Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a married woman be independent?

111 replies

Smartish · 10/05/2023 14:08

AIBU or is DH?

DH was saying how he likes to look after me financially. He feels good knowing he gives me money to buy clothes and things I like. The thing is, I work FT, earning pretty much an equal salary. All of our money goes into a joint account and we each take an equal amount for our own discretionary spends. I buy all of my things from this money. I pointed this out and said I’m independent (I meant it to mean that financially, I am self sufficient and pay my way). He’s taken it to mean that I consider myself single, that I don’t need him etc…

So, AIBU? Once married, are women no longer independent?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 10/05/2023 15:12

Smartish · 10/05/2023 15:09

To clarify a couple of points:
We came up with the joint account system when we used to earn unequally so that we both had the same amount of spending money (when I was a student and when i earned considerably less this was especially nice). We earn more or less the same now but have our own savings, the joint account covers our bills.

The other point is that he doesn't seem to think he's independent either. He seems to be of the opinion that once married, neither of you are independent anymore. It's a bizarre way of thinking.

Am him to clarify what he means by dependent but yes, I wouldn't like it either being told I can't be independent of him because of a ring

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/05/2023 15:11

I would class myself as financially independent as I bring in enough money to cover all our existing costs alone, should the need arise. All our money is pooled, we have free access to it each, and do not need to ask permission to spend it.

I don't like your husband saying he basically "keeps" you. Like you are a possession.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/05/2023 15:11

OK darling, I'll be dependent on you. My wages are for me, you can pay am the bills and then give me spending money

See how long he keeps that up.

LolaSmiles · 10/05/2023 15:10

He has a weird attitude and sounds like he fancies himself as some sort of 1950s breadwinner whilst you're both contributing 50/50.
What sort of reaction is he hoping for when he reminds you about how much he likes providing you with things from money you're supplying to the joint account.? If he's expecting gushing and gratefulness that would be eye-roll worthy.

PinkFootstool · 10/05/2023 15:10

Ref the joint accounts question - we do have one and we transfer the same amount into it each month for the bills and another £150 each for household savings. Those are spent on things like household repairs, replacements for furniture, car repairs etc.

Our wages are paid into our own accounts! I also earn a bit extra from time to time doing surveys or admin work for my brother - I spend it on treats for myself as its usually £50 now and again!

Didtheythough · 10/05/2023 15:10

I dont understand how he thought he was looking after you if you both earn the same, it makes no sense. Does he NEED to feel like he looks after you? Is it a feeling manly issue, so he had been deluding himself on purpose.

Smartish · 10/05/2023 15:09

To clarify a couple of points:
We came up with the joint account system when we used to earn unequally so that we both had the same amount of spending money (when I was a student and when i earned considerably less this was especially nice). We earn more or less the same now but have our own savings, the joint account covers our bills.

The other point is that he doesn't seem to think he's independent either. He seems to be of the opinion that once married, neither of you are independent anymore. It's a bizarre way of thinking.

OP posts:
TheMoops · 10/05/2023 15:06

What an odd way of looking at the relationship.
Does he consider himself independent?
Why does he think he's giving you money to buy things?

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 15:02

If we broke up right now or he died I could live to the same standard I do now. I wouldn’t have as many amassed assets financially as they would be split 50/50 but then neither would he.

MargotBamborough · 10/05/2023 15:01

It sounds like in his head he's living a 1950s style fantasy where he's the big manly breadwinner supporting his little wife, when in reality he isn't actually paying for anything except his own equal contribution to your partnership.

Your actual setup sounds fair on the face of it. I'd be questioning why he seems to want to pretend you are not equals.

MargotBamborough · 10/05/2023 14:59

Your DH sounds like an idiot.

He is no more paying for your lifestyle than you are paying for his.

If you're not financially independent, then neither is he. I bet he thinks he is financially independent though.

lunaloveroo · 10/05/2023 14:56

I would say I'm independent. I earn a bit more than him, pay my own bills and we share out household bills equally. Never had a joint account in 20 years. I can spend what I want, save what I want without seeking approval or permission. We're mortgage free anyway but if he left me I could afford to get a mortgage or I'd just downsize and be mortgage free. I can afford to look after my dc alone. I holiday without him (and with him) and do activities without him (and with him). We have a very equal and balanced marriage.

notteallyme · 10/05/2023 14:55

Agree with above how on earth can he think he's looking after you if you earn equally and contribute equally. Looking after you would mean you aren't putting into the pot and he's putting enough in to cover all your joint needs.

