Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to be violent and insulting to a woman who makes a mistake.

339 replies

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:26

A female calls a person 'lady' in error because she thought the person was female. The person identifies as non binary. The trans manager then verbally insults and finally physically assaults the woman and the man outside.

Is this really what we have come to. A simple word and the non binary is upset and so the trans person can kick a customer from the shop, purposefully insult and then assault.

So is misgendering (even by accident) so serious it merits verbal abuse and physical violence? I mean it isn't even obvious whether the person she called 'lady' behind the counter is non binary, looks female. The trans woman manager looks male and certainly acts it!

Why are so many trans women displaying what was formally seen as masculine traits (violence) now that they identify as female.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 14:50

Swrigh1234 · 10/05/2023 14:49

Oh here we go, right on cue. The first misogynist makes an appearance.

Yep to this.

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 14:49

I can see what the story suggests. I’m saying we haven’t been eyewitness to the full interaction. I highly doubt it went from one innocent mistake to the manager immediately screaming and throwing the customer out. More likely the customer was also being argumentative or reacted badly
to being corrected. I have never seen someone react this badly to someone being misgendered unintentionally without any other aggravating factors.

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 14:49

No, there’s never any misgendering on mumsnet is there (?)

Swrigh1234 · 10/05/2023 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh here we go, right on cue. The first misogynist makes an appearance.

Lockheart · 10/05/2023 14:47

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 10/05/2023 14:43

Typical male behaviour from a man, yet somehow, (mainly) women are called names and silenced for daring to speak up.
Well I won't stop speaking up.
Transwomen are men.

"Being silenced"? This story has been all over the news and social media this week and the commentary is almost universally negative about this person's actions.

OneTC · 10/05/2023 14:47

As with every one of these videos I'd love to see the lead up.

When the video starts there's one person being aggy

13Bastards · 10/05/2023 14:47

Hmmm, I'm of the mind that there was more to this than a short video. The customer is asking for a refund, I assume the person behind the till made an error, spoke to the manager and Mis gendered and it's escalated from there. Pure speculation on my part of course but I don't think this customer simply referred the person behind till a lady once by accident and it led to this reaction by the manager.

Either way, however the manager identifies. They clearly aren't cut out for retail if that's how the react to someone. Get a thicker skin

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:46

RoseRobot · 10/05/2023 14:44

@Ilovetea42 - then you watched a different video from the rest of us. The trans manager was looming over her using classic mysogynistic male pattern aggression - using physical presence to try and dominate and intimidate a woman, clapping in her face. If some huge man's hands came at my face I'd think I was about to be slapped - that was the clear intention. He called her Karen - an intentional insult. She didn't intend to insult anyone. She was a customer. My guess is that if a man a foot taller than the trans manager, built like a brick shithouse had called the non-binary person 'lady' trans bully have done no more than raise an eyebrow. he clearly got a huge kick out of threatening the woman and I think the onlooker was absolutely right to film the evidence of this unwarranted aggression from a man to a woman.

That was my 'take' too. The classic misogynistic male pattern but in a persons who identifies as a trans woman. But 'nothing to see here' is the response of many.

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 10/05/2023 14:46

Shoxfordian · 10/05/2023 14:43

It sounds like the customer was already being difficult - was probably just the last straw

I doubt she was being difficult

He was just an aggressive male on edge. Whatever is worn can’t hide that.

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:45

RoseRobot · 10/05/2023 14:44

@Ilovetea42 - then you watched a different video from the rest of us. The trans manager was looming over her using classic mysogynistic male pattern aggression - using physical presence to try and dominate and intimidate a woman, clapping in her face. If some huge man's hands came at my face I'd think I was about to be slapped - that was the clear intention. He called her Karen - an intentional insult. She didn't intend to insult anyone. She was a customer. My guess is that if a man a foot taller than the trans manager, built like a brick shithouse had called the non-binary person 'lady' trans bully have done no more than raise an eyebrow. he clearly got a huge kick out of threatening the woman and I think the onlooker was absolutely right to film the evidence of this unwarranted aggression from a man to a woman.

Just because she's a customer does not give her the right to shout at the staff and be rude which is what she was doing. I thought the manager was quite restrained to begin with, if a customer acted that way towards me I'd want them removed as well. She was well out of order to begin with

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:45

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 14:42

Obviously violence isn’t okay and I’m not sure where it’s been implied that it is?

Without seeing the start of the interaction it’s difficult to understand why the situation escalated so much. This is definitely not a typical reaction to innocent misgendering, so either there is more context that we have missed to explain why the manager was so riled up (not that that excuses her becoming physically violent) or just a case of the manager being aggressive. Her being trans is largely irrelevant, just as with any other demographic there are good and bad people. One aggressive trans person isn’t a reflection on trans people as a whole and most would not act this way over one mistake.

The story suggests that the female used the word 'lady' with regard to the person behind the counter. The person behind the counter identifies as 'non binary' so the trans woman then took that as an insult and so called the biological woman a 'Karen' and insisted she leave, she called her a transphobe' to which the biological woman says she isn't. The trans woman refused to give the biological woman a refund and made her leave, grabbing a camera and shoving the biological woman out through the door. Then broke the door.

OP posts:
RoseRobot · 10/05/2023 14:44

@Ilovetea42 - then you watched a different video from the rest of us. The trans manager was looming over her using classic mysogynistic male pattern aggression - using physical presence to try and dominate and intimidate a woman, clapping in her face. If some huge man's hands came at my face I'd think I was about to be slapped - that was the clear intention. He called her Karen - an intentional insult. She didn't intend to insult anyone. She was a customer. My guess is that if a man a foot taller than the trans manager, built like a brick shithouse had called the non-binary person 'lady' trans bully have done no more than raise an eyebrow. he clearly got a huge kick out of threatening the woman and I think the onlooker was absolutely right to film the evidence of this unwarranted aggression from a man to a woman.

Shoxfordian · 10/05/2023 14:43

It sounds like the customer was already being difficult - was probably just the last straw

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 10/05/2023 14:43

Typical male behaviour from a man, yet somehow, (mainly) women are called names and silenced for daring to speak up.
Well I won't stop speaking up.
Transwomen are men.

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 14:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:43

senua · 10/05/2023 14:39

I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team.
You missed sexism out of your list. You list gender but not sex.Hmm
How do we know that somebody is a 'they'?

Yes I also left off religion and other isms which I felt were covered by the etc... signifying there are plenty more...

You don't. But like I said most trans and non binary people understand this will happen at times but the reaction they get to someone being corrected is what matters. I mean for a start the manager doesn't even raise their voice initially I'd say they're quite calm while the woman in the video is shouting. You can also hear her yelling that she thinks they're "disgusting " as the manager walks towards the door. In this instance I think the customers haven't given the full story and its being used to inflame tensions that already exist.

TheFluffiestHobo · 10/05/2023 14:42

If you require a special pronoun then you need to get a badge to inform people of it.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:42

It's very easy to make a mistake of someone's assumed 'gender'. People have evolved over hundreds of thousands of years and go by the look and feel for sex. Guessing a gender or guessing non binary is much more difficult to do.

OP posts:
fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 14:42

Obviously violence isn’t okay and I’m not sure where it’s been implied that it is?

Without seeing the start of the interaction it’s difficult to understand why the situation escalated so much. This is definitely not a typical reaction to innocent misgendering, so either there is more context that we have missed to explain why the manager was so riled up (not that that excuses her becoming physically violent) or just a case of the manager being aggressive. Her being trans is largely irrelevant, just as with any other demographic there are good and bad people. One aggressive trans person isn’t a reflection on trans people as a whole and most would not act this way over one mistake.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:41

senua · 10/05/2023 14:39

I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team.
You missed sexism out of your list. You list gender but not sex.Hmm
How do we know that somebody is a 'they'?

Many don't think of sex based abuse important. Strange how the creep of the word gender to try to eliminate biological sex. Sex based protections are really important.

OP posts:
Watchkeys · 10/05/2023 14:40

I don't think this is what we're coming to. I think it's what those individuals chose to do at that moment. There have always been angry incidents, for all sorts of reasons. They're not statements on society, they're just a few pissed off people losing their shit. There will have been a million kind, decent interactions going on all over the world at the same moment.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:39

FisherthemsFriend · 10/05/2023 14:37

According to the Mail she hasn’t received a refund.

So no refund.

If they fired the trans manager then one would assume that they have seen the store recording and spoken to the non binary staff member called 'lady' in error to clarify what happened.

OP posts:
senua · 10/05/2023 14:39

I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team.
You missed sexism out of your list. You list gender but not sex.Hmm
How do we know that somebody is a 'they'?

thedogisstaring · 10/05/2023 14:38

Lockheart · 10/05/2023 14:32

Well it's not "ok" is it because the person was fired and the police are looking into it.

I have no idea why you have the impression that this is "ok".

Exactly this. I don't think anyone has said it's ok?

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:38

CountryStore · 10/05/2023 14:35

The woman in the video is brave to stand up for herself though. I would've been terrified to be confronted in such an angry aggressive way by anyone, man or woman. Way out of control.

Indeed. The manager is talk and young and very aggressive. Grabbing a phone and pushing not only the man filming but the woman too and apparently slammed the door so hard it smashed. Some strength and anger there.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread