Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with school

209 replies

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 12:07

My child was very poorly this morning- sore throat, temperature and had been up most of last night. She had her SATs test due this morning but was zonked out so I explained to school that she was just too poorly to sit a test today. I was then bombarded with unpleasant calls from both her teacher and the headteacher demanding that I force her to come in. They implied that I didn’t care about her education and they said she would not be able to resit it and would get a zero. They just wouldn’t leave me alone. So I ended up dragging a sobbing child out of bed, forcing her to get dressed and get in the car. She took the test and then I picked her up. I know schools are under a lot of pressure but does that really excuse this kind of behaviour? Surely something is wrong with the system if this is acceptable, putting this amount of pressure on parents and children?

OP posts:
Margot78 · 10/05/2023 15:51

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:44

Did you ever say what your child’s absence rate is?

Not sure how many days would make this justifiable but this is her 4th day off this academic year.

OP posts:
TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:50

This really is one thread where I’d be interested to hear these conversations!

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:48

her form teacher rang saying angrily that this was important and she needed to come in. That they were all waiting for her to start. I said she was too sick. My daughter heard me talking to her and got stressed. Teacher asked me to see if I could get her ready and hung up.

Teacher rang back again to see if I’d managed to convince her. Told her child was distressed and still feeling hot with a sore throat. Teacher got extremely angry and said it was a shame I was going to let my child score a zero when she was good at reading. She hung up before I could respond.

Almost right away I get a call from the head demanding that I bring her in. This was followed up by another call checking she was on her way. She also demanded to speak to my daughter. She gave the strong impression she didn’t believe me. I felt quite tearful and shaky by this point tbh.

i have just reread

are you seriously saying the teacher actually out the phone down on you.
that the teacher was “extremely angry” (how so - shouting?)
and that the head “demanded”? What did she actually say? “I DEMAND your daughter comes in”?

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:44

Did you ever say what your child’s absence rate is?

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:44

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 13:28

Thank you I appreciate your understanding. That’s just how it was. I don’t understand why my child’s absence rate or how much I like the school has any bearing on whether their approach was appropriate.

Why does it matter?

because if you were to say “oh I have a terrible relationship with the school, lots of ongoing issues and the head and teachers are all twats”

Most of us would become a touch more skeptical re your version of events

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:41

The sats do matter for your child, unfortunately the results and the targets they lead to will be a feature of all her progress and reports throughout secondary school. I wish people would stop saying sats don’t matter, this is not really accurate.

Amazing then that my child is doing A Levels at a selected 6th form and looking to achieve top grades despite not doing year 6 Sats.

At most highschools they reassess in the first few weeks.

Sats are also an appalling measure for children with learning differences, especially the SPAG assessment.

Comefromaway · 10/05/2023 14:22

The sats do matter for your child, unfortunately the results and the targets they lead to will be a feature of all her progress and reports throughout secondary school. I wish people would stop saying sats don’t matter, this is not really accurate.

They really do not count. Both of my children went to a private primary school who didn't do SATS. Both went onto different secondary schools where the other children had all done SATS. Dd's school did CATS testing on entry for all pupils. Both were given target grades, put into appropriate sets etc etc with no problem.

balzamico · 10/05/2023 14:17

Please ensure that the head of governors knows about this, it is an appalling way to behave.

CoastPath · 10/05/2023 14:17

I was caught off-guard by DD's secondary school ringing me when she was off sick. I had already reported her unwell that day and they still rang me and cross-questioned me aggressively as to why she was off sick. They demanded I bring her in for the afternoon session. I refused. They rang DH and tried the same tactic with him too. He also said no, she was ill.

We made a formal complaint to her Head of Year and got an apology for the way the member of staff spoke to us.

CaptainMyCaptain · 10/05/2023 14:17

PartTimer923 · 10/05/2023 12:12

That is unreasonable. One SAT test score does not change her education! As far as I understand it, the score is used by secondary schools to group children by ability. In the absence of a test score, surely the school could just make a recommendation based on her performance over the last 6 years at the school!

The secondary school my grandchildren go to doesn't even do that, they do their own tests at the beginning of year 7. The Yr 6 tests are to judge the school that's why the Head is so keen to get results.

BTW I was a teacher and so is my daughter. She was not the slightest bit concerned about her children's SATs results. I would have kept the child at home but I understand why you gave in to the bullying from school.

GOW56 · 10/05/2023 14:13

The sats do matter for your child, unfortunately the results and the targets they lead to will be a feature of all her progress and reports throughout secondary school.
In the scheme of things they don't matter at all nor do arbitrary targets and progress reports based on them. Also sensible secondary schools do their own progress tests rather than rely on a test when the child.is 10 years old.

Scarydinosaurs · 10/05/2023 14:06

I would definitely type that up - but remove the emotive language. When you say ‘got really angry’ I would instead say what she did ie raised her voice

be really cold and matter of fact about it and email a complaint to the head and the chair of governors.

And if she is sick tomorrow keep her home - no test is worth this!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/05/2023 14:04

And if the head teacher demanded to speak to your daughter, then again, the correct response is a polite but firm "no, sorry, she is unwell and she cannot come to the phone right now."

CouldNotStayAway · 10/05/2023 14:03

@Margot78 goodness that sounds absolutely awful. Had it been gcse or a level exam I'd maybe understand. I appreciate SATs scores are used for league tables and therefore only benefit the school- but I can't imagine an ill child performing too well anyway.

Just for reference my DS didn't do SATs, secondary school has zero issue with it, continuous assessments throughout the school year have given a far better indication with regards to targets etc for all the pupils.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/05/2023 14:02

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 13:55

I left a message on school answerphone saying she was sick.

Her form teacher rang saying angrily that this was important and she needed to come in. That they were all waiting for her to start. I said she was too sick. My daughter heard me talking to her and got stressed. Teacher asked me to see if I could get her ready and hung up.

Teacher rang back again to see if I’d managed to convince her. Told her child was distressed and still feeling hot with a sore throat. Teacher got extremely angry and said it was a shame I was going to let my child score a zero when she was good at reading. She hung up before I could respond.

Almost right away I get a call from the head demanding that I bring her in. This was followed up by another call checking she was on her way. She also demanded to speak to my daughter. She gave the strong impression she didn’t believe me. I felt quite tearful and shaky by this point tbh.

Sounds like you need to work on your assertiveness skills, OP.

All that was needed in this situation was a polite but firm "Yes, I know it's an important week and it's very unfortunate that she can't do the test, but I'm afraid she really isn't well enough so I won't be bringing her in."

Over and over like a broken record if needs be. You can absolutely complain to the governors if you wish - it sounds like the school was unnecessarily belligerent. However, you need to reflect on why you allowed yourself to be bullied into something that was contrary to what you considered to be the best interests of your child.

Spidey66 · 10/05/2023 14:00

Sheepsheepeverywhere · 10/05/2023 12:14

My dd did her gcse's under a bout of tonsillitis...
Your dd will be fine.

I’m not a parent and SATS weren’t a thing when I was at school, but my understanding is they’re mainly use to see if a school is meeting it’s targets, so it benefits the school more than the child. GCSEs are a different kettle of fish. The grades your child receives is more important to your child than SATS. Fair play to your daughter though….tonsillitis is horrible!

GOW56 · 10/05/2023 14:00

My dd did her gcse's under a bout of tonsillitis...Your dd will be fine.
GCSEs are not the same as SaTs which are completely unnecessary tests and will have absolutely no impact on her education.
OP you should not have taken her into school.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/05/2023 14:00

Fuck that. I'd be even less inclined to send my kid in after being 'told off.' Then I'd make a complaint.

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 13:55

Scarydinosaurs · 10/05/2023 13:39

I can’t understand what happened.

you called her in sick and left an answer phone message presumably?

Did they call you back? How many times did they call you?

When they said “can’t you bring her in” and you replied “no she is sick” what did they say back?

If I were you I would write it all down while it’s fresh in your mind and then email a complaint because bullying you into sending an unwell child to school is awful and completely against the school’s own absence policy, surely??

I left a message on school answerphone saying she was sick.

Her form teacher rang saying angrily that this was important and she needed to come in. That they were all waiting for her to start. I said she was too sick. My daughter heard me talking to her and got stressed. Teacher asked me to see if I could get her ready and hung up.

Teacher rang back again to see if I’d managed to convince her. Told her child was distressed and still feeling hot with a sore throat. Teacher got extremely angry and said it was a shame I was going to let my child score a zero when she was good at reading. She hung up before I could respond.

Almost right away I get a call from the head demanding that I bring her in. This was followed up by another call checking she was on her way. She also demanded to speak to my daughter. She gave the strong impression she didn’t believe me. I felt quite tearful and shaky by this point tbh.

OP posts:
AllOfThemWitches · 10/05/2023 13:50

No one learned anything from covid then

CabernetSauvignon · 10/05/2023 13:50

Seems very shortsighted of the school, given that this means she has probably spread her bugs to the other pupils.

PollyPut · 10/05/2023 13:48

@Margot78 I do wonder how many other parents also called in to say their child wasn't coming in today. If school had, say, 5 parents call in, then it would massively affect their numbers. It puts them in a very difficult position and might be very hard for them to work out which were truly sick.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 10/05/2023 13:45

The only place I would have taken my daughter is the dr. The school overstepped and do not get to order you to force your child to school. You are her advocate and let yourself be bullied. I would make a complaint and never allow this to happen again. The school only did this for their own interests and results not for the well being of your daughter. You knew how unwell she was and they did not. Do they not care that she may have spread her illness to other children? No apparently not because they only care about results.

sunlovingcriminal · 10/05/2023 13:45

Just to add my support OP. You sound like you were put in a horrible position, which made you doubt your own judgement. That wasn't fair of the school.

In life, we don't blame those being bullied- instead we blame the bullies. That's what the school did to you, they bullied you into submission and it made you question yourself.

I hope your daughter is beginning to feel better. SATS or no SATS, what are we teaching our children? That even if you are feeling shit, those in authority expect you to go in (and not rest and recover) and be a cog in the bigger wheel? No thanks.

My work wouldn't want me in if I was poorly. Schools need to extend the same dignity to our children.

Scarydinosaurs · 10/05/2023 13:39

I can’t understand what happened.

you called her in sick and left an answer phone message presumably?

Did they call you back? How many times did they call you?

When they said “can’t you bring her in” and you replied “no she is sick” what did they say back?

If I were you I would write it all down while it’s fresh in your mind and then email a complaint because bullying you into sending an unwell child to school is awful and completely against the school’s own absence policy, surely??