Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are your barriers to sustainable living? What would it take for you to ^get there^?

191 replies

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:13

Inspired by yet another message from David Attenborough.

● Car - I can't afford one, DH gets to work in a company van (up to 10 men at a time) but he works all over so the emissions are still probably very high.
● Bicycle - Storage and cost was a problem before I moved out of my flat
● Public transport - great where I live and cheap.
○ Plastic packaging - I cant afford butcher, fruit and veg shop, zero waste shops are too much
● Grow fruit and veg (loads of community gardens and allotments to pick from, now I have a garden I have space, it was a barrier living in a flat), my grandparents had fruit trees so I got fruit from them
●Buy mostly second hand (easy its cheaper)
●Save water (easy with small children sharing a bath, use the bath water in the garden etc
● Passing on used clothes/ toys- Charity shops collect round here but you need to have more than 20 black bags worth. So it's easy when we have a massive sort through.
○Buying things that last- Tricky for us, we buy about 3 pairs of rubbish s hool shoes per child per year. I can't afford the upfront cost of a better pair and to be honest I thought £20 was expensive for school shoes
○Recycling- we didn't have Recycling bins in our flat, I've recently moved and have normal and Recycling bin. The council took all of the big recycling bins when they gave residents Recycling bins but people in flats didn't get one.
●Electric and gas usage, even before the cost of living we live in terrace and a flat so it was easy enough t o keep the house warm with little heating. We didn't have central heating in our flat and used to only use hot water bottles and blankets to stay warm when we first moved out. It was scary when we had a newborn and it was freezing though. I used to make a den in the kids bunk bed and sleep in bottom bunk altogether when it was really cold. We didn't have heating in there for 7 years! Now we have heating after we moved it's difficult to not use it, but we only have it on about half hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. old habits and all. We were ready for the Cost of living crisis at least.

I can't think of any more right now, but the main barrier for me is plastic packaging.
If supermarkets gave the option I would buy without.
If the local bakery self bread fir less than £6 a loaf I'd come in every day.
I used to go to the butcher and fruit and veg shop but when I moved (5 min walk from an aldi and lidl) I stopped going, the cost and convenience of a supermarket has to win.
I'm a sahm so I have time to mess about with charity shops, a vegetable garden etc.

I want to know what everyone else's barriers are, in a perfect world I'd live in the shire and my food would come from next door.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:49

user4750 · 11/05/2023 09:25

Unfortunately the batteries in EV cars last on average 10 years (to the extent that they can be used in the car). They then need replacing which whacks up their carbon footprint massively.

None of these issues are simple. I can recommend the book "How Bad are Bananas" its really well written and a fascinating read and it helps you to work through some of these dilemmas with properly researched facts and calculations carried out by a world leading scientist in this field (who is also British).

If you download the Polestar EPDs there's a really good comparison of ICE and EV carbon footprint. Current batteries have lifespan of 100,000 to 200,000 miles and can still be repurposed. So pretty much the same as a diesel.

greenspaceplace · 11/05/2023 09:32

That book sounds great, I'm currently in the middle of the secret life of trees and it's really changed the way I view them. Not quite on topic but if you're feeling down, trees love eachother haha 😆

OP posts:
MooseBreath · 11/05/2023 09:28

I used to cycle to work, but in all honesty, I was a danger on the roads. I am not good at riding a bicycle. I waver and fall at random and I stopped cycling because it wasn't safe for me or other people on the road. No way in hell would I do this with 2 children in tow.

Public transport is very expensive and basically non-existent where I live. Lugging around 2 children under 3 when the nearest bus stop is a 20 minute walk across a busy road to then ride to a shop that is another 5 minute walk from a bus stop to do groceries is far too difficult. Plus, buses only come twice per day.

Pretty much all supermarkets use plastic packaging. I buy loose produce where possible, but it's not feasible to avoid all plastic packaging. The local butcher and greengrocer are far too expensive for me.

My garden is small and won't even let grass seed take, so attempting to grow my own produce would be futile. I also don't enjoy gardening, but that's besides the point.

I wish I could buy better quality clothing and household items, but there is a definite cost barrier. I try not to buy poor quality, but when you can get a pair of children's shoes for £6 that would last 3 months instead of forking out £40 to last until they're outgrown in 6 months, I can't justify the hit on our finances at the moment.

We had our heating on more than usual this winter because we had a newborn. We're in a rental, so installing solar panels as if we could afford to isn't an option.

My family live in Canada, so we fly across the Atlantic every few years and my parents fly to visit us a few times per year. There isn't really a viable alternative to travel that far, so plane it is. I would also fly to a holiday destination if we had the money, but only once per year at most. British holidays are always rainy and expensive in my experience.

We eat meat 3-4 times per week, which I'd like to change, but in all honesty, I haven't found many vegetarian recipes that I like. I would not consider veganism, as I disagree with many of the principles involved, and if I'm drinking milk, eating cheese and wearing leather, I may as well utilize the full animal and eat the meat. Buying from an eco-friendly local butcher would be ideal, but as I said before is cost prohibitive.

I am conscious of the environment. I use secondhand clothing and items, maximalize use of everything we own, walk where possible, buy locally where possible, recycle, use eco-cycles on my washing machine and dishwasher, don't use disposable sanitary products, and conserve water with short showers twice per week and bathing the children together twice per week. Until big businesses and governments face up to the massive impact of their actions, I don't think changing anything else that my family does is worth the sacrifice in the grand scheme of things.

user4750 · 11/05/2023 09:25

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:16

Source = DEFRA, Cambridge University, KCL etc. There are a lot of peer reviewed studies. 40,000 is one of the higher estimates (root mean square) but not the highest, 28,000 is the lowest.

Why would an EV last 10 years if diesel car lasts 20? That makes no sense.

Unfortunately the batteries in EV cars last on average 10 years (to the extent that they can be used in the car). They then need replacing which whacks up their carbon footprint massively.

None of these issues are simple. I can recommend the book "How Bad are Bananas" its really well written and a fascinating read and it helps you to work through some of these dilemmas with properly researched facts and calculations carried out by a world leading scientist in this field (who is also British).

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:16

MintJulia · 11/05/2023 08:56

Source?

As another poster said, all vehicles produce particles. And there are plenty of other sources. Producing one diesel car that lasts 20years is more environmentally friendly than two electric cars that last 10 each.

Source = DEFRA, Cambridge University, KCL etc. There are a lot of peer reviewed studies. 40,000 is one of the higher estimates (root mean square) but not the highest, 28,000 is the lowest.

Why would an EV last 10 years if diesel car lasts 20? That makes no sense.

MintJulia · 11/05/2023 08:56

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 15:03

@onefinemess re your 15 year old diesel. 40,000 people a year die from particulate emission linked diseases. I hope your pleased with yourself? No doubt in your world a good day maybe most of these will be children.

Source?

As another poster said, all vehicles produce particles. And there are plenty of other sources. Producing one diesel car that lasts 20years is more environmentally friendly than two electric cars that last 10 each.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/05/2023 21:55

I try harder in some areas than others. We are relatively good at everything but travel but pretty rubbish at that

I’m unsure what we are doing makes any difference but if everyone does a little bit it can’t really hurt

NorthFaceofthelaundrypile · 10/05/2023 18:16

Proper cycle paths connecting all towns and villages. I would be more than happy to cycle the 9 mile to and from work if I didn’t have to cycle on the roads.

minipie · 10/05/2023 18:09

“what’s the point” is a massive one for me.

Frankly, I and a few other privileged individuals tinkering round the edges buying from plastic free shops is going to make sod all difference compared with the massive scale use of resources happening industrially and globally.

I hate waste and try to plan / use up / reuse / recycle/ donate wherever possible. But I’m not kidding myself it makes much difference.

What we really need is 1) global agreements, backed up by national legislation and 2) fewer humans being born. I believe both will happen but unfortunately not until things have got a lot worse environmentally.

Howmanysleepsnow · 10/05/2023 17:59

basically, cost is the biggest barrier. It’d be much easier if I could afford to insulate my home, treat mould, buy a more environmentally friendly car etc.
Time is another barrier. My commute would double on public transport (which I can’t manage with kids/ school to work around) and I can’t easily go to various grocers/ butchers/ bakers while out at work 8-6

Howmanysleepsnow · 10/05/2023 17:55

Car - i have an non eco friendly diesel car, would love something more economical or better still, electric, but can’t afford to replace. I only use the car for commuting or the vet really (elderly dog needs monthly visits and can’t walk that far). Otherwise I tend to walk

Public transport - I have a bit of a phobia of being attacked on it so it’s a no from me.

Plastic packaging - butcher, fruit and veg shop are only open Monday-Friday and I’m in work so I’m at the mercy of supermarkets

Grow fruit and veg- I have fruit trees, but there’s too many rats to feel safe eating anything low growing

Buy mostly second hand- yes. Or not but at all as I don’t have much disposable income.

Save water (easy with small children sharing a bath, don’t water the garden)

Passing on used clothes/ toys- Toys and books yes. Shoes/ clothes get worn until worn out.

Buying things that last- can’t afford this. But hardly buy anything unless replacing worn out stuff

Recycling- yes. Except soft plastic as no facility locally

Electric and gas usage- try to minimise, though we have a damp / mould problem if heating is off unless we use a dehumidifier

Semtee · 10/05/2023 17:43

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:37

Biodegradable nappies are basically a myth. Nothing can biodegrade in a landfill. So you'd have to compost those nappies and it's probably like those biodegradable bags that I used to buy, they sit in a compost bin for years not biodegrading. There are products marketed as Bio Degradable or degradable which is plastic that degrades, not good for anything. If the worms don't eat it, it's not good.

There was a really good documentary about green washing and how companies can claim something is biodegradable but it isn't really.
I'll Tey to find it. The do the same with 'organic'. There are factory farmed chickens that are labelled organic but not free range, not organic in the sense we think but technically its allowed to be labelled as such.
green washing where companies make it seem like something is eco but it isn't.

Don't know if it's already been covered but they absolutely do compost, just as long as you don't wrap them up really tight. Wee is very good for soil. We don't compost pooey ones and use reusables in the day. Potty training at just turning 2 rather than 3 is a big thing you can do to reduce nappy usage, but a lot of people think their children aren't ready (probably unlikely in most cases as it's very much the norm in other countries and was here until at least the 1980s).

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 17:37

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 17:11

Running an old diesel car is more environmentally damaging than a new EV after about 150,000km. Lot's of studies to support that.

The study into non exhaust particulate emissions was dodgy at best, and beyond was really badly reported. I suspect you haven't read the paper, I have.

Woodburners should be banned in suburban and urban areas. Agreed.

It is well recognised that there are approximately (no statistic is 100% certain) 40,000 deaths in the UK each year due to particulate emissions. If you really don't think this is an issue there are some absolute bargain properties next to congestion hot spots - fill your boots.

It is well recognised that there are approximately (no statistic is 100% certain) 40,000 deaths in the UK each year due to particulate emissions.
That's simply incorrect.
The 40K estimate is based on a combination of estimates of NoX and particulate deaths. You are misrepresenting it.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-39129270

Exhaust fumes from a car

Reality Check: Does pollution cut short 40,000 lives a year?

Where does the figure of 40,000 early deaths per year in the UK come from?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-39129270

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 17:24

@Lcb123 Have an energy supplier which does renewable electricity

These are scope 2 emissions and quite possibly, alongside traveling, this is the single biggest thing a household can do. It's simple, costs little, no hassle or inconvenience.

Genuinely fabulous 🤩

Sparklybutold · 10/05/2023 17:22

Money

Using maslows hierarchy - I feel in survival mode. Being sustainable requires an extra layer of thinking I just don't have the capacity for.

Bananah · 10/05/2023 17:16

Where I live there’s a 20 year waiting list for an allotment. A house with a garden big enough to grow veg will set you back best part of a million pounds. Pretty much nobody is growing veg even though they’d like to.

And I can’t use zero waste shops because of the risk of cross contamination. If someone puts a scoop in the flour then uses the same scoop on the rice, the rice is contaminated with wheat and will make me sick. I need food sealed in plastic (or similar) at the factory so it doesn’t touch other food.

Everything is miles away (school would be a 90 minute walk, cycling to work would take 3hrs) so we need a car.

The fact is, our society is set up in a way that is not environmentally friendly and it’s impossible to change it. We can’t have unwrapped food at supermarkets because of the risk of contamination or tampering. We can’t walk or cycle because everything is too spread out. We don’t have the infrastructure for everyone to have an electric car. House prices make it impossible for people to have gardens, new build plots are too small. Etc.

gogohmm · 10/05/2023 17:11

I can't use public transport because first bus of the day is 10am and they are every 2 hours (that bus takes 22 minutes, the only other routing takes 1 hour 45, car takes 14 minutes) no space to grow veg as all gardens are size of postage stamps (have 6 pots of herbs), no greengrocer in town, butcher is a luxury one 5x price of lidl, no fishmonger.

On the positive side I have a house built to very high energy efficiency so heating switches off mostly. I have triple glazing etc.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 17:11

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 16:30

A ridiculous response. That figure is an estimate, and doesn't relate solely to particulate emissions.
All motor vehicles emit particulates - yes even electric ones from tyres and brakes.
Another very significant source of particulates is wood burners.
This ridiculous ignorance about diesel cars is silly.
Running an old diesel car while it's still viable actually saves the earth's resources, and the uncomfortable (for many) truth is that diesels are better in terms of carbon emissions.
It's ridiculous over-simplification of this type that just shows up wannabe eco-warriors as bandwagon jumping frauds.

Running an old diesel car is more environmentally damaging than a new EV after about 150,000km. Lot's of studies to support that.

The study into non exhaust particulate emissions was dodgy at best, and beyond was really badly reported. I suspect you haven't read the paper, I have.

Woodburners should be banned in suburban and urban areas. Agreed.

It is well recognised that there are approximately (no statistic is 100% certain) 40,000 deaths in the UK each year due to particulate emissions. If you really don't think this is an issue there are some absolute bargain properties next to congestion hot spots - fill your boots.

