Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are your barriers to sustainable living? What would it take for you to ^get there^?

191 replies

greenspaceplace · 10/05/2023 10:13

Inspired by yet another message from David Attenborough.

● Car - I can't afford one, DH gets to work in a company van (up to 10 men at a time) but he works all over so the emissions are still probably very high.
● Bicycle - Storage and cost was a problem before I moved out of my flat
● Public transport - great where I live and cheap.
○ Plastic packaging - I cant afford butcher, fruit and veg shop, zero waste shops are too much
● Grow fruit and veg (loads of community gardens and allotments to pick from, now I have a garden I have space, it was a barrier living in a flat), my grandparents had fruit trees so I got fruit from them
●Buy mostly second hand (easy its cheaper)
●Save water (easy with small children sharing a bath, use the bath water in the garden etc
● Passing on used clothes/ toys- Charity shops collect round here but you need to have more than 20 black bags worth. So it's easy when we have a massive sort through.
○Buying things that last- Tricky for us, we buy about 3 pairs of rubbish s hool shoes per child per year. I can't afford the upfront cost of a better pair and to be honest I thought £20 was expensive for school shoes
○Recycling- we didn't have Recycling bins in our flat, I've recently moved and have normal and Recycling bin. The council took all of the big recycling bins when they gave residents Recycling bins but people in flats didn't get one.
●Electric and gas usage, even before the cost of living we live in terrace and a flat so it was easy enough t o keep the house warm with little heating. We didn't have central heating in our flat and used to only use hot water bottles and blankets to stay warm when we first moved out. It was scary when we had a newborn and it was freezing though. I used to make a den in the kids bunk bed and sleep in bottom bunk altogether when it was really cold. We didn't have heating in there for 7 years! Now we have heating after we moved it's difficult to not use it, but we only have it on about half hour in the morning and an hour in the evening. old habits and all. We were ready for the Cost of living crisis at least.

I can't think of any more right now, but the main barrier for me is plastic packaging.
If supermarkets gave the option I would buy without.
If the local bakery self bread fir less than £6 a loaf I'd come in every day.
I used to go to the butcher and fruit and veg shop but when I moved (5 min walk from an aldi and lidl) I stopped going, the cost and convenience of a supermarket has to win.
I'm a sahm so I have time to mess about with charity shops, a vegetable garden etc.

I want to know what everyone else's barriers are, in a perfect world I'd live in the shire and my food would come from next door.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 12:57

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 12:29

My quote was 40,000 people a year die from particulate emission linked diseases I didn't link all of those to diesel cars,
You are still misrepresenting the science. The 40K figure is a combined estimate for excess deaths from NoX and particulate emissions. It does not solely refer to particulate emissions and no amount of misrepresentation by you or other posters will change that.

And the biggest source of NOx is?

Diesel engines.

roundcork · 11/05/2023 12:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

Gettingbysomehow · 11/05/2023 12:46

I can't not have a car as I work all over the county for the NHS but I have a lease car, I do not own my own. The local public transport is useless.

I can't ride a bike as I need knee replacements for osteoarthritis.

I eat a strictly vegetarian diet and I can easily grow all of my veg at home for the summer. Winter I buy frozen so there is zero food waste.

I avoid all plastic where possible and buy bees wax food wraps, eco toothbrushes and shampoo and conditioner bars wrapped in cardboard but some plastic things you can do nothing about such as the plastic wrapped around tofu etc. All these things are higher cost but I can afford it at the moment.

All my furniture is recycled.

I never bath only shower for 5 mins.

All my "junk" goes to charity shops. I don't buy much. I have a very small wardrobe and prefer clothes made in the UK. Again much more expensive so I have a capsule wardrobe.

Recycling - everythng is recycled. Food as its vegetarian goes into my compost heap. I only have a courtyard garen but I've got a full sized tree in it - essential for wildlife.

Electric and gas usage, absolutely minimal as I have a super insulated house. The builder in the 1990s had the foresight to put in sound proofing, double glazing and insulation so I don't need the heating on for most of winter.

My biggest eco saving is having only one child. My DS is not having any - he's 40 this year. No more consumers being born here.

TwinkleSprite · 11/05/2023 12:38

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 12:24

ULEZ to cover all/most cars and not penalise 0.1% of older cars, tight restrictions on when drivewaysand fake grassare allowed,
Care to elaborate on these?

ULEZ expansion in London is pointless and only affects very old cars, meanwhile people are free to idle and drive their 4x4s for 5 minute journeys as they are ULEZ compliant.

Driveways are destroying habitats as people pace over the whole thing. It's also just plain ugly a lot of the time. Same applies to fake grass. Imagine how things would be if everyone did this to their house.

