Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are your barriers to sustainable living? What would it take for you to ^get there^?

191 replies

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:13

Inspired by yet another message from David Attenborough.

● Car - I can't afford one, DH gets to work in a company van (up to 10 men at a time) but he works all over so the emissions are still probably very high.
● Bicycle - Storage and cost was a problem before I moved out of my flat
● Public transport - great where I live and cheap.
○ Plastic packaging - I cant afford butcher, fruit and veg shop, zero waste shops are too much
● Grow fruit and veg (loads of community gardens and allotments to pick from, now I have a garden I have space, it was a barrier living in a flat), my grandparents had fruit trees so I got fruit from them
●Buy mostly second hand (easy its cheaper)
●Save water (easy with small children sharing a bath, use the bath water in the garden etc
● Passing on used clothes/ toys- Charity shops collect round here but you need to have more than 20 black bags worth. So it's easy when we have a massive sort through.
○Buying things that last- Tricky for us, we buy about 3 pairs of rubbish s hool shoes per child per year. I can't afford the upfront cost of a better pair and to be honest I thought £20 was expensive for school shoes
○Recycling- we didn't have Recycling bins in our flat, I've recently moved and have normal and Recycling bin. The council took all of the big recycling bins when they gave residents Recycling bins but people in flats didn't get one.
●Electric and gas usage, even before the cost of living we live in terrace and a flat so it was easy enough t o keep the house warm with little heating. We didn't have central heating in our flat and used to only use hot water bottles and blankets to stay warm when we first moved out. It was scary when we had a newborn and it was freezing though. I used to make a den in the kids bunk bed and sleep in bottom bunk altogether when it was really cold. We didn't have heating in there for 7 years! Now we have heating after we moved it's difficult to not use it, but we only have it on about half hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. old habits and all. We were ready for the Cost of living crisis at least.

I can't think of any more right now, but the main barrier for me is plastic packaging.
If supermarkets gave the option I would buy without.
If the local bakery self bread fir less than £6 a loaf I'd come in every day.
I used to go to the butcher and fruit and veg shop but when I moved (5 min walk from an aldi and lidl) I stopped going, the cost and convenience of a supermarket has to win.
I'm a sahm so I have time to mess about with charity shops, a vegetable garden etc.

I want to know what everyone else's barriers are, in a perfect world I'd live in the shire and my food would come from next door.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lenfir · 10/05/2023 14:18

We don't have a car which is fine as we're in Central London.

Wouldn't use a bicycle in London as I'm aware of too many accidents, and thefts.

Fly a few times a year not loads, but visit family and also like to visit other countries for tourism. Prefer Eurostar when it's an option.

Eat meat daily, as I like the taste and veggie options are uninspiring.

All food is bought from supermarkets and have lots of packaging. It's the most convenient option as we can get a weekly delivery at a reliable time slot.

Disposable nappies because I find it hard enough to keep on top of laundry as it is, it's far more convenient.

But I've used the same mooncup for half a decade as it's cheap and reliable.

Don't want to grow fruit or veg as we have a tiny garden which is used entirely as the dc's play area. And I probably couldn't be bothered with all the planting and watering even if we had a bigger garden.

Would like solar panels but the cost efficiency doesn't seem worth it.

I have 3dc, which is probably too many, but they're here now. The youngest mostly has hand me down stuff though.

OnNaturesCourse · 10/05/2023 14:05

(not read the whole thread...)

My biggest stall is the initial expense of setting up for being sustainable for most things.

  • the cost of reusable nappies (although I have found some secondhand but unfortunately they don't fit my huge toddler)
  • the cost of water butts and garden compost bins
  • "green" stores that are atleast 50% more expensive than brand bought in super markets.
  • expense of setting up the garden to grow my own food.

We are in a lower income family and most month we just get by so don't have the upfront cost of setting things up despite knowing it would likely save us money once set up.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 14:04

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 14:00

It really isn't. The 20 percent figure includes all aspects of transport, not just the actual running of the engine, but the making of the machines to make the vehicles.

It's a convenient statistic to use when trying to manipulate people but it's not really accurate. It doesn't take into account the remanufacture of other components from recycled vehicles or the reduction in net carbon emissions from driving an old vehicle. For example, making a new EV is environmental suicide compared to just running a 15 year old diesel.

No it doesn't, the 20% is scope 1 emissions only. You seriously are making yourself look silly.

You cannot compare the scope 3 emissions with scope 1.

Do you know anything about carbon accounting?

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 14:02

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:59

onefinemess name change fail?! 😆🧦

What?

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 14:00

It really isn't. The 20 percent figure includes all aspects of transport, not just the actual running of the engine, but the making of the machines to make the vehicles.

It's a convenient statistic to use when trying to manipulate people but it's not really accurate. It doesn't take into account the remanufacture of other components from recycled vehicles or the reduction in net carbon emissions from driving an old vehicle. For example, making a new EV is environmental suicide compared to just running a 15 year old diesel.

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:59

onefinemess name change fail?! 😆🧦

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 13:58

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:45

Bad Lad

The number of people on earth has little to do with each individual's climate impact. The carbon footprint of one person in the USA is many multiples that of one person in sub Saharan Africa. Consumption is the key issue here, rather than population.

But, as I'm sure you know, global birth rate is declining sharply, and global population is predicted to go into reverse sometime around the 2060s. It would probably be declining already if it wasn't for the fact that people aren't dying young as much as they used to.

So your clever "gotcha" wasn't quite as clever as you think 🙄

Some sense at last.

CalistoNoSolo · 10/05/2023 13:58

Taliban ffs

CalistoNoSolo · 10/05/2023 13:56

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 13:28

Transport is responsible for less than 2 percent of worldwide carbon emissions.

You could stop every single ICE vehicle tomorrow and it would make diddly squat difference to the environment.

People cause pollution. Reduce the population and you reduce the pollution. It really is that simple.

If you actually care about the environment (and most people don't, even the previous posters are deluding themselves) you would stop doing the one thing which is killing this planet.

STOP. HAVING. CHILDREN.

If you have children, you have no voice when it comes to climate change. There is NOTHING you can do to mitigate the damage you have caused to the planet through your utterly selfish decision to have children.

The argument that "we need children to look after us in our old age and to pay taxes" is just fucking stupid. Society doesn't need either of those things.

How ridiculous and ironic is it to educate children to be good little climate warriors when it's their literal existence that is the cause of the problem in the first place.

We need a carefully managed worldwide depopulation. There should be financial incentives for childless people, and massive tax hikes for those who choose to damage the planet by having them. Villages cleared first, no children to replace the adults, then towns, then cities and eventually whole countries and states.

The immediate goal should be a fifty percent worldwide reduction in the number of children.

But none of you have the stomach for that, so instead you just fiddle about with ULEZ, and recycling your yoghurt pots. It gives you something to do, keeps you distracted, so you can congratulate yourselves for being such good little Green Soldiers.

It's the elephant in the room and political suicide as a manifesto pledge. I fully support education of and free birth control for women in third world countries but when you have medieval loons like the talisman popping up everywhere and being funded by the likes of Putin and Xi, there really is very little hope for the planet and its non-human residents.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 13:56

SusiePevensie · 10/05/2023 13:40

Single biggest thing is not flying.

Don't be ridiculous. The utter ignorance on this thread is astounding.

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 13:52

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:45

Bad Lad

The number of people on earth has little to do with each individual's climate impact. The carbon footprint of one person in the USA is many multiples that of one person in sub Saharan Africa. Consumption is the key issue here, rather than population.

But, as I'm sure you know, global birth rate is declining sharply, and global population is predicted to go into reverse sometime around the 2060s. It would probably be declining already if it wasn't for the fact that people aren't dying young as much as they used to.

So your clever "gotcha" wasn't quite as clever as you think 🙄

I wasn't being clever.

And it's irrelevant where people live. Whether you have a tract home in suburban Detroit, or sleep on a plank in the middle of a slum in Mumbai, you need to stop having children.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 13:50

@onefinemess transport is responsible for almost 20% of emissions, you haven't a clue what you're talking about.

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 13:47

SusiePevensie · 10/05/2023 13:40

Single biggest thing is not flying.

Nonsense.

Flying is actually an incredibly efficient and environmentally friendly mode of mass transit.

You have fallen for the green propaganda.

Agriculture is way more damaging to the environment. Carbon emissions of 1.7% and 22% respectively.

If you want to decry anything it should be beef burgers, not jet engines.

BadLad · 10/05/2023 13:47

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:45

Bad Lad

The number of people on earth has little to do with each individual's climate impact. The carbon footprint of one person in the USA is many multiples that of one person in sub Saharan Africa. Consumption is the key issue here, rather than population.

But, as I'm sure you know, global birth rate is declining sharply, and global population is predicted to go into reverse sometime around the 2060s. It would probably be declining already if it wasn't for the fact that people aren't dying young as much as they used to.

So your clever "gotcha" wasn't quite as clever as you think 🙄

So your clever "gotcha" wasn't quite as clever as you think

Neither is yours, considering I didn’t actually say any of that.

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:45

Bad Lad

The number of people on earth has little to do with each individual's climate impact. The carbon footprint of one person in the USA is many multiples that of one person in sub Saharan Africa. Consumption is the key issue here, rather than population.

But, as I'm sure you know, global birth rate is declining sharply, and global population is predicted to go into reverse sometime around the 2060s. It would probably be declining already if it wasn't for the fact that people aren't dying young as much as they used to.

So your clever "gotcha" wasn't quite as clever as you think 🙄

SusiePevensie · 10/05/2023 13:40

Single biggest thing is not flying.

BeethovenNinth · 10/05/2023 13:39

I have been interested in this for more than a decade. I barely fly. I was using refill lentils before it was trendy.

I am now completely and utterly disengaged. I actually feel like doing the opposite now. It feels like an attack on the ordinary poor person whilst the rich jet around. The push for net zero means fuel poverty. My barely used old car is banned from the cit centre yes the move to electric doesn’t stack up. Everything is made very hard and the costs prohibitive

i feel it’s turned to another way to control the masses.

so I am giving up. I feel like rebelling.

if I felt like everyone shared the pain and it wasn’t nonsensical in many ways I might change my mind.

crackofdoom · 10/05/2023 13:37

A lot of progress has been made, and we shouldn't discount that. The need to combat climate change has rocketed in public awareness worldwide over the last few years. Politicians openly acknowledge the need to do something- all they need to do now is actually do something 🙄 On a national level, I thought the massive uptick in the election of Green councillors in the local elections was significant. But there is a massive amount more to do, in the face of malicious counter briefing, as demonstrated on this thread 🙄

The received wisdom that living sustainably will mean a drop in living standards is an example of this. I would rather live in a well insulated house than a draughty one that costs £££ to heat. I would rather have cheap electricity from wind and solar than expensive electricity from coal and gas. I would rather charge an electric car than pay a fortune filling up with diesel. I would rather live in a green, leafy, low traffic neighbourhood than by the side of a bleak 4 lane highway. I would rather travel by clean, cheap public transport than spend hours sitting in traffic jams in my car. All these would be both improvements to one's quality of life AND examples of living sustainably.

BadLad · 10/05/2023 13:34

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 13:28

Transport is responsible for less than 2 percent of worldwide carbon emissions.

You could stop every single ICE vehicle tomorrow and it would make diddly squat difference to the environment.

People cause pollution. Reduce the population and you reduce the pollution. It really is that simple.

If you actually care about the environment (and most people don't, even the previous posters are deluding themselves) you would stop doing the one thing which is killing this planet.

STOP. HAVING. CHILDREN.

If you have children, you have no voice when it comes to climate change. There is NOTHING you can do to mitigate the damage you have caused to the planet through your utterly selfish decision to have children.

The argument that "we need children to look after us in our old age and to pay taxes" is just fucking stupid. Society doesn't need either of those things.

How ridiculous and ironic is it to educate children to be good little climate warriors when it's their literal existence that is the cause of the problem in the first place.

We need a carefully managed worldwide depopulation. There should be financial incentives for childless people, and massive tax hikes for those who choose to damage the planet by having them. Villages cleared first, no children to replace the adults, then towns, then cities and eventually whole countries and states.

The immediate goal should be a fifty percent worldwide reduction in the number of children.

But none of you have the stomach for that, so instead you just fiddle about with ULEZ, and recycling your yoghurt pots. It gives you something to do, keeps you distracted, so you can congratulate yourselves for being such good little Green Soldiers.

(Grabs popcorn, waits for replies).

whoateallthecookies · 10/05/2023 13:34

We've been able to keep our transport costs right down by living fairly centrally in a small city, so we walk or cycle almost everywhere - most years I travel further by bike than by car (and we do have a car). However the house was expensive, and we are privileged to be able to live here. Many people don't have that choice.

Also, we're currently healthy. At one point DH had to drive to work as he wasn't well enough to cycle. Thankfully he's now much better, but I have friends with blue badges who work, and for whom there's no alternative to using a car.

onefinemess · 10/05/2023 13:28

Transport is responsible for less than 2 percent of worldwide carbon emissions.

You could stop every single ICE vehicle tomorrow and it would make diddly squat difference to the environment.

People cause pollution. Reduce the population and you reduce the pollution. It really is that simple.

If you actually care about the environment (and most people don't, even the previous posters are deluding themselves) you would stop doing the one thing which is killing this planet.

STOP. HAVING. CHILDREN.

If you have children, you have no voice when it comes to climate change. There is NOTHING you can do to mitigate the damage you have caused to the planet through your utterly selfish decision to have children.

The argument that "we need children to look after us in our old age and to pay taxes" is just fucking stupid. Society doesn't need either of those things.

How ridiculous and ironic is it to educate children to be good little climate warriors when it's their literal existence that is the cause of the problem in the first place.

We need a carefully managed worldwide depopulation. There should be financial incentives for childless people, and massive tax hikes for those who choose to damage the planet by having them. Villages cleared first, no children to replace the adults, then towns, then cities and eventually whole countries and states.

The immediate goal should be a fifty percent worldwide reduction in the number of children.

But none of you have the stomach for that, so instead you just fiddle about with ULEZ, and recycling your yoghurt pots. It gives you something to do, keeps you distracted, so you can congratulate yourselves for being such good little Green Soldiers.

MouseTime · 10/05/2023 13:03

I send tweets to all the hypocritical supermarkets that stock items that are over-packed as heck. It annoys me so much. The likes of Waitrose and Marks drone on about sustainability yet they double and triple package things using the most packaging possible.

👎🏻I drive a diesel biggish car
👎🏻I fly way too much. My husband has lifetime BA gold membership he has flown so much. His carbon footprint must be huge.
👍🏻recycling
🫳🏼public transport
👍🏻cycling and walking
🫳🏼House and general energy usage
👍🏻buying second hand/re-purposing etc

👍🏻Try and buy local food

I suspect I'm very 'average' in my approach to these things. When you look at what China, India, USA, Russia chuck out I wonder why I bother sometimes.

At least I try not to be a hypocrite about things. I know people who are very keen to be seen to be green but their behaviour contradicts their desired image.

Celebs, politicians and the Royals are often awful for this.

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 12:56

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 12:42

We are all living unsustainably, and will most likely continue to until we kill our race off.

I don't know, we won't give up without a fight.
I mean look at what we've accomplished.
The human races problem is that we have too comfortable lives (sorry, I know not everyone but we do on this phone or computer have great lives) that's a pretty impressive problem to have, we made so much stuff to make life incredibly easy and pleasurable that it's going to kill us (and is already killing other species and people) its mental. you couldn't make it up

OP posts:
CiderRefresher · 10/05/2023 12:53

Public transport is where I struggle. I'd like to use the car less for longer journeys but buses are infrequent, often late or cancelled without notice. It's also dirty, overcrowded and expensive. When I make use of the incredible public transport in other countries it makes me wonder how we've got it so badly wrong.

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 12:42

dontlookbackyourenotgoingthatway · 10/05/2023 12:23

So you literally want to live, unsustainably? Is that right?

We are all living unsustainably, and will most likely continue to until we kill our race off.