Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that statistically it feels like good relationships are rare?

29 replies

ThatFraggle · 10/05/2023 15:15

Finding a good relationship seems statistically impossible.

  1. You want someone who you like as a person.
  1. And they like you back.
  1. And your values are compatible.
  1. And your religious and political views are compatible, or at least tolerable.
  1. They have the emotional maturity to navigate a relationship. AND
They have done work to resolve past traumas, family issues, past hurts, etc.
  1. They are financially solvent and can manage money in a healthy way.
  1. You find them physically attractive, and they find you the same.
  1. They are competent in cooking/cleaning and they carry their own weight when it comes to housework.

It seems like a needle on a haystack situation to find that, and that if relationships met those criteria then 90% of people would be single or in meaningless hook ups.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 10/05/2023 15:48

Well - I think that 3, 4 and 7 lead into 1 and 2. And 1/2/3/4/7 are all subjective so while there will only be a minority of people who fulfil those criteria specifically for you, the idea that most people can find compatible partners in this area should not be so far fetched.

I think 5 is fairly key in the relationship being healthy and is often overlooked.

6 and 8 are really just values - there will be people who don't particularly care about money/income, and/or are happy to eat ready meals/takeaways/do all the cooking/live in a less clean environment, so I think you should roll that into criteria 3: shared values.

Booklover40 · 10/05/2023 15:46

I would say dh ticks all the boxes except no8! But I’m a sahm mum and he works long hours so il let him off!

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 15:43

I'm afraid to say I think finding someone who will tick every one of those boxes is indeed rare. Which is why so many women compromise and increasingly many decide it's not really worth it. I can think of perhaps two out of all my friends where I think their spouse/LTP is a genuinely good, compatible match. Most of the rest are compromising in one are or another.

The thing I have come to terms with in life is that on the money front it's basically a lose lose for women. There are basically two types of men and neither is ideal. You either find someone who is solvent/earns more than you and they (whether explicitly or not) will consider themselves to be "in charge" of finances, financial and living decisions. This person is dynamic, ambitious and driven and often happy to more than pay his way but very unwilling to compromise his career in order to support yours and implicitly considers you as a support animal.

Or, you find someone who earns less than you and is happy to take more of a back seat and comfortable with you being the breadwinner and doing more domestic work as a quid pro quo. This person, though, consequently is much less driven and ambitious, happy go lucky and chilled about life in general (and at the extreme end) a cocklodger.

Every relationship I have ever had with a man has fallen into one of those two categories. I am in my 50s and have never found one who considers himself a genuine equal. I can't stand being ordered around and playing second fiddle so I've tended to opt for man B in this scenario and have found a fairly good compromise with my current partner but it can be a slippery slope to boredom, resentment and financial exploitation.

ThatFraggle · 10/05/2023 15:16

*in a haystack

OP posts: