Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying a property together unmarried

112 replies

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 06:49

Just wondered if anybody has done this or split up and how things worked out for you.
I've been with my partner just over 3 years, lived together 2.5 years.
I'm 32 and he's 28, 29 start of next year. We aren't engaged, I asked him in March if he'd considered marriage with me as I'd like to and he said he hadn't thought about it yet, it was a massive commitment, not ready yet, none of his friends are married etc.

Fine, now the topic of purchasing a house together has come up. He's said he's happy to do this (well that's what he said at least). He hasn't mentioned marriage since so clearly not changed his mind, I haven't mentioned either.

Aibu to think it's too risky to buy property together if we aren't married? What if we buy it then a year later he still doesn't want to get married?
I don't want to seem like I'm putting pressure on him, but as I say it just seems too risky, it's not quite as easy as renting. Just wondered people's thoughts?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 10/05/2023 08:11

I am buying with my partner and not married, no intention of ever marrying. People buy property unmarried together all the time: it’s fine and normal.

The point for you is you want to be married. In a way the property is a bit of a red herring. The bottom line is you want to get married. If he doesn’t you have a problem.

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 08:06

What @Artemi has written

Ultimately the issue isn't "buying a property unmarried" (fine) but "buying a property with someone with different priorities/future plans" (not a very good idea)

Hits the nail firmly on the head, don’t waste years hoping. Maybe with the biggest benefit of the doubt to him he hasn’t thought about it. Tell him to think about it on and off for a month and see what conclusion he comes to. Don’t demand, don’t debate just say think about it.

Artemi · 10/05/2023 08:00

It sounds like you areal not compatible on this issue OP.

Plenty of people buy together unmarried- it is a perfectly normal/common thing to do and as people have said you can protect your percentage share of the deposit etc.

However it's also ok not to want that. I wanted to be married before buying together, we talked about it, and we got married. My partner was younger than yours and we'd been together less time.

Ultimately the issue isn't "buying a property unmarried" (fine) but "buying a property with someone with different priorities/future plans" (not a very good idea)

I'm sorry because it's shit. Sending supportive thoughts to you

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/05/2023 07:54

In my experience when a man in a 3 year relationship in his late 20s/early 30s says he hasn’t thought about marriage is what he really means is - ‘I have thought about marriage with you, I don’t want that so please don’t ask me about it because I want to avoid the conversation’

Fadedstripes · 10/05/2023 07:52

There is the legal protection.

However what does marriage mean to you?

People meet at all sorts of ages, my sister is remarrying and is in her sixties, she was widowed a few year ago. But it does get harder as you get older. There is the whole the better ones have gone mindset, is that true? I may get lambasted for this but I do think there are less decent men than women overall.

If marriage is non negotiable to you then do not buy with him. Trends are changing with the age of first marriages rising. People will also let you know they had healthy kids at 40 plus and they do but it is harder.

I have known or known of too many women waiting for a proposal or children. They waste their most fertile years and then the bloke buggers off and marries someone he has known for a small amount of time.

TheKobayashiMaru · 10/05/2023 07:47

I'm sorry if this is harsh, but in my experience if a man you've been in a relationship for a few years in his late 20's says things like 'it's a big commitment, none of my friends are married', it means he doesn't want to marry you.

I wouldn't buy a house with a man for whom I am miss right now rather than someone committed to a future together.

Trixibella · 10/05/2023 07:47

i would say based on conversations with my male friends and colleagues in my thirties, that men know if they want to marry someone within six months of a relationship starting.

Even when they met younger, they said they knew they were going to marry them. And those who left after 12 years before marriage said they knew they weren’t ‘the marrying kind’.

Inevitably the ones who weren’t the marrying kind were married sighing 18 months.

it depends what matters to you but men in their late 20s would hope to be with someone they’re keen to marry, even if they haven’t thought about the wedding details.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 10/05/2023 07:46

I bought a house with a partner, had children with said partner, he refused to marry (which I was fine about) and then broke up with him. I bought him out of the house and still live here.

One thing I would say is protect your deposit if you are putting a large amount in.

RuthTopp · 10/05/2023 07:46

Also to add to the mix , if you do decide to buy together , and set up the relevant precautions , 100% you need to do wills . Would you want it to go to him or another person/s .

honeylulu · 10/05/2023 07:46

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:10

It is difficult, he has all the power. I could wait another year, another 2 years. I could leave after 2 years whereas he might have been ready by year 3 but then it's too late.

I think you've answered your own question here. Men are often not bothered about marriage particularly if they have everything they want without it. When I was in my 20s my partner wasn't interested in marriage though he loved me and wanted to stay together/live together. I definitely did want marriage and children. He really wanted us to buy a place together and get on the property ladder but I knew if we did that (a) he'd have zero incentive to get married and (b) it would be a stupidly committed thing to do since I'd have to extricate myself but only from the relationship but the property/mortgage when things inevitably ended because we wanted different things. I bought a flat on my own though he did come to live with me. I felt "safer" knowing I was still in control of my destiny. Punchline - we did get married 3 years later (and are still married).

oioimatey · 10/05/2023 07:45

If someone can't commit to even the idea of marriage after three years together then I wouldn't do it, I'm afraid. I don't understand why people are so afraid of commitment.

If you do go ahead with it, then ensure you have an agreed plan in place if you break up. Keep note of who pays what, sign the mortgage as tenants in common so you look after your own financial interests, and what you do about any direct debits for house stuff (renovation work, bills, etc), how you handle making a profit on your property. Can you afford to rent and have a mortgage at the same time?

I had a friend who bought with her now ex-bf, and it turned into a 3 year battle including court dates and sky high solicitor fees, mainly because she refused to move even though he was the one who put in all the money so they could buy the house in the first place.

I think it's perfectly fine to buy a house with someone if you're both on the same page and unmarried, but it seems as you and your DP are not quite there.

MyTruthIsOut · 10/05/2023 07:41

Lcb123 · 10/05/2023 07:07

We bought a flat together unmarried, but we had discussed getting married and having kids. I’d be more worried about him not wanting to get married but you do - regardless of the property

I completely agree with this.

Do not buy a property with this man until you are on the same page regarding marriage and children.

And don’t let him just brush you off with excuses like “I haven’t really thought about it” because this is about the future you want for yourself and you cannot give it up for a man on the hope things will work out as you want them to.

I know being 32 years isn’t classed as old…. but if you want marriage and children then you need to seriously consider whether you are willing to sacrifice this for a man who isn’t as committed to the relationship as you are.

Theee years is plenty long enough to know if you want to marry someone or not.

Funkyblues101 · 10/05/2023 07:40

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:04

I've been told that 28 is fairly young these days for a man? Although he'd be 29/30 by the time we actually married I suppose.

If a man likes a woman enough he will want to marry however old he is.
This man does not want to marry you and, having been with you 3 years, that is unlikely to change.
You are most likely wasting your time if you want marriage and children to feature in your future.
Buying a house will not speed things up, it's just an opportunity to show you he has already made that commitment, and not to rush him.
Your need for commitment is more important than his aversion to it - I'd get out of the relationship now.

wildfirewonder · 10/05/2023 07:39

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:31

I would be confident otherwise, it's just that at present he has all the power with the marriage thing. I don't want to be long term with somebody but never get married.

He only has all the power if you choose not to exercise your own.

It is OK to say to someone - long term, marriage is a deal breaker for me, so we are a bit stuck for now. Have you said this to him?

flipperdoda · 10/05/2023 07:37

Oh and I understand what you mean about "he has the power" - I felt similarly. I want marriage, he says he does but is less ready, so I felt like if we bought a house maybe he'd just go "alright that's us sorted then, no need for marriage" which is not what I wanted!

So I told him. Through tears because I suck at these conversations(!) but I used the words "it feels like you have all the power and once we've bought a house what's to say you won't just not agree to marry" and we talked about it. Can't say it was initially particularly fun as he (reasonably!) took a bit of offence at the idea that I had to keep something back to "blackmail" him into marriage...but once we talked about it properly we understood more about our opinions on marriage and how our childhoods had shaped those, and we could talk rationally.

Can you talk to him about this sort of stuff? If you can't, I wouldn't buy a property or marry him until you can to be honest.

Oaktree1233 · 10/05/2023 07:37

You are wasting your most marriageable years with this man. If you buy a house together and house prices fall what then? You are stuck in negative equity unable to sell and stuck together in misery whilst each dates other people. Can you afford to buy a property alone and make him pay rent as a lodger - drawing up a formal licence agreement?

Merrow · 10/05/2023 07:36

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:27

And it's more in my situation about buying with someone who's unsure about marriage. It would be different if we'd both agreed not to.

It sounds like you're not sure of his level of commitment, and I wouldn't buy a house with anyone that I didn't think was committed to our relationship as a long term thing. Obviously things can still not work out, nothing is risk free, but I think there's a significantly higher risk of things not working out if after 3 years you're both not on the same page about commitment levels.

Quitelikeacatslife · 10/05/2023 07:35

The timing of how long you've been together isn't really that relevant, do you love him and want to be with him? If you can see yourselves together forever then great foundation. Be sure that he wants the same and really wants to buy a house together be very careful not to lead his answers and make sure he is active in booking appointments, looking at potential houses etc. then you will know he is committed to you.
The marriage thing is so so so frustrating that men seem to hold this power that they Will decide when the time is right . That the magic surprise proposal is still seen as the norm. It's pretty ridiculous really isn't it? What other thing in life do we apply that to?
Saying that it is a two way thing.
Don't worry about the marriage unless you want to have kids or get pregnant then insist upon it to protect your inevitable earnings hit.
Build your career as far as you can

NotQuiteUsual · 10/05/2023 07:35

I'd want to be sure he understood that financially, buying a property together is a bigger commitment than marriage. You also both need to lay your cards down on the table and have an honest conversation about what you both want and need long term. If marriage is an absolute must for you, but he doesn't see the need. There's no way it won't cause problems for you later down the line.

Peekingovertheparapet · 10/05/2023 07:33

The mechanics of buying a house as an unmarried couple are straighforward. We had a ‘tenants in common’ arrangement which stipulated exactly what would happen on splitting up.

Marriage was quite important to me too, especially before having children. So to some extent, I insisted on an engagement before we bought our first house together. It wasn’t quite the same situation as you, I was the younger party, and had lower earnings. But at the end of the day buying the house was important to him, and a more formal commitment of our relationship was important to me.

wildfirewonder · 10/05/2023 07:33

One other thing to throw into your thinking process is whether you want to use your first time buyer status now.

If you are focussing on your career and you may have higher purchasing power in the near future, it might be worth thinking that all through as there are options for FTBs that are not available to others.

However prices do rise, so this requires balanced approach.

flipperdoda · 10/05/2023 07:32

I would not buy a house with someone who had not indicated (via sensible, grown-up discussion with me) that they thought there would be a long term future with me. House buying is expensive, faffy, and I only want to do it with someone who is excited for a future with me!

I am currently in the position of buying with boyfriend so can say this very honestly, as I've had plenty of sort-of-exciting-sort-of-awkward (always loving) conversations about marriage, babies, fertility, being ready/not ready, what is holding us back from being ready, my concerns around buying unmarried (there were tears) etc. I'm genuinely now comfortable and that's because we had the potentially difficult conversations and I know where we both stand. You need that level of respect before you buy, I think.

I'm his age and bf is 3 years older. In general men seem to be older before they're ready, but I also have a friend who married at 27 (non religious). When good men are ready they're all over it!

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:31

I would be confident otherwise, it's just that at present he has all the power with the marriage thing. I don't want to be long term with somebody but never get married.

OP posts:
kweeble · 10/05/2023 07:30

If you want to have children and that is the bigger issue here then don’t buy with him.
You could sell up if you split up or one of you keep the house but it’s much harder to do when you own somewhere and can add to the heartbreak.
Could you afford to buy somewhere alone?

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:30

I'm sorry to hear that :(

OP posts: