Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to be violent and insulting to a woman who makes a mistake.

339 replies

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:26

A female calls a person 'lady' in error because she thought the person was female. The person identifies as non binary. The trans manager then verbally insults and finally physically assaults the woman and the man outside.

Is this really what we have come to. A simple word and the non binary is upset and so the trans person can kick a customer from the shop, purposefully insult and then assault.

So is misgendering (even by accident) so serious it merits verbal abuse and physical violence? I mean it isn't even obvious whether the person she called 'lady' behind the counter is non binary, looks female. The trans woman manager looks male and certainly acts it!

Why are so many trans women displaying what was formally seen as masculine traits (violence) now that they identify as female.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Badgeringabout · 10/05/2023 17:39

But saying theyre inTenerife to get over the trauma just undermines their credibility

Credibility? Did you watch the video or not? What she said happened, happened. There is no question over her 'credibility' - it's captured on film.

He was aggressive and intimidating and I would have been very scared in that situation as I am a small woman and he is massive, angry man. She did bloody well to hold it together.

BeginningToLookALotLike · 10/05/2023 17:38

So many posters here are trying to prove that the woman bears some responsibility for her being physically handled, intimidated, and then traumatised by such a horrible experience.

Sadly, this is nothing new.

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 17:35

PollyPeptide · 10/05/2023 16:33

She wasn't in fear of her life and they weren't traumatised. It's just ridiculous hyperbole.
She was quite right to stand up for herself and demand her money back. The employee behaved disgracefully and deserves to lose their job and whatever else that happens to them. But saying theyre inTenerife to get over the trauma just undermines their credibility.

@PollyPeptide that sounds like Piers Morgan saying on national television that Meghan Markle wasn't suicidal. He agreed to leave that role, didn't he?

How could Morgan know what was going on in Markle's head? I didn't, so he had no right to announce that definitively. But that is what some men do about women they don't agree with and some women back them up if it suits them.

So do you know what was going on in this woman's head in that branch of Starbucks when the male born but trans identifying person confronted her?

If someone younger, taller and more physically robust than me was shouting in my face I would definitely feel intimidated even it was a woman. But this was a male-born person, wasn't it?

I agree the woman should get her money back and the manager should seek other employment in a role that does not require contact with living beings.

Where she chooses to go on holiday is neither here nor there, is it?

Badgeringabout · 10/05/2023 17:34

CinnamonJellyBeans · 10/05/2023 16:40

A lack of control on both sides.

I feel the customer is not entirely blameless. She's yelling like a fishwife and pointing in the manager's face. I also notice that as the manager walks away towards the door, she's still yelling, calling the manager "disgusting". Nice.

I also wonder how the biscuits got on the floor...

A fishwife? A fucking fishwife? And the manager WAS disgusting! A disgusting example of unfettered male aggression and I think that he was very close to hitting her.

FuckNuggets · 10/05/2023 17:31

Shoxfordian · 10/05/2023 14:43

It sounds like the customer was already being difficult - was probably just the last straw

I'd hate to buy something in a shop you worked in.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 10/05/2023 17:26

"The linked article as well as the OP both referred to the manager as a trans woman. If that is incorrect then I apologise."

actually the linked article says "trans manager" and the OP says identified as non binary. I only mention to demonstrate just how ridiculously easy it is to make a mistake and how unreasonable the expectations that we will be able to know and use someone else's GI even when there are clues/ hints we could have picked up on.

FuckNuggets · 10/05/2023 17:25

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:35

I mean I've watched the video - the manager was not violent towards the woman and they attempted to remove the phone from the other customer who was recording them. If someone was trying to record me out of context without my consent likely to put on social media with their own spin I 100% would be angry and want them to stop recording. I also think it's impossible to know the context from a 50 second video. I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team. We have only one side of the story here which is the person who was being asked to leave and their husband who was filming so it's hardly an impartial article is it? We've no way to know if they repeatedly do this, if they did it on purpose, if they come in regularly and are difficult towards staff etc.

The vast majority of trans and non binary people understand that misunderstandings will happen and usually all that's expected is an apology and correct gendering going forwards. Its highly unlikely that's what happened here.

She didn't abuse the staff. She referred to the woman behind the counter as "lady". How on earth was she supposed to know this woman who looks like a woman identifies as non-binary? She wasn't abusive in the slightest. The trans-identified man on the other hand was terribly abusive and violent.

Climbles · 10/05/2023 17:23

The manager was being violent and aggressive and I’m glad they were sacked. I really hate the term ‘Karen’ it’s sexist and ageist. The customer needs to be refunded and given an apology. However, I’m interested in what happens between the accidental miss-gendering and when the camera came out. Why did the manager say ‘you’re calling me a man’ if it was the other member of staff the customer miss-gendered? I think there might be slightly more to this story.

Xenia · 10/05/2023 17:22

Same here - you say lady rather than woman as lady is the politer phrase. if the serving person is a man who thinks he is a woman I am not going to be stopping calling him lady

mydoghasanattitude · 10/05/2023 17:21

I'd have sympathy for someone being filmed in a public place if they were only minding their own business and not being a jerk. Getting filmed in a public places because you're acting like an aggressive prick? It goes viral and you lose your job (in a public-facing role) due to your inability to behave like a mature adult? Good! He's acting in an unstable, threatening way, and he shouldn't be dealing with unsuspecting customers with such a thin skin and hot temper. Maybe he'll try to control himself, next time.

JaneorEleven · 10/05/2023 17:16

I’m a similar age to the woman on the receiving end of the diatribe. I was brought up to call other women “lady” as a sign of respect, and not use they or she (she is a cats mother).

How this situation got so badly out of hand is horrifying. I thought the woman stood up for herself and handled things as well as she could, under the circumstances.

AlisonDonut · 10/05/2023 17:15

izimbra · 10/05/2023 16:48

This whole thread, the article and the strawman arguments - just the biggest pile of bs.

So sick of f*ckwits grinding their axes about trans people.

Just bloody nonsense. Get another hobby.

This is about male violence.

SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 17:15

izimbra · 10/05/2023 17:09

It's the Daily Mail - well known for being a pile of trash and fanning the flames of the culture wars around gender identity issues

"Perhaps they could just get on with living their lives without all the performative drama, threats, violence and abuse because other people don't agree with compelled speech or belief."

I'm 57. How could I have lived this long and never been subject to oppression and abuse by trans people?

Might it be because trans women make up just 0.2% of the population?

Maybe you should be asking yourself why the Daily Mail and mumsnet are so obsessed with trans issues, and feel so victimised by them, given that in material terms the existence of trans women makes bugger all difference to the rest of us.

Because we’re discussing women’s rights and male aggression

As much as some of the media keeps calling it ‘culture wars’ and ‘trans issues’ and hoping women will stop talking about it, it’s unlikely because of the above. Women are often at the end of male aggression and it’s not trans issue it’s women’s rights

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 17:12

izimbra · 10/05/2023 17:09

It's the Daily Mail - well known for being a pile of trash and fanning the flames of the culture wars around gender identity issues

"Perhaps they could just get on with living their lives without all the performative drama, threats, violence and abuse because other people don't agree with compelled speech or belief."

I'm 57. How could I have lived this long and never been subject to oppression and abuse by trans people?

Might it be because trans women make up just 0.2% of the population?

Maybe you should be asking yourself why the Daily Mail and mumsnet are so obsessed with trans issues, and feel so victimised by them, given that in material terms the existence of trans women makes bugger all difference to the rest of us.

@izimbra undoubtedly true. But do you think the manager handled this specific situation well or poorly?

Clarice99 · 10/05/2023 17:11

I think a calm but firm: "Would you please leave, Madam?" covers it.

How can anyone ask a customer to leave the premises for telling the truth?

The female customer said what she saw, calling the biological female 'lady'. The biological female member of staff needs to get over herself. Non-binary is just 'made up' nonsense that is meaningless to sane most people. How on earth are customers supposed to know what a female member of staff 'identifies as' or what anybody 'identifies as' for that matter?

As for the male manager, he displayed disgraceful behaviour and should be held accountable for that. I hope that he's charged with assault.

We say what we see. We see a male, we use the term man. We see a female, we use the term woman. Buying into gender identity means we have to lie to appease others. I refuse to do this as it's fake, a lie and I will not pander to lies.

ArabeIIaScott · 10/05/2023 17:11

izimbra · 10/05/2023 16:48

This whole thread, the article and the strawman arguments - just the biggest pile of bs.

So sick of f*ckwits grinding their axes about trans people.

Just bloody nonsense. Get another hobby.

Well, you've answered the OP's question so eloquently and politely, I'm convinced.

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 17:09

Karen, Uppity - insults which are used against women with a racial tinge and usually, but not exclusively, by men.

I was called a Karen for politely advising a young man that it wasn't a good idea to leave his beautiful ruby cocker spaniel pup tied to the hitching post outside the supermarket even though it was Waitrose.

I didn't really give much of a fuck. It wouldn't be me who'd have to explain to my wife and kids that some bastard had stolen our dog because I was a fuckwit who couldn't take gentle guidance from a woman.

izimbra · 10/05/2023 17:09

It's the Daily Mail - well known for being a pile of trash and fanning the flames of the culture wars around gender identity issues

"Perhaps they could just get on with living their lives without all the performative drama, threats, violence and abuse because other people don't agree with compelled speech or belief."

I'm 57. How could I have lived this long and never been subject to oppression and abuse by trans people?

Might it be because trans women make up just 0.2% of the population?

Maybe you should be asking yourself why the Daily Mail and mumsnet are so obsessed with trans issues, and feel so victimised by them, given that in material terms the existence of trans women makes bugger all difference to the rest of us.

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 10/05/2023 17:06

Redebs · 10/05/2023 15:32

Totally correct summary of the individuals involved

on the evidence I've seen I believe the manager also identifies as non binary i.e. does not consider themselves to be a man or a woman (this could easily be out of date though)

I would only say this is what narcissistic rage looks like so if the manager is not a narcissist they're pretending so well I can't tell the difference https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-narcissistic-rage-5183744

What Is Narcissistic Rage?

Narcissistic rage is a behavior sometimes exhibited by people with narcissistic personality disorder. Learn the signs and what to do if you experience this behavior.

https://www.verywellmind.com/what-is-narcissistic-rage-5183744

Helleofabore · 10/05/2023 17:05

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 14:49

No, there’s never any misgendering on mumsnet is there (?)

If there is, report it.

StarbucksKaren · 10/05/2023 17:03

ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 15:52

The filming wasn't out of any context, give over 🙄

I agree. Also many many women have been filmed completely out of context to create many of the viral ‘Karen’ videos over these last few years, causing huge distress, loss of privacy, reputation, online and irl reprisals etc.

This situation has witnesses and full cctv coverage. The manager here is in no way a victim of the footage. And Vanessa, the customer he called Karen - who didn’t set out to ‘talk to the manager’ btw, has received public support from far and wide.

Boudicasbeard · 10/05/2023 17:00

The logic here is weird:

accidental misgendering= traumatising, worth shouting at someone.

Being shouted at and physically manhandled and insulted= get over it snowflake.

It’s almost as if their is a cognitive bias at play.

SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 16:55

thedancingbear · 10/05/2023 16:53

Quite. The thread title asks 'if it's OK': it's not. They've been sacked, and I gather the police are investigating.

Stop stirring up hatred, OP. This one dickhead is not representative of trans people as a whole, however much some people on this site would love you to believe. And yes, I'm sure other trans people have misbehaved, as have some straight people, some white people, some Asian people etc. Shitstirring off the back of this single ugly but minor incident is repellent.

Women often come across male aggression, it’s not unusual

Many don’t want to excuse it or ignore it, some do but not all

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 16:55

izimbra · 10/05/2023 16:48

This whole thread, the article and the strawman arguments - just the biggest pile of bs.

So sick of f*ckwits grinding their axes about trans people.

Just bloody nonsense. Get another hobby.

@izimbra then regard it in the prism of what we can see. Do you think the Starbucks manager behaved appropriately?

Beowulfa · 10/05/2023 16:55

GailBlancheViola · 10/05/2023 16:52

And I'm sick of trans people grinding their axes and expecting everyone to adhere to their ideology.

Perhaps they could just get on with living their lives without all the performative drama, threats, violence and abuse because other people don't agree with compelled speech or belief.

Yes, we should all be able to go into a cafe and order overpriced coffee without having to join in someone else's fantasy drama.

I wonder if the reaction would have been the same if the customer had called a staffmember a cunt (rude word)? rather than lady (not a rude word)?