Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it ok to be violent and insulting to a woman who makes a mistake.

339 replies

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 14:26

A female calls a person 'lady' in error because she thought the person was female. The person identifies as non binary. The trans manager then verbally insults and finally physically assaults the woman and the man outside.

Is this really what we have come to. A simple word and the non binary is upset and so the trans person can kick a customer from the shop, purposefully insult and then assault.

So is misgendering (even by accident) so serious it merits verbal abuse and physical violence? I mean it isn't even obvious whether the person she called 'lady' behind the counter is non binary, looks female. The trans woman manager looks male and certainly acts it!

Why are so many trans women displaying what was formally seen as masculine traits (violence) now that they identify as female.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Redebs · 10/05/2023 15:32

RunningRunningRunningRunningRunning · 10/05/2023 15:31

I find it impossible to follow these threads, am I the only one who reads these threads and in my head goes "right so a man, pretending to be a woman" "an actual woman pretending she isn't either" and "a woman who is really a woman and not pretending to be anything else". So confusing.

Totally correct summary of the individuals involved

RunningRunningRunningRunningRunning · 10/05/2023 15:31

I find it impossible to follow these threads, am I the only one who reads these threads and in my head goes "right so a man, pretending to be a woman" "an actual woman pretending she isn't either" and "a woman who is really a woman and not pretending to be anything else". So confusing.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/05/2023 15:30

And no one needs permission to film anyone anywhere. It’s totally legal. Except within the precincts of a court.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:30

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:24

So let's get this straight, male member of staff is verbally abusive to a middle aged woman uses a misogynistic term towards her and is violent to her partner because she correctly sexed someone and it's the woman's fault for asking for it?

Rule of Misogyny Number 1.

Women are responsible for what men do.

I bet that young man wouldn't have been so rude and aggressive to a male customer who had made the same 'mistake'.

I'm glad Starbucks have sacked him. If I go out for a coffee I don't expect to have to go along with another persons gender delusions or else suffer abuse.

This is my point.

But since it's directed towards a woman, many women come to the defence of the manager who is describe as trans but might be a man/woman/them or identifying as opposite to what they appear to others.

OP posts:
Redebs · 10/05/2023 15:29

Fladdermus · 10/05/2023 15:26

Man abuses woman and the conclusion of many on this thread is that she must have done/said something to provoke it. Because it's always the woman's fault isn't it.

Exactly.

Even when it is agreed by all concerned that all she did was call a woman, 'a lady'

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/05/2023 15:29

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:45

Just because she's a customer does not give her the right to shout at the staff and be rude which is what she was doing. I thought the manager was quite restrained to begin with, if a customer acted that way towards me I'd want them removed as well. She was well out of order to begin with

Were you there, then? Because the video didn’t show the beginning of the incident. It showed the manager looming over the customer, using misogynistic slurs, using typical aggressive tactics and shouting at her, for referring to a person who says they identify as non-binary as a lady, something she couldn’t possibly know.

She was defending herself saying she was not transphobic. And I don’t believe she is. The ‘manager’ saw an opportunity to bully and make a scene and by fuck did they take it. And I’m really, really pleased they’ve been sacked.

This sort of behaviour from them does nothing but create tension and sets everyone back.

SweetiePi3 · 10/05/2023 15:28

Ilovetea42 · 10/05/2023 14:35

I mean I've watched the video - the manager was not violent towards the woman and they attempted to remove the phone from the other customer who was recording them. If someone was trying to record me out of context without my consent likely to put on social media with their own spin I 100% would be angry and want them to stop recording. I also think it's impossible to know the context from a 50 second video. I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability etc and I think it's fair for a manager to defend their staff team. We have only one side of the story here which is the person who was being asked to leave and their husband who was filming so it's hardly an impartial article is it? We've no way to know if they repeatedly do this, if they did it on purpose, if they come in regularly and are difficult towards staff etc.

The vast majority of trans and non binary people understand that misunderstandings will happen and usually all that's expected is an apology and correct gendering going forwards. Its highly unlikely that's what happened here.

It's perfectly legal to record or photo anyone in public. Most of us are filmed everywhere we go everyday.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:27

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 15:20

So what biological sex was the person called Lady out of interest? Because I’m not clicking on the clip but assume the people in it are customer left and manager right.

I have almost always called everyone mate, unsure why just always have for decades, it’s pretty handy these days.

Plus can someone clarify non binary to me as a term, does it mean a person identifies as neither gender but can be either bio sex but gives no indication of sexuality or asexuality. Could be straight, gay, bi or asexual?

Gender of them/they non binary but in appearance look biologically female and so the customer make a mistake. The mistake wasn't directed to the tall and intimidating manager though (not sure if tall intimidating sacked manager is them/they or man or trans woman though or trans male - the article just says trans manager.

OP posts:
Annoyingwurringnoise · 10/05/2023 15:27

fabbykadabra · 10/05/2023 14:42

Obviously violence isn’t okay and I’m not sure where it’s been implied that it is?

Without seeing the start of the interaction it’s difficult to understand why the situation escalated so much. This is definitely not a typical reaction to innocent misgendering, so either there is more context that we have missed to explain why the manager was so riled up (not that that excuses her becoming physically violent) or just a case of the manager being aggressive. Her being trans is largely irrelevant, just as with any other demographic there are good and bad people. One aggressive trans person isn’t a reflection on trans people as a whole and most would not act this way over one mistake.

It’s the man who’s the manager who was being physically violent, not the woman. The woman looks quite calm whilst he is shouting at her and clapping in her face. I’d be bloody terrified if a man was being aggressive like that towards me.

And it doesn’t matter what she said, it doesn’t give him an excuse to kick off like that. What an absolute psycho he is.

ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 15:27

funinthesun19 · 10/05/2023 15:22

Fgs. How was she supposed to know the non binary person is non binary unless they stamp in on their forehead? Lots of people still think a person who looks like a she doesn’t mind being called a she. It’s easy to forget about the non binary trend.

And even if the customer did know the non binary person is non binary and still called her a woman, the manager was beyond unprofessional to kick off and use her/his/their/its (?) job as a platform to kick off with random members of the public.

It's a whole lot of things, but "complicated" seriously isn't one of them...
Where are the complications for you, @whatisgoingonintheworld ?

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:26

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 15:03

As we’re all advised by the experts over in feminism to do I have reported this thread for countless examples of misgendering.

And so far as I know compelled speech is not the law.

Fladdermus · 10/05/2023 15:26

Man abuses woman and the conclusion of many on this thread is that she must have done/said something to provoke it. Because it's always the woman's fault isn't it.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:25

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 15:03

As we’re all advised by the experts over in feminism to do I have reported this thread for countless examples of misgendering.

Correctly sexing.

His gender is unclear, no one knows whether he is a She or a They.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:24

So let's get this straight, male member of staff is verbally abusive to a middle aged woman uses a misogynistic term towards her and is violent to her partner because she correctly sexed someone and it's the woman's fault for asking for it?

Rule of Misogyny Number 1.

Women are responsible for what men do.

I bet that young man wouldn't have been so rude and aggressive to a male customer who had made the same 'mistake'.

I'm glad Starbucks have sacked him. If I go out for a coffee I don't expect to have to go along with another persons gender delusions or else suffer abuse.

Redebs · 10/05/2023 15:24

OneTC · 10/05/2023 14:47

As with every one of these videos I'd love to see the lead up.

When the video starts there's one person being aggy

But that would mean that it was set up beforehand by someone intending to create a scene, wouldn't it?

This woman just went to buy a coffee and called the woman behind the counter a lady. It only started being videoed when the manager came out and started calling her names and being intimidating.

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:24

funinthesun19 · 10/05/2023 15:22

Fgs. How was she supposed to know the non binary person is non binary unless they stamp in on their forehead? Lots of people still think a person who looks like a she doesn’t mind being called a she. It’s easy to forget about the non binary trend.

