlic etc dont fry mince and boil the chicken? wtaf.

CabernetSauvignon · 12/05/2023 07:58

Try using the "I consider it a betrayal" line back to him. For instance, "I need proper nutrition, so does our son. Our son needs to grow up free of the effects of your phobia. I've spent 11 years pandering to you but you still refuse to get treatment to help yourself or to help us. I consider that a betrayal".

Efacsen · 12/05/2023 07:49

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/05/2023 07:38

Ive asked this numerous times and no one seems to want to answer. Why should op cook outdoors when she has a fully functioning kitchen in her home?

Totally agree!

Yet more accommodations on the OPs part whilst he continues to do nothing helpful

Plus how would all this outdoor cooking work in the middle of winter

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/05/2023 07:49

Simplestateside · 11/05/2023 22:17

Would it be worth cooking something very gentle smelling like an infused creme brulee and just very gradually building it up for there to gently expose him to more cooking smells. Might not work but worth a try?!

Op hasn't been able to cook for 11 years, yet you are advising her to make an infused creme brulee, this must be the most middle class mumsnet comment Ive ever read.

I cook daily and wouldnt have a clue how to make an 'infused creme brulee'.

Reminds me of Gooseberry Cinnamon Yoghurt 😂

Socksey · 12/05/2023 07:49

This is a long thread so not read all of it.... but
What about your mental health....??
Is it not affecting your physical and mental health to not eat properly and only eat a few things that cause minimal smell just for someone else being ott all the time?

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 12/05/2023 07:48

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/05/2023 07:38

Ive asked this numerous times and no one seems to want to answer. Why should op cook outdoors when she has a fully functioning kitchen in her home?

I’d like to know as well.

@Bambambino1 of course it’s been unappreciated. He just expects you to bend to his needs because that’s how important he is.

It wouldn’t take long to explain why daddy doesn’t live with you either.

”Why doesn’t daddy live with us mummy?”
”Daddy is mental darling”

Couldyounot · 12/05/2023 07:43

"Then I'll move out and you can explain to our son why his dad doesn't live here anymore"

"Why doesn't Daddy live here any more? Well, it's a long story, but the gist of it is that he is a stroppy overgrown toddler with weird hangups about smells, who considers me cooking lunch in my own kitchen to be a 'betrayal', and who is prepared to abandon us all rather than sort himself out."

WHAT a wanker. Sorry to hear this, OP

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/05/2023 07:38

Woopzies · 11/05/2023 19:51

Got a garden, OP? A couple I know had this problem - they built an extra kitchen in - what is essentially - a garden shed.

Ive asked this numerous times and no one seems to want to answer. Why should op cook outdoors when she has a fully functioning kitchen in her home?

MadeofElephantStone · 12/05/2023 07:33

He is disgraceful OP. Your poor child, having a father that would leave and blame you over bloody mince, like it's a totally justifiable reason. That and the other awful comments he has made about his child is appalling, he doesn't deserve to be a father.

dontlookgottalook · 12/05/2023 07:12

Newestname002 · 12/05/2023 03:34

@Bambambino1

It's extraordinary that you've been putting up with your husband's selfishness for so many years. Thank goodness you are, hopefully, coming to the end of your tolerance of someone who won't do anything to get help but preferred to impose his will instead.

"Then I'll move out and you can explain to our son why his dad doesn't live here anymore"

I hope he does move out - but wonder if he really will. I have to say, if he'd given me the above ultimatum my response would have been "OK".

Hold your nerve both for you and your son. 🌹

It really isn't that extraordinary. Coercive control often works like that. Restrictions to behaviours can come to seem normal.

AuntieJune · 12/05/2023 07:11

That's ludicrous. Has he ever tried anything at all to treat it?

It's kind of egotistical to think he has some unique and terrible problem beyond medical science. There are plenty of non-pharmaceutical approaches to this kind of aversion, I'm sure.

He expects you to sacrifice a huge part of life and he's not prepared to try anything at all?

LudicrouslyCapaciousBag · 12/05/2023 07:03

No, @PollyPut. I'm sure your post is meant kindly but it all comes back down to OP pandering to him and his appalling coercion.

OP has had more practical suggestions on this thread to address cooking smells than her DH has ever considered in eleven years together. In her position I would present him with a practical list to put in place as she will be cooking NORMALLY from now on:

  • a door on the kitchen (FFS)
  • a powerful extractor fan
  • splatter guards
  • air filters
  • cooks' candles

If he can't be arsed with any of that and he wants to leave over cooking mince, off he can fuck quite frankly.

MichelleScarn · 12/05/2023 06:56

Sorry @PollyPut completely disagree, , why should op pander to him doing all that given his behaviour towards her and their child?

PollyPut · 12/05/2023 06:54

Whatever you do, do it slowly. I'd work on the basis that there are either emotional or physical triggers from the smells and minimise the smells/reactions as much as possible.

"Mince" was a dish in my grandparents generation. Some form of mince and onions. I had it once and it was horrible (to me). I wonder if he had to eat it as a child?

Don't cook with onions for now. It's not worth it. There is a reasonable chance your child might not like them anyway. Some people find them hard to digest. They can be added in later and really smell. You don't need them now.

Garlic - the garlic press really smells until it's been cleaned by hand and then hands smell - avoid it for now. I'd suggest frozen crushed garlic - you can get it in some supermarkets. Taj crushed garlic is cheap and good, and you can put it straught into the dish - although you might need to only use half a cube at a time if you don't want it strong.

Bolognese for example you can make with mince (choose the lowest fat content you can afford so 5% or 10%, not 20%). Fry the mince, and then add canned tomatoes (passata gives it a smooth texture which DC might prefer).

You can add frozen garlic for flavour directly to the pot, it shouldn't smell if you just put it in straight from the freezer instead of chop and crush it on the counter.

Grated carrots can be added - no smell. That's a simple start to a meal.

Portions can be frozen and then reheated in the microwave,

I did a stir fry dish recently and I don't think it smelled much, but then I didn't use much oil. Certainly the kitchen doesn't smell today. A trick is to pre-boil the chicken and then add it to the stir fry at the end. This means you are not frying the chicken for long - it tastes good and will minimise smells. Look up "velveting" chicken here - although if short for time I don't actual coat the chicken before I par-boil it. https://www.kikkoman.co.uk/inspiration/a-guide-to-the-velveting-technique/

Chinese dishes sometimes wilt vegetables in hot water before serving (e.g. pak choi). This is a no-fry veg dish you might not have considered. Also edamame/soya beans from freezer can just be soaked in hot water to warm up - no smell.

A Guide to the Velveting Technique

Learn the secret of how the Chinese make their meat and seafood utterly tender and juicy

https://www.kikkoman.co.uk/inspiration/a-guide-to-the-velveting-technique

Beargrumps22 · 12/05/2023 06:49

this would be time for an ultimaton for me get help or get out. if you have/had kids you would need to cook for them and they make far worse smells!

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 12/05/2023 06:44

Sorry but you can't allow your son to be brought up in this. You have to cook and eat nutritional meals, as does your son.

The fact he said he wouldn't have had your son if it was his choice and then using that to control you for things you want to do is appalling. Coercive controlling behaviour.

He needs therapy. And if he won't seek help, he needs to leave.

I don't know how you've managed to live like this for so long!

Elfandwellbeing · 12/05/2023 06:38

I sympathize because i can and do have similar reactions to cooking smells in my home. However mine are triggers, the cooking smell triggers memories and it really is a physical response. I don’t insist no one cooks though. Good ventilation and it’s all ok.
He needs to get some support, his no cook zone is kinda controlling even if not intended to hurt you.

MichelleScarn · 12/05/2023 06:30

Well done for holding your ground @Bambambino1 this is the hard stage, he's going to keep pushing and guilt tripping to get you to reverse. Wouldn't be surprised if suddenly he'll become v v ill...

Muu · 12/05/2023 05:31

It is not a betrayal.

you have the right to cook in your own kitchen. Frying food is normal. Most of us do it several times a week and when our husbands get home, all they are interested in is eating the food.

there is definitely help out there for his problem.

threatening divorce, and talking about your son like that is manipulative.

you did nothing wrong.

Fraaahnces · 12/05/2023 05:03

“What’s that, dear? Daddy said that you smell during access visits? He is a very strange, strange man, isn’t he, Darling? You smell perfectly fine to me. Pass the garlic bread please, darling…”

Nanaof1 · 12/05/2023 04:51

BadNomad · 12/05/2023 01:49

"Then I'll move out and you can explain to our son why his dad doesn't live here anymore"

Um he thinks saying "Dad left because I cooked mince" will make you the bad guy? It will be him who needs to explain that logic to the kid.

Thank you! I am imagining all the conversations:

"I left because your mother FRIED something! I feel so betrayed!"
"Daddy left because he was afraid I would cook mince, or make lasagna. He needs a stink free-life and life isn't stink-free.""
"My Mom and Dad split up because Dad didn't want Mom to cook. We had BBQ last night and it was really good! Food tastes GOOD!"

Newestname002 · 12/05/2023 03:34

@Bambambino1

It's extraordinary that you've been putting up with your husband's selfishness for so many years. Thank goodness you are, hopefully, coming to the end of your tolerance of someone who won't do anything to get help but preferred to impose his will instead.

"Then I'll move out and you can explain to our son why his dad doesn't live here anymore"

I hope he does move out - but wonder if he really will. I have to say, if he'd given me the above ultimatum my response would have been "OK".

Hold your nerve both for you and your son. 🌹

aloris · 12/05/2023 02:48

"Then we'll buy different oven meals. But I don't want frying and I don't want anyone cooking mince in this house. I consider it a betrayal."

Notice how instead of him making any sort of reasoned argument, he says "I don't want" as if that ends the matter. His "I don't want" is sufficient argument for the decision to be made - there is no negotiating of his wants vs your wants, his want is the only factor that needs to be considered. Under this reasoning, he is the decider of what happens in the house and you have to ask his permission. He did not give you permission therefore it's a betrayal.

Cooking normal food that you like and that you choose is a normal thing that normal people do that is part of living a normal life. You're not raising pet spiders here. You are being prevented from doing a normal thing and told it is a betrayal if you do a normal thing in your own home. Your own eating is being controlled. This is not good.

givemecoffeenow · 12/05/2023 02:40

And to put this into some perspective for you. I suffered some long covid symptoms and was very sensitive to smells for about 2 years. In that time most food and even coffee smelled like a sewer to me, and during this time I just learned to deal with it. At no point did it even occur to me to restrict my partners diet or ban foods that he likes from the house.
Because I know that would be completely selfish and unreasonable. And by exposing myself to the smells and flavours that at the time were completely repulsive to me. I eventually got my sense of smell back to normal.

Please don’t justify his controlling ways. Even if there is an issue with sensitivity to smells he shouldn’t be treating you in this way. He should at least be willing to compromise. If he isn’t, that says a lot about his character.