Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to leave "ideal" job

63 replies

Nordicrain · 10/05/2023 09:21

I have worked in my company for 13 years. In that time I have had decent progression and forged a career. I work a 4 day week in a senior "professional" job, and am relatively well paid. I can work from home as much as I likke, and I can basically do my job with my eyes closed. I have good benefits (car, private health insurance, etc). I get to travel to my home country with work once in a while so I can visit my family.

But I want to leave. I am paid less than I am worth IMO, my boss is impossible to talk to about anything like money or progression, the company is mainly men and has a rubbish gender pay gap. I think I am largely taken for granted. I just feel bored, fed up and disillusioned with it and struggle to see how I can progress from here. The last straw is a department restructure, where I am not demoted or anything, but not identified for progression either despite lots of great feedback, work achievements etc.

But I can't shake that I am throwing away the "ideal" job and I will regret it. Maybe I am just burnt out and a new job where I don't know what I am doing will just be worse. Has anyone done similar and how did it go? WIBU to walk away from a pretty cushty job?

OP posts:
Poppins2016 · 10/05/2023 21:41

Savoury · 10/05/2023 19:54

Is it a case that the people who are seeing progression work 5 days a week and are in the office more, but the boss is maybe too scared to say that to a woman?
This happened to me: the male bosses were too scared to say anything for fear of a discriminatory claim. The first woman boss I had said it outright. I changed my working practices and boom, got promoted.

Just a thought..

That was still discrimination... just happened to be discrimination by a woman and not a man!

https://www.gov.uk/part-time-worker-rights

Part-time workers' rights

Part-time workers should not be treated less favourably than full-time workers; employers' responsibilities and what part-time workers can do if they're treated unfairly

https://www.gov.uk/part-time-worker-rights

BeverlyHa · 10/05/2023 21:41

stay in the job and take up a hobby :)

ModestMoon · 10/05/2023 21:29

Doesn't have to be either / or! Apply for jobs that look better but which offer you the benefits that you care about. Leave when you've secured something you're happier with. That way it won't be throwing away an ideal job, it will be leveraging your experience to secure an even more ideal job. See you current job as a step in your progression.

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/05/2023 21:28

You will always regret what you didn’t do more than what you did.

It’s a cliche but true. You don’t want to get to the end of your working life and think that you wasted 40 years being undervalued and treading water. Some people really don’t care, but you do - so get on with making a move while you still have the patience to plan it sensibly.

Labraradabrador · 10/05/2023 21:20

Nordicrain · 10/05/2023 09:31

I suppose that's true. It's not so much ideal as very convenient.

I couldn't work somewhere else, that would be against my terms of employment, but I will start looking for something else I think. Like you say, i don't have to actually take another job if I don't think it compares.

get some advice on terms of employment. More than once an employer has tried to add terms that aren’t actually legal and/or enforceable- you might have fewer restrictions than you think.

missyC17 · 10/05/2023 21:12

From experience once you've made up your mind you've had enough, it's hard to keep going in a role which you've outgrown! It sounds like you need a new challenge.

Look for new jobs, take interviews but remember you don't have to take them. You'll get a good feeling if the right thing comes along.

It might even be that the interviews help you find a new love for your job, or make management realise that you need to be recognised. I guess sometimes if they think you are happy they will leave you be!

Stoic123 · 10/05/2023 21:00

Test the market by contacting agencies and then applying for jobs.

At the moment it's just a hypothetical dilemma as you don't anything else to go to or compare it with anyway.

A few years ago I moved from a very male dominated working environment to a much more female-friendly one. I'm much happier now, it's made a big difference.

Casuaala · 10/05/2023 20:50

OP, I left a very cushy job, ideal on paper, and very well-renumerated. I was desperately unhappy though and left without anything to go to. It was probably because I wanted to leave the industry completely, but I was incredibly naive to think that it would be easy to find a job as an over-qualified, middle-aged woman. It wasn't and things got a bit hairy.

If at all possible, I would advise getting your next job lined up before you hand your notice in.

TiaraBoo · 10/05/2023 20:44

I’d look around for other jobs but I’d also really push for the development and progression, not just with your boss- his boss? Other senior leaders? Get your face noticed more - you’ve got a solid 13 years there. Make them know your worth.
If that doesn’t work, at least you’ve built up a list of great things ready for interviews and you overcome those awkward feelings of trying to sell yourself and can negotiate a good salary/benefits package.

Crystaltipsvariation · 10/05/2023 20:42

I would not say you are a coward, just cautious about jumping out of the frying pan and into an empty grate. I imagine that you have already updated your CV and gone on LinkedIn etc. I would also take good stock of your ‘total compensation’ eg. It’s quite unusual to have a company car for a home based job. What would your ideal package look like if fringe benefits not comparable? What would your ideal job look like? You could approach this on two fronts. As others have said to explore the job market. The other is to think how your present job could be made more ideal? How could the company make better use of your experience and talents ( give them the ideas). Above all do try to have a meaningful talk with your manager. As a highly thought of employee they way not realise how unhappy you are. If there is a total refusal to engage then at least you know where you stand. Good Luck

mellicauli · 10/05/2023 20:34

What people are saying here all chime with my experience.

I am in a similar position to you in that I had the perfect ideal job at a time when professional part time jobs didn't exist. But I was part time and, unfortunately, that is the Mummy track where nothing interesting ever happens. I was overlooked for pay increases and professional challenges.

I did get progression in the end and a pay rise, after I went back full time for 5 years - but I could have done better if I'd moved around. On the other hand, I spent plenty of time with the kids, I paid the mortgage and minimised stress in a stressful period.

I think if you really want to keep your career alive you need to move. And if you don't move it will become increasingly difficult to do so as you start to age and look institutionalised.

Justalittlebitduckling · 10/05/2023 20:28

I don’t think it sounds ideal for you any more. I think you’re ready for a new challenge.

Mariposista · 10/05/2023 20:26

Life is too short to be in a job that makes you miserable. But make sure you have something to go to before you quit.

Pearfacebananapoop · 10/05/2023 20:12

I was you. But throw in a major restructure too. I've just changed job. It's early days and it is a shock to the system but I'm getting paid 40% more and working on more interesting projects. I think sometimes you have to make the move or you never will.

Stokey · 10/05/2023 20:09

Definitely see what's out there. Do you have a specific area of expertise? I'd imagine 13 years of experience would make you very employable elsewhere.

I've just moved after 5 years somewhere ( and after being passed over for promotion despite very positive EYRs etc). It was very freeing and nice to be wanted. I worked a 4 day week so whilst interviewing was clear with HR that I wanted to continue doing that and would ideally work hybrid 50:50. I got what I wanted, and a pay rise. I have the same amount of holidays and better health benefits now.

Sadly it's generally true that you need to move to get a decent pay rise.

Minierme · 10/05/2023 20:00

Get another job and a good salary offer then go back to your current company and say you’d like to stay but can they match the offer.

Gemst199 · 10/05/2023 19:59

If you have a skill (and it sounds like you do) then that kind of job is not unusual these days - I work for an insurance company and they've embraced work at home to the point that they're closing one of their two big offices and the smaller ones. I work 16 hours a week with no pressure to do more, lots of people do 3 or 4 days. If the kids are off school for some reason I can do my hours on a different day with no issues.
Career progression isn't a concern for me at the moment (I'd be doing more hours if it was) but I still get 3 monthly reviews to discuss what I want to do and how the company can support me. Pay is competitive.
This is my 4th job in probably the same amount of time you've worked with the same company (including 3 years of maternity leave), and each has been better than the one before. The last job I had definitely got worse the longer I stayed,and I think I stayed as long as I did due to a combination of fear and remembering what it was like when I started, when actually a lot of the things that had made it good weren't true anymore.
The point being you are not being unreasonable, and you should definitely put your CV on LinkedIn and see what happens.

Savoury · 10/05/2023 19:54

Is it a case that the people who are seeing progression work 5 days a week and are in the office more, but the boss is maybe too scared to say that to a woman?
This happened to me: the male bosses were too scared to say anything for fear of a discriminatory claim. The first woman boss I had said it outright. I changed my working practices and boom, got promoted.

Just a thought..

Couldntthinkofausername24 · 10/05/2023 18:52

I left my one and only job of 15 years back on 2021 and it was thr best decision I ever made. Yes it was scary being thr new person again and I had many sleepless nights but once I knew what I was doing I fit right in.

Follow your heart and look elsewhere. I too felt undervalued and couldn't move any further up the ladder. Was doing the same crap day in day out. My new place is completely opposite field and I love it

Good look @Nordicrain what ever you decide

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/05/2023 13:14

Nordicrain · 10/05/2023 13:01

Honestly this is part of what grates. I feel this is against EVERYTHING I believe in, and I am somehow complicit by putting up with it. But equally I am not prepared or motivated to take the battle about it here (mainly because where I have even tried before I was absolutely shot down and I can't be bothered with the greif it will cause), so I can't help but think I need to vote with my feet.

I worked somewhere similar. The boss was appalling. Actively paid newly qualified men more than extensively qualified and experienced women. He’d run away from me when I’d arrange meetings with him. Literally. It was astonishing. So I left. And I voiced exactly why in my exit meeting, to colleagues and to others in the industry who asked. It’s a very ‘networky’ business and fortunately, it only reflected poorly upon him.

Nordicrain · 10/05/2023 13:01

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/05/2023 12:36

Nothing is ‘ideal’ about a woman underpaid and taken for granted in a male dominated workplace, where the boss refuses to talk about progression or a pay increase in order to close a gender pay gap.

Honestly this is part of what grates. I feel this is against EVERYTHING I believe in, and I am somehow complicit by putting up with it. But equally I am not prepared or motivated to take the battle about it here (mainly because where I have even tried before I was absolutely shot down and I can't be bothered with the greif it will cause), so I can't help but think I need to vote with my feet.

OP posts:
Smoky1107 · 10/05/2023 12:42

I jumped for much the same reasons two years ago and regretted it almost immediately. I missed my job. I moved again a year later and I'm much much happier again, but it took two job moves it certainly wasn't easy

greennotepad · 10/05/2023 12:38

You will definitely be underpaid if you've been at a company for 13 years- the quickest way to advance your salary is to move jobs.

It sounds like you're bored which is understandable after so long- if you think you can find somewhere with better pay and comparable benefits then I would make the move!

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 10/05/2023 12:36

Nothing is ‘ideal’ about a woman underpaid and taken for granted in a male dominated workplace, where the boss refuses to talk about progression or a pay increase in order to close a gender pay gap.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 10/05/2023 10:16

i mean heaps of jobs have remote and flexible working now - so find a better one!

it's not unusual to work 4 days or work at home