Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to be violent and insulting to a woman who makes a mistake.

339 replies

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:26

A female calls a person 'lady' in error because she thought the person was female. The person identifies as non binary. The trans manager then verbally insults and finally physically assaults the woman and the man outside.

Is this really what we have come to. A simple word and the non binary is upset and so the trans person can kick a customer from the shop, purposefully insult and then assault.

So is misgendering (even by accident) so serious it merits verbal abuse and physical violence? I mean it isn't even obvious whether the person she called 'lady' behind the counter is non binary, looks female. The trans woman manager looks male and certainly acts it!

Why are so many trans women displaying what was formally seen as masculine traits (violence) now that they identify as female.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 16:17

momtoboys · 10/05/2023 16:02

I think that now we need to refer to everyone as they/they regardless of a preconceived notion of the person. Identifying someone incorrectly even accidently has seen major ramifications in the world and the workplace.

No thanks.

People need to take anger management classes if the word lady or similar is a big issue.

Alwaystheweather · 10/05/2023 16:17

Fladdermus · 10/05/2023 15:26

Man abuses woman and the conclusion of many on this thread is that she must have done/said something to provoke it. Because it's always the woman's fault isn't it.

Abso-fucking-lutely. This is basically the First Amendment in Gender Ideology land in particular.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 16:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It's what the article refers to. The manager is 'trans' doesn't say transitioning into woman or man. 'Starbucks trans manager'. There you go.

OP posts:
ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 16:16

The vast majority of trans and non binary people understand that misunderstandings will happen and usually all that's expected is an apology
Tough. They'd be waiting a long time for me to apologise for acknowledging biological reality.

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 16:16

momtoboys · 10/05/2023 16:02

I think that now we need to refer to everyone as they/they regardless of a preconceived notion of the person. Identifying someone incorrectly even accidently has seen major ramifications in the world and the workplace.

Sorry but I haven't signed up to this ruining of English. I am not calling everyone "they" just because a few people want to play at womanface.

funinthesun19 · 10/05/2023 16:15

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:24

That's my point. I wasn't defending the trans woman and her assault on a woman at all. I was making the point that how would anyone know what to use if not obvious or a label stating please call me 'them/they'.

Oh I know I having a moan with you 😄

Noicant · 10/05/2023 16:12

I really hate that clapping in peoples face shit, it’s so childish and irritating. Non binary is basically bullshit, your internal feelings don’t prevent you as being identified as male or female by people interacting with you, how the fuck is anyone supposed to look at you and intuit what you identify as.

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 16:12

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:43

I think a calm but firm: "Would you please leave, Madam?" covers it.

Do you really think that a coffee shop should refuse to serve a customer for correctly sexing a member of staff?

That's getting dangerously close to compelling speech.

It's pretty Orwellian stuff.

I think her shouting at the staff and later yelling she thinks they're disgusting is the reason why she'd be asked to leave.

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 16:12

If someone was trying to record me out of context without my consent likely to put on social media with their own spin I 100% would be angry and want them to stop recording. I also think it's impossible to know the context from a 50 second video.
Luckily no-one needs your consent.

The vast majority of trans and non binary people understand that misunderstandings will happen and usually all that's expected is an apology and correct gendering going forwards. Its highly unlikely that's what happened here.
So you are able to determine what did and didn't happen from a 50 second out of context video.......?

Shelefttheweb · 10/05/2023 16:11

And the fact that they're now in Tenerife getting over their trauma...!! 🙄

You think people can only complain of assault if they end up in hospital? Going on a prepared holiday somewhere away from the place where they were assaulted and where they can relax seems a good way to get over trauma to me.

Alwaystheweather · 10/05/2023 16:09

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:45

Just because she's a customer does not give her the right to shout at the staff and be rude which is what she was doing. I thought the manager was quite restrained to begin with, if a customer acted that way towards me I'd want them removed as well. She was well out of order to begin with

Watch the video again. She is raising her voice to defend herself as he is hurling insults at her (transphobic! ). But apparently in your world, insulting people by calling them names is ‘ quite calm really’ so I guess that explains your strange interpretation of what is happening here.

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 16:09

SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 15:49

Using the word lady isn’t causing a problem

The problem was his aggressive reaction

Probably not.

But whatever happened it is a manager's job to deal with incidents in a reasonable manner and definitely not get bad publicity for their company in a national newspaper over two days.

That's why this manager is looking for a new job.

It would be different if Starbucks said they were backing their manager when we could all see how badly they failed Manager 101.

But they are not. I think that is a good decision and I agree it should be highlighted just in case any managers, for Starbucks or other companies, were under the impression that this was a good look.

GailBlancheViola · 10/05/2023 16:09

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 16:04

The linked article as well as the OP both referred to the manager as a trans woman. If that is incorrect then I apologise.

Who are you apologising to?

You are, however, showing up this nonsense for exactly the nonsense it is.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 10/05/2023 16:07

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 15:56

I’m aware of who was being physically violent and clearly in my post I’ve said it was the manager. You’re deliberately misinterpreting what I’ve written because you take issue with me using her correct pronouns. It’s pretty obvious who I was referring to in my post, no need to be obtuse.

I also clearly said in my post that her physical violence is inexcusable. So I really don’t know what point you’re trying to make here.

Correctly identifying a person’s sex is not being obtuse, using misleading pronouns to confuse people so they’re not sure who the bloody hell you’re on about is.
The manager is a man and the customer is a woman. The manager can believe whatever nonsense he likes about himself, but he has no right to inflict that on anybody else, and nobody else has any obligation to pander to it. HTH

Naunet · 10/05/2023 16:06

PollyPeptide · 10/05/2023 16:03

I think the employee was totally out of line, clearly shouldn't have laid their hands on anyone and should have refunded their money. Apparently they've either quit or lost their job over this and the police are investigating.

But this couple are pretty annoying in what they're now saying too. I support the woman defending herself and wanting her money back. But for her to say that she was in fear of her life is ridiculous. If she was, she would have just left. And the fact that they're now in Tenerife getting over their trauma...!! 🙄 It's so hard to have sympathy for anyone when they say such over the top things.

To be fair though it sounds like it escalated beyond the video if the CCTV showed him breaking the glass door as he threw her out.

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 16:04

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:58

You are misgendering.

The manager identifies as they/ them.

Why on earth do you assume that he is a woman?

The linked article as well as the OP both referred to the manager as a trans woman. If that is incorrect then I apologise.

Alwaystheweather · 10/05/2023 16:03

RoseRobot · 10/05/2023 14:44

@Ilovetea42 - then you watched a different video from the rest of us. The trans manager was looming over her using classic mysogynistic male pattern aggression - using physical presence to try and dominate and intimidate a woman, clapping in her face. If some huge man's hands came at my face I'd think I was about to be slapped - that was the clear intention. He called her Karen - an intentional insult. She didn't intend to insult anyone. She was a customer. My guess is that if a man a foot taller than the trans manager, built like a brick shithouse had called the non-binary person 'lady' trans bully have done no more than raise an eyebrow. he clearly got a huge kick out of threatening the woman and I think the onlooker was absolutely right to film the evidence of this unwarranted aggression from a man to a woman.

Absolutely this!

ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 16:03

It is the manager's job to deal with incidents and to protect his or her staff and sometimes the best way to do that is calmly to ask the customer to leave and probably give them a refund to smooth the process.
Usually, yes.
In this case the manager caused the "incident".

PollyPeptide · 10/05/2023 16:03

I think the employee was totally out of line, clearly shouldn't have laid their hands on anyone and should have refunded their money. Apparently they've either quit or lost their job over this and the police are investigating.

But this couple are pretty annoying in what they're now saying too. I support the woman defending herself and wanting her money back. But for her to say that she was in fear of her life is ridiculous. If she was, she would have just left. And the fact that they're now in Tenerife getting over their trauma...!! 🙄 It's so hard to have sympathy for anyone when they say such over the top things.

momtoboys · 10/05/2023 16:02

senua · 10/05/2023 14:39

I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team.
You missed sexism out of your list. You list gender but not sex.Hmm
How do we know that somebody is a 'they'?

I think that now we need to refer to everyone as they/they regardless of a preconceived notion of the person. Identifying someone incorrectly even accidently has seen major ramifications in the world and the workplace.

willWillSmithsmith · 10/05/2023 16:01

When is the world going to understand that gender is not a thing! It’s like the whole world being legally obliged to tip toe around someone because they feel down or grumpy or irritated. That’s all gender is just another feeling - of no more genuine importance than feeling grumpy! The world has gone mad but I do think more people are pushing back and not feeling like they have to accept this gender shite. Also who cares if you’re called a transphobe, it’s being used like some kind of weapon. Ignore it, it’s just a stupid meaningless word used to intimidate.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 16:01

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 15:58

@lifeturnsonadime None of us saw the original encounter. I am prepared to believe the customer did not deliberately insult the non-binary server by calling her "that lady" but something else may have happened.

It is the manager's job to deal with incidents and to protect his or her staff and sometimes the best way to do that is calmly to ask the customer to leave and probably give them a refund to smooth the process.

There's no need for any judgement or calling someone transphobic or a Karen or clapping in their face or snatching phones.

It's not Orwellian it's called doing your job. The manager didn't did it well which is presumably why they are now looking for another.

So you think it is ok to refuse to serve a person coffee if they correctly sex another human?

What you are saying is that we have to lie about what we see with our eyes.

I find that Orwellian.

I don't agree with having my speech compelled.

Any organisation that would throw me out for saying what I see will not get my custom.

If a human being needs me to lie about what I see to bolster their identity then they are the one with the problem not me.

I have had enough of this. It is not progressive it's authoritarian bullshit.

N0tANOoDl3He4D · 10/05/2023 16:00

Customer gets uppity about no cash payments, snipes about it to barista, manager interjects because of customers tone & will be required to back up company policies, customer snaps at manager and misgenders barista in process, manager points out barista doesn't identify as female, both customer and manager continue to jointly escalate situation with shouting and gesticulating and rudeness ending in second customer videoing and manager taking things too far because they're all worked up.

It doesn't look good for either side. This is what I took from reading through the whole article three times, carefully, as well as watching the video.

Shelefttheweb · 10/05/2023 15:59

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 15:56

I’m aware of who was being physically violent and clearly in my post I’ve said it was the manager. You’re deliberately misinterpreting what I’ve written because you take issue with me using her correct pronouns. It’s pretty obvious who I was referring to in my post, no need to be obtuse.

I also clearly said in my post that her physical violence is inexcusable. So I really don’t know what point you’re trying to make here.

Difficult understanding who you are referring to. Are you misgendering the aggressive male who goes by ‘they/them’?

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 15:58

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:43

I think a calm but firm: "Would you please leave, Madam?" covers it.

Do you really think that a coffee shop should refuse to serve a customer for correctly sexing a member of staff?

That's getting dangerously close to compelling speech.

It's pretty Orwellian stuff.

@lifeturnsonadime None of us saw the original encounter. I am prepared to believe the customer did not deliberately insult the non-binary server by calling her "that lady" but something else may have happened.

It is the manager's job to deal with incidents and to protect his or her staff and sometimes the best way to do that is calmly to ask the customer to leave and probably give them a refund to smooth the process.

There's no need for any judgement or calling someone transphobic or a Karen or clapping in their face or snatching phones.

It's not Orwellian it's called doing your job. The manager didn't did it well which is presumably why they are now looking for another.

Swipe left for the next trending thread