Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to leave "ideal" job

63 replies

Nordicrain · 10/05/2023 09:21

I have worked in my company for 13 years. In that time I have had decent progression and forged a career. I work a 4 day week in a senior "professional" job, and am relatively well paid. I can work from home as much as I likke, and I can basically do my job with my eyes closed. I have good benefits (car, private health insurance, etc). I get to travel to my home country with work once in a while so I can visit my family.

But I want to leave. I am paid less than I am worth IMO, my boss is impossible to talk to about anything like money or progression, the company is mainly men and has a rubbish gender pay gap. I think I am largely taken for granted. I just feel bored, fed up and disillusioned with it and struggle to see how I can progress from here. The last straw is a department restructure, where I am not demoted or anything, but not identified for progression either despite lots of great feedback, work achievements etc.

But I can't shake that I am throwing away the "ideal" job and I will regret it. Maybe I am just burnt out and a new job where I don't know what I am doing will just be worse. Has anyone done similar and how did it go? WIBU to walk away from a pretty cushty job?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TaraRhu · 13/05/2023 13:26

I could have written this. It’s the ‘flexibility’ trap…. I’m in a similar situation. Jobs easy but there’s not much scope for progression. I’m bored mentally but I’m scared to leave because I can balance it with my life.

yoshiblue · 13/05/2023 08:31

I am about to move on after 6 years and in that time have recognised out of sync my salary is with the industry (gender pay is less of an issue where I work). I have managed to secure a 40% pay rise and additional benefits, yet maintain a flexible/compressed work week which I was told I wouldn't get elsewhere.

I would urge you to look at other opportunities in your industry and know your worth! You don't have to jump at the first thing but keep your options open! Best of luck!

kerryelaine100 · 12/05/2023 23:37

If you are NOT HAPPY then the job is NOT the dream job babe .. ❤️

Ihadenough22 · 12/05/2023 17:14

I noticed that you said this: And while I think he will be a better manager generally, my existing manager will be his and still refusing promotions and pay rises. I was honest with a senior leader in the team and said I really struggled to see were I could go from here.

You have been in a job for a long period of time and you have a boss won't give you the pay rise or promotion you deserve. You said this to a senior leader so if you hand in your notice down the line they can't be surprised.
My advice is to start looking for a job and see what is out their. Look at the salaries, benefits ect and how moving job can improve your own situation financially or benefits wise.
Once the right job comes and you have a signed written contract I would hand in my notice where you are. If they ask why are you moving I would say why in a nice way.

The truth is that you have tried to speak to your boss about things and they won't give you a payrise or promotion so what do they expect you to do?
I know people who are staying in jobs due to various reasons but when the time is right for them they are planning to move on.

Nordicrain · 12/05/2023 15:56

MonthofSunnydays · 11/05/2023 18:53

I haven’t read all the replies, so sorry if someone has suggested this. Can you not raise an equal pay grievance due to gender pay gap so they cannot fob you off? Maybe speak to Acas for advice. I did this in 2007 and won. Surely you stand a good chance in 2023. I had mine backdated and stayed at the same company for another 4-5 years.

It's a tricky one because I am not being paid less than a man in equivalent position. But overall my company is hugely male dominated and that gets more and more pronounced the more senior you get. I am sick and tired of being the only woman in the room/ meeting. So I am not directly discriminated against as such, but it's a male heavy culture and - clearly - it's men who are being promoted.

This thread has been great food for thought though, so thanks.I am so risk adverse sometimes and I worry this huge focus on stability can really hold me back, so it is great to see lots of encouragement and positive stories about moving forward. I had my first interview this morning and loved the company, she has already progressed me to the next stage. I don't think it will end up in a job (mainly because it requires relocation), but who knows. If not it was a great dip into job seeking, and I have reached out to a specialist industry recruiter too.

OP posts:
DucksNewburyport · 12/05/2023 15:29

Good luck OP. I hope you find somewhere that values you more. And if/when you do move, make sure that you have an exit interview and talk openly about the gender pay gap!

Inwiththenew · 12/05/2023 09:00

You’ll never know the answer to that unless you make the leap. I did it years ago because of new management, takeovers etc but I never found a position where I enjoyed the work as much again. Don’t regret it though my life has taken many twists and turns because I’ve always gone with my instinct. I just prefer that to security.

Hawkinsresident · 12/05/2023 03:57

This is me, except I’ve been at my co for about 5 yrs. No wonder I’m up at stupid hour reading this thread!

the reason I won’t leave is the people here, they are not as nasty as I’ve experienced elsewhere. My field is very operations and mgmt heavy which is full of arrogant, selfish and bitchy. Makes work less fun. So I’m choosing mental health over career ambitions.

Good luck with your search, if there is no financial pressure I would say take a leap of faith and try other organisations. Apart from Glassdoor reviews, my tip would be to network with some of future companies employees and see what their feedback is like.

AllNineLives · 11/05/2023 22:14

I think I it depends on where you are in your career OP. If you’ve been in your first job for 13 years then it sounds like time to move on. If you’re further down your career path then there’s a lot to be said for “better the devil you know”. However, your description of how you feel suggests that far from being your ideal job it is just convenient and not satisfying you at all.
I had a job like that a few years ago, after having been made redundant a couple of times and I wouldn’t have left of my own accord even though I was bored stupid and had no career progression whatsoever!! The company made me redundant so I had no choice and I was terrified of not getting something comparable. I did though, in fact the job I have now is far and away the best job I’ve ever had. I’m getting on a bit now and hope to retire in the next few years. I’ve been with my current company for over 10 years and don’t plan to move on!!

Harls1969 · 11/05/2023 19:20

19lottie82 · 10/05/2023 09:22

It doesn’t sound like your ideal job?

This

FootieMama · 11/05/2023 19:17

I could have written you OP. Perfect hours, good pay but always given a bit less than the men. Not valued, tken for granted.
I have just gave them my notice. Feel the change is needed after such a long period. Its difficult to grow otherwise.
I read somewhere that life is movement

Yourcatisnotsorry · 11/05/2023 19:15

I could have written this myself. I decided to go, was offered the first job I applied for at 50% salary increase. I’m currently on garden leave so only time will tell if it is the right choice but I think you regret the things you didn’t do/try more than the risks you do take. I am nervous though!

MonthofSunnydays · 11/05/2023 18:53

I haven’t read all the replies, so sorry if someone has suggested this. Can you not raise an equal pay grievance due to gender pay gap so they cannot fob you off? Maybe speak to Acas for advice. I did this in 2007 and won. Surely you stand a good chance in 2023. I had mine backdated and stayed at the same company for another 4-5 years.

whittingtonmum · 11/05/2023 18:45

Can you find an opportunity for you for promotion/progression in the restructure and pitch that to your boss - ideal if you can present it as a win-win for both of you and the company.

You can look for a better paid position elsewhere while you're negotiating at your old place and see with what options you end up with.

Mummadeze · 11/05/2023 18:29

I do think after all this time, your career will not really progress unless you make even a sideways move to another company. I see it where I work, people get pigeon holed and when a good new role opens up, they often want external talent. But, it depends a bit on your age and life stage, there are times when I have just wanted an easy ride at work because my outside work life has been stressful. I am also now sticking in my current role to wait for eventual redundancy because I need a lump sum payoff to help my retirement. You need to factor lots of external factors in too.

CharlieRight · 11/05/2023 15:30

I think you’re right OP, they are taking you for granted. But I also think you are you are cruising a bit. Which came first the chicken or the egg? It doesn’t matter it’s okay to get bored I think you are ready for a change.

JenJuni · 11/05/2023 14:25

Few tips:

  1. getting an offer elsewhere can be used to bargain harder where you are
  2. before you take another job, sit somewhere discreetly opposite the entrance/exit at the end of the day. Take a look at what time people are leaving for the day and whether they look content or strung out.
Mirabai · 11/05/2023 09:45

PP suggested i work elsewhere on my day off

Ah right I couldn’t see what you were responding to.

I’d get a firm offer elsewhere and ask them if they want to match it - but realistically even if they offer you a pay rise to stay, as long your ex manager is still around you may struggle to get promoted. Unless you take the opportunity of the offer to go above your ex manager’s head.

Nordicrain · 11/05/2023 09:24

@Mirabai PP suggested i work elsewhere on my day off. I can't do this, my employment contract doesn't allow it. At least not in the type of job I'd be interested in - they'd probably be ok with me working in a shop where there is zero confliect of interest! That is not unsuaul for my position which is fairly senior and involves accessing lots of confidential and commercially sensitive information.

As of yesterday I have a new manager. My manager was promoted and this other guy is now my manager. I can see how it makes sense, he is more senior than me and it was probably, at least in part, to appease him re my manager's promotion. But it has meant that there's just another layer and another person between me and promotion. And while I think he will be a better manager generally, my existing manager will be his and still refusing promotions and pay rises. I was honest with a senior leader in the team and said I really struggled to see were I could go from here.

But thanks all, there are some really great points. I won't leave without something else, definitely not, and in fact I have already been offered an interview. The job market is very hot in my field right now (I know as I have been recruiting myself!) so I should be able to find something. I think I will make some enquiries and see what else is out there and how it compares. I am not desperate to leave at all, in fact I am really torn about even looking, so it's probably a good time to do it.

OP posts:
Hellenabe · 10/05/2023 22:55

Hi OP,

I'd echo what people are saying and start looking externally but only leave if you have a role to go to. My company have given me the tiniest pay rise and its really annoyed me and I want to leave as well. However the flexibility is brilliant and perfect for my kids. The market seems to be on its knees at present in my field (finance) so I'm aware its going to take a while to find the right role. One great bit advice I got was look for roles when you are in a good place mentally. Interviewers sense if you are desperate to leave somewhere

2bazookas · 10/05/2023 22:23

the company is mainly men and has a rubbish gender pay gap. I think I am largely taken for granted. I just feel bored, fed up and disillusioned with it and struggle to see how I can progress from here.

Put that in writing to your boss and request a substantial pay rise. Otherwise you will be leaving the company.

Savoury · 10/05/2023 22:23

@Poppins2016 I note your point but the supervisory roles were full-time roles in that org because the managers needed to be there on business days and it would have been hard to do the role working part-time. Is that discrimination or just reality or maybe both?

Mirabai · 10/05/2023 22:20

I couldn't work somewhere else, that would be against my terms of employment

What do you mean by this OP?

Changeychang · 10/05/2023 22:16

Just chiming in to agree with others. Apply for other jobs and interview your interviewer. I was offered a job following interview but knew (thanks to how open they were in interview) that I wouldn't like the culture. So the search continues. I have a comfortable job now but I would like to move if a good fit comes along.

MsMcGonagall · 10/05/2023 22:00

Yes OP start looking for and applying for jobs. I left an organisation I'd been at for over a decade. New job is better paid and I haven't looked back. Despite previously not being able to imagine working elsewhere.

The excellent advice to me on MN was to not resign from my old job before I'd found the new job. This was difficult for me at the time as I'd got to a point where I really wanted to leave. But it was good advice.

I was previously part time so I designated Fridays as job hunting day - look through the vacancies and ideally, make 1 application a week.

It took me 4-5 months to get a job offer.

Looking back there might have been some of the jobs I went for that would have been "worse" - some were short contracts for example.

My new job is full of lovely people who I'm getting to know, and lots of variety. So, go for it OP. I now don't know why I stayed in the old place so long. (Though part of that reason is that it was handier while my kids were younger)