Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can a married woman be independent?

111 replies

Smartish · 10/05/2023 14:08

AIBU or is DH?

DH was saying how he likes to look after me financially. He feels good knowing he gives me money to buy clothes and things I like. The thing is, I work FT, earning pretty much an equal salary. All of our money goes into a joint account and we each take an equal amount for our own discretionary spends. I buy all of my things from this money. I pointed this out and said I’m independent (I meant it to mean that financially, I am self sufficient and pay my way). He’s taken it to mean that I consider myself single, that I don’t need him etc…

So, AIBU? Once married, are women no longer independent?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 18:33

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 17:45

You don't seem to be grasping the point I am making.

You had the CHOICE to go back. You may not have. Not everyone can. But that isn't even the point.

I am agreeing with you that women CAN be vulnerable without their own earned income. You don't seem able to see that you CAN also be vulnerable by being financially independent. Very vulnerable, and very badly off. And that you can be much better off by being not independent.

Can you understand that all ways can turn our badly, or well?

I just don't agree with you.

A woman paying half no matter what can stop paying her half and use that to help her get out of the relationship if needed. She has more options than the woman with no income who wants to get out of the relationship, especially since the woman paying half no matter what could also ask for full time hours, she doesn't have to look for a job after potentially years out of work.

She is still more vulnerable than the other woman.

pippabg · 12/05/2023 17:46

He's deluded. Of course, you're independent! The fact you pool money together in a joint bank account (especially. 50/50) means nothing. We do something similar, but my partner earns more and I still consider myself independent, because I could remove that money and support myself anytime I wanted.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 17:45

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 17:31

That's a reason why I went back after 3 months and full time. So I could continue my career and at the same level.

Not every woman accepts the ''mummy track'' by going part time, being the default parent etc.

Even if that is the case, I still feel like it is a better situation than having no income at all and doesn't leave you as vulnerable.

You don't seem to be grasping the point I am making.

You had the CHOICE to go back. You may not have. Not everyone can. But that isn't even the point.

I am agreeing with you that women CAN be vulnerable without their own earned income. You don't seem able to see that you CAN also be vulnerable by being financially independent. Very vulnerable, and very badly off. And that you can be much better off by being not independent.

Can you understand that all ways can turn our badly, or well?

MoominFeatures · 12/05/2023 17:41

Wow. I’m married (to a man), female and the sole earner so my short answer to the question is “yes”!

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 17:31

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 13:32

I’ve seen and heard all too well about how easy completely shared finances can go wrong and women become vulnerable, especially if they become SAHM’s and have no income at all

So have I, but I've also seen and heard all too well how a slavish devotion to independence can go wrong and women become vulnerable. When you earn less than half what he does because he's not on the mommy track and you're still insisting on paying half of everything because you're so independent, that's can very quickly go sour too.

That's a reason why I went back after 3 months and full time. So I could continue my career and at the same level.

Not every woman accepts the ''mummy track'' by going part time, being the default parent etc.

Even if that is the case, I still feel like it is a better situation than having no income at all and doesn't leave you as vulnerable.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 13:32

I’ve seen and heard all too well about how easy completely shared finances can go wrong and women become vulnerable, especially if they become SAHM’s and have no income at all

So have I, but I've also seen and heard all too well how a slavish devotion to independence can go wrong and women become vulnerable. When you earn less than half what he does because he's not on the mommy track and you're still insisting on paying half of everything because you're so independent, that's can very quickly go sour too.

PrettyMaybug · 12/05/2023 12:52

But what he has said doesn't even make sense. Confused

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 12:51

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 12:38

Ok, that works for you. But what if you couldn't have gone back after 3 months? It doesn't take much for that independence to fall apart.

I don't agree about the majority. I don't think the majority of couples are totally independent at all, men or women.

I've never really understood why committed couples would share a house, a bed, there actual DNA and make new people, and be so affronted and sharing money (to me the least important aspect of things), but I assume it works for those who care about it. I wish they would be as sensible/generous to assume it can work very well the other way as well.....

The only reason that would happen would be due to something unavoidable such as disability or mental health which are exceptions. It isn’t a choice I would ever willingly make.

We share money, just not all of it. What’s left after our shared expenses is ours to do whatever we like with, we earned it and I wouldn’t like my husband having an opinion about how it should be spent and/or saved.

I’ve seen and heard all too well about how easy completely shared finances can go wrong and women become vulnerable, especially if they become SAHM’s and have no income at all.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 12:38

their and at. Typos!

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 12:38

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 12:04

In the majority of situations.

There will always be some exceptions but even then, still problematic because it is almost always the woman financially relying on the man.

I took 3 months of maternity leave and during that time still paid my fair share which was my choice. It was absolutely the better option to me but then I wouldn’t agree that sharing all of my money is the better option either because other than joint expenses such as mortgage, nursery fees etc we have separate finances and I would never agree to completely joint finances.

Ok, that works for you. But what if you couldn't have gone back after 3 months? It doesn't take much for that independence to fall apart.

I don't agree about the majority. I don't think the majority of couples are totally independent at all, men or women.

I've never really understood why committed couples would share a house, a bed, there actual DNA and make new people, and be so affronted and sharing money (to me the least important aspect of things), but I assume it works for those who care about it. I wish they would be as sensible/generous to assume it can work very well the other way as well.....

RagingWoke · 12/05/2023 12:18

I'd be creeped out that he thinks independence is a bad thing. Does he want a wife to stand behind him sheepishly and grovel for pocket money? Ick.

I'm married, financially independent in that we have separate accounts and split everything 50/50. I have my own friends, interests, hobbies etc and we split housework and childcare between us for whatever is convenient. We have a perfectly healthy relationship with no codependency (ok, maybe I occasionally exaggerate how heavy the bin is when it's raining and I don't want to go out 😉), we spend time together and have shared interests but DH is very comfortable with my independence and i with his.

I do know women, and it's always women ime, who completely loose themselves in a relationship and end up financially and emotionally dependent on their partner. One very close friend gave up her house, job and entire personality to the point now she won't be away from her dh, she just stands there grinning at him and refuses to spend money unless he benefits from it. The whole set up makes me so sad for her as she used to be really fun to be around.

HunterAngel · 12/05/2023 12:16

I’m fairly independent. Financially I couldn’t afford my house without DH’s salary but we have separate accounts and pay a set amount into a joint account for bills. Socially we usually go out together, I wouldn’t go on holiday or make Christmas plans without his input but we’re not attached at the hip.

Your DH sounds a bit insecure

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 12:04

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 11:29

Not in every situation.

Say you have a child with significant care needs that means one parent has to stay home. They might be financially dependent, trying to retain financial independence would be the worse option. Both my dh and I have been that parent at different times.
We've both also been the partner who was unemployed, economically inactive for personal reasons, and been on parental leave. Both of us have relied on the other to be the one earning money, while earning none

In a fair, equal, mutually interdependent, relationship...financial dependence is just not an issue. There are instances where complete financial independence is actually very bad for one party...you often see here women trying to pay their full half of the mortgage from savings while on maternity leave, to maintain their independence at huge cost to them. That's not intrinsically better than sharing every cent you earn with the person you love and co-parent with.

In the majority of situations.

There will always be some exceptions but even then, still problematic because it is almost always the woman financially relying on the man.

I took 3 months of maternity leave and during that time still paid my fair share which was my choice. It was absolutely the better option to me but then I wouldn’t agree that sharing all of my money is the better option either because other than joint expenses such as mortgage, nursery fees etc we have separate finances and I would never agree to completely joint finances.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 11:29

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 09:18

I'd disagree there. Financial independence is intrinsically better.

Completely relying on someone else financially is risky, not to mention how problematic it is that it is almost always the women who is financially vulnerable.

Not in every situation.

Say you have a child with significant care needs that means one parent has to stay home. They might be financially dependent, trying to retain financial independence would be the worse option. Both my dh and I have been that parent at different times.
We've both also been the partner who was unemployed, economically inactive for personal reasons, and been on parental leave. Both of us have relied on the other to be the one earning money, while earning none

In a fair, equal, mutually interdependent, relationship...financial dependence is just not an issue. There are instances where complete financial independence is actually very bad for one party...you often see here women trying to pay their full half of the mortgage from savings while on maternity leave, to maintain their independence at huge cost to them. That's not intrinsically better than sharing every cent you earn with the person you love and co-parent with.

SouthLondonMum22 · 12/05/2023 09:18

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 08:59

Well done for being financially independent OP. Make sure it stays that way

There's a thread running through this post, and this site, that's a sort of massive pride in being totally independent, and the accompanying implication that there is something wrong with women who are not, for whatever reason.

It's a pretty shitty attitude. There's nothing intrinsically better about one or the other.

I'd disagree there. Financial independence is intrinsically better.

Completely relying on someone else financially is risky, not to mention how problematic it is that it is almost always the women who is financially vulnerable.

shammalammadingdong · 12/05/2023 08:59

Well done for being financially independent OP. Make sure it stays that way

There's a thread running through this post, and this site, that's a sort of massive pride in being totally independent, and the accompanying implication that there is something wrong with women who are not, for whatever reason.

It's a pretty shitty attitude. There's nothing intrinsically better about one or the other.

Bumpitybumper · 11/05/2023 12:26

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves
I feel like some of this semantics. The vast vast majority of married people would function in the event of the marriage ending. There may well be some struggle and readjustment at first but eventually every single person I know (man and woman) has gone on to be ok in the end. They may have had to downsize their material assets, change their working patterns, lean on family and friends for emotional support or turned to the state for assistance but they are all ultimately able to cope and function to a large extent. So by this definition, very few people 'need' their partner or spouse to survive.

For most married people though, it makes sense to merge resources (financial, emotional, time, skills etc) to enable a better quality of life for the unit. For example, use both incomes for a mortgage application, share childcare costs and responsibilities, split domestic chores etc. This means that the joint lifestyle you develop is only possible within the marriage and it would be very hard for one person to achieve the same standard of living on their own. So the husband and wife may well 'need' each other to maintain the current lifestyle but equally it doesn't mean that they couldn't be independent if required and create a new, potentially less nice lifestyle that they themselves could resource alone.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/05/2023 09:20

PuzzledObserver · 11/05/2023 08:47

There is a lot more to marriage than how finances are split. One PP said they didn’t need their husband financially, practically or emotionally - am I alone in finding that a little bit sad?

A marriage should be about partnership - mutual support, emotionally and practically, as well as financially. You cook the tea and I’ll put the washing on. Tell me about your shitty day, and I’ll tell you about mine. What do we want to do with the house, and how are going to afford it?

There is such a thing as being too dependent on another person, to the extent that you can barely function without them - you do see this with couples who have been so enmeshed with each other that when one dies, the other struggles with everyday things and is intensely lonely. That’s not healthy. But you can go too far the other way, IMO - essentially living separate lives with no overlap apart from sharing a bed.

In healthy relationships, each can have their own opinions and activities while still being a unit which works as a team.

I don't think it's sad, personally.

I don't need my DH either - financially, practically or emotionally. By that, I mean that could cope perfectly well without him, as indeed I had to recently when he had to be overseas for a very extended period.

I choose to be with him though, because our relationship enriches my life in many different ways.

The fact that I don't need him doesn't mean that he adds no value or that we lead separate lives. It just means that he is a positive addition to my life rather than a necessity for me to function.

PuzzledObserver · 11/05/2023 08:47

There is a lot more to marriage than how finances are split. One PP said they didn’t need their husband financially, practically or emotionally - am I alone in finding that a little bit sad?

A marriage should be about partnership - mutual support, emotionally and practically, as well as financially. You cook the tea and I’ll put the washing on. Tell me about your shitty day, and I’ll tell you about mine. What do we want to do with the house, and how are going to afford it?

There is such a thing as being too dependent on another person, to the extent that you can barely function without them - you do see this with couples who have been so enmeshed with each other that when one dies, the other struggles with everyday things and is intensely lonely. That’s not healthy. But you can go too far the other way, IMO - essentially living separate lives with no overlap apart from sharing a bed.

In healthy relationships, each can have their own opinions and activities while still being a unit which works as a team.

Testina · 11/05/2023 08:26

He sounds needy, creepy and irritating.

TheDogCaravan · 11/05/2023 08:21

This sounds like classic modern man struggling to understand what his purpose is. Some men can’t or won’t grasp that women don’t need them anymore.

Well done for being financially independent OP. Make sure it stays that way.

crumpet · 11/05/2023 08:15

Neither of you are as independent as you would be if you were both single. If you disagreed on the financial split we’re you to divorce, a court would order how it should be split.

I presume neither of you would make a massive purchase (house, car etc) without consulting the other? Or take off for a months round the world trip?

this doesn’t mean that neither of you have a degree of independence, but you are married, so no, the independence thing is t quite the same as for single people.

BiddyPop · 11/05/2023 08:05

DH is feeling it a bit at the moment. He was the bigger earner for over 20 years and covered a lot of things. I still always earned and it increased but so did his.

This past year, he took a new job in the same area but public sector side rather than private sector so dropped 40%, while I got promoted to that same level. So we now earn identical amounts.

But I am used to budgeting and watching my pennies whereas he has always saved but had plenty to not worry and teen dd is draining him dry.

So I did get raised eyebrows when he saw my relatively new satchel for work papers I had treated myself to. ...after years of liking and longing, current work backpack is over 8 years old, and I needed something to carry in my hand occasionally and to drop over suitcase handles when travelling. And I had saved for it so while it was a bit of a "splurge" purchase when I saw the perfect thing, I don't feel guilty about it as he's had every bit of tech and gadget he wanted over the years. (It probably doesn't help that I am contemplating a new Apple Mac as dd took my old one for school, again something I had saved for a long time to afford, and it's trashed from being hauled in and out for a couple of years but I may be going abroad for a couple of years myself and will need a decent laptop for that).

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/05/2023 21:54

By your description you are financially self sufficient. And your DP is clearly deluded.

Financially independent would imply you had capital and didn’t have to work.

AliceMay55 · 10/05/2023 21:51

Tell him you too enjoy looking after him financially and giving him money to buy clothes etc. See how that goes?

Either he ups the game significantly to earn 2x the salary so you can sit at home (if you like) and have a socialite lifestyle, or he accepts the reality (and behaves accordingly)