Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a married woman be independent?

111 replies

Smartish · 10/05/2023 14:08

AIBU or is DH?

DH was saying how he likes to look after me financially. He feels good knowing he gives me money to buy clothes and things I like. The thing is, I work FT, earning pretty much an equal salary. All of our money goes into a joint account and we each take an equal amount for our own discretionary spends. I buy all of my things from this money. I pointed this out and said I’m independent (I meant it to mean that financially, I am self sufficient and pay my way). He’s taken it to mean that I consider myself single, that I don’t need him etc…

So, AIBU? Once married, are women no longer independent?

OP posts:
Fupoffyagrasshole · 10/05/2023 16:39

money not monday hhahaha

Fupoffyagrasshole · 10/05/2023 16:36

husband and I earn around the same - have a child - we both put 50/50 in joint acc for the mortgage / bills / stuff for our daughter / food shops

we both are paid into our own private accounts and do a manual transfer to join acc

and we keep our own Monday in private accounts to do what we like with! If he wants to get me a gift or treat me to a night out or whatever out of his own money pot thats nice sometimes and i do the same for him!

but i would class myself as very independent and I do not need him or any man but i do want to be with him - it's not the same thing

Mrsweasleysclock · 10/05/2023 16:29

LolaSmiles · 10/05/2023 16:26

The way he's phrased it its as if he gets a buzz from "keeping her": enjoying the fact he buys things for her and getting the hump about her describing herself as independent. In other words he actively wants her to be dependent. It's not a good look.
That's how I read it too. It comes across like he wants to position himself as the provider husband and OP as the kept wife.

I initially read it that way but then when op said that he also doesn't consider himself as being independent I thought maybe he's just getting his point across in the wrong way.

SinglePonders · 10/05/2023 16:26

Well if your lifestyle requires another person, financially, emotionally, physically, psychologically, then of course the person isin’t ’independent’
Abd this goes for women and men.
But I’d say most people can’t or even want to do that.

LolaSmiles · 10/05/2023 16:26

The way he's phrased it its as if he gets a buzz from "keeping her": enjoying the fact he buys things for her and getting the hump about her describing herself as independent. In other words he actively wants her to be dependent. It's not a good look.
That's how I read it too. It comes across like he wants to position himself as the provider husband and OP as the kept wife.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 16:22

Mrsweasleysclock · 10/05/2023 16:17

Do you think it's just miscommunication. If he thinks neither of you are independent maybe he is just pointing out that as you're in a committed relationship you run decisions or expenditure or plans etc past each other even if just as a courtesy. You wouldn't do that if you weren't in a committed relationship and so then you would be truly independent.

He may just be pointing out that while you both have the ability to be independent financially, socially etc you do have to consider each other as things stand now. It's not a bad thing, just how things are in a relationship.

But that's not how he's phrased it. The way he's phrased it its as if he gets a buzz from "keeping her": enjoying the fact he buys things for her and getting the hump about her describing herself as independent. In other words he actively wants her to be dependent. It's not a good look.

Mrsweasleysclock · 10/05/2023 16:17

Do you think it's just miscommunication. If he thinks neither of you are independent maybe he is just pointing out that as you're in a committed relationship you run decisions or expenditure or plans etc past each other even if just as a courtesy. You wouldn't do that if you weren't in a committed relationship and so then you would be truly independent.

He may just be pointing out that while you both have the ability to be independent financially, socially etc you do have to consider each other as things stand now. It's not a bad thing, just how things are in a relationship.

Cas112 · 10/05/2023 16:14

He's being ridiculous. You are independent and clearly not single Confused

Smartish · 10/05/2023 16:06

Jazzyjezzabelle · 10/05/2023 16:03

I don’t know how he doesn’t give you the ick. Not due to his stereotypical views but as he earns the same as you so treats you to fuck all .

What do you mean he treats me to fuck all? Where did I say that? He buys me gifts...

OP posts:
Jazzyjezzabelle · 10/05/2023 16:03

I don’t know how he doesn’t give you the ick. Not due to his stereotypical views but as he earns the same as you so treats you to fuck all .

Citygal3 · 10/05/2023 15:55

What you do is quite normal and a good idea I would say. Each person should have the same amount of disposable income in a partnership. It is his take on it that is weird.

Firstmonthfree · 10/05/2023 15:53

@Heretomakeadiff if they were 140 years old she wouldn’t be earning the same as him. Propping up this bizarre illusion that he has where he is the “head of the household” giving her money for clothes and things when she earns the same amount!!!

if it were purely antediluvian and he was financing everything I wouldn’t have so much of a problem as I do with this Prince gifting her own money back to her.

Dont know what these posters who have got the ick are going on about, I’ve gone straight through that into rage.

mrsbyers · 10/05/2023 15:51

PinkFootstool · 10/05/2023 14:14

Damn right I'm independent. We pay 50/50 on the bills etc, but if he dropped dead tomorrow or decided to leave me, I'd be fine. I would be v sad etc but I would still be able to pay the bills and generally financially and physically survive a bereavement etc.

I also go on holidays without him, see friends without him and encourage him to do the same without me.

Marriage doesn't mean I lose my identity or ability to be self sufficient! It does make it easier to afford the bills when there's two of you but otherwise we are only in a marriage because we generally like one another (most days!).

This ^

I have never relied on a man financially and never will

Heretomakeadiff · 10/05/2023 15:46

How old are you both, 140 years old?

Firstmonthfree · 10/05/2023 15:44

How is he looking after you financially if you are earning half the money????

if he wants to play the big man and be responsible for the little woman he needs to earn a bit more!

I can’t believe you are considering pandering to this guys ego. You don’t NEED him. You choose to be with him and want to be with him but you absolutely do not NEED him

LolaSmiles · 10/05/2023 15:44

The other point is that he doesn't seem to think he's independent either. He seems to be of the opinion that once married, neither of you are independent anymore. It's a bizarre way of thinking
His attitude to keeping you and presenting himself as some breadwinner gives me the ick to be honest.

But I don't entirely disagree with his view here though. To me choosing to marry involved both me and DH saying that we become a unit. I'd say DH are dependent on each other, but in a freely and mutually dependent sort of a way. There are times I've been breadwinner and times he has been, we have our own pensions and have our own careers. We could live independently if we wanted or needed to.

shammalammadingdong · 10/05/2023 15:39

It's not at all weird to share finances, it's perfectly normal.

There are a great many functional married couples where only one works, or one works less, and/or they contribute very different amounts, and share money.
Some people here seem to think that sahp or the disabled or retired people do not have functioning marriages?

Smartish · 10/05/2023 15:37

Mariposista · 10/05/2023 15:22

Goodness no. Him treating you every now and again is one thing, giving you pocket money when you already have a good salary is another!
In most functional married couples, both work, both contribute, both spend their own money on their own things. What you describe is weird.

It's weird to share finances? I mean, I will accept that everyone sorts things out differently but I don't understand how taking an equal amount to spend for ourselves is weird? It started when I earned less so we just pooled everything and shared equally what wasn't needed for the bills.

We do holiday separately (and together) and have separate friends. I go out alone and have all my own opinions! He just seems offended that I consider myself independent.

I like how some of you have pointed out that it's nicer to WANT to be together rather than feel forced because of marriage/finances etc.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 10/05/2023 15:32

Smartish · 10/05/2023 15:09

To clarify a couple of points:
We came up with the joint account system when we used to earn unequally so that we both had the same amount of spending money (when I was a student and when i earned considerably less this was especially nice). We earn more or less the same now but have our own savings, the joint account covers our bills.

The other point is that he doesn't seem to think he's independent either. He seems to be of the opinion that once married, neither of you are independent anymore. It's a bizarre way of thinking.

Well in that sense he is correct. Even if you kept everything strictly separate during your marriage, that illusion would be shattered were you ever to divorce, when everything would go into one pot and be divvied up between you.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 10/05/2023 15:30

it's one thing to acknowledge that life cam be easier with two wages coming into a household than 1

It's bizarre though for him to be swanning around congratulating himself that you have clothes to wear as if somehow you are not an equal contributer

I was with my DH when I was a student and he was 4 years post graduation though and it took him awhile and a few arguments before he got himself out of the mindset that he was the breadwinner and I earn pin money.

GCWorkNightmare · 10/05/2023 15:23

Absolutely not.

Married 19 years yet also independent. I’m not financially reliant on my husband. We don’t share finances or names, I don’t use Mrs. We don’t wear rings, we have separate hobbies. Holiday together and separately. Still very much married.

Mariposista · 10/05/2023 15:22

Goodness no. Him treating you every now and again is one thing, giving you pocket money when you already have a good salary is another!
In most functional married couples, both work, both contribute, both spend their own money on their own things. What you describe is weird.

ghyt · 10/05/2023 15:18

Ew he's giving me the ick and I don't know the bloke.

JudgeRudy · 10/05/2023 15:17

It's unclear what's offended him but my guess is its that you've pointed out that financially he gives you nothing. You'd get the same from a lodger. In his position I'd flip that on It's head. You're not with him hecause you need to be, you're with him because you want to be. Tell him you don't need a rich man, his lovely self is enough.

shammalammadingdong · 10/05/2023 15:16

Pinkbonbon · 10/05/2023 14:42

First off, ffs, put your own money in your own bank account.

Joint account are for paying money into to cover the household bills but don't ever put your whole salary in them. I don't care how much you trust the other person, its utter madness to give them free access to all your savings.

This guy sounds somewhat volatile. Like he could start an argument in an empty room. You've pointed out you are his equal and he's taken it as a personal attack.

Get your own bank account ASAP.
So many women on here thought it would never happen until he actually leaves (often after creating some silly drama) and drains the bank account! Take no chances.

It's not one size fits all. For example, I have no need of such advice. I've had a joint bank account with my partner for 30 years, and I do know 100% thats no way at all he is ever going to empty it and take off!

Yes , of course you can be financially independant after marriage. But you can also be dependent or interdependent, and if that works for you, that's good too. There's no prizes involved here.