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 16:57

@Garethkeenansstapler 100% recyclable, the public would be in uproar as the prices would be astronomical.

It's called extended producer responsibility. Current rules cover cars at 85% recyclable content and WEII which covers electrical goods.

Lcb123 · 10/05/2023 16:52

Similar to you. We have chosen spend more on living in a town centre and therefore have minimal car use because we can walk and regular buses. Our car is a self charging hybrid.
I take soft plastics to the recycling at Tescos so at least, hopefully, it's recycled.
Minimal meat, usually 3-4 dinners a week and never for lunch.
Try and only buy fruit and veg grown in UK, or at least in Europe
I rarely buy new clothes, get almost everything from Vinted.
Never flown in the UK, and we get the train a lot rather than driving in the UK.
Never have any food waste at home, and always free range eggs.
Have an energy supplier which does renewable electricity.
We're moving to a house soon after years in a flat, I'm very excited to grow veg!

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 10/05/2023 16:45

Public transport is dreadful around us. I occasionally work til 7pm and there are no buses at that time of night. Dh would have to either change buses or do a combo of bus or car to the station for his commute. It currently takes him 40 minutes by car but would take 2 hours roughly every other way. We manage with only one car just.

We buy all our limited red meat from a farm a 10 minute walk away and regularly visit farmers markets/farm shops for vegetables/meat/Seafood. I grow herbs and my mil grows most of our vegetables in summer as well as loads of fruit.

School is a 2 min walk.

The house is old and stone but seems to keep heat well plus we have loads of extra blankets lying around.

We buy a lot of second hand clothes and toys as well as passing on things our kids outgrow. I use the library a lot and books I do buy I give to friends/put in the village free book box. Shoes etc I buy "good" so they last but I know we are lucky to be able to do that.

We limit flights.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 10/05/2023 16:44

We holiday in the U.K., recycle, have meat free nights, buy our milk from a vending machine at the village farm. We do have children and I do drive a 1.2 car but work in rural community nursing covering a wide rural area so public transport isn’t going to work and our area is not yet ready for electric cars as well as I don’t have a drive. The need for community nurses is not going to stop any time soon so I will always need a car.

masses of waste from the nhs of course but no idea how to tackle this e.g. those with leg ulcers and compression bandaging not being able to be used again etc not to mention the dressings used as well as

Neededanewuserhandle · 10/05/2023 16:30

Daftasabroom · 10/05/2023 15:03

@onefinemess re your 15 year old diesel. 40,000 people a year die from particulate emission linked diseases. I hope your pleased with yourself? No doubt in your world a good day maybe most of these will be children.

A ridiculous response. That figure is an estimate, and doesn't relate solely to particulate emissions.
All motor vehicles emit particulates - yes even electric ones from tyres and brakes.
Another very significant source of particulates is wood burners.
This ridiculous ignorance about diesel cars is silly.
Running an old diesel car while it's still viable actually saves the earth's resources, and the uncomfortable (for many) truth is that diesels are better in terms of carbon emissions.
It's ridiculous over-simplification of this type that just shows up wannabe eco-warriors as bandwagon jumping frauds.

Lemonademoney · 10/05/2023 16:28

We are trying to be more conscious… we drive much less than we did although I plan to cut it down further this year.

We eat a lot less meat than we did. Again could probably cut it down more. Also eat much less dairy than we used to although still eat a lot of eggs.

We have always been very meagre with heating. We mainly shower/kids share bath water.

We recycle all of our clothing and buy second hand books or download onto a kindle.

We have just ordered a water butt for the garden and I would love to add solar panels as we are south facing but the cost is prohibitive.

The tumble dryer is all but redundant…

We have lots of trees and our flower beds are full of pollinator friendly plants. We have nesting boxes on the far end of the garden with blue tits.

BUT we do wash clothes a lot as our children are still very young. And we do go abroad once a year most years. Too much of our food comes plastic wrapped which irks me - I’m slowly trying to shift us all always from plastic wrapped snacks but it’s easier said than done.

MintJulia · 10/05/2023 16:20

Car - I wfh 4 days a week but need car for school run and 1 day commuting. 9,000 miles per year.

Heat - we have a wood burner and I cut and stack our own wood all year so I use less gas then most. Utilities in last 12 months were about £1200. House is well insulated.

Food - I grow most of our veg/salad in the summer plus some fruit. Obviously not in the winter. I buy local meat, normally chicken, pork or venison. Hardly ever beef or lamb. We eat some fish.

Water - we use about half of normal level for two people.

Flights - every four or five years.

I do my best to keep our carbon footprint down. Try to recycle most things. Generate a wheelie bin of rubbish about every 6/7 weeks.