Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any female insight welcome!

65 replies

Cluelessidiot · 09/05/2023 23:13

Apologies for the intrusion here - I’m not a mum or female but I have been aimlessly googling and contemplating and a few searches directed me to Mumsnet threads that were full of useful advice and thought I’d give it a bash.

im a few weeks away from 40. Currently living with my elderly mum who is in the last few months of her life. Challenging time but trying to make it as ‘nice’ as possible. I broke up with a girlfriend of 5 years two years ago, it was for the best and ultimately the right person hasn’t come along since. Not as easy to meet people in late 30’s and I’m usually v busy with my own business.

when I was 24, I did a post grad and met an incredible girl. She was 18: if I’m honest my mates ripped the piss out of me for her age, look back and cringe a bit. She was utterly stunning too and a nice person, we had a lot in common. Initially we had a ‘FWB’ relationship. She was hard to read and I played hard to get. Absolutely pathetic on reflection but there we are. She always seemed a lot older than her years and had recently suffered a very traumatic sibling death. I’m a bit apprehensive about revealing too much detail in case she reads here tbh but it was truly awful. She often spoke about her separated parents quite negatively and didn’t really reveal much about them aside from that she didn’t get on with her mum at all. She spoke a lot about her sibling and I was very conscious that she’d been through a lot.

I quickly fell for her tbh. She showed absolutely no indication she wanted more. We had quite an intense relationship, was much more than just sex. I could give examples but reluctant to do so incase she reads here. This shamefully went on for 4 years until one day she messaged me and said she loved me but had met someone. I didn’t interpret this to mean that she was ‘in’ love with me and frankly I thought about her for a good few years after and often thought about her. I learned through the grapevine that she’d got married.

I bumped into her at a hotel event last week. Absolutely out of body experience. She hadn’t changed a bit and was just as beautiful as I remember. We ended up going to the bar upstairs and chatted from 5pm - 2am but it felt like 2 mins. Long story short, I broke her heart. I don’t want to add too many details, but it transpires that her childhood was extremely traumatic and just thinking of how much she carried during that times makes me feel very emotional and protective of her. She didn’t tell me because she “didn’t want to put me off” and actually our casual relationship (with lots of affection and couple in all but name and commitment) really caused her a lot of pain even though she was quite embarrassed to suggest so. I could just tell. She said I was her lifeline at that time and the only person she had emotional/physical intimacy with. She was an absolute socialite at the time, friends everywhere but her family circumstances were very very difficult. I wish I’d known.

the chemistry was absolutely unreal and it was like no time had passed over the years. She is extremely successful and I’m really proud of everything she’s achieved. She is recently separated from her husband and has a 3 year old. I asked about her husband and marriage and she said that she had no interest in meeting anyone new because she’d never want her daughter to have to experience other men in her home because she doesn’t have the interest in meeting someone and spending time getting to know them at a cost of time with her daughter.

not sure where I’m going or what I’m expecting the advice to do but what would you suggest in these circumstances? We have exchanged numbers and have been texting multiple times daily. She’s not flirty but very familiar and we always did get along very well. Is it appropriate to ask to see her again? I am not usually this clueless but when I say that I can’t believe I am speaking to her it’s the biggest understatement imagineable.

OP posts:
BreatheAndFocus · 10/05/2023 08:30

I think you should let your emotions settle a bit first. It’s easy to be impulsive or make rash decisions when you’re in an emotional state. Wait till you feel less intense. Then, I’d just concentrate on being her friend (if she wants that) and see how things go.

To me, there’s something very unattractive about a pushy man, and with having children that’s just heightened.

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 08:29

Can see what you mean by that comment. Absolutely not my opinion, I was raised by a very strong, confident single mum (as it happens, she never met anyone after my dad either). Meant it as a compliment.

can’t deny that there is an element of nostalgia but she was always the one I thought of over the years. Yes I am prepared to follow her lead

OP posts:
Persiana · 10/05/2023 08:11

I think you need to untangle your thoughts and feelings. Are you yearning for an earlier time and want to recreate that with her now? it stuck out that you say she looks the same, beautiful etc. Are you prepared to really understand this time what she's been through, what that means for her and you if you were to start a relationship? Is there any part of you that just wants sex? Are you prepared to go really slowly, never expect to move in and live with her anytime soon, her daughter will always come first and you will never be able to ask her to choose you. I suppose essentially do you really truly love and respect her, and she is worth you choosing an unconventional relationship in order for it to be with her?
I also didn't like your not immodest comment, to me that screams of a man who has conflicted views over women being confident and seeing this as somehow negative - is too much confidence immodest?! Why should women be modest? This rings major alarm bells for me

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 07:58

StoatofDisarray · 10/05/2023 07:55

I tend to agree. The bit where you said she was confident but not immodest stood out for me. Quite odd phrasing.

I meant that she is confident but seems to lack self esteem. Ie it’s a bit of a front.

OP posts:
StoatofDisarray · 10/05/2023 07:55

SinglePonders · 10/05/2023 07:35

The way you write and more you go on, the clearer it becomes that you should just leave her be.

I tend to agree. The bit where you said she was confident but not immodest stood out for me. Quite odd phrasing.

Parisj · 10/05/2023 07:44

I think you might find it helpful to understand avoidant and disorganised attachment styles - she has been affected by trauma and you don't scream clarity about how to relate in healthy ways. Its helpful to remember to be boundaried but openhearted, communicate directly but with vulnerability and honesty about feelings, to not try to be a rescuer etc. Look up the drama triangle, you are already being viewed as oscillating between various roles. Its exciting, and it could be good, but look to learn healthy relationship advice to protect yourself and her.

SinglePonders · 10/05/2023 07:35

The way you write and more you go on, the clearer it becomes that you should just leave her be.

MushMonster · 10/05/2023 07:30

The big question is why did you not snatch her off the shelf all those years ago? Why did you not 100% commit to her then? Playing the hard to get? Have a good thinking about this. There was a reason why you did not ask her to be your girlfriend/ fiance/ wife. And furthermore, you just let her go to another guy without putting a fight.
Maybe you like her very much, but not as a life partner. I think this is a sad line, very difficult to spot and see clearly.
If you do love her, though, you need to tell her and ask her out on dates.

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 07:15

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 07:05

Totally fair. She was stunning initially so I was very interested but also wasn’t (at that time in my life) wanting a relationship so fairly early on made that clear. She claimed to feel the same. Fairly soon after I started having feelings for her and suppose I assumed it would eventually develop into more. I used to ask her if she wanted more but she’d always say no. I mentioned this and she said “but you framed it in a way which suggested that if I said I wanted more, you would end it because that wasn’t what you wanted”. in all honestly, we were a couple in all but name and I can see on reflection how this would have been very confusing for her. We knew each other for 4 years - after the first year and a half I was conscious that it wasn’t right and said I wanted to remain friends and made the decision to stop sleeping together. Guess I thought she’d tell me at that point if she wanted more; god knows why I didn’t just tell her then but I regretted that a lot for years after.

we did eventually start sleeping together again but not with regularity like previously. I’d graduated at this point and moved away and she used to visit me about once a month. Then a couple of years later out of the blue I saw she’d deleted me on social media and when I questioned her by text as to why, she said she loved me but had met someone. It transpires that she hadn’t but “didn’t want to frame her message as an ultimatum”. I never contacted her again.

who was I then? Someone who really cared about her but yes, I was stupid and selfish. She was a catch and images were impressed. Not proud of this.
who am I now? Same person obviously but I’m not naive: I take full responsibility for my actions then.

I wasn’t suggesting she was damaged in any way but the context is relevant because I want to be mindful of this. The fact that she was so breezy about it spoke more volumes bizarrely. I suppose it was the classic case of “you don’t know what others are dealing with” and I’m pretty ashamed now.

’mates’ not images.

OP posts:
Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 07:13

gwenneh · 10/05/2023 02:46

she said that she had no interest in meeting anyone new because she’d never want her daughter to have to experience other men in her home because she doesn’t have the interest in meeting someone and spending time getting to know them at a cost of time with her daughter.

I'm curious, why you don't believe her? She's already told you what she thinks and what she wants.