Puppyseahorse · 10/05/2023 14:52

I’m confused. How does he think he’s looking after you if you earn the same amount?

because he’s a man….? How does that work?

WhyOhWine · 10/05/2023 14:51

i find this a bit odd. I earn significantly more than DH, although both of us could manage financially if we split up (he would have more of a drop in lifestyle ignoring any divorce settlement). we both also socialise independently (as well as together) without asking "permission", although when DC were little we would check in to ensure the other one was going to be in or whether we would need a sitter). The regular bills are paid out of a joint accounts. We both buy stuff (for ourselves and the house and DC) without checking. However, we do not operate entirely independently. Eg i would not just book a holiday for us without discussing with him where we might go, I dont make plans for Christmas Day without discussing etc.

So I guess it depends on what you mean by independent. But overall I think sex is irrelevant - a married woman can be just as independent (or dependent) as a married man.

Horizons83 · 10/05/2023 14:50

I absolutely do not need my husband, either financially or emotionally. So I suppose I am independent.

But I want to share my life with him.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 14:43

@Pinkbonbon

Joint account are for paying money into to cover the household bills but don't ever put your whole salary in them. I don't care how much you trust the other person, its utter madness to give them free access to all your savings.

And yes, this. Never understand why people would pool all household finances. It's nuts.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 14:42

It depends how you define "independent". If you mean you could continue to live in the same house with the same outgoings then technically not all married people are totally financially independent.

If you mean able to support yourself without recourse to the spouse's funds in the event of a separation I'd say anyone who works has a degree of independence.

Inevitably a lot of women earn less than their husbands so their independence may not be total at the lifestyle level they enjoy but they are able to support themselves, which is critical. That's the standard I would apply.

A lot of married people these days maintain separate finances (which is a good thing in my book although I know a lot of people are horrified by this). The more women get to keep their own money, the better.

Pinkbonbon · 10/05/2023 14:42

First off, ffs, put your own money in your own bank account.

Joint account are for paying money into to cover the household bills but don't ever put your whole salary in them. I don't care how much you trust the other person, its utter madness to give them free access to all your savings.

This guy sounds somewhat volatile. Like he could start an argument in an empty room. You've pointed out you are his equal and he's taken it as a personal attack.

Get your own bank account ASAP.
So many women on here thought it would never happen until he actually leaves (often after creating some silly drama) and drains the bank account! Take no chances.

Hbh17 · 10/05/2023 14:37

Of course she can! I have been married over 30 years and we have never had a joint bank account - neither of us wanted it. My husband was the higher earner, so he paid more for some things, but we both always contributed. Neither of us know how much money the other one has/spends on personal stuff, hobbies etc - what he does with his money is none of my business and it makes for a much happier life.
Also it's a mindset - we do things together, but we also have our own interests, occasionally separate holidays etc and both of us know that we could cope perfectly well without the other one, because we're not emotionally dependent.

Comedycook · 10/05/2023 14:35

He's got a cheek. He wants to play the big man who's supporting his wife financially without actually having to do it because you do actually work full time.

VaddaABeetch · 10/05/2023 14:34

Ask he how he likes being a keptman

ErrolTheDragon · 10/05/2023 14:33

YANBU, of course.

Married couples can be financially independent - neither depends on the others earnings or wealth. They can (should) be equal, mutually supportive partners.

Perhaps he should consider trying to do nice things for/with you rather than buying you stuff that you can afford anyway? Emotional rather than financial support.

AhNowTed · 10/05/2023 14:33

What is he on about! Bizarre take on your financial arrangements.

5128gap · 10/05/2023 14:31

If there's any type of dependency it's probably co dependency in that while each of you could manage alone, as a partnership you' may be 'dependent' on each other for the extras. You may both need each other to be able to live in the house you do, have the amount of holidays or luxuries you now enjoy through your pooling of resources. But that's reciprocal not something he provides for you.