Bumdealoftheweek · 11/05/2023 12:32

Time and money are our biggest barrier. If I didn't work I would spend a lot more of my time making our lives more sustainable - grow more of my own veg, have chickens and cook better meals with higher quality produce. I also wouldn't need to commute. Public transport is nonexistent near us so I spend a lot of time in the car.

I do my best at the moment. We have an electric car and have solar panels on our house. I cook from scratch 85% of the time - this includes making all our bread, pastry and sauces eg pesto . We buy very little ultra processed food which means that we don't have that much plastic packaging although we do recycle. We have insulated our house as much as possible and we hope to do more.

It does often feel like a pointless struggle but I think if we all make a conscious effort on an individual level then we might start to influence the direction of the companies that control us.

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 12:29

My quote was 40,000 people a year die from particulate emission linked diseases I didn't link all of those to diesel cars,
You are still misrepresenting the science. The 40K figure is a combined estimate for excess deaths from NoX and particulate emissions. It does not solely refer to particulate emissions and no amount of misrepresentation by you or other posters will change that.

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 12:24

ULEZ to cover all/most cars and not penalise 0.1% of older cars, tight restrictions on when drivewaysand fake grassare allowed,
Care to elaborate on these?

Nicecow · 11/05/2023 12:21

It seems a bit silly to say you're doing your bit if you have solar panels etc if you have children and/or pets ... Hmm

NotAnotherBathBomb · 11/05/2023 12:09

Money. It's that's simple.

I have to work long hours across the week to maintain a basic existence. I don't have the time or mental headspace to devote it to anything outside of that.

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 12:09

And start/stop technology has been available for well over twenty years and should have been compulsory a long time ago.

TwinkleSprite · 11/05/2023 12:05

TwinkleSprite · 11/05/2023 11:56

STOP. HAVING. CHILDREN. @onefinemess

You're calling other people delusional yet you somehow think it's realistic for people to give up on having children. Continuing their family. Something so important for many people.

This is the height of decision. It if FINE. TO. HAVE. CHILDREN. as long as it's not an excessive number and you do your best.

Caring about the environment doesn't mean give up on your own aspirations (meanwhile having to watch other people do those same things). You don't have to martyr yourself. Balance. Just stick to 1 or 2.

Also, without children there's little reason to care about sustainability for the future. I'd be flying out and doing all sorts, not caring about any of that. The answer is have fewer children, not give up your aspirations and live a miserable life. Futile and recipe for depression.

Imagine the resentment you'd feel about giving up on having children and having to watch everyone else still do it, and not only that, still damage the environment. That's not a healthy way to do things. It's too much for many people. Giving up a car or small conveniences is one thing... just not comparable.

TwinkleSprite · 11/05/2023 11:58

I really want to see bigger change like banning disposable plastics in many cases, restrictions on fast fashion, ULEZ to cover all/most cars and not penalise 0.1% of older cars, tight restrictions on when driveways and fake grass are allowed, sustainable farming practices to be the norm etc.

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 11:58

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 11:34

The 40K deaths is being repeatedly misrepresented on this thread.
It's a decent study but it is NOT 40K deaths from diesel cars.

My quote was 40,000 people a year die from particulate emission linked diseases I didn't link all of those to diesel cars, but it's undeniable that old diesels will have vastly more PM2.5 and PM10 than an electric vehicle.

The particulate study alluded to upthread referring to brake and tyre emissions has been misrepresented by the group that commissioned the study and even more so by the media. The study collected roadside data over a period of time, what it found was that the PM in the air could be orders of magnitude higher than the tail pipe PM emissions from the most modern EU6 diesels. Dig deep and the report explains that the PM suspended in the air after a dry spell is cumulative from all the vehicles (not just cars) that have passed that point over a period of time. The press release stated that PM suspended in the air, including tyre and brake dust, could be up to 1000 times the tail pipe emissions of a single car. The media spun this to "tyre and brake emissions are 1000 time tail pipe".

As @user4750 said it's complicated, particularly when the science is so badly reported in the press.

Don't get me started on Cows and water.

TwinkleSprite · 11/05/2023 11:56

STOP. HAVING. CHILDREN. @onefinemess

You're calling other people delusional yet you somehow think it's realistic for people to give up on having children. Continuing their family. Something so important for many people.

This is the height of decision. It if FINE. TO. HAVE. CHILDREN. as long as it's not an excessive number and you do your best.

Caring about the environment doesn't mean give up on your own aspirations (meanwhile having to watch other people do those same things). You don't have to martyr yourself. Balance. Just stick to 1 or 2.

Scalottia · 11/05/2023 11:48

I do as much as I can...I think.

• electric car
• solar panels
• very good insulation and triple-glazed windows
• recycling of everything possible
• no children
• fruit/vegetable garden
• eat seasonal food (mostly...still working on this)
• as little foodwaste as possible and a green bin/compost
• don't use any disposable wipes etc
• no fast fashion etc, wear my clothes for ages, don't bother to keep up with trends
• use public transport very often (am lucky that it's good here).

Maybe I can do more. I have pets and I know that isn't great either (carbon footprint).

It's hard though isn't it. I agree that big corporations are so much worse. I just hope my actions help a tiny bit.

essaytwenty · 11/05/2023 11:36

We are totally off-grid. Solar for electricity, although this does have to be supplemented occasionally by a generator during the winter. Heating is by wood. Cooking is wood or bottled gas.

The downside is can’t generate enough power to charge an electric car and the nearest public charger is nearly ten miles away. We also need a 4x4 that will work off-road and that isn’t even an option for EVs yet, as far as I know.

Public transport is practically non-existent.

We recycle virtually everything and a good proportion of our clothes are secondhand as are other things we buy.

Neededanewuserhandle · 11/05/2023 11:34

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:16

Source = DEFRA, Cambridge University, KCL etc. There are a lot of peer reviewed studies. 40,000 is one of the higher estimates (root mean square) but not the highest, 28,000 is the lowest.

Why would an EV last 10 years if diesel car lasts 20? That makes no sense.

The 40K deaths is being repeatedly misrepresented on this thread.
It's a decent study but it is NOT 40K deaths from diesel cars.

Scalottia · 11/05/2023 11:28

Poursomesugaronme88 · 10/05/2023 10:20

Disposable nappies should be fully biodegradable as standard and not cost more than others. Same for baby wipes

Better yet, have fewer kids. Or at least stop using so many baby wipes and disposable nappies.

cupofdecaf · 11/05/2023 10:57

We recycle what we can, buy second hand where we can, save rain water, reusable nappies, solar panels.
However public transport is rubbish where we live. Even when we lived in a city it was slow and unreliable.
Recycling some plastics is difficult and needs improving.
The amount we put in landfill or burn makes me cringe, everything I throw away but the recycling just isn't there.
People in older houses (not us but we know plenty) need help insulating in a way that's cost effective and won't cause damp.
We have a hybrid but would like our next car to be electric. I'm concerned about the metals used in the batteries. There also needs to be many more public charging points and they need to charge faster. We tried an electric car a couple of years ago and charging it was a bit of a flop.

MintJulia · 11/05/2023 10:47

And to be fair, my last diesel did 243,000 miles before I sold it on with a full MOT. It is not unusual for some marques of diesel car to clock up half a million miles.

My current diesel is a Group 6 so as clean as they get, and is regularly serviced.

I'll move to an EV when I retire in a few years, and range/immediacy are not so essential.

user4750 · 11/05/2023 10:22

Oh sorry I misread. I will find the stats for you. The reason the warranty is 100,000 miles is because that’s when the degradation issues set in. Most people of course do more than 10,000 miles a year so will reach 100,000 miles before ten years have passed

user4750 · 11/05/2023 10:21

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:53

@user4750 a quick google shows the battery warranty is generally 100,000 miles not the lifespan.

Aka an average of ten years.. if you do 10,000 miles a year after ten years you’re at 100,000 miles.

Clearly there will be differences between users which is why you can only look at averages.

im all for electric cars but the carbon footprint issue is not simple

JuneShitfield · 11/05/2023 10:01

I recycle, I vote for parties/candidates who have clear renewables/progressive environmental policies, I don't have kids, and I try to make things last. Beyond that I don't worry about it much.

Gtsr443 · 11/05/2023 09:56

I'm still trying to get my head round the fact that 2 fossil fuel fields in Turkmenistan created more global heating than the UK's entire carbon emissions in 2022.
We really are pissing in the wind.

I focus on personal plastic use, not pruning shrubs & hedges at wrong time of year, not over weeding, not using weed killer, encouraging pollinators etc.
We're not materialistic and have always been frugal with clothing and will make do and mend everything. Been veggy all my life.
If our rural public transport were better we'd use it all the time but without our car we are stuck.
We live in an AONB and the health of our rivers and waterways is of primary importance particularly as our Tory wanker MP has just voted against restrictions on water companies.

Daftasabroom · 11/05/2023 09:53

@user4750 a quick google shows the battery warranty is generally 100,000 miles not the lifespan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread