Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be furious with school

209 replies

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 12:07

My child was very poorly this morning- sore throat, temperature and had been up most of last night. She had her SATs test due this morning but was zonked out so I explained to school that she was just too poorly to sit a test today. I was then bombarded with unpleasant calls from both her teacher and the headteacher demanding that I force her to come in. They implied that I didn’t care about her education and they said she would not be able to resit it and would get a zero. They just wouldn’t leave me alone. So I ended up dragging a sobbing child out of bed, forcing her to get dressed and get in the car. She took the test and then I picked her up. I know schools are under a lot of pressure but does that really excuse this kind of behaviour? Surely something is wrong with the system if this is acceptable, putting this amount of pressure on parents and children?

OP posts:
TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 17:20

It wasn’t.

it was pairing two people who didn’t know one another. So not relevant

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 17:19

Crustsamongus · 10/05/2023 17:10

I take it no one saying OP was wrong to relent has ever heard of the Milgram experiment? Don't overestimate the likelihood you will resist when pressured by an authority figure.

OP, I am shocked the school behaved like this. I am a secondary teacher and we manage fine if there are no SAT scores for a particular child. We also know our children and their parents (though nowhere near as well as a primary would, I imagine) so would know if it's likely to be MH related, a pisstake or genuine illness.

Was that experiment involving parents and their sick child?

Crustsamongus · 10/05/2023 17:10

I take it no one saying OP was wrong to relent has ever heard of the Milgram experiment? Don't overestimate the likelihood you will resist when pressured by an authority figure.

OP, I am shocked the school behaved like this. I am a secondary teacher and we manage fine if there are no SAT scores for a particular child. We also know our children and their parents (though nowhere near as well as a primary would, I imagine) so would know if it's likely to be MH related, a pisstake or genuine illness.

MrsToadflax · 10/05/2023 16:49

I would definitely write a formal complaint. To make a parent, another grown adult feel anxious, pressurised and scolded for advocating for their child is not acceptable. I'm sure it does create a bit more work with rescheduling, but a child can't help being sick. They had a duty of care which they neglected in favour of ticking a box. Please complain so no one else has to go through it. Good luck to your DC.

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 16:40

Would be odd if their motivation is results results results

surely you’d presume a very sick child wasn’t going to exactly bring the average result up

Justalittlebitduckling · 10/05/2023 16:35

It’s all about the school and their results. It’s not about the welfare of your child. You are right to be cross.

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 16:34

cassgate · 10/05/2023 16:19

I am a year 6 TA. Trust me when I say that the head and teacher hate that they had to do this. The problem is that if a child doesn’t sit the paper on the same day as the rest of the class, the head has to apply for a timetable variation for that child. In the meantime they are not allowed contact with their class (easy to stop them mixing in school but we have no control over contact outside school). The paperwork involved and extra staffing required to allow children to sit tests in isolation is huge. Last year, we had 1 child who didn’t sit the test with the class because of illness. The situation above was explained and parent was given an option for them to sit it same day but on their own in the afternoon otherwise a timetable variation would kick in. This was a low ability child who was not likely to pass but we still had to go through the motions. Child came in the afternoon and sat the test in an office with myself and another TA observing. They sat all the other papers with the rest of the class.

Thank you for explaining. I understand that this would put immense pressure on them and I’m
certainly not denying that the logistics of it all must be a nightmare. I’m not without sympathy for schools at all. I suggested in my original message to school that she could maybe sit it in the afternoon instead as a sleep in the morning might be enough to perk her up. They told mw when they rang back that it’s basically now or never. Yes of course there are staffing issues to consider but surely it is preferable to make contingency plans in advance in cases of illness rather than putting last minute pressure on families in this way? It just doesn’t seem to be a good way of dealing with it or communicating that’s all.

OP posts:
TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 16:28

She won an attendance record last year despite you starting a thread about keeping her off for two days and wondering if you should continue to keep her off because she was still getting diarrhoea?

So the school isn’t too harsh when it comes to absence rates 🤷‍♀️

recyclemeagain · 10/05/2023 16:22

So we can ascertain that the school learned absolutely nothing from Covid then. Encouraging you to bring an ill child into school to sit with all the other kids to then take home whatever bug has been shared. How thoughtful of the school!
I'd be straight onto them in the morning and they would absolutely hear me.
Very very very glad to live in Scotland where we don't have SATS. Hope your girl is feeling better soon and don't be too hard on yourself either, yes you should've kept her home but I can understand how pressured you will have felt especially after a broken night of sleep.

Dinopawus · 10/05/2023 16:21

Sorry OP school are ridiculous to do this. I'm going to assume your DD is expected to do well and school want her to perform in order to optimise their average scores.

Well they deserve to have egg on their faces if a sick child doesn't magically achieve the required scores. Meanwhile your DD will be just fine at secondary who will assess her and set her accordingly.

I'm raging as much at their stupidity as their cruelty towards your DD. The best option for school and your DD is for her to resit when she is well enough.

I hope she is feeling better soon.

WeWereInParis · 10/05/2023 16:21

I am a year 6 TA. Trust me when I say that the head and teacher hate that they had to do this.

If it happened as OP describes then they did not have to do it like that.

cassgate · 10/05/2023 16:19

I am a year 6 TA. Trust me when I say that the head and teacher hate that they had to do this. The problem is that if a child doesn’t sit the paper on the same day as the rest of the class, the head has to apply for a timetable variation for that child. In the meantime they are not allowed contact with their class (easy to stop them mixing in school but we have no control over contact outside school). The paperwork involved and extra staffing required to allow children to sit tests in isolation is huge. Last year, we had 1 child who didn’t sit the test with the class because of illness. The situation above was explained and parent was given an option for them to sit it same day but on their own in the afternoon otherwise a timetable variation would kick in. This was a low ability child who was not likely to pass but we still had to go through the motions. Child came in the afternoon and sat the test in an office with myself and another TA observing. They sat all the other papers with the rest of the class.

Teawithnosugarplease · 10/05/2023 16:13

For what it's worth OP, I would have felt and done exactly the same as you did.

It was wrong of them to pressure you like that in those circumstances.
They may realise that now having seen your daughter perform her test in tears and clearly unwell.
Tonsillitis can make anyone feel rotten.

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 16:09

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 16:00

Fuck what a cruel thing to do to a child!! Why not just go for a re-sit FFS

No where does this poster say she forced or made her DD do this.

if I’d spent weeks / months revising and I knew the alternative was resits when all my friends would be moving on and getting their results… damn right I would have done the exams with tonsillitis!

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 16:04

Soapboxqueen · 10/05/2023 16:02

SATs are used for targeting setting at GCSE.

Which is in turn used to identify which children should be targeted for booster groups etc in the run up to exams

So while not the most important thing to think about before taking SATs, it's incorrect to say it has no impact.

My DD’s school doesn’t do SATs, I’m sure she’ll be fine all the same

MintJulia · 10/05/2023 16:04

SATs are completely irrelevant except for the school.

I'd make a formal BBC complaint to the Board of Governors about their bullying, and I would have let her sleep.

gogohmm · 10/05/2023 16:02

Unfortunately they probably had multiple parents saying the same and can't tell who is genuinely ill, plus minor illnesses used to be something we just carried on with.

Soapboxqueen · 10/05/2023 16:02

lifeturnsonadime · 10/05/2023 15:41

The sats do matter for your child, unfortunately the results and the targets they lead to will be a feature of all her progress and reports throughout secondary school. I wish people would stop saying sats don’t matter, this is not really accurate.

Amazing then that my child is doing A Levels at a selected 6th form and looking to achieve top grades despite not doing year 6 Sats.

At most highschools they reassess in the first few weeks.

Sats are also an appalling measure for children with learning differences, especially the SPAG assessment.

SATs are used for targeting setting at GCSE.

Which is in turn used to identify which children should be targeted for booster groups etc in the run up to exams

So while not the most important thing to think about before taking SATs, it's incorrect to say it has no impact.

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 16:01

Of the 32 other pupils… are you or your daughter aware of anyone else being off sick today?

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 16:00

Sheepsheepeverywhere · 10/05/2023 12:14

My dd did her gcse's under a bout of tonsillitis...
Your dd will be fine.

Fuck what a cruel thing to do to a child!! Why not just go for a re-sit FFS

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 16:00

Did the teacher put the down on you twice?

YouWonJayne · 10/05/2023 15:58

MN never ceases to amaze me in that they think a sick child should be in school no matter what

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 15:58

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:50

This really is one thread where I’d be interested to hear these conversations!

I didn’t record it unfortunately. The teacher had a very annoyed tone of voice and it was like being told off. Didn’t let me get a word in and yes the head said she “has to” come in, she repeated that several times that’s why I interpreted it as a demand as opposed to “please can you bring her in?” which would have been a request. I’m not someone who exaggerates or tries to make others sound bad. I’ve always got on fine with them that’s why this was shocking. If they had been nice and reasonable I wouldn’t have felt the need to drag her out of bed, I would have felt able to say no. The reason I (wrongly) forced her to go was because I genuinely felt harassed and pressured . I promise.

OP posts:
TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:57

Margot78 · 10/05/2023 15:51

Not sure how many days would make this justifiable but this is her 4th day off this academic year.

Again. Context.

So if she was a school refuser and multiple times had claimed illness that was later shown or she said had been her making it up… it would put a different slant on your version

TuesandThursNero · 10/05/2023 15:55

Did the teacher really put the phone down on you. Twice?

and how did her “extreme anger” manifest itself”

and how did the head actually demand your daughter come in? What language was used