Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying a property together unmarried

112 replies

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 06:49

Just wondered if anybody has done this or split up and how things worked out for you.
I've been with my partner just over 3 years, lived together 2.5 years.
I'm 32 and he's 28, 29 start of next year. We aren't engaged, I asked him in March if he'd considered marriage with me as I'd like to and he said he hadn't thought about it yet, it was a massive commitment, not ready yet, none of his friends are married etc.

Fine, now the topic of purchasing a house together has come up. He's said he's happy to do this (well that's what he said at least). He hasn't mentioned marriage since so clearly not changed his mind, I haven't mentioned either.

Aibu to think it's too risky to buy property together if we aren't married? What if we buy it then a year later he still doesn't want to get married?
I don't want to seem like I'm putting pressure on him, but as I say it just seems too risky, it's not quite as easy as renting. Just wondered people's thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lifeisapeach · 10/05/2023 22:32

I think you need to make sure you are on the same page before committing to a house purchase. What if he never wants marriage… would you still want to buy a house with him? What about kids. Personally I wouldn’t want to commit to a house with someone without knowing where you both stand on the big life stuff. Age doesn’t really matter. You should know after 3 years if you’re committed to someone what the direction of travel is. If marriage is important to you I think you need to make that clear.

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/05/2023 22:31

bigalt · 10/05/2023 21:01

Yes next of kin to one another.

Happy to be educated on the benefits :)

They always come out with the “benefits” but I’ve yet to have one person educate me on these “benefits” I’m missing out on.

We are:
-beneficiaries on each others pensions (along with our children) and life insurance
-we have LPA over each other should we need it
-beneficiaries on each others wills
-inheritance tax won’t impact us as our property isn’t worth enough for it to be a concern
-we earn too much for tax breaks
-joint owners and mortgage holders of our property.

We both entered the relationship with nothing. We have pooled our resources from day 1; we have both taken stints of SAHP/part time work and full time work; overall we have both contributed equally to our finances.

There is literally no benefit to us marrying except because we could have a party. Which tbh we could do regardless …

Its definitely an outdated view that marriage is some sort of holy grail; and if you look at marriage rates you will see that it’s falling out of favour. And really, what’s the point if there is a 50% chance of divorce anyway.

Whenisitsummer · 10/05/2023 21:15

Buying a property together is absolutely fine even though you aren’t married. We bought our first home together 18 years ago. It would be 50/50 if we were to separate. Being married was never a life goal of mine though. It sounds like you want to be married and he doesn’t - that’s a problem so it’s probably not wise to purchase a property together when you want different things.

bigalt · 10/05/2023 21:01

MrsJamin · 10/05/2023 20:38

Are you your partner's next of kin? It's just not true that there are no benefits to marriage.

Yes next of kin to one another.

Happy to be educated on the benefits :)

bigalt · 10/05/2023 20:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

FinallyHere · 10/05/2023 20:42

get pregnant then insist upon it to protect your inevitable earnings hit.

Having recognised that a man may not eat to get married, it is laughable to suggest if you get pregnant you should insist on marriage.

What leverage would you have to insist?

MrsJamin · 10/05/2023 20:38

bigalt · 10/05/2023 19:48

I think it's a generational thing.

Traditionally couples would get married as a show of commitment and getting married changed things. You'd move in together, consummate your marriage etc. That's no longer the case. You wake up the following day with a new surname if that!

I adore my partner and we have been together years. I want to spend the rest of my life with her but there are no benefits to getting married. Our paperwork when buying property supercedes anything marriage deeds would outline so marriage would just be an excuse for a big party, nothing more. It's by no means out of the question but it's by no means a big deal anymore

Are you your partner's next of kin? It's just not true that there are no benefits to marriage.

FinallyHere · 10/05/2023 20:35

It is difficult, he has all the power.

I understand how you feel that this is true. In fact, you each have equal power to stop the relationship.

I would not hang on hoping that he will eventually agree to marry you. The power dynamic is all wrong.

Split up. Find someone who will move heaven and earth to be with you.

TimeForCcchanges · 10/05/2023 20:11

bigalt

But there are many benefits to marriage

Look up the legal differences between 2 single people versus being married

drpet49 · 10/05/2023 19:50

DustyLee123 · 10/05/2023 06:53

See a solicitor to discuss percentages, and get it as Tenants in Common so you both own a certain percentage in case of a split.

This is the best advice

bigalt · 10/05/2023 19:48

I think it's a generational thing.

Traditionally couples would get married as a show of commitment and getting married changed things. You'd move in together, consummate your marriage etc. That's no longer the case. You wake up the following day with a new surname if that!

I adore my partner and we have been together years. I want to spend the rest of my life with her but there are no benefits to getting married. Our paperwork when buying property supercedes anything marriage deeds would outline so marriage would just be an excuse for a big party, nothing more. It's by no means out of the question but it's by no means a big deal anymore

Tinkerbyebye · 10/05/2023 14:23

After three years i would expect him to know if there is a future. You have made it clear you want marriage, he doesnt

so personally i would be looking elsewhere now otherwise you will just end u0 resenting him

Thesharkradar · 10/05/2023 13:58

In my experience men are always working to try and get the upper hand, to be in a position where they can have control and make things go in their favor.
The fact that he doesn't want to get married but he does want to own property with you tells me that he feels this will give him the power and control that he wants.

powerpufff · 10/05/2023 13:54

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:05

I just wonder if I'm expecting too much after only 3 years?

I think as women we always expect too little- 3 years is def enough
I'm in a two year relationship - I am expecting a marriage proposal in the next year
If It doesnt happen I will move on- partner knows it and he knows he does not have to feel pressure to do anything and he does not
Those were just my priorities
So we shall see - I am done wasting precious time with people who do not want to marry - I cant wait forever

Also the idea that 28 is young for a man? Why are they held to a different standard than women in this regard?

powerpufff · 10/05/2023 13:50

Hi OP

It is possible and lots of people do it - make sure you have very good legal advice and that you understand the contract fully ( deeds etc) - this may seem obvious but I cant stress this enough. I personally wouldn't do it- especially if marriage is not on the cards. Unpopular opinion: why commit to a home together without marriage? I guess it's an investment- I think the first investment should be in each other first but again unpopular ( I just don't think it is necessary and a massive headache depending on if and how you breakup )

My current partner bought a house with his ex - a lovely house made renovations then they broke up sold the house ( a massive headache and will not go into deets) when they broke up he left their home and he did not know this ( his fault) but he had to pay hefty capital gains tax
Again people do it all the time- I personally wouldn't. Once you have the house there is no incentive to marry even - I say : expect the commitment to get married first if that is what you want
Marriage is a priority for me I am giving my partner another year to propose then we will buy a house - if he does not propose I am not going to play house with him

Thesharkradar · 10/05/2023 13:13

he said he hadn't thought about it yet, it was a massive commitment, not ready yet, none of his friends are married etc
This response here....to me this is an insulting brush off, he doesn't want to be serious about the relationship but he wants to string you along as his adoring slave patiently waiting for him to offer to marry you.
I think he just likes the idea of you being tied to him because you own a house with him, he will enjoy the fact that you're wanting to get married and he can just go 'nah, not ready, none of my friends are married' as he goes off out with his mates leaving you to keep house.
Or maybe I'm just old & cynical, but your comments about him having all the power are ringing alarm bells for me.

Thesharkradar · 10/05/2023 13:05

It sounds to me like he wants to keep his options open, he likes the fact that you want to commit to him but he wants the freedom to not commit to you.
If you buy a house with him you will be trapped, he might decide to start acting like a single man and there'll be nothing you can do because you'll be forced to live with him, you won't be able to afford to move out, he'll be able to put a spanner in the works when it comes to selling and makes life uncomfortable for you if he wants to.
If it was me I would buy a smaller place on my own and not live with him.

katemulberrybush · 10/05/2023 12:54

If you're renting, it makes sense to invest in property

Have a deed of trust or
Make sure you split everything 50/50 so deposit, mortgage repayments, maintenance, paid equally

If you do split, you ensure you each take 50% if equity out

Jarstastic · 10/05/2023 12:16

on a purely practical monetary level what deposits and mortgage payments would you each make?

if it’s 50/50, it’s fine to buy joint tenants. and if anything happens to one of you, the other automatically inherits which would not be the case if you were not married and held tenants in common.

if it’s not 50/50 particularly if it’s you putting more in, buy tenants in common and have a deed of trust drawn up.

Auxbutteschaumont · 10/05/2023 12:15

Perhaps it’s a generational thing or just differing views but I don’t think it’s that unusual for a man (or woman) in their late 20s to have not really considered marriage.

Most of my friends have been in long term relationships since their early 20s but spent the years focusing on their careers, going to gigs, travelling etc. None of us really thought about marriage & then into our early 30s we all gradually got married & started having kids. Some had bought houses in their 20s,
some hadn’t.

So as I say I don’t think it’s unusual if he hasn’t considered it, nor do I think it means he doesn’t want to marry you. But what I absolutely would say is that communication is key here, if he hasn’t thought about it much yet then he needs to, if being married is a deal breaker for you (which is fair enough) then he needs to consider your long term future and decide if that’s something he wants too. In the mean time I’d hold off on buying a house until you both know where you stand.

Rainbowqueeen · 10/05/2023 11:51

I wouldn’t buy a house with this guy. It sounds like you have very different plans for your futures.

Id look at buying on your own. I’d also be assessing the relationship. You shouldn’t feel like he has all the power.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 10/05/2023 11:44

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:10

It is difficult, he has all the power. I could wait another year, another 2 years. I could leave after 2 years whereas he might have been ready by year 3 but then it's too late.

He only has ‘all the power’ if you give it to him.

maybe it’s time that you sat down and had a full and frank discussion about where your relationship is going, and what you both want from it. You seem to have been fairly quick to move in together ( nothing wrong with that, we basically never went back to our respective houses after Night One, and that was 44 years ago) but it sounds as if you want things to be settled and legalised….and he doesn’t.

Did you move in with him ? Does he see you as a useful partner subsidising the mortgage rather than an equal partner building a life?

If you give him all the power, you can’t complain if he uses it for his own advantage.

wildfirewonder · 10/05/2023 11:39

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 10/05/2023 09:10

Yes, but similarly you can be married and not committed - hence why half of all marriages end in divorce.

The only time I can see buying together before marriage as being risky is if only one person is on the mortgage/deeds, or if the financial input is uneven. Or, like I say, if inheritance tax is likely to apply - which is not a consideration for most first time buyers.

The fact people get divorced is not evidence they were not committed at the outset. It is just evidence it broke down, and these days we know when to call it a day rather than persist in misery.

For people who in principle want to get married, they are not fully committed until they are ready to say yes to that proposition.

For people who in principle don't want to get married, they obviously can be fully committed without being married.

mindutopia · 10/05/2023 11:36

I think buying property together is a big commitment. It's not a permanent one, in the way that children are, but it's a long-term one nonetheless.

There are ways to buy a property (tenants in common, ring-fencing deposits, etc.) that protect your individual investments if you split. But in the current market, if you aren't both really certain this is going to be a long-term relationship, I'd be hesitant to buy.

BIL has only just managed to force the sale on his property that he bought with his partner (of 15 years). They weren't married but were together quite a long time. But the house purchase was sort of a last ditch effort to try to hold on to some permanency in the relationship, as BIL found out that partner had cheated on him while on a hen do just previous (and also potentially with a neighbour, if you can believe it). They did end up buying but the relationship was quite shaky. They split up a year and a half later, but partner refused to sell. And then ended up having to do this dance for another 3 years where they each would move back into the house for a period of time while the other moved out (BIL lived in a shed at the bottom of his boss's garden for 2 years!) and get a lodger. Their lives ended up being very up in the air for years and BIL only finally managed to force a sale to release the equity so he could buy again.

In the end, despite all the stress, due to COVID and rising house prices, they ended up making about £100K on the purchase in only 5 years. So they've now both been able to move on and buy other properties. But in the current market, I would be reluctant to take the risk if you aren't very certain you are both committed for the long-term, because negative equity is a real risk if you need to sell up in 2-5 years time. That doesn't have as much to do with being married, but more to do with if either of your aren't sure yet because the relationship is still quite new.

ConsuelaHammock · 10/05/2023 11:12

Breakfastbaguette · 10/05/2023 07:05

I just wonder if I'm expecting too much after only 3 years?

He will know if he wants to marry you after 3 years. If you want the marriage and the children and he doesn’t I’d cut my losses and leave . Worse case scenario you get pregnant and stay together for the children . You both realise it’s not working and you separate but now there are children involved.