Not suggesting that I don’t believe her at all. She said it in a jokey kind of way but ultimately that she’d have to weed out predators (she mentioned her mum had a lot of boyfriends and her experience wasn’t positive so I can read between the lines here) and she wasn’t prepared to invest the considerable effort and time this would take. She really does sound like an amazing mum and her daughter clearly means the absolute world to her.

im being honest here, but I obviously know I don’t fall into the above category 😂 that sounds creepy written down and like I say this with motive when she has expressed otherwise but it’s true. We’re not exactly strangers to each other but at the same time this is no guarantee we’d end up together forever which I guess is what she’s trying to avoid for her daughter (disruption). What I’m saying is that I understand it’s a different ball game when kids are involved and this is perhaps why I was interested in a female perspective.

OP posts:
Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 07:05

4plusthehound · 10/05/2023 02:32

This really stood out to me -
She was hard to read and I played hard to get
followed by this
I was very conscious that she’d been through a lot.

This younger you was selfish. Very selfish. Took the good (for you) but walked away from the rest.

So the question is - who are you now? What type of man are you now?

She is a person who has pain in her heart. Life threw a lot at her. You could be a person who walks with her. Or a person who takes from her.

Totally fair. She was stunning initially so I was very interested but also wasn’t (at that time in my life) wanting a relationship so fairly early on made that clear. She claimed to feel the same. Fairly soon after I started having feelings for her and suppose I assumed it would eventually develop into more. I used to ask her if she wanted more but she’d always say no. I mentioned this and she said “but you framed it in a way which suggested that if I said I wanted more, you would end it because that wasn’t what you wanted”. in all honestly, we were a couple in all but name and I can see on reflection how this would have been very confusing for her. We knew each other for 4 years - after the first year and a half I was conscious that it wasn’t right and said I wanted to remain friends and made the decision to stop sleeping together. Guess I thought she’d tell me at that point if she wanted more; god knows why I didn’t just tell her then but I regretted that a lot for years after.

we did eventually start sleeping together again but not with regularity like previously. I’d graduated at this point and moved away and she used to visit me about once a month. Then a couple of years later out of the blue I saw she’d deleted me on social media and when I questioned her by text as to why, she said she loved me but had met someone. It transpires that she hadn’t but “didn’t want to frame her message as an ultimatum”. I never contacted her again.

who was I then? Someone who really cared about her but yes, I was stupid and selfish. She was a catch and images were impressed. Not proud of this.
who am I now? Same person obviously but I’m not naive: I take full responsibility for my actions then.

I wasn’t suggesting she was damaged in any way but the context is relevant because I want to be mindful of this. The fact that she was so breezy about it spoke more volumes bizarrely. I suppose it was the classic case of “you don’t know what others are dealing with” and I’m pretty ashamed now.

OP posts:
Summer2424 · 10/05/2023 02:48

@Cluelessidiot sorry about your Mum 😔

gwenneh · 10/05/2023 02:46

she said that she had no interest in meeting anyone new because she’d never want her daughter to have to experience other men in her home because she doesn’t have the interest in meeting someone and spending time getting to know them at a cost of time with her daughter.

I'm curious, why you don't believe her? She's already told you what she thinks and what she wants.

Summer2424 · 10/05/2023 02:45

Hi @Cluelessidiot I would ask if she wants to meet up. If she does great but if she doesn't just continue being there for her. Hope things workout for you.

4plusthehound · 10/05/2023 02:32

Cluelessidiot · 09/05/2023 23:13

Apologies for the intrusion here - I’m not a mum or female but I have been aimlessly googling and contemplating and a few searches directed me to Mumsnet threads that were full of useful advice and thought I’d give it a bash.

im a few weeks away from 40. Currently living with my elderly mum who is in the last few months of her life. Challenging time but trying to make it as ‘nice’ as possible. I broke up with a girlfriend of 5 years two years ago, it was for the best and ultimately the right person hasn’t come along since. Not as easy to meet people in late 30’s and I’m usually v busy with my own business.

when I was 24, I did a post grad and met an incredible girl. She was 18: if I’m honest my mates ripped the piss out of me for her age, look back and cringe a bit. She was utterly stunning too and a nice person, we had a lot in common. Initially we had a ‘FWB’ relationship. She was hard to read and I played hard to get. Absolutely pathetic on reflection but there we are. She always seemed a lot older than her years and had recently suffered a very traumatic sibling death. I’m a bit apprehensive about revealing too much detail in case she reads here tbh but it was truly awful. She often spoke about her separated parents quite negatively and didn’t really reveal much about them aside from that she didn’t get on with her mum at all. She spoke a lot about her sibling and I was very conscious that she’d been through a lot.

I quickly fell for her tbh. She showed absolutely no indication she wanted more. We had quite an intense relationship, was much more than just sex. I could give examples but reluctant to do so incase she reads here. This shamefully went on for 4 years until one day she messaged me and said she loved me but had met someone. I didn’t interpret this to mean that she was ‘in’ love with me and frankly I thought about her for a good few years after and often thought about her. I learned through the grapevine that she’d got married.

I bumped into her at a hotel event last week. Absolutely out of body experience. She hadn’t changed a bit and was just as beautiful as I remember. We ended up going to the bar upstairs and chatted from 5pm - 2am but it felt like 2 mins. Long story short, I broke her heart. I don’t want to add too many details, but it transpires that her childhood was extremely traumatic and just thinking of how much she carried during that times makes me feel very emotional and protective of her. She didn’t tell me because she “didn’t want to put me off” and actually our casual relationship (with lots of affection and couple in all but name and commitment) really caused her a lot of pain even though she was quite embarrassed to suggest so. I could just tell. She said I was her lifeline at that time and the only person she had emotional/physical intimacy with. She was an absolute socialite at the time, friends everywhere but her family circumstances were very very difficult. I wish I’d known.

the chemistry was absolutely unreal and it was like no time had passed over the years. She is extremely successful and I’m really proud of everything she’s achieved. She is recently separated from her husband and has a 3 year old. I asked about her husband and marriage and she said that she had no interest in meeting anyone new because she’d never want her daughter to have to experience other men in her home because she doesn’t have the interest in meeting someone and spending time getting to know them at a cost of time with her daughter.

not sure where I’m going or what I’m expecting the advice to do but what would you suggest in these circumstances? We have exchanged numbers and have been texting multiple times daily. She’s not flirty but very familiar and we always did get along very well. Is it appropriate to ask to see her again? I am not usually this clueless but when I say that I can’t believe I am speaking to her it’s the biggest understatement imagineable.

This really stood out to me -
She was hard to read and I played hard to get
followed by this
I was very conscious that she’d been through a lot.

This younger you was selfish. Very selfish. Took the good (for you) but walked away from the rest.

So the question is - who are you now? What type of man are you now?

She is a person who has pain in her heart. Life threw a lot at her. You could be a person who walks with her. Or a person who takes from her.

Ohdofuckofdear · 10/05/2023 02:06

I'd say be her friend first and then see what develops from there.

That's how things happened with my DH, I'd been through hell before I met him and I was divorced with young DC,he was divorced with no children, we've now been together over 17 years and have 5DC and a DGC.

I'm very sorry about your poor mum and I hope things work out for you and your friend.

LeMoo · 10/05/2023 01:27

Just to build on the need to be emotionally mature further; people who live trauma are not always capable of always being emotionally mature. They may react from a place where they feel in danger (emotional or physical) - of course, we all do this to an extent! But you will be carrying your own trauma from grief about your mum and however together and mature she seems on the outside, you don't know what her sensitivities are.

I'm not for one moment suggesting she's unstable in any way, just that even if you'd never met before you'd both be coming at this with a lot of baggage.

Having the ability to recognise when either of you is lashing out and struggling emotionally and then to be able to take the steps necessary to help that person feel safe again is worth it's weight in gold - but it's tough, which is why I was talking about the need to be very self aware. The same is true of her too, but you can only be responsible for your own behaviour.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/05/2023 01:13

If you don't 100% believe you can be the emotionally mature partner then don't even go there, there's too much at stake (for both of you).

I agree. You set a pattern last time that she has said didn't work for her and made her unhappy. Now you're feeling like you've gone back in time and everyone is the same and that's a good thing. That's a bad thing if you pick up the same pattern. You will have to make a conscious effort not to be the same in this (possible) relationship. You need to be open, honest, emotionally mature, steady, understanding. That's a lot.

However you genuinely seem to really like each other so there's something.

Also, when children get older they have sleepovers, friends, spend less time with you. She may never want to live with you but having a relationship only gets easier even without involving children.

LeMoo · 10/05/2023 01:03

Ime = in my experience

LeMoo · 10/05/2023 01:02

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 00:52

Appreciate this and you’re spot on I think. There’s definitely a sense that she is quite guarded and I can understand why.
she said our relationship was confusing at the time because there was lots of affection and closeness and we spent a lot of time together. She said I was the only person to ask her questions about her sibling when other people (at that time) avoided the subject so as not to upset her.

im not suggesting I feel like I need to ‘rescue’ her - she’s doing quite well by herself from what I can see and is very successful in her industry - but I don’t think she has got all she deserved in life and I do feel very guilty to think that I could have been responsible for a lot of damage had she not been able to overcome her difficulties.

Then it sounds like you're coming at this from a good starting point (and you might be surprised how many guys do feel a need to 'rescue' women).

Just be careful - about your own feelings as well as hers (contending with the circumstances around your mum makes you emotionally vulnerable too).

She's able to speak openly about her past vulnerabilities and clear on her boundaries now which is a good thing but ime people who are openly guarded are so because they know that once they let someone in its much harder to protect themselves. If you don't 100% believe you can be the emotionally mature partner then don't even go there, there's too much at stake (for both of you).

NeedCoffeeNowPlease · 10/05/2023 00:58

My friend was 18 and her husband was 24 when they got married. He got a bit of ribbing about the age gap but he didn't let it stop him.

Get to know her slowly as a friend. She's made it clear she doesn't want a man in her life and she's a different person now. Don't assume it's a potential relationship.

Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 00:53

Loria · 10/05/2023 00:45

I wonder if you know her at all.

Maybe. But it’s amazing how quickly you can pick up where you left off.

OP posts:
Cluelessidiot · 10/05/2023 00:52

LeMoo · 10/05/2023 00:39

Her opinion was that I used her and didn’t think she was good enough.

You need to take a hard look at why this was her impression. Because you acted like a d*ck and played hard to get maybe?

She was vulnerable and she felt exploited. That should be your key take away from this. From what you've written, she may well have been totally justified in feeling this way.

The chemistry may be there but so is plenty of warning. She's still vulnerable and you need to be clear in your own assessment of your character now about how you would treat her in the present and the future. Old habits in relationships do have a way of resurfacing so if you want to pursue this and not hurt her or play a part in perpetuating a cycle of trauma in her life then you need to be incredibly self aware.

I know it sounds like I'm being really hard on you but I don't think you're a bad guy, just being very honest about some hard facts (And I'm genuinely very sorry about your mum,life must be very difficult for you right now).

She is not someone for you to rescue, no matter how protective you feel or how beautiful she is or how guilty you might feel over how you behaved when you were last sleeping together.

She has learned to build a life while living with immense trauma and however keen she is to be in contact you need to remember she said she won't put her daughter through her having boyfriends.

My advice? Once you've really examined your past behaviour and how you feel compelled to behave now then you should put your cards on the table and respect any decision she makes.

For your own peace of mind, if she decides not to go there then I'd advise having no contact going forward or you'll be perpetually torn, confused and hoping. You don't deserve to suffer unrequited love and i think it would get messy.

Good luck :)

Appreciate this and you’re spot on I think. There’s definitely a sense that she is quite guarded and I can understand why.
she said our relationship was confusing at the time because there was lots of affection and closeness and we spent a lot of time together. She said I was the only person to ask her questions about her sibling when other people (at that time) avoided the subject so as not to upset her.

im not suggesting I feel like I need to ‘rescue’ her - she’s doing quite well by herself from what I can see and is very successful in her industry - but I don’t think she has got all she deserved in life and I do feel very guilty to think that I could have been responsible for a lot of damage had she not been able to overcome her difficulties.

OP posts:
Loria · 10/05/2023 00:45

I wonder if you know her at all.

CuteCillian · 10/05/2023 00:44

Don't make things complicated. You get on and have loads to chat about. In you next text suggest a coffee at a time to suit her. Who knows what a friendship can lead too? But no rush.