And even if the customer did know the non binary person is non binary and still called her a woman, the manager was beyond unprofessional to kick off and use her/his/their/its (?) job as a platform to kick off with random members of the public.

That's my point. I wasn't defending the trans woman and her assault on a woman at all. I was making the point that how would anyone know what to use if not obvious or a label stating please call me 'them/they'.

OP posts:
whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:23

ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 15:17

I think it's fair for customers to be asked to leave for abusing staff whether due to race/ gender/disability
Yeah, yeah. Nobody suggests otherwise. The word "lady" is not a term of abuse.

Is 'lady' directed towards someone who looks like a female but identifies (unbeknownst to customer) as a they/them an insult worthy of this level of anger from the trans woman manager?

OP posts:
funinthesun19 · 10/05/2023 15:22

whatisgoingonintheworld · 10/05/2023 15:08

It's complicated. The biological woman called the non binary individual a 'lady' and the trans woman manager decided that was 'transphobic' and so asked her to leave and refused a refund. The trans woman manager has been sacked over this now.

Fgs. How was she supposed to know the non binary person is non binary unless they stamp in on their forehead? Lots of people still think a person who looks like a she doesn’t mind being called a she. It’s easy to forget about the non binary trend.

And even if the customer did know the non binary person is non binary and still called her a woman, the manager was beyond unprofessional to kick off and use her/his/their/its (?) job as a platform to kick off with random members of the public.

Verv · 10/05/2023 15:22

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 15:20

So what biological sex was the person called Lady out of interest? Because I’m not clicking on the clip but assume the people in it are customer left and manager right.

I have almost always called everyone mate, unsure why just always have for decades, it’s pretty handy these days.

Plus can someone clarify non binary to me as a term, does it mean a person identifies as neither gender but can be either bio sex but gives no indication of sexuality or asexuality. Could be straight, gay, bi or asexual?

Counter worker female, called lady, "identifies as" non binary.
Manager - trans identified male.
TIM takes it upon himself to berate customer for calling non binary female employee lady.
It is unclear whether or not the female behind the counter had a massive sandwich board declaring non binary status to customers.

limitedperiodonly · 10/05/2023 15:22

"Would you please leave, Madam?" would be a reasonable response by a manager to a customer who appeared to be causing a problem.

That could be followed by: "I will refund your £10 payment via the card you used to pay, but I have to insist that you leave immediately afterwards."

You might follow it up with: "I am behaving calmly Madam, but it you don't leave now, I will call the police."

But the manager wasn't reasonable or calm which is why they are no longer employed by Starbucks. Mind you, if Starbucks ever wanted a training video on how not to behave as one of their managers, that's a good one.

ReadersD1gest · 10/05/2023 15:21

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 15:03

As we’re all advised by the experts over in feminism to do I have reported this thread for countless examples of misgendering.

🙄. Yes, dear. I'll refer to biological sex all I bloody well please.

EdithStourton · 10/05/2023 15:20

I mean I've watched the video - the manager was not violent towards the woman
Oh okay. No physical contact actually made = no violence whatsoever, nothing to see here, move along?

The manager was bloody intimidating. Said manager was aggressive, angry, over the top and all self-control had gone.

(Trying hard not to misgender but also struggling to deny the evidence of my own eyes and ears.)

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 15:20

So what biological sex was the person called Lady out of interest? Because I’m not clicking on the clip but assume the people in it are customer left and manager right.

I have almost always called everyone mate, unsure why just always have for decades, it’s pretty handy these days.

Plus can someone clarify non binary to me as a term, does it mean a person identifies as neither gender but can be either bio sex but gives no indication of sexuality or asexuality. Could be straight, gay, bi or asexual?

WallaceinAnderland · 10/05/2023 15:19

PinkyU · 10/05/2023 15:03

As we’re all advised by the experts over in feminism to do I have reported this thread for countless examples of misgendering.

Do you know the gender of the assailant? I don't think it's been reported has it?

Strawberrydelight78 · 10/05/2023 15:19

Tell them to write it on they're head.

Swipe left for the next trending thread