Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a married woman be independent?

111 replies

Smartish · 10/05/2023 14:08

AIBU or is DH?

DH was saying how he likes to look after me financially. He feels good knowing he gives me money to buy clothes and things I like. The thing is, I work FT, earning pretty much an equal salary. All of our money goes into a joint account and we each take an equal amount for our own discretionary spends. I buy all of my things from this money. I pointed this out and said I’m independent (I meant it to mean that financially, I am self sufficient and pay my way). He’s taken it to mean that I consider myself single, that I don’t need him etc…

So, AIBU? Once married, are women no longer independent?

OP posts:
Equalitea · 10/05/2023 21:22

I don’t know whether it’s an ego thing?

When I’ve earned more than DH and I’ve for example bought a handbag, I’ve always instinctively said that DH bought it for me. He feels good and I am happy that I have the bag.
In reality, we’ve both contributed probably equally to the bag but I suppose without his half I wouldn’t have the bag.
DH also does the same whether he earns more or less, if he says he needs a new sweater for example, I’ll buy it from joint money (he hates shopping)and he will say that I bought it for him.

I am not sure why we are like this but it works for us (and has done for many years), I think it’s perhaps just a nod of appreciation that we both contribute to each other having nice things. Perhaps for him it’s an ego thing, you know, treated the missus to this and that 🤷‍♀️🤪

darjeelingrose · 10/05/2023 18:33

EggInANest · 10/05/2023 18:26

Entering into the marriage contract automatically means that you are not independent but in certain key legal and financial matters are part of a contracted partnership.

No one who is married, man or woman, married to man or woman, is legally and financially independent: that’s the whole point.

And each partner has a duty to support the other.

Lovely of him to be pleased that he is in a financial partnership with you, enjoying sharing his and your incomes to make each other happy.

Very paternalistic of him to assume that he ‘looks after you’ financially when clearly it is a joint and mutual support that you are able to provide for each other.

I think you are talking about obligations rather than independence. It's not the same. You have an obligation to the person that you have married. Independence means that you are not controlled by another, nobody has authority over you. In a good marriage, that is absolutely true.

FinallyHere · 10/05/2023 18:31

If your earnings are pretty even, then he is deluded.

If you want to continue the relationship, every time he mentions 'looking after' you, smile , say thank you and I'm pleased to do the same for you' and notice how he reacts.

When someone shows you who he is, believe them.

I'd be judging him. W*nker.

darjeelingrose · 10/05/2023 18:30

He just doesn't understand what being independent means. The opposite is dependent. You aren't dependent on him because you contribute equally, in this case financially, but it could be in kind. You can still be independent when you get married, you don't became dependent on the other person, you just stop being single.

caringcarer · 10/05/2023 18:29

DH and I have separate finances. We both have a salary paid into our own bank account then transfer an equal amount into a joint account to pay bills. It works because we earn about the same. If dh died I could manage financially on my own. The mortgage is finally paid off. I'd be better off because a mortgage on a btl would be paid off and I'd receive death in service and half his pension for life from one pension and two thirds of his other pension for life. Emotionally I'd be a mess and so sad. Emotionally we have a very strong connection and get on really well. DH is my best friend as well as my lover. I'd miss his support of me and encouraging me to stretch myself. I'd miss just chatting together and laughing together and all the stuff we do together.
If I want to buy something or buy something extravagant or give a generous gift to my sister or niece I just do it I don't ask DH. I might tell him but I might not.

EggInANest · 10/05/2023 18:26

Entering into the marriage contract automatically means that you are not independent but in certain key legal and financial matters are part of a contracted partnership.

No one who is married, man or woman, married to man or woman, is legally and financially independent: that’s the whole point.

And each partner has a duty to support the other.

Lovely of him to be pleased that he is in a financial partnership with you, enjoying sharing his and your incomes to make each other happy.

Very paternalistic of him to assume that he ‘looks after you’ financially when clearly it is a joint and mutual support that you are able to provide for each other.

YouJustDoYou · 10/05/2023 18:18

It's a very old-fashioned view point, but one some men do really like it that way I suppose. Doesn't really mesh with now-times though...

Northby · 10/05/2023 18:16

He could mean it in a sexist way as you seem to describe.

Otherwise he could mean it in a team-work sense. I think when you are married you choose to be interdependent - you choose to share and share alike. I like to know I can provide for my husband and I’m sure he likes to know he can provide for me. I don’t think it’s unreasonable from that perspective and I think I would feel a little stung if my husband said he was totally independent from me because that goes against how we have connected the practical and emotional aspects of our marriage (ie. we both contribute and it’s all simultaneously “ours” and “each other’s”).

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/05/2023 18:13

I think people are jumping on this a bit, and using it to proclaim how ‘modern’ and ‘ self reliant’ they themselves are….not terribly helpful to the OP

Ive been with the same man, single and married , since Methuselah was a boy. Sometimes I earned more than him, sometimes he earned more than me. We have a joint account, and single accounts, but now it’s all so enmeshed that it’s hard to say whose is whose.

however, DP still likes to ‘give me a present’ even if he pays for it on the joint cc ( which I think I am the main signatory for). I do the same, I say in Tesco oh get some Bombay Sapphire instead of Gordon’s , I ll treat you…. Of course it goes through the till with everything else.

Perhaps OP’ chap just wants to feel that he is giving her something, contributing to her welfare, because he loves her ; gracious acceptance could be a strategy.

Pythagoras said that in true love ‘ there is no yours or mine between us’.

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 10/05/2023 18:02

A married person is not independent by definition.

But this doesn’t mean your DH isn’t a sexist idiot in saying what he says about finances.

ChopperC110P · 10/05/2023 17:51

Smartish · 10/05/2023 15:37

It's weird to share finances? I mean, I will accept that everyone sorts things out differently but I don't understand how taking an equal amount to spend for ourselves is weird? It started when I earned less so we just pooled everything and shared equally what wasn't needed for the bills.

We do holiday separately (and together) and have separate friends. I go out alone and have all my own opinions! He just seems offended that I consider myself independent.

I like how some of you have pointed out that it's nicer to WANT to be together rather than feel forced because of marriage/finances etc.

It’s not weird to share finances. Joint account and equal spending money is how most married couples do it.

ChopperC110P · 10/05/2023 17:47

He feels good knowing he gives me money to buy clothes and things I like.
It’s good he does this.

YANBU, but neither is he.
He may have a different take on definition of independent. I think to him you have the means to be independent, but by being married and thus in a partnership you aren’t independent, and neither is he because you both rely on each other. These don’t have to be relying on each other financially, because independence also means free of any influence from others and couples do influence each others decisions.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/05/2023 17:41

I couldn't be married to someone who thinks a married woman can't be independent.

I also wouldn't be putting all of my money into a joint account. No way.

spir1t · 10/05/2023 17:40

Id say you're overthinking this OP. If it's important to you to feel independent, then do just do that. But obviously, being married is about co-dependency to some extent, otherwise why bother? Bit ridiculous to have children together and then fuss about separate money and independent this and that (in my opinion). It all goes the same way.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 10/05/2023 17:38

Things is there are things in life that are dependent on being a couple. Good example being salary multiples for a mortgage. When we bought this house, neither of us could have borrowed enough alone. I live here because DH does and vice versa.

Smartish · 10/05/2023 17:35

spir1t · 10/05/2023 17:22

OP, I'm not really sure what you are looking for here because you say yourself, you earn the same as him - so what is the issue? How is he 'keeping' you? And what does 'independence' have to do with it?

If anyone is 'dependent' then its both of you - 'co-dependence.' I'm sure they'd are things you can afford as a couple that neither of you could do single?

Probably, all he meant was that he likes having joint finances?

Of course in true MN fashion, people are tripping over themselves to talk you how wonderfully 'independent' they are from their DH and each buy their own cars / clothes/ loo roll or some such triviality.

My husband earns all the money on our family and has done for over 15 years. It's absolutely fine btw,

Well, he basically thinks that all married people are dependent on each other. I think he's using the word incorrectly. When I mentioned being independent, I didn't just mean financially but in other ways. I have my own opinions. He didn't seem to like that he isn't 'needed' as such but I think it's more of a compliment to be with someone because you want to be rather than have to be.
So that'd what I'm asking - does marriage mean you're no longer independent.
Looks like the majority think I'm ok to consider myself independent.

OP posts:
AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 10/05/2023 17:34

Well, does he mean that he likes that your jointly earned lifestyle means you can buy a nice handbag if you want it, or is he suggesting his contribution to the pot pays for the things you buy? They're very different.

It's not a particularly nice discussion on Mumsnet. There seems to be this idea that if you don't each individually earn enough to support yourself plus any children in your existing home you are a kept spouse.

I am "independent" in that I work 3 days a week so have my "own" money but I couldn't cover all of our expenses on that if DH died, so we've got a shitload of life and critical illness insurance. If he left, we'd have a big chunk of equity to split.

I'd probably downsize anyway. DS and I wouldn't need a 4 bedroom house with 3 toilets.

spir1t · 10/05/2023 17:22

OP, I'm not really sure what you are looking for here because you say yourself, you earn the same as him - so what is the issue? How is he 'keeping' you? And what does 'independence' have to do with it?

If anyone is 'dependent' then its both of you - 'co-dependence.' I'm sure they'd are things you can afford as a couple that neither of you could do single?

Probably, all he meant was that he likes having joint finances?

Of course in true MN fashion, people are tripping over themselves to talk you how wonderfully 'independent' they are from their DH and each buy their own cars / clothes/ loo roll or some such triviality.

My husband earns all the money on our family and has done for over 15 years. It's absolutely fine btw,

CrackersCheeseAndWinePlease · 10/05/2023 17:18

I'd say I'm financially independent as is my DH. We don't have a joint account but go 50/50 on bills, we both work full time.
Neither of us know how much the other has in the bank and we never ask,
If he left me tomorrow, financially id be fine

saltinesandcoffeecups · 10/05/2023 17:08

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 14:43

@Pinkbonbon

Joint account are for paying money into to cover the household bills but don't ever put your whole salary in them. I don't care how much you trust the other person, its utter madness to give them free access to all your savings.

And yes, this. Never understand why people would pool all household finances. It's nuts.

Umm because it works very well for some 🤷‍♀️ On the flip side there are those of us who don’t understand the ledger of accounts and nickel and dimming that goes on between spouses.

honeylulu · 10/05/2023 17:03

I'm a married woman and I'm independent in my view. We have a joint account for household stuff but if we split we could both support ourselves financially from our separate earnings without the other. I think your husband is considering the words "single" and "independent" as the same. They aren't.

Jazzyjezzabelle · 10/05/2023 16:56

Smartish · 10/05/2023 16:06

What do you mean he treats me to fuck all? Where did I say that? He buys me gifts...

All of our money goes into a joint account and we each take an equal amount for our own discretionary spends. I buy all of my things from this money.

so this statement was untrue? You also are gifted stuff from him, which is what he was referring to?

Jazzyjezzabelle · 10/05/2023 16:55

Smartish · 10/05/2023 16:06

What do you mean he treats me to fuck all? Where did I say that? He buys me gifts...

Then is this what he’s referring to? He’s saying he buys you gifts and it makes him feel good and now you’re saying he does in fact buy you gifts?

InFlagrante · 10/05/2023 16:40

Horizons83 · 10/05/2023 14:50

I absolutely do not need my husband, either financially or emotionally. So I suppose I am independent.

But I want to share my life with him.

This.

Bumpitybumper · 10/05/2023 16:40

I honestly think that hyper individualism has so much to answer for and some of the responses on this thread are shocking. OP has clarified that her DH believes that neither of them are 'independent' so he isn't being sexist. The question instead therefore is whether married people (men or women) can be totally independent of each other? I believe the answer is that this is technically possible but in most cases highly undesirable, especially when children are involved.

Marriage should mean that you act as a team and each of you contributes fairly to achieving the overall goals. Of course each person in the marriage should future proof themselves as much as possible if the marriage was to breakdown but that doesn't mean you have to act as completely separate units throughout the marriage and 'prove' you could be independent if it was needed at any given time. The sad fact is that almost anyone can be independent if it is absolutely necessary and whilst they might need assistance from the state of other sources they would survive and the vast majority would go on to have a decent quality of life.

Excessive focus on what happens if things go wrong though can lead to some women taking on more than their fair share in a marriage in a desperate attempt to prove they are still independent and don't need to rely on a man. Women solely self funding the maternity leave to have joint children, paying for their children on their own, taking on all domestic tasks etc... The list goes on. Marriage should not be harder than living alone and should be easier. This may be controversial but otherwise what is the point in teaming up with someone?