Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are your barriers to sustainable living? What would it take for you to ^get there^?

191 replies

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:13

Inspired by yet another message from David Attenborough.

● Car - I can't afford one, DH gets to work in a company van (up to 10 men at a time) but he works all over so the emissions are still probably very high.
● Bicycle - Storage and cost was a problem before I moved out of my flat
● Public transport - great where I live and cheap.
○ Plastic packaging - I cant afford butcher, fruit and veg shop, zero waste shops are too much
● Grow fruit and veg (loads of community gardens and allotments to pick from, now I have a garden I have space, it was a barrier living in a flat), my grandparents had fruit trees so I got fruit from them
●Buy mostly second hand (easy its cheaper)
●Save water (easy with small children sharing a bath, use the bath water in the garden etc
● Passing on used clothes/ toys- Charity shops collect round here but you need to have more than 20 black bags worth. So it's easy when we have a massive sort through.
○Buying things that last- Tricky for us, we buy about 3 pairs of rubbish s hool shoes per child per year. I can't afford the upfront cost of a better pair and to be honest I thought £20 was expensive for school shoes
○Recycling- we didn't have Recycling bins in our flat, I've recently moved and have normal and Recycling bin. The council took all of the big recycling bins when they gave residents Recycling bins but people in flats didn't get one.
●Electric and gas usage, even before the cost of living we live in terrace and a flat so it was easy enough t o keep the house warm with little heating. We didn't have central heating in our flat and used to only use hot water bottles and blankets to stay warm when we first moved out. It was scary when we had a newborn and it was freezing though. I used to make a den in the kids bunk bed and sleep in bottom bunk altogether when it was really cold. We didn't have heating in there for 7 years! Now we have heating after we moved it's difficult to not use it, but we only have it on about half hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. old habits and all. We were ready for the Cost of living crisis at least.

I can't think of any more right now, but the main barrier for me is plastic packaging.
If supermarkets gave the option I would buy without.
If the local bakery self bread fir less than £6 a loaf I'd come in every day.
I used to go to the butcher and fruit and veg shop but when I moved (5 min walk from an aldi and lidl) I stopped going, the cost and convenience of a supermarket has to win.
I'm a sahm so I have time to mess about with charity shops, a vegetable garden etc.

I want to know what everyone else's barriers are, in a perfect world I'd live in the shire and my food would come from next door.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MrsDoylesTea · 10/05/2023 11:26

No interest in doing this whatsoever. Removing all technological advances and significantly degrading our standard of living so we can feel virtuous about "being first" whilst every other country looks at us and laughs. And advances ahead of us economically.

I think it's a shame these ideas have become so mainstream.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 11:23

user1497207191 · 10/05/2023 11:15

I'm a bit jaundiced re recycling. I got a car load of stuff to take to the recycling centre, all organised into different types, including a few small electricals, some hard plastics (a bin, knackered old watering can etc), some timber from an old fence, etc At the recycling centre, the wood, plastics and small electrical skips were all closed and were clearly full, so the guy working there just glibly said to throw it all in the non recycling skip! I asked whether they'd be emptied later that day or the following day as I was happy to go back, but he just shrugged and said he didn't know. I went back the next day and they were still blocked off so I just dumped them as he said in the non recycling as I couldn't leave the car full of it for another day! I really don't believe that recycling is taken seriously by the councils/waste firms at all - we've all seen the "recycling" being dumped in landfill or transported across the world to be dumped in third world countries!

Agree. I don't care for recycling. plastic is a waste and only can be down cycled.
Glass and tin and paper is the way but we don't have the space to deal with the amount of waste th uk produces. We should have big community compost bins though, so many black bags of garden waste gets dumped into the woods here. Just empty the bag!

Flytipping is a big problem here.

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 11:22

@greenspaceplace there is a big UK coal plant that apparently 0 emissions because we bought the coal from China, so our emissions get counted towards China's emissions.

I'm really surprised by that, the UK government will be audited. My understanding is that coal fired power stations are only fired up in extreme circumstances.

Could you link the documentary please?

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 11:19

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 10/05/2023 11:01

^This right here.

I don’t give a monkeys anymore. I had a baby and can’t be effed to recycle when most of it gets spoilt by other residents throwing in organic matter and dirty nappies. It all goes in one big black bag now.

The sorts of concerns the OP listed are for privileged people with time and capacity to bother about this.

You are part of the problem. Organizing your recycling takes minutes. I can't believe you don't care more about your babies future.

Cheesenpickleontoast · 10/05/2023 11:17

I use a lunchbox with compartments for the kids lunches, a bento box type thing. I haven't needed cling film or food wraps for years. Same with leftovers in the fridge. They go in a sealed container.

Pyrex dishes with lids to use for cooking in the oven rather than covering food wth aluminium foil.

Taking pride in having mismatched dishes and kitchen ware! Only replacing single items as they break and not worrying if they don't match.

I don't do air travel. I holiday in the UK or travel by ferry or train, if going abroad. I loathe the airport experience, so its not hard!

I like the idea of the airport taxes increasing with each flight. Love hearing about these things here first.

I went for 18 months without a car (by choice) but I couldn't get to see my elderly parents very easily or safely on foot or by bike as they live down 60mph country lanes. SO, I've written to my local Councillor to ask to reduce speed limits on tiny country lanes from 60mph and put a decent footpath on one side of the road. Doubt much will come of it. In the meantime, I had to get a small car.

I try to choose products with minimal or biodegradable packaging. Price is still a big issue for me though.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 11:15

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 11:10

The above post is perfect proof of the corrosive effect of all these "What about China?" posts (and it's always China, never any of the other big polluters like USA, Russia, Australia etc 🙄) The people who post this stuff may not be aware of what they're doing, but the people who spend billions on PR campaigns dripfeeding exactly these sentiments to a friendly media know exactly^ what they're fucking doing.

Fully agree. It works. there was a 40 minute piece on the news about the government basically fudging the numbers on emissions.

there is a big UK coal plant that apparently 0 emissions because we bought the coal from China, so our emissions get counted towards China's emissions.

There is also the issue of who's responsible for the emissions for imported goods? The people who produce them of course (china). It doesn't matter that the UK buys it and discards it but China made it, its their fault.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 10/05/2023 11:15

I'm a bit jaundiced re recycling. I got a car load of stuff to take to the recycling centre, all organised into different types, including a few small electricals, some hard plastics (a bin, knackered old watering can etc), some timber from an old fence, etc At the recycling centre, the wood, plastics and small electrical skips were all closed and were clearly full, so the guy working there just glibly said to throw it all in the non recycling skip! I asked whether they'd be emptied later that day or the following day as I was happy to go back, but he just shrugged and said he didn't know. I went back the next day and they were still blocked off so I just dumped them as he said in the non recycling as I couldn't leave the car full of it for another day! I really don't believe that recycling is taken seriously by the councils/waste firms at all - we've all seen the "recycling" being dumped in landfill or transported across the world to be dumped in third world countries!

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 10/05/2023 11:14

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 11:10

The above post is perfect proof of the corrosive effect of all these "What about China?" posts (and it's always China, never any of the other big polluters like USA, Russia, Australia etc 🙄) The people who post this stuff may not be aware of what they're doing, but the people who spend billions on PR campaigns dripfeeding exactly these sentiments to a friendly media know exactly^ what they're fucking doing.

It’s not all about China, of course. There are problems with USA, Brazil, India, etc. The UK is a tiny country and anyone here thinking they can make a difference has delusions of grandeur.

Sustainable living is a nice sentiment but unless the other 6.9 billion people in the world want to get on board, we’re on a fool’s errand. If your life is empty and it keeps you busy, fine, but I don’t have the time, space, financial or mental capacity to fret about my footprint.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/05/2023 11:14

I’d like David Attenborough to move out of the eight bedroom Georgian detached three storey house which he lives in on his own except for his nurse.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 11:12

Not affording a car, holiday or heating isn't privileged, I'm a sahm in a one income household with a family of six who recently moved out if a tiny flat that was so crap it didn't even have heating!

The only thing I think was privileged was the no waiting list on allotment plots and access to local community gardens and good transport.

I fully agree with other residents messing up the recycling bins with nappies. That's why ours were taken (after they tried to split 4 bins between 50 flats, no wonder it didn't work) I think we had them installed maybe 6 months before they were taken away.

OP posts:
crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 11:10

Wow, italics gone rogue 😬

IhearyouClemFandango · 10/05/2023 11:10

I think you can be irate and feel hopeless about what big corporations and private jets get up to, but it still makes sense to do what we are able to.

For us, we only manage the following:

  • Walk to local primary school and car share or bus for the secondary
  • Run one car
  • Cycle where possible
  • Buy milk from local farm vending machine in glass refills
  • Meat from local small producers, used more sparingly. If can't get there M&S for higher welfare stuff.
  • Rarely travel, 1 flight per year
  • Efficient house
  • New boiler
  • Grow our own where we can (I'm not very good at it)
  • Plan for solar in the future
  • Heating on low, limited tumble use
  • Buy second hand for the vast majority of stuff
crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 11:10

The above post is perfect proof of the corrosive effect of all these "What about China?" posts (and it's always China, never any of the other big polluters like USA, Russia, Australia etc 🙄) The people who post this stuff may not be aware of what they're doing, but the people who spend billions on PR campaigns dripfeeding exactly these sentiments to a friendly media know exactly^ what they're fucking doing.

CheekNerveGallAudacityandGumption · 10/05/2023 11:01

Moonmelodies · 10/05/2023 10:16

Meantime in China, they're making the same amount of concrete every three years that the USA alone used in the entire 20th Century.

^This right here.

I don’t give a monkeys anymore. I had a baby and can’t be effed to recycle when most of it gets spoilt by other residents throwing in organic matter and dirty nappies. It all goes in one big black bag now.

The sorts of concerns the OP listed are for privileged people with time and capacity to bother about this.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:58

RoomOfRequirement · 10/05/2023 10:41

Both time, and also the knowledge that so many large corporations and countries do so much bad that my tiny contributions don't actually mean anything.

I'm not proud of that, but it's exactly how I feel and what stops me going above and beyond, or doing anything too onerous.

This is a big barrier, But we are the many, they are the few and your changes make an impact. For example, when I got into growing food other people I knew were interested too. One person got an allotment, one started a veg patch in their garden, another just had a few pots of herbs but it is a change in attitudes.
My grandad has fruit trees. We picked apples for apple pie, now my children know we pick apples and eat apples in autumn and winter. they aren't a summer or spring fruit, blackberries, plums, tomatoes etc are seasonal and when they are older they start off with more knowledge than me. And with more fruit trees to pick from. imagine if we put gardens and orchards in schools, and 250 kids have the opportunity to start thinking about food seasonally?

Then we won't need to pick apples from Africa. An apples travelled further than I have. its fucked up!

OP posts:
crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 10:58

Well, other than posters doing the oil companies' work for them by constantly spewing out misleading whataboutery on threads like this....🙄

A lot of it is structural, and out of the reach of the average person. For example, I have air source heating and a well insulated home and it's amazing, but that's thanks to having a forward looking HA as landlord. Renters have little control over how their homes are heated, and many homeowners can't afford to upgrade.

Transport: we live rurally. Work and DS2 's school are within walking distance and DS1 takes the school bus to secondary, but all his mates are on the other side of the bloody catchment area and there's no bus after after school clubs, so I do a lot of driving him around. He would love to cycle, but the roads are very dangerous- single track, heavily used, lots of blind bends.

As for the two biggest things you can do personally- not flying and giving up meat and dairy- the former is pretty easy. From where we live, it's cheaper to go by train with an Interrail pass- we've just come back from a 2 week Interrailing holiday to Italy.

The latter? Well, I'm vegetarian and gave up cow milk (actually prefer oat), but kind of got stuck on cheese and eggs 😬 Um....the barrier is greed, really.

Billblight · 10/05/2023 10:48

We only turn the heating on if a puffa jacket and blanket doesn’t do the job

Have 2 meat free days a week minimum

no internal UK flights and try to holiday overseas via train

Try to get most things - esp children’s toys / baby gear 2nd hand where possible

Not changing our grim kitchen as the units are still serviceable. Painting and changing handles is a DIY job on the list

Food waste is a sin in our house

Eggs / chicken has to be free range. It annoys me the way that none of the exciting chicken kebabs / herby chicken / ready meals etc that supermarkets sell are free range. Why not? M&S and Waitrose not doing this pisses me off more. If you can afford to shop there you can afford to pay a little regard to animal welfare. To me buying non-free range chicken is exactly like buying battery eggs. Totally inhumane.

drawingmaps · 10/05/2023 10:48

Car: I can't drive (medical) so I zip about in my powerchair a lot but also get lifts when I can
Public transport: I get the train frequently (bc no car) but the buses near me are terrible, infrequent and so expensive I may as well get a taxi.
Plastic packaging: I use more than I used to because I need a lot of ready made food/ convenience food (bc disability), and baby wipes etc. If it was easier to recycle curbside would be better.
Fruit and veg in Spanish supermarkets are all loose and you can bring a reusable mesh bag or get a biodegradable one, that would be easy to implement in the UK.
Food: can't grow my own. I do pay attention to food miles for fresh food, eg yesterday I bought British apples over grapes from India, no idea on the prepackaged stuff. I eat cheese and some yogurt, but use oatmilk. I eat fish (try to go for sustainable options like pollack) but not meat.
Clothes: 95% are from charity shops, made by family, or hand-me-downs from other family members. I occasionally buy sustainable pieces eg I have some dungarees from Lucy and yak.
Recycling: I produce a fair amount of waste (plastic bags, medicine packets) but recycle everything I can, including taking the collection of medicine packets to superdrug and the bag of soft plastic to the big supermarket.
Reusables: I use reusable period pads, but disposable wipes to clean when I don't feel well enough to shower (saves water?).

Poppins2016 · 10/05/2023 10:45

Without a doubt, money is the barrier for our family.

I'd like to choose an electric car, insulate the house properly, install new double glazing, install solar panels, shop at zero waste stores, choose food with less packaging, take the train instead of drive... However we don't have the income to facilitate even the 'low' cost options. If, for example, vegetables cost less in plastic packaging, we go for that option as the food shop would cost (even more of) a fortune otherwise.

It makes me furious that the government recently heavily subsidised the airline industry instead of focusing on making bus and train travel more affordable. It's absurd that it's often cheaper to fly than get a train (e.g. London to Newcastle).

RoomOfRequirement · 10/05/2023 10:41

Both time, and also the knowledge that so many large corporations and countries do so much bad that my tiny contributions don't actually mean anything.

I'm not proud of that, but it's exactly how I feel and what stops me going above and beyond, or doing anything too onerous.

Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight · 10/05/2023 10:39

OP, may I suggest that if you have the space and the money, a second hand Panasonic bread maker will save you money and plastic waste. You can pick them up for around £40-50 if you hunt around (£200 ish new). You can get other brands for less but in my experience they don’t give such good results. Get one with a seed dispenser if possible. They have timers so you can wake up to fresh bread.

Bread Flour still comes in paper bags and a 800g homemade whole meal loaf (flour, yeast, butter, sugar, salt and water) costs about 60p for all the ingredients, about half what it costs in the supermarket so your machine will pay for itself quite quickly. The electric used is low as it’s on ‘rest’ for most of the time and for the 30 minutes cooking time it will help warm your kitchen and save on the heating.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:37

Moonlightsonatas · 10/05/2023 10:24

I agree with this, I would love to use better nappies, I have tried loads of the reusable ones and just couldn’t get them to work (no end of Mum guilt there). I would use the biodegradable ones but they are almost 3 times as expensive as supermarket own brand and I have 2 kids in nappies.

I try my hardest in other areas - we recycle as much as possible, even all the plastic packaging I take back to recycle at the supermarket. We only make about 1 bin bag of waste a fortnight. Then 1 bag of nappy waste per week.

Biodegradable nappies are basically a myth. Nothing can biodegrade in a landfill. So you'd have to compost those nappies and it's probably like those biodegradable bags that I used to buy, they sit in a compost bin for years not biodegrading. There are products marketed as Bio Degradable or degradable which is plastic that degrades, not good for anything. If the worms don't eat it, it's not good.

There was a really good documentary about green washing and how companies can claim something is biodegradable but it isn't really.
I'll Tey to find it. The do the same with 'organic'. There are factory farmed chickens that are labelled organic but not free range, not organic in the sense we think but technically its allowed to be labelled as such.
green washing where companies make it seem like something is eco but it isn't.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 10/05/2023 10:36

Public transport is dire around here. A 2 hourly bus service in the evenings and weekends, no buses at all after 11pm. Our local main line train station isn't on a main bus route, so you have to get a bus to the city bus station and then another bus (indirect that goes around the houses) to the train station. Buses don't serve our local out of town retail park at all - it's a good half mile walk to a bus stop!

Personally, I used to drive two hours per day to commute to work. I gave that up and started my own self employment, with a small office in our village, so I now walk to work every day, so that's a massive reduction in emissions for my daily "commute". That's at a big personal cost as I was on a high wage and my income is now a lot less - my client base is much reduced compared to having a city centre location.

It's a shame that there's no drive for "localism", i.e. living, working and shopping close to home. That would massively reduce congestion, pollution, etc. I know that's possible in major cities, London, etc., as there are actually amenities close to where people live, but in smaller cities, towns, villages, etc., most people have no choice but to travel into town and city centres. I think there's too much emphasis on "sustainable" transport which just encourages centralisation and we should do the opposite, to incentivise localism so people don't need to travel, green or not!

As for other things, I recycle, I don't buy crap I don't need, still wearing some clothes that are 10-20 years old, I sell loads of old stuff on ebay, i.e. our son's toys and clothes etc as he grew up.

Billblight · 10/05/2023 10:35

We can’t vote greens here in Scotland because they are all batshit-bonkers and have virtually nothing to do with the environment- sigh!

I used a train and bus for a journey that I usually do by car the other day (car in garage), and I wouldn’t do it again. The train guard was so outraged that I had deigned to try to take a pram on a train (‘there’s no room for that love - what were you thinking?’ Said loudly infront of the whole carriage to shame me) and the bus driver also made a hell of a song and dance. The bud didn’t come on the way back so we had to get a taxi to the train station. And the tickets were much more expensive than the petrol. Why would anyone bother???

I totally agree with that air passenger tax proposal though- getting far more expensive the more trips you take per year.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 10:32

@Moonmelodies consumption based per capita emissions in China are almost identical to those of the UK at 7.04t and 6.94t respectively. USA are at a whopping 15.47t. Your making a deliberately